@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

I assure you: I sometimes find the abuse of this heuristic smug and annoying, but I am not a Dallas Cowboys fan.

The thing about it is basically every Harvard undergrad would most want to go to Harvard grad school, and most of the rest of their choices will be other blue state schools. Blue states certainly have enough grad schools to keep it running.

Accreditation literally doesn't matter for Harvard or Stanford except as a technicality, it matters to East Sheepdick Bible College.

The thing is Harvard Law grads basically want to work in like three or four places (coming out of law school) and they're all in blue states. NYC and Cali big law and clerkships alone could easily absorb a few HLS classes. I'd imagine on the med school side it's similar. New York and California professional associations are unlikely to go along with Trump on the topic.

More likely Trump could manage to drag down the whole concept of accreditation and college rankings in this scenario. Which would be a good thing for the world, actually. But the schools most harmed would be schools like UVA or some of the UC campuses or Michigan, schools that have national profiles thanks to rankings, not the ivies Berkeley Stanford, which have a national profile independent of rankings. If anything the lesser ivies would benefit from a world where Ivy league carries more cache again without the rankings to interfere.

At any rate I support them for the same reason I supported Musk buying Twitter: what's the point of Fuck You money if you never say Fuck You?

No, but if a sports league gets rid of the best team, it hurts the league because you now know that the league champion is getting a tin belt, they're not the real best in the world.

Quality post. You probably won't like Elena Ferrante if you didn't like the lack of plot in One Hundred Years of Solitude.

I think one aspect that is missing from your analysis is that it is primarily a parody/parable of Latin American history.

For one they would no longer be eligible for the US News college rankings list. Going from a consistent top 5 to not in contention doesn't seem good for admissions or donation solicitation.

The US News rankings would cease to be relevant if Harvard wasn't on them. They basically started the rankings by figuring out that Harvard, Yale, Princeton should be at the top and backwards engineering how to rank the other schools by what metrics make those schools the top schools. It's like taking the obvious undisputed champion out of your boxing federation, or FIFA kicking out UEFA.

None of the rankings or loans or grants really matter, as long as businesses keep hiring from Harvard, bar associations keep admitting Harvard Law grads, Medical Boards keep licensing Harvard Med grads, other schools keep admitting Harvard undergrads to grad school or hiring Harvard PhDs for professorships, etc.

If 90% of Harvard Law grads get prestige jobs out of school, but the rankings don't include Harvard, we'll just get new "true" rankings somewhere.

And that's pretty much the story top to bottom.

On other hand, the pro-Trump camp who wants Abrego Garcia to stay in El Salvador are not at all concerned that they will be next, because in their view citizens and non-citizens are two morally distinct categories.

I don't understand your use of the word "morally" here. The question isn't who counts as an American citizen in some legal or moral sense, so much as what physically can happen to a citizen or non citizen. Facts are disputed, and even the worst cops get things right most of the time, but it is unclear to me where in the process the circuit breaker exists for me to avoid being deported to El Salvador. This is of course, incredibly unlikely: I'm a blond American and I've never lived anywhere north of the Narragansett or south of the Mason-Dixon. But assuming I was picked up, it's not clear at what point any of that becomes relevant. I don't get a hearing before deportation. Speaking English, or being white, are no guarantee of anything. Once I get to El Salvador, do they give me a hearing?

If there is no functional way for me to assert my citizenship, then my citizenship is of no value, and in order to protect my rights as a citizen I must protect the rights of anyone else from whom it is impossible to distinguish myself. I don't want to live in a country where I must carry an ID card at all times at risk of being sent to a foreign torture prison.

The moral core of the question in my mind is whether El Salvador is acting primarily as the USA's paid jailor, or are they acting as a sovereign choosing to imprison their own citizen. I'm not sure there is a clear answer there.

A little analogy...

I go over to BJJ tonight, an assistant coach is teaching class. During open mat after, one of the three guys at the gym named Tom rolls with me. Tom is a bit of a dirty fighter, and when we're rolling and he's trying to get out of a single leg, he hits me with the old oil check. I shout what the fuck, we yell at each other, I leave. The next day I come back for the morning class, and the gym owner asks me how the Tuesday night class was, I tell him the class was good but Tom fucking oil checked me and that's not why I come here, if it keeps happening I might have to quit. The owner says no, that's fucked, Tom is fucking banned.

