@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

Reviewing Predictions on the Israel-Gaza War

The Institute for the Study of War opines that

The Israeli campaign into the Gaza Strip was a military success but has fallen short thus far of setting conditions to replace Hamas as a governing entity. The Israeli government enumerated three objectives at the beginning of the war: destroy Hamas’ military, return the hostages, and destroy Hamas’ government.[1] These objectives—though expansive—were achievable through a combination of military and political action. The Israeli campaign succeeded in destroying Hamas’ military and securing a ceasefire that would release the hostages. The campaign has also isolated Hamas in the Gaza Strip, though Israel and its partners will need to ensure that Hamas remains contained. But neither Israel nor the United States has tried seriously to achieve a political end state that would build upon this military success and permanently replace Hamas as a governing entity in the Gaza Strip. Israel’s failure to achieve this final war aim means that the strip will remain without an alternative governance structure and security broker, and Hamas remnants will inevitably try to fill that role again, especially as the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) withdraw. Hamas will use this space to reassert its political authority and reconstitute its forces—unless the United States and Israel take further steps to prevent those things from occurring.

The Middle East Monitor meanwhile summarizes Israeli opinion:

Unlike previous military campaigns in Gaza – on a much smaller scale compared to the current genocidal war – there is no significant strand of Israeli society claiming victory. The familiar rhetoric of “mowing the lawn”, which Israel often uses to describe its wars, is notably absent. Instead, there is a semi-consensus within Israel that the ceasefire deal was unequivocally bad, even disastrous for the country. The word “bad” carries broad implications. For Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, it represents a “complete surrender”. For the equally extremist Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, it is a “dangerous deal” that compromises Israel’s “national security”. Israeli President Isaac Herzog refrained from offering political specifics but addressed the deal in equally strong terms: “Let there be no illusions. This deal – when signed, approved and implemented – will bring with it deeply painful, challenging and harrowing moments.”

In Haaretz we get headlines like: "Total Victory in Gaza? Dismantling Hamas? The Hostage Deal Is Exposing Netanyahu's Lies” and "The Gaza Cease-fire and Hostage Deal Is the Same One From Eight Months Ago. Why Did Netanyahu Accept It Now? Ailing hostages rotting in tunnels for 15 months and over 120 Israeli soldiers killed since Benjamin Netanyahu declined a previous cease-fire and hostage deal with Hamas are the least of the Israeli prime ministers' concerns. He wanted to be pressured just ahead of Trump's inauguration”

I can’t track it down online and I’ve since recycled the paper, but at the signing of the ceasefire, I read a WSJ op-ed in which the writer bemoaned that the hostage exchange, as lopsided as it was, constituted a defeat for Israel, and provided an obvious structure for future defeats. There’s been a consistent drumbeat of sentiment among committed Zionists and self-described foreign policy realists that the ceasefire constitutes an Israeli defeat. And inasmuch as one takes Netanyahu seriously earlier in the war, it does seem a defeat of a kind. Israeli hawks have said from the beginning that they were fighting to destroy Hamas root and branch and obtain lasting peace and security for Israel. That this was not another “mowing the grass” operation, that their intent was to totally and permanently alter the relationship between Israel and Gaza such that there would never be another attack originating from Gaza against Israel.

Now, at the end of the war, the grass is well and truly mowed, but permanent changes seem unlikely to materialize. Fighting for peace is like fucking for virginity, while the doomerism seems overwrought it’s tough to see how Israel emerged from this more secure in its long term future. In the short term, perhaps even for a decade or so, Hezbollah is neutered, Hamas is pulling itself off the mat, Iran has been punched in the nose, Baathist Syria is gone; the grass is mowed, there is no immediate threat of attack. But in the longer term, it is hard to see what strategic objective Israel achieved. While a great many Palestinians were killed, amid cries of GENOCIDE from the usual suspects, I’m not even sure there are fewer Palestinians now than there were on 10/6/23. The attitude of those left behind in Palestine towards Israel requires little guesswork. Support for Israel is in decline among younger American voters, they may not be able to count on unconditional US support in the future (I’m not sure Zionism is a position likely to shift with age in the way that positions of issues like Taxes and Racial Equality have historically shifted with age). Israel still has no actual operational plan of what an acceptable government of Gaza would look like, a group that they would endorse as an alternative to Hamas rule in the enclave, or even an outline or an idea of what such a group might be. Many Israeli officials and soldiers face risk of prosecution abroad on war crimes charges, which I imagine will not come to pass in any significant quantity, but it means something that thousands of Israelis will be unable to travel to much of Europe. Israel is unlikely to see a revival of the Abraham Accords peace process with the Gulf States under a second Trump admin, though we can all hope that the Dealmaker in Chief can pull a rabbit out of the turban and get this done.

