@JarJarJedi's banner p

JarJarJedi


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


				

User ID: 1118

JarJarJedi


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

					

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


					

User ID: 1118

The good thing there ageism is likely not going to be the thing in the industry for very long, even if it still exists (got mixed data on that). I mean, with the declining quality of the new cadre, people still would need somebody who is actually able to make the code work. So if someone wants to be employed in their advanced age, and still remembers how to do that, there will always be some demand.

Afghanistan was NOT a hit to American credibility

Depends on what you mean by "Afghanistan". You describe the whole 20 years - and true, the 20 years weren't the hit. The panic run from it was. Even if we recognized we've reached the end of what we could do there, it should have been an ordered dignified exit, not a disorganized run. And the worst thing is, it was completely unforced - there was no reason it had to be that bad, it's just were executed very badly. And that's what hurts credibility - any army can have an unlucky battle and suffer losses, but if it is not able to perform in the conditions where everything is on their side - then it's rotten.

There’s no credibility question here.

On the Putin side, I do agree.

is constantly embarrassing themselves with ludicrous overblown rhetoric and saber-rattling

Why do you think they are "embarrassing themselves"? I mean, it's not what is considered respectable in the West, but would it be embarrassing for a Chinese person to behave this way?

doing the kinds of things Credibility-mongers argue the US ought to have done in Afghanistan/Iraq/Syria: institute a draft

Wait, when the mongers, whoever they are, argued for the draft in relation to Afghanistan/Iraq/Syria? I thought the argument was we should support local allies on the ground and given them weapons, etc. instead of dumping everything and running like we're competing in 400m sprint? What this has to do with the draft?

loosen rules of engagement

Not sure what this means in regards to Putin - what rules have been changed lately and how?

knock out infrastructure of neutral parties that support the enemy

What are you talking about? I've never heard of Putin knocking out any third-party infrastructure, and as most of the aid to Ukraine comes through Poland, I'm sure Poland would be screaming Article 5 very loudly if Putin tried to knock out anything there.

Putin keeps pushing farther with each reputation-shattering defeat to get all the credibility he has lost back and more

I'm not sure what "credibility" you are talking about - Putin and his surrogates repeatedly claimed there's no war, there's just a little special military operation which would end very soon with total victory, and no draft is going to be necessary, not now, not ever. And there's no need for draft anyway because there are almost no losses. Now there's a draft (and it's called "limited" but on the ground it's "grab everybody who remotely looks like capable of holding a rifle"), and with numbers from 300 thousands to potentially a million - which is a humongous number. This is completely contrary to every claim that has been made about the war by Putin and his surrogates for months. What "credibility"?

In Russia, there's not even much of such thing as "credibility" - everybody knows the government lies all the time. I mean: All. The. Time. They're actually ok with it - as long as there's at least some benefit from it - e.g. if the lie served the cause of the Greatness of Russia, then they live in the Great Russia of which everybody is afraid, and thus they're ok with the government lying.

He is behaving as though he is doubling down on a lost cause to prove a point to the international community.

He's not "proving a point". And "international community" is not his main target audience, either. He started a war, with the promise of easy win. There's no win. Now he can either admit he lost - and in Russian culture, there's no way of honorably losing a fight, there's no such concept. Or throw more and more resources into it to hope maybe somewhere there would be some situation that somehow may be presented as a win. Except it's kinda hard when Ukrainians are kicking their asses day to day. The only thing he needs from the "international community" is to falter in their support for Ukraine, so that such "win" situation may present itself - e.g. pressure Zelensky to negotiate without conclusive military victory and surrender the occupied territories. It's not a question of "credibility" as in some gentleman's debate - it's a question of survival for his power structure (and his own person, of course, but it's not only about him personally). If he's not getting a win - he's a loser, and a loser can't be a Tzar. It's not a question of any "credibility", it's a question of claiming the power but not actually having the power - that's something you can't do in Russia.

If you deny somebody their free will entirely, and then give back a tiny bit of it, only enough to kill themselves and thus escape further torture - it's not an exercise of a free will. There's torture involved. Just as "your wallet or your life" is not exercise of free choice. If Alice tortured Bob, until he begged for death, then Bob got hold of a gun, shot Alice, escaped the torture chamber, and lived happily ever after - that would be a restoration of the free will.

torture for suicidal depression.