Two scenarios from here:

  1. The next day, Tom calls me, and says "Hey, I'm sorry, I shouldn't have done that, I got too worked up, I'm gonna work on myself and make sure that never happens again. Let me buy you a case of Yuengling as an apology, and maybe we can be friends again?" I might forgive Tom, or I might not, but I'm under no obligation to tell the gym owner to let Tom back in. After all, it's his gym, not mine, I can't make him change his mind, if he feels that behavior is unacceptable even once that's his right.

  2. The next day, Tom2 calls me, and says "Hey, what the fuck dude, I didn't oil check you, I wasn't even there that night, you got me confused with Tom1!" At this point, I definitely have a moral obligation to tell the gym owner to let Tom2 back in, and explain the mistake, and that he shouldn't keep Tom2 out on my account. The gym owner could, of course, ban Tom2 for totally unrelated reasons. It's his gym not mine. But I'm obligated to tell him that he has the wrong Tom.

Which of these scenarios we are in makes the difference for me, morally.

A lot of would-be immigrants change their mind about crossing the border.

Revoking Harvard's accredited status wouldn't harm Harvard, it would destroy the concept of accreditation.

Reading through Scott, and the replies here and there to Scott, it seems that POSIWID is primarily a meme, or perhaps it has even attained the status of a minor shibboleth. The argument is becoming less intellectual and more and more personal. I'm not sure what that indicates.

I'm a dirty monolingual so I read it in English, but the language wasn't difficult, nor were the concepts. There is a lot of mentions of interplay between dialect and "Italian" in the text, so idk if in the original you'll run into Neapolitan slang. The first book is pretty self-contained, and it's mostly one of those post-modern one damn thing after another books anyway, but knowing it's a quartet I'll probably finish it up.

The Bukele government might want him in jail anyways.

Might. I think it's relevant to ask if they do, independently of the Trump admin, want him in jail.

I think it's valuable to formally count for a while to get the hang of it, but mostly I just try to mostly eat large amounts of food with a better protein/kcal than whole milk. Simple rule of thumb, does the job.

Wait, I'm a little confused here: is the foreign country in this case holding him for any reason other than on the USA's request?

I just finished Elena Ferrante's second Neapolitan novel. The writing is terrific and beautiful, but the plot movement left something to be desired in my mind. The first book was far better. I might still get around to the third some time this summer if I can get it from the library, it's not a difficult book to read, so it's a good vacation book.

This weekend I'm planning to dig into Moneyland, which my mother picked up for me at the bookstore because an old advance copy was available free, I guess it's a book about how rich people move money around. Should be a fun read.

I'm wrapping up The Cartiers on audiobook. I'll do a bigger writeup when I finish it, but it's a really fascinating work of family and business history. The jeweler aspects are interesting, the innovation of platinum settings and the creation of iconic pieces like the Santos and the Tank. There's also a personal view of European history to it, the family firm working its way through wars. In 1870, the business almost failed during the commune, but ultimately survived and made money selling the gems of bankrupt Paris aristocrats. In 1914, all three brothers (Louis, Jacques, Pierre) served; Louis most famously as a general's aide behind the lines would invent the Tank style of watch based on seeing early tanks at the front line, though it was Jacques who would win the Croix de Guerre and serve at the front lines despite his brothers and father urging him repeatedly to avoid combat service and think of the company. After the war they lost their Russian customers, but did a roaring business recycling gems for cash for exiled Russian Whites and (sub rosa) for the Soviets. With the firm remaining open through WWII, it's a snapshot of real life for frenchmen in occupied Paris, and what it actually looked like. The aftermath permanently reoriented their business toward their US offices. It's not exactly a worms-eye view (these are guys who had bitter rivalries with Faberge, challenged Rothschilds to duels, and made gems for kings and capitalists) but it's a uniquely selfish view: the Cartiers cared most about Cartier, and though they were often patriotic ideology was secondary to personal interest.

So this happened

Anyone know anything about the Order of Nine Angles? Sounds a little Monty Python.