Looking back, this leaked intelligence paper from Israel detailing plans for removing the population of Gaza to camps in the Sinai before occupying Gaza, was remarkably prescient. The authors predict that the violence required to occupy a populated Gaza would be too great, unsustainable for the Israeli forces politically, and result in the Israeli forces ultimately exiting Gaza without achieving their goals. This has now occurred. While Trump is now making noises about removing Gazan civilians, it is not clear how this would be achieved physically.

@Pasha had an excellent comment near the beginning of the war presaging the situation facing Israel now:

To delve deeper into the uncomfortable topic of the looming genocide, I also increasingly get the feeling that contrary to the expectations of some whose view of geopolitics is eerily similar to RTS mechanics, the genocidal military power IDF is displaying right now is ultimately going to harm Israel a lot more than it helps. I think it mainly has to do with political/military leadership trying to cover their ass and muffle their enormous failures with the sound of bombs. If IDF really goes through with their plan which seems likely to cost civilian lives in the hundreds of thousands, I don't think the nation of Israel will ever recover from this. It is a country that is already losing two of its most powerful weapon: Endlessly idealistic and intelligent Ashkenazi founders who knew to out-think and out-work their opponents at very turn, and most importantly to not lose the sight of their goal even when they had to take very nasty decisions at times: to create a people. Not to destroy one. These people are not only losing out in demography but also they are losing the soul of the nation. Their spirit will not survive a Gazan genocide [AND] Zionist influence in the Western world. Through a combination of dedication, money, human quality, well-crafted propaganda, historical guilt and Cold War positioning, Zionists has always had a very unique power position in Western institutions, especially the US ones. This is quickly disappearing. Western Jews are assimilating into the PMC deracinated blob at a breathtaking pace. They are losing the set of assumptions that motivated them to identify with their kin in Israel, and they are losing the power that comes from ethnic favoritism. A Gazan genocide is very likely going to be the final nail in the coffin here.

I fully agree that the situation with Gaza is entirely unsustainable. But if Israelis go through with what they are plotting right now, they will slowly but surely find out that they are 7 million souls surviving in an ocean of half a billion through miracles, and they are pissing in the miracle potion.

It seems clear that predictions at the outset that “eliminating” Hamas/Islamism as a force in Gaza was not an achievable goal. I’m curious to see if this is an example people reach for in the future. Given the failure to consider predictions based on the 9/11 experience before this war, I doubt it.

What other predictions did you find particularly prescient or wrongheaded?

That being said, I'm also taking the position that not all places have allegiances to all sports.

College allegiances also probably play a role.

This is the most natural way to coalesce pre-existing cultural affinities, but how would you account for differences in the importance of allegiances? Delco is both Eagles and Sixers country, but it cares about the Eagles vastly more. I imagine there are places this might become relevant.

If army helicopter pilots can't be sent to conduct routine flights in common use air corridors, what makes you think they can go to war?

Accidents happen. We seem to read about a fatal training accident routinely a few times a year.

But the civilian casualties of military training accidents should be zero.

I'd agree with all that EXCEPT for the one area where the planes come in and out of the runway. That's not the entire Potomac, it's perhaps a ten miles radius around the airport. Avoid that area and you put the odds of hitting an airliner at zero.

Or, rather than tell them to look out for planes, tell them to stop and wait until there's a fifteen minute period with no planes.

It seems blindingly obvious that helicopter training missions shouldn't be passing through the one area in all of DC where they could plausibly hit a passenger airplane.

Yes, that's my opinion. I'm not going to get into an argument with you about how often you make love to your wife, or the raw hormonal horniness underlying it, especially as the two are both obviously separate and almost impossible to parse.

Moreso a joke about aging curves in baseball.

