FtttG
Gheobhaidh mé bás ar an gcnoc seo.
User ID: 1175
Per the description: "Culture war topics are accepted."
cis-by-default
Is this Ozy's term? I must confess I still don't understand what it's supposed to mean.
The only context I can imagine not knowing the sex of one of your colleagues being a problem is if you've been emailing someone back and forth and you agree to meet in person: "I'll meet you just outside the conference room at 3pm", and you don't know who to look for. But this can easily be rectified by:
- A blanket policy of including the person's staff photo in their email signature, which many companies already have
- A staff directory which includes staff photos, which many companies already have
- The person telling you who to look for: "I'll meet you just outside the conference room at 3pm, I'll be wearing a red scarf." (which they would probably do anyway even if their name was unambiguously gendered and their staff photo was in their email signature)
If I'm a native English speaker who is familiar with the "preferred pronouns" convention and what it entails, if I receive an email from someone from a foreign culture and I'm uncertain of whether they're a man or a woman, their choice to include their preferred pronouns in their email signature will absolutely be helpful. Even if I'm a native English speaker who was never formally trained about preferred pronouns and what they entail, I'll probably be able to infer from context.
By contrast, if I'm a Romanian or Pole who only very recently migrated to an Anglophone country, who has a very weak grasp of the English language, is wholly unfamiliar with woke shibboleths, and who has just received an email from someone whose gender he is uncertain of - I struggle to imagine that that person including their preferred pronouns in their email signature would be terribly enlightening. In that person's position, I would likely assume that "Preferred pronouns: they/them" is just a component of that person's job title, or one of their professional qualifications, or a means by which to contact them (you know, the only stuff that we thought was appropriate to include in a professional email signature before ~10 years ago, and which is still the case outside of the Anglosphere).
In that case one of them could be referred to as the "birthing mother": two mothers, only one of whom actually gestated the child in question.
I think part of the perception of Person A that Person B is basically saying "ROGD isn't a thing. Also it's happening and it's good", is likely due to the fact that what Person A is saying isn't their true objection.
But like, either X is happening/happened or it isn't. If I assert "for fear of being accused of being racist, multiple police departments in English towns independently decided not to investigate Pakistani grooming gangs for years", that is a factual statement which must be judged accordingly. Asserting that I'm only bringing it up to foment anti-immigration hysteria (or criticise Islam) has no bearing on the simple factual question of whether I'm describing events that really happened, or describing them accurately and fairly - even if I really am only bringing it up to foment anti-immigration hysteria. Transparent Bulverism. The fact that I may have ulterior motives/a hidden agenda for mentioning a factually true statement does not in any way undermine the truth of said statement.
On the transgender issue in particular, Wikipedia seems fully ideologically captured by radical trans activists. On the article about women, the third sentence explains that women are only "typically" of the female sex (meaning at least some women are not female), and the fourth paragraph is entirely about trans women.
Remember ten years ago, when a canonical demand made by "geek feminists" was for nerdy men to stop referring to women as "females", because it's creepy, clinical and alienating? And now these same geek feminists are demanding that we refer to women as "menstruators", "chestfeeders" and "birthing people". Anyone else find that weird?
Many of you have probably seen this already, but if not, some of the questions are pretty funny: https://computerwebsite.net/ratpurity
Hol' up, there's an actual Arabic word for "hiding your power level"?
So we're right back to Chesterton's fence/jugaad, as usual.
When we spoke, it wasn't the only argument I made, but I did suspect that the "fifty Stalins" one would have the greatest impact.
In my last job, the head of marketing was trying to get us to put our preferred pronouns in our email signatures (something which is very much not common practice in this country). I was very opposed and told her so, pointing out that there were (to my knowledge) no trans or non-binary people on staff, but plenty of first-generation Polish, Romanian and Brazilian migrants, for the majority of whom the concept of "preferred pronouns" is alien, and who would most likely feel confused and excluded by such a policy. I argued that it seemed like very skewed priorities indeed, to roll out a policy with the goal of making hypothetical future employees feel more included - at the cost of making current staff members feel more excluded.
The thing that most transitioners (and a whole lot of others who don't go down that path) have in common is that they want, very badly, to be the opposite sex.
I think this accurately describes pretty much all trans women who are making even a token effort to medically transition. For a lot of trans men (the canonical example being Ellen/Elliot Page), to me it looks less like wanting to be a man and more like wanting not to be a woman (including not being able to have children, not being someone who is the object of sexual desire etc.). For trans women, medical transition tends to scan as an attempt to fulfil a fantasy; for trans men, an elaborate form of self-harm and self-obliteration. The difference in the tone of trans memoirs is striking: trans women's tend to read like "coming out was the most joyous and uplifting moment of my life, I finally truly understand who I am and now I'm free to be my best self", while trans men's tend to read like "it was after my third suicide attempt during my second hospitalisation for anorexia (prompted by getting raped) that I finally realised I'm actually a trans man, and I am exactly as miserable and dysphoric since my mastectomy as I was beforehand".