Torture is a willfull act. Depression isn't. If you have means to stop somebody's suicidal depression, by exercise of your own free will, then you should do it. But somebody getting sick is not a willful act of anybody. When it is a willful act (driving somebody to suicide by means of physical or psychological torture, or other means) then it is commonly regarded akin to murder. The difference is in the presence or absence of the willfull act, you can't just "substitute" it away, it changes the whole picture.

You're confusing "the press is always calling everybody who's not socialist 'far right'" and "if the press is calling somebody 'far right', their actual political affiliation could be anywhere rightwards from socialists". Do I need to draw a Venn diagram to explain the difference?

The "99%" figure is clearly a rhetorical device (I can't believe I have to explain that) - I readily admit I did not make a compendium of all mentions of "far right" ever in the press and calculated how far from socialists they actually are. What I meant (I can't believe I have to explain that, again) by it that the accuracy of this label is overwhelmingly very low and most of the mentions of "far right" is nothing but the label, and can be attached to anybody on the right. And has been attached to Boris Johnson, Liz Truss, etc. I don't watch French and German politics that closely so I'm not sure how that label is being used there.

hysterical tribal right wing persecution complexes

You sure know how to demonstrate that famous "balanced, empiricial rationalism" thing. Or maybe you do think that's what "balanced, empiricial rationalism" actually is? Oh my.

what do you think the odds are that they're anything anyone actually cares about beyond getting Trump?

Very close to zero. It is absolutely clear ploy to attach something to Trump to a) hurt Rs chances in midterms (Trump is not in the run, but anything that smears him also reflects on any Trump-supporting R) and b) if possible, kneecap him for 2024 and c) grab some papers in which something facilitating a) and b) could be found. Well, I guess there's intimidation value too - if we could do this to former President, do you really want to talk about reforming the FBI this much?

Now, can they make anything stick or not is anybody's guess (my guess is no because they couldn't do it previous 9000 times they tried). There are rumors that Trump may have some documents that he could use against people who performed the whole "collusion" thing if he ever comes back (or maybe even if he doesn't) and they were looking for those. But I think it's not the case as Trump already proven his inability to take on the FBI when he was a President, and he's certainly haven't become more capable since then. So no documents could help him with that.

There could also be some documents for which Trump failed to check some required boxes before taking them, likely because same happened to previous presidents, but nobody gave a hoot then (see the whole FARA story or the Logan Act story) but this comes to "who has lawyers with better knowledge of obscure never-before-used regulations and comes down again to politics more than anything. Ultimately, the President has authority to declassify anything he wants, and there's no constitutional limit to that, but who knows what supplementary regulations may be lurking around. Likely all ends in a ton of "walls are closing in" reports after which it quietly dies with D being sure Trump almost sold nuclear codes to Putin but FBI stopped them and Rs being sure it's another in the long list of abuses they suffered at the hands of the corrupt DOJ, and nothing else comes out of it.

There's a big difference though. Allowing a person to kill oneself (by whatever means they chose) is not the same as murdering them. I know some people do not believe free will exist (and I understand - they just can't help it) but in the Western culture the whole system of law has this concept as one of its cornerstones. Whether allowing a person that we think is mentally unwell to kill oneself is moral is a tough question, I think, but equating it to murder makes no sense however you end up resolving it.

While cooks and bussers aren't threatened by automation just yet, waiters very much are. Not to the point of full elimination, but electronic ordering certainly would reduce the numbers of required waitstaff, and it's certainly catching up lately.

TBH I am not sure that the problem of "cut-to-the-bone wages" has a good solution - nobody is going to pay $100 for a medium-quality hamburger, and most of those "need two human hands" don't need much beyond - which means the pool of potential applicants is unlimited, and if you disrupt the market by coercion ("living wage", etc.) you'd either get law-free zones (e.g. hiring illegals or just ignoring the law), or shortages (yes, you'd get your minimum wage, you'd just be doing alone the work three people did before - hello "abusive bosses"), or elimination of low-and-medium scale food industry, due to the economy of it not being sustainable. The only stable resolution here would be to eliminate the contradiction - e.g. by automation.