A 22 year old Dominican flamethrower who sits at 96 and can reach for 100 in a big spot, at 28 he's probably sitting 93 and can still reach for 97 when he needs it, and at 33 his fastball is 90-91 and if he's serviceable at all it's by learning to rely on location and clever breaking balls to trick hitters rather than blowing by them with raw stuff. He might actually peak as a pitcher in quality at 27, when he's got the best mix of velocity and experience, and he might keep pitching to 35, but almost never will he add velocity in his career.

A 24 year old clever college lefty who debuts with a fastball that never breaks 92 and starts by relying on tricking hitters, at 32 he is going to be sitting at 86 and throwing batting practice. He started by sneaking by, and pretty soon there just isn't enough there to work with.

To return to relationships, if you meet your partner and start making love, you're never going to exceed the raw attraction and numbers you had then. There's no trick to it, you're just never going to be as horny for each other as you were then. The sex might get better over time in quality, but sheer desire will never exceed the start.

And if you started at fucking twice a day every day can't get enough of each other, then ten years down the road the decline will still keep you at a place where experience and tricks can carry you. Where if you started at "meh I guess if it's convenient" the decline quickly leaves you at zero. You're almost never going to add attraction during the course of the relationship.

Horniness is best modeled as declining linearly from relationship debut. Like baseball pitcher velocity.

Only some of the time. It probably worked more in high school and college.

Go Birds!

We're past analysis.

The Eagles are in their third playoff game in which there is no analytical reason to pick their opponent; but their opponent has good coaching and a QB that might put the team on their back.

The Bills are slight dogs in another pickem; the Chiefs are probably not that good but no one wants to be the guy picking against Pat Mahomes and Andy Reid.

Nothing to do but watch the games. This is Jimmies and Joes territory. I'm doing everything I can to feed superstitions. LFG.

By remembered do you mean the exact lines in full; or do you mean the themes, concepts, or feelings of the piece?

What do you think the cartels are, exactly? Who do you think they sell to?

This just feels very standard in a lot of documentaries.

Guys, don't feed the troll.

I'm not in a real position to argue for or against them as factual representations of the Vietnam war, I've never been in a fistfight in Vietnam let alone a war there.

But I can tell you that's what these guys told me. They experienced it, and they felt that the information from that experience could best be communicated to me by those fictional films. They felt it captured something about what it felt like. When you say the films are all very different: the experience of the war was different for different people. When you say they drew influence from other fiction: there's a universality to the experience, and the soldiers themselves would have viewed it through those narratives.

Als, bit of a sidenote but can we talk about how Philly managed to get all the best players from that Georgia Bulldogs squad?

They also have Kellee Ringo at 4th CB and gunner on punt returns, and they just added Lewis Cine off Buffalo's practice squad for fun. There's a theoretical lineup next year, with Dean healthy and Cine actually a part of the team, where they have UGA players at 6/11 spots on defense.

The discourse around the play has been that it single-handedly lost the game for the Ravens - and while it was the final nail in the coffin, I firmly believe they would have lost even if he held on. Hell, it didn't even give them the lead!

This is buzzer-beater discourse in general. Any time you have one play that decides the game, every other play decides the game just as much. Not only every play the Ravens missed on points, but every play the Bills missed on points. If the Bills get an extra field goal earlier in the game, then the play doesn't matter.

I highly suspect that Philly will beat Washington in the least convincing manner possible, then lose in the Super Bowl to either AFC team, so that the Eagles will manage to make two Super Bowls while still getting the "They haven't beaten anyone" treatment, and in the season between they'll have a historic collapse in a year they beat both the Chiefs on the road and the Bills in the rain.

The Rich treating The Poor as having less agency, and also The Poor claiming less responsibility, has been normal throughout human history. The Poor have more agency and responsibility than children, but less than The Rich. At the same time, exceptions have always been recognized (some Poor Men, and even some children, have more agency and responsibility than some Rich People). However, not until the last few decades has anyone tried to reorganize society and culture around the exceptions rather than the norm.

Do you think the above is a fair or an unfair summary of human history, and do you think it is equally recommended by an examination of history to have class inequality as to have gender inequality?