Policy proposal: anything with an American Flag on it must be manufactured in the USA. American flag T shirts? Must be MiUSA. Buckets? MiUSA. NFL making those weird camo sweatshirts with the patch on it? MiUSA. Your beer can better have American beer in it if it has a flag on it.

Why am I wrong about this one? Seems like a slam dunk.

To what extent is it incumbent on a person who desires to see more US manufacturing to purchase already existing US made goods?

To what extent is it a fair critique to say "If you want to see Tariffs, buy all your t shirts and underwear from LAA, buy your shoes from Allen Edmonds, buy an American car, etc. And if you aren't already doing that, you aren't serious about Tariffs."

Or is that the participating in society meme?

Personally, I'm not really pro-autarky, but I do try to buy as much as possible from America. I had to giggle at some of the tariff takes the last couple weeks: I already buy American made socks (from Costco but that's too obscure I guess) and most days the majority of my outfit is American with LAA and Gustin handling most casual basics, Outlier pants, and a lot of things from Boathouse right where I used to row at Dadvails every year. Sneakers are the one thing I buy exclusively foreign, in that I only buy obscure Amazon minimalist-shoe knockoffs because they're the only thing that fits my weird feet. And that's pretty much my ideal: I should have the ability to buy American, and I prefer to, but I like having the ability to buy a vast variety of things that are exactly to my taste. If there were a MiUSA alternative to WHITN, I would buy them, even for a premium!, but they don't exist to my knowledge.

I believe just a short jump through time brings us to alien worlds, besides across geography.

Short, short time jumps. I'd be curious to correlate answers to the question about the USA over the past 250 years, with their answers to two questions:

  1. When did Rome end?

  2. Do you think that your father approves of you and your life?

The first is obvious. Do you think of Flavius Aetius before riding into battle against Attila, reflecting on himself as part of a Roman tradition that reaches back to Scipio; do you hear that and think "You absolute fool, don't you realize that the post-Marian reform legions were a completely different thing, and the imperium again, and the dominate yet again?"

The second, I'm curious to what extent the personal is the political. I have an older father, he was in his late 40s when I was born, and so many aspects of my world are inexplicable to him. Nonetheless I feel that he loves me and approves of me and my life. I suspect the feeling that the Founding Fathers would not approve of the modern USA because of it's inexplicability is related to an observation or feeling of rejection by one's biological ancestors.

As for my answer: I don't think that America has ever exactly been one thing. There are visions of America that failed, and visions of America that succeeded. The Founding Fathers were not, by nature, factionalists or followers, they were individualists to a fault. There were at least a dozen views of what America would be among the signers of the Declaration and the Constitution. Some of the Founders expressed different views at different times, and probably felt different ways at different times. It is hard to imagine that Thomas Jefferson had a consistent view on race when one reads his writings on the subject.

My view is more along the lines of how do you define a dynasty in sports, as long as you have consistent success and players who played together with other players, you have a single team. The break comes when you have bad seasons or you have a complete turnover in personnel. So the 1920-1964 Yankees constitute a single Dynasty, even though no single player could possibly span that period, and the game itself changed so much in that time. Because you never had discontinuity, Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra played with Joe DiMaggio who played with Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth. It wasn't until the down years that you see discontinuity.

Similarly, the Trump admin is a big change from the Bush II admin, but there are a lot of guys who served in both, and you can push that back through every Republican admin (and parallels in the Dems) to the start of the century, and probably earlier. Over time the population of the country has turned over, is demographically different, but there's direct succession. As long as that exists, there's America, and I think some of the founders would look at it and smile, at least some of the time.

Man, this is one of those times I read something and think living in the 80s must have been awesome. What kind of pissant planning commission would put up with that? Nowadays even in the small towns I work in, they'd tell you to go fuck yourself and call the cops on your concrete pour.

Combined with this we might be seeing a major back-down on a lot of Trump's programs:

U.S. President Donald Trump suggested on Thursday that farmers will be able to petition the federal government to retain some farmworkers in the U.S. illegally, provided the workers leave the country and return with legal status.

"We're going to work with farmers that, if they have strong recommendations for their farms, for certain people, that we're going to let them stay in for a while and work with the farmers and then come back and go through a process, a legal process. We have to take care of our farmers and hotels and various places where they need the people," Trump said.