This makes me think, while the bien-pensants proclaim that the state literally perpetrated genocide (regardless of whether it is true or not, they seem to believe it), they usually do not support restricting the abilities of the state to do such things again in any way. Moreover, the same category of people (generally speaking of course, there might be individual exceptions but I suspect if they exist, they are rare) they support things like forced vaccinations, lockdowns, school closures, blocking bank accounts of people who protest the government, widespread speech censorship and punishment for speaking against the government-approved narratives, equating dissent or doubt about the dogma with violence, etc. - all look like the things which while do not compare to a genocide, could be easily deployed to enable one if the government decides to do something like that again. A person with systemic thinking would use the opportunity of the dedicated day - shirt or no shirt - to discuss these things and maybe make the students start thinking about such matters, and may be how it is possible to make a society which would make things like that less like, and how to evaluate government actions with the lens of "can this also be used to oppress people?".

As for the shirt itself, wearing a non-orange shirt saying "this shirt is not orange, ask me why" would be heroic, in my opinion, but I understand not making a scene part. Taking a stand is usually very costly and only rare people can handle it. If you feel it'd be too much for you, just wear the shirt and try to do what you can to make it mean something you'd want to mean instead of meaningless guilt-absolution gesture. I think as a teacher you have a good opportunity to do so.

Given he's underway on throwing Russian economy back to the 19th century, and decimating productive Russian population, sending them unprepared, unclothed, unfed and unorganized to the meat grinder in Ukraine - I'd say not very likely. But human capacity for delusion is bottomless, maybe one day he decides he's now ready to conquer Europe, or maybe even the USA.

I don't think even in the most feverish dreams Putin does imagine himself the Emperor of Earth, having won the planetary war and conquered all countries. That's too much even for him. And sure, I realize "some people also did some predictions and those came out wrong" is the ultimate answer to every prediction, but I'm still pretty confident in this one. The plan here is not to conquer the West, at least not for now - the plan is to scare away the West and let Putin continue building his Empire - at least until he feels ready to take on the West directly, which is not yet.

Even if you don't, a cursory knowledge of 20th century history should tell one that it's not how you deal with a nascent Fascist state declaring it's going to restore it's rightful place in the world by taking whatever territory it likes to, and nobody should dare to contradict them because they are The Greatest Nation. Feeding them little pieces of neighboring countries is not a recipe for peace in our time.

These are trifles. He didn't start the war to open the canal.

Not everybody can bag a high-level State Department official. Third-grade spymasters must be doing something too. I imagine that's the kind of people they're dealing with.

Looks like the initiative came from the wife, Anna Gabrielian, who was genuinely sympathetic to the Russian cause (there more such people in the US then you think - but then if you read history, in the 1940s there were enough people in the US sympathetic to the Nazi cause) and wanted to do something to help Mother Russia. She got the husband involved, and the trans angle seems to be coincidental to this. This is a weird coincidence, but from what is publicly known about the case, I don't see any play for the trans angle here.

A lot of them probably don't work, because what's invested on paper and what actually exists are a very different things in Russia. But it doesn't matter - they're not going to try to win a war here. They just need to make one successful strike anywhere to cause humongous losses to all Western economic system. And both sides know it.

If there was a world where letting Putin keep Crimea etc. would solve the problem, it could be something to discuss. But we're not living in such a world, and we know it for the fact since February 24, because Putin de-facto had all that already. Ukraine had neither capability nor will to retake any of the territories occupied by Russia in 2014, the West was not inclined to support it with anything substantially more than "blankets and helmets", and sanctions on Russia were feeble and inconsequential. Biden himself supported opening North Stream 2, for one!

To seriously consider that if we roll back to pre-Feb 24, and pretend nothing ever happened, that will be a stable situation acceptable to any side and a long term solution - it's just impossible for anybody seriously thinking about the situation.

To what end? Putin is not going to abandon his strategy of rebuilding Russian Empire, and he is considering the West as the antagonist which they need to fight. Throwing him a bone won't change it - he'd not suddenly feel warm and accepting towards Western values or concerns, or abandon his plans of territorial expansion. What he'd learn from it, is that the price for the bone is X soldiers dead and Y money spent. As long as he finds this price acceptable - and no amount of soldiers dead has ever been unacceptable in Russia, and due to green policies hydrocarbon prices will likely remain high for a while, giving him enough money - he will continue to reach for the bones. As long as the West guarantees there will be always "saving face" at the end, it's all worth it for him. There's no incentive to not do it again, and again, and again, and again.