A big part of my growing into maturity sexually was moving past taking a legalistic attitude towards consent ("If I obtain agreement, then all questions about her needs are off") towards a more paternalistic approach with partners ("Do I think this is good for her?"). For me, this was the result of repeatedly having women say yes to things ("Yeah, I'm not looking for anything serious either!") that clearly they didn't mean. And for me, it was about realizing that I didn't want to have sex that hurt women, and that if I didn't want to have sex that hurt my partners I had to take responsibility for it, and not just take her word for it.

Growing up, multiple Vietnam war vets I worked with or had as scoutmasters or baseball coaches told me that to understand what Vietnam was like, I should watch Platoon, Full Metal Jacket, and Apocalypse Now.

I'm not sure what you find objectionable about a work of historical fiction being used to illustrate a period. It's a tradition that dates back to...I'm not sure it actually has a beginning. If it does, it certainly goes back so far that it predates or mingles with the creation of our concept of fiction.

Well, that was some football. Turns out, both theories of snow-game football were correct: the snow made the passing game difficult, and the snow increased variance; the benefit going to running teams and underdogs.

In Philadelphia, heavy snow that we're still digging out of this morning, and we saw the Eagles run for close to 300 yards and three long explosive touchdowns. Unfortunately, for drops and slips and sacks, the passing game never got going, with Jalen Hurts passing for 128 yards but losing 66 to sacks. An apparent knee sprain hobbled him for parts of the game, and when I've had back or knee stability injuries I know that slipping on snow/ice makes your whole body go haywire so I can't imagine being out there playing agile football; but he gutted it out, and most importantly avoided turning the ball over once. If the Rams had just managed to get a safety to stop those 40+ yard touchdown runs after 30 yards, the Rams win this game. But then if the Eagles had made two snow-slipping PATs, they win the game comfortably and there's not much to talk about. Both teams had drops and screwups that, if you reverse them, change the oucome of the game, it was a sloppy snowgame. So, six of one, half a dozen of the other. The Rams played well, with Jared Verse backing up his trash talk about Eagles fans, but ultimately a couple lost fumbles probably makes the difference in the game. This might be the Rams' swan song with Stafford, and if so it's a damn good run and they should be proud of it.

In Buffalo, Josh Allen won with a very similar formula to Jalen Hurts: throw for about 120 yards, run well, don't turn the ball over, score 28 points at home and count on your defense to get a last minute stop to win the game. The sacks are the difference between Jalen Hurts being criticized as a backup-tier QB, and Josh Allen being praised as a clutch winner who got it done. Which, hey, the sacks happened, including a real bad safety that could have cost the game. But I don't remember ever seeing the term "Net Passing Yards" used a lot by football writers over "Passing Yards" until writers discovered it could be used as a way to criticize Jalen Hurts, and I think a lot of readers don't notice the sleight of hand. Allen is going to get the opportunity to duel Mahomes. Over/Under on the number of plays that end in star QBs lobbying the refs?

Lamar Jackson probably won his third MVP this year, but this loss will define his season, despite it ultimately coming down to drops in single degree weather away in Buffalo. Brutal sport. There's no reason the Ravens shouldn't just run the team back as much as they can, they probably win if Flowers is healthy.

Just finished the Odyssey. This read, I thought a lot about connections to other epics, like Milton or the Ramayana. What do the differences tell us about the cultures that produced them?

I picked up Gaiman's Sandman series. I'm on to volume 4 now. It might be that I'm not used to horror or comics or horror comics, but the first two volumes (A Doll's House and the process of getting the tools back) struck me as witchy and atmospheric, but pretty uninteresting plot wise. On the other hand, the self-contained stories in Dream Country like The Dream of One Thousand Cats were great. Though, given recent news, having the author in Dream Country repeatedly rape his imprisoned muse for story ideas is a liiiitle...well...you know...

Total disasterpiece for the Lions last night. The motor city kitties never felt like the favorites, they were pressing all game. Washington played fast and loose, and won the game comfortably. Which annoyed me personally, because I was rooting for the Lions, and because I was very tired and planning to go to bed as soon as the Lions put the game away...which they never did. The Lions will hopefully be back next year with better health and better luck, but this was the best Detroit Lions season in 40 years, and sometimes the moment passes. It's elegaic. The sadness for me is muted by the fact that this is the outcome that was best for my Eagles.