I've heard this a lot, sometimes phrased as something like "well, 'birthing person' or 'menstruator' are more precise and accurate terms than 'mother' or 'woman', because #notallwomen menstruate, and some people who menstruate don't self-identify as women".
On the one hand, yes, strictly speaking I suppose the term "menstruator" is more "precise" than "woman". On the other hand, don't bullshit me - you're not promoting the use of this term because it's more precise or accurate than the previous standard. There are plenty of factually accurate assertions which have been known to drive trans activists into violent rages and/or floods of tears. A trans woman can't complain that it's extremely dysphoria-inducing to be described as "male", or for it to be pointed out that trans women are just as likely to be violent as cis men - and then turn around and say "we're just trying to use more accurate and precise language!"
I would expect a dedicated trans man to avoid giving birth.
@zackmdavis theorises that this is a (possibly unconscious) motivation for Scott and Eliezer's rabid defense of trans rights. The massive overrepresentation of trans women in the Rat-sphere is the only defense they can offer against accusations that the movement is a white boys' club.
About halfway through The City and the City by China Miéville. As I mentioned last week the comparisons to Kafka seem well-earned. Also reminds me of Paul Auster's The New York Trilogy a smidge.
I'm a musician in my spare time, but I live in a tiny apartment with my girlfriend - no room for my guitars or even a practice amp. I was browsing a guitar shop in Adelaide in February and I spotted one of these Traveler guitars - extremely compact guitars designed for people on the road. I bought this one. This guitar is tiny: 71cm long, 13cm wide (a typical full-size guitar is 101cm x 38cm) and weighs only a little over a kilo. But its scale length is very slightly longer than my preferred guitar when I'm in the studio, so it's not like I'm cramping my fingers playing a half-size guitar. One of the ways they achieved such a small length is by integrating the machine heads into the body of the guitar, so there's no headstock. The tone from the guitar is very respectable, considering how small the body is. I can plug the guitar into my recording interface connected to my laptop, lay down a quick demo, then stash the guitar under my couch when I'm not using it. It even comes with a removable laprest so you can play it sitting down. Best of all, it set me back less than €400, and I got it on finance.
See also Eliezer's post "Outside the Laboratory". Few people have fully generalised rationality: many people who are extremely intelligent and rational in one domain can be exactly as susceptible to peer pressure, social contagion, motivated reasoning, bias etc. in other domains. I suspect that this is the rule rather than the exception among anyone of above-average intelligence. I'm not sure if I've ever met someone whose intelligence is (per your account) four standard deviations above the norm, but I see no good reason why this wouldn't also be true within that cohort.
Mar(k/y)
Mark and the Funky Bunch.
I understand that your intention with this post isn't anything as simple-minded as "this genius came out as trans, therefore trans is legit and TERFs should shut their mouths". But even if you're not doing that, some people may take it that way, and I see similar arguments for all kinds of political stances all the time, so I'm going to lay out here why the argument is fallacious.
Years ago, Scott had a post arguing that brilliant people also holding some very strange (and presumably incorrect) beliefs is precisely what you'd naively expect. A genius (broadly defined) is a person who identifies actionable patterns that no one else has noticed before, which means that they must have an unusually sensitive pattern-matching ability, which can very easily devolve into fully-fledged apophenia if left unchecked:
Linus Pauling thought Vitamin C cured everything. Isaac Newton spent half his time working on weird Bible codes. Nikola Tesla pursued mad energy beams that couldn’t work. Lynn Margulis revolutionized cell biology by discovering mitochondrial endosymbiosis, but was also a 9-11 truther and doubted HIV caused AIDS.
To Scott's examples I'll add the laundry list of mathematicians who went mad, including Alexander Grothendieck, Kurt Gödel and John Forbes Nash among others.
"This extremely smart person is also trans" is not a persuasive argument that we should take the empirical, experiential or normative claims of trans people/trans activists seriously, any more than the argument that no one should eat sugar because Hitler did too, or that we should all be Christian because that student's name? Albert Einstein. If you think the arguments in favour of this or that component of trans rights make sense, it wouldn't make a blind bit of difference if the only people advancing them were the dumbest people you've ever met; if you think they don't make sense, it likewise doesn't make a difference if everyone advancing them got into Harvard on an academic scholarship, is a card-carrying MENSA member and/or has a PhD in theoretical physics. It's Bulverism in reverse.
Based on the first four paragraphs, I was expecting this post to lead to Mark refusing to attend the "mandatory" harassment training, and management being unable to do anything about it because Mark is such an invaluable asset. Kudos on the curveball, didn't see that coming.
I don't get it

"I'm not the siring father, I'm the father that stepped up."
More options
Context Copy link