I haven't listened for many podcasts lately but various new streaming subscription services are equally garbage. Why can't I watch an episode of Star Trek without being interrupted in the middle 8 times for several minutes to listen in the 20th time for the same moronic ad? Not enough that they want me to subscribe to a dozen of different ones, they also insist on shoving ads down my throat to milk my wallet a bit more.

That just makes me to unfold my old Jolly Roger flag that I hoped to retire for good one day, because there's a limit of how much abuse one can take while paying money for it.

A communist still accepts that capitalism exists.

Sure, there's a difference between what communist wants to happen, ideally, and what's existing on the ground now. So a communist may push for higher taxation of private business - but always with the ultimate goal in mind that these businesses should eventually be all nationalized and under the control of Gosplan. So if we talk about tactical flexibility, then yes, that's a thing. But if we're talking about dogmatic position - then I can't call someone who accepts capitalism a dogmatic communist. And I can't see any libertarian support regulation of private business on a purely dogmatic basis. On the tactical grounds, as a political move to improve an imperfect situation and make it less imperfect - sure.

One that accepts the public utility infrastructure principle applied to last mile (libertarians here, not anarchists)

There's no such principle in libertarianism. For anarchists, "public" doesn't mean anything at all, since there's no state. For libertarians, "public" means "operated by the government", and the only thing that can be so is the institutions that are dedicated to preserving natural rights (e.g. the police putting murderers in jail) and enforcing contracts (e.g. if you promised to pay your bills, you better pay them or else). I don't see much place for "public utility infrastructure principle" here. Now, you may like the practical benefits of this, whatever it means - but if we're talking about "dogmatic basis", there's just no place for it, and anybody who accepts it may be dogmatic anything, but not a libertarian. Just as somebody who accepts private ownership of means of production is not a communist, even though there are probably much proven benefits to that concept.

left libertarians would favor a common carrier equal service regulation.

They may favor anything they like, but they're not any kind of libertarians then. It doesn't make sense to use the label "libertarian" for somebody that accepts regulation they like and rejects regulation they don't - everybody is "libertarian" like that, the label will provide zero selectivity then.

In the "community". The idea is to imply they have as much claim on being the members of the "community" as you do, and the fact that you have a home, pay taxes, contribute to maintaining infrastructure, etc. while they do drugs, defecate on the street and turn sidewalks into dumps - is a pure coincidence, and with correct redistribution of resources from you to them it all can be fixed. Usually this claim is advanced by people who hope to do the redistribution of resources.

Am I crazy for thinking her first paragraph is negated by the second?

No, and as soon as you saw the word "diverse", you can predict the rest. The DIE religion credo is very formulaic and well-rehearsed, and you'll see it anywhere the adepts of this particular sect are encountered. It's like "Proletariat of the world, unite!" of DIE. And of course, it does not imply any actual equality (equality is a racist concept anyway) or inclusion for everybody. It implies a hierarchy of oppression (and thus of value, since value is directly proportional to being oppressed) - in which, unfortunately for them, white straight people occupy one of the lowest levels. Well, when you have an hierarchy, somebody has to be at the bottom, right? That's who. Sorry, better luck next time being born.

Taking all this at face value is like reading USSR Communist Party reports in 1980s about how USSR is about to reach communism any day now and comparing it to what happens on the ground. You'd go crazy if you tried to do it genuinely. In fact, you were literally declared crazy (they invented special kind of "schizophrenia" to put dissidents into forced psychiatric care) if you tried to do something like that in public. We're living in much milder environment now - all that'd happen you'd be banned on Twitter and Facebook. But the divergence between religious formula and actual facts is not going anywhere.

I don't understand their motivations.

Can you understand motivations of monks, fasting for years to achieve religious enlightenment? Then you can understand motivations of people who place themselves at the lowest rung of societal ladder (sometimes in pretend to achieve actual power, sometimes genuinely) to atone for the sins of their ancestors. It's not exactly a new recipe. And it doesn't actually cost them that much - at least in what they can see - and makes them feel very righteous.