Jayden Daniels is going to get the opportunity to be the first rookie QB to ever lead his team to the Super Bowl, playing away against the winner of Eagles-Rams today. My Philadelphia Eagles are touchdown favorites, but we saw how much that meant last night. They're calling for 8 inches of snow during the game, which should favor the Eagles and their road-grading offensive line and strong run game over a precision Matthew Stafford passing attack and speed rushing line from the Rams; but it also makes for unpredictable outcomes which the underdog prefers. The stakes for this game just went up: rather than a chance-at-a-chance-at-a-chance, the winner will be strong favorites against Washington at home. Hoping the Eagles don't get caught looking ahead, and play a disciplined football game today. There's no reason the Rams should beat the Eagles unless you think Nakobe Dean (who to be fair was having a breakout season) was the key to the entire Eagles D. But the Eagles have always been capable of beating themselves.

Elsewhere, the Chiefs handled the Texans fairly comfortably, in a game marred by unfortunate officiating. I wouldn't expect that the game would have gone any differently without a few 15 yard penalties here or there, but it sucks that this is the conversation after that game. I'd like to see the RTP calls become reviewable. The talmudic quality of NFL rules fascinates me, and it's not going anywhere any time soon.

Bills-Ravens was always going to be the main event of the weekend, and there's no way I'm missing it. Rooting for the Bills, as all right thinking people outside Maryland should.

It's an interesting field this year. Good chance that the only real game is in Buffalo, the others being pretty low stakes by playoff standards and likely to be less competitive. In my mind the tiers of teams in terms of pressure are:

Playing With House Money: Washington, Texans, Chiefs, Rams. All four teams here are, for different reasons, already satisfied with their team outcomes and have nothing to prove. Washington has made it far behind a OROY QB in Daniels, and will have the opportunity to add talent and beat out a cursed Eagles team (no consecutive NFCE winners since Andy Reid) and a suddenly in transition Cowboys squad (Deion Sanders taking over the Cowboys would be hilarious and I've no doubt it would end horribly) for the division. The Texans faced a lot of skill-player injuries, but their win over the Chargers was proof of concept for their defense and offense. Both teams figure to be better next year. The Chiefs, meanwhile, have nothing to show to anyone, they're under no pressure here. Kelce may move on after this year, but the team has weathered so many skill player losses already that it's hard not to think they'll handle this one. Win or lose, they'll be back next year. The Rams are the opposite: they were supposed to be in the wilderness with an aging core after selling out for the Super Bowl win a few years back, and it looks like the band had one more show in them. It's understood that Stafford is moving on, but it's amazing he's still here, nobody's job or legacy is on the line this weekend.

Perpetual Bridesmaids: Ravens, Bills, Eagles. All these teams have their QBs signed (one of these things is not like the others!), have made the playoffs with most of the same cast and crew in prior years, and will have most of the same core again next year and possibly the year after that. But none have won the Super Bowl with the current core, and only the Eagles have made it, getting filleted by Patty Mahomes in the big game instead of cockblocked from getting there at all. All three teams will see some sniping about ability to get all the way if they don't hoist a Lombardi, but all three had good seasons and will return most of the same team next year. They face a lot more pressure than the last tier, but not nearly as much as the one team saying

This is Our Year: the Detroit Lions. The Motor City Kitties of Football have more urgency than any other team on this list. The Lions are coming off decades of futility, and their team is going to change drastically next year, with one or both of their coordinators likely to take head coaching jobs elsewhere, and the roster set for turnover. They might never get another chance like this, with the one seed and a tight knit team ready to run through a wall to win.

So as a result, looking at the three predicted blowouts, I think the most likely upset is the Commies over the Lions. The Commies are playing loose and easy, and they've shown no fear in deep water with multiple huge comeback wins. The Lions meanwhile have the pressure hanging over them that if they don't win this game the season is a failure. Jayden Daniels leading a comeback drive to win the game against this battered Lions offense will be a threat unless the Lions put the Commies away. I"m still betting on, and rooting for, the Lions, but I think they're the most likely to fall. The Chiefs just don't seem likely to lose to a team they just beat, while there is no analytical reason beyond variance and losing Nakobe Dean that the Rams will beat the Eagles.

I've always felt like our George was the kind of guy who genuinely looks good in a hat.