I'll note that personally I'm basically in favor of a policy by which migrants who are employed should be a much lower priority for deportation, and that ultimately a variably-sized fine is the best punishment.

But this fundamentally undermines any wignat hopes that this administration will seriously halt the melanation of America.

Pessimistically, the upshot of all this is that both Tariffs and Deportations are fundamentally unserious policies, which won't really help the headline numbers, while a few random unlucky individuals get caught up and destroyed in the gears of government.

Optimistically, this is the start of both a more restrained approach from the Trump admin and perhaps even an understanding that we need to restrain the imperial presidency.

It depends if we're talking about big decisions or little ones. One of the pernicious aspects of the administrative state is that you have minutiae that can have huge impacts on businesses, tax classifications of particular business inputs or what constitutes a "tree" or whatever, and I can absolutely believe that those kinds of decisions are influenced by money.

On the other hand, the recent SCOTUS kerfluffles seem goofy to me, in that it seems to be built around the idea that Clarence Thomas can't possibly believe what he does in fact believe.

‘mowing the grass’ was politically impossible after October 7th

  1. What does politically impossible mean? It always seems to mean something like "restraint was impossible without ending Bibi Netanyahu's political career." Which isn't something that I think we need to value all that highly in terms of impossibility. We wouldn't accept, in a wartime situation, saying "It's impossible to take that position" when what we mean is "it's impossible to take the position without suffering casualties." If Bibi isn't patriotic enough to take one for Israel, history should hold him accountable for that.

  2. In what way is this operation not just another example of mowing the grass? Even accepting the absurd maximalist goal of "eliminating Hamas;" let's imagine that Hamas ceases to be a going concern, does anyone really think we won't see a new terrorist organization form? Israel may not be mowing the grass, but they are fertilizing it.

If a violent response was necessary, it had to be done in three months. Dragging it out over multiple years has been foolish.

could just hire a bunch of people. And he has many options for external manpower too - local police, red state governors, the national guard. Even the military is an option under the Insurrection Act.

Lots of people like eating meat, not everyone will work in a slaughterhouse.

The Purpose of a System is What It Does inasmuch as it is controlled by competent actors and serves their intent. I'll get to this in my example later.

The problem with TPOASIWID is that the WID part isn't typically uncontested, and where people think it is uncontestable we're typically lacking in nuance. You start with taking the most uncharitable view of something or someone you don't like, then smugly pronounce that TPOASIWID. You have to do the work to prove that is what the system does, before you can determine that is the purpose of the system.

So for example, the purpose of the Dallas Cowboys in this millenium is to field a premium-mediocre NFL team that never makes it anywhere in the playoffs, while making money selling merch. You can tell because they never get anywhere in the playoffs and TPOASIWID!

That's just a boo light, a funny applause line on an Eagles fan forum.

On the flip side, one can justify the statement.

The purpose of the Dallas Cowboys, despite the regular pronouncements from the Jones family that they are ALL IN this year, is to field a great regular season team year in and year out, and winning a Super Bowl is secondary or tertiary to that. You can tell, because they consistently try to abide by the salary cap year to year, rather than accept dead money in future years the way teams like the Eagles have to maximize their effective cap during the current seasons and improve their chances of winning during a specific window, because they don't want to maximize the amount of money they can spend this year, they want to save money and make sure they never have a down year in the future when they have to eat the dead cap. You can tell, because they don't typically trade away draft picks for useful players, like the Rams did, because they don't really want to win a super bowl, like the Rams did, they want to maintain competitiveness such that they can win more games than they lose and fleece their fanbase. You can tell because, instead of extending players early to lock in lower rates the way the Eagles or Chiefs have, the Cowboys wait until the last possible second and pay extra. This reduces the odds of a big miss, which might put them into a losing season or two, but it slowly saps their resources to keep them from getting over the top, but that doesn't matter because their purpose is to win regular season games. TPOASIWID, the Cowboys exist to sell the idea of a good football team, not to win championships.

TPOASIWID went from the insightful the first few times I read it, to unbearably smug and annoying, within a very short period of time. It's used to shut down a conversation, without justifying why that is, in fact, what the system does.