@JarJarJedi's banner p

JarJarJedi


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


				

User ID: 1118

JarJarJedi


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

					

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


					

User ID: 1118

Of course, the real situation is quite chaotic and a lot is based on a pile of ad-hoc decisions. FDA got lucky with Thalidomide - if you are very slow in approving everything, sooner or later some bad stuff will slip by faster regulators and it's time to uncork the champagne! - so they took it as the confirmation that not approving stuff is much better than approving stuff for many years after. But it's not based on some well-founded general scientific truth. And definitely doctors and what they think - at least if we're talking about rank and file doctors who actually talk to patients, not the ones that spend their days sitting in committees - have pretty little input into it and very little power in the process, as far as I know. It's not like "doctors were ruling it with their awesome knowledge and Trump came and started banning life-saving stuff because he's evil". It's "doctors did what FDA said to do before, and keep doing it under Trump, and will continue to do so long after Trump is forgotten".

If for some reason, people decide the economic data has partisan spin

Under Biden, it was routine for BLS to publish jobs data, gather all the press and then "update" it to lower numbers a couple of months later which the mainstream press largely ignored (rare counter-example: https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/revised-data-exposes-overstated-job-creation-claims-by-harris-biden-admin-revealing-818000-nonexistent-jobs/ar-AA1pc1Ez). Shenanigans like this is what makes people to decide economic data is being used for partisan spin purposes. Of course, since it wasn't Trump doing it, nobody in the chattering class gave a hoot about it. It is possible that "announce high numbers, than revise it to much lower numbers" is how the process works and in fact there's no way to make it work otherwise - I seriously doubt that, but let's assume it were the case. In that case, an objective non-partisan official should have spent a lot of effort to inform the public that's what is going on, and to make sure the corrections get at least as much attention as the original - incorrect - data has gotten, and that the initial estimates are reported as rough estimates, to be substantially corrected later, and not as objective truth. This is not what has been happening.

In general, I think the chances that Biden administration appointed an absolutely neutral, non-partisan purely technical person to a politically sensitive position which generates a lot of press attention, are close to zero. Thus, for Trump it's completely legitimate to dismiss that person, and appoint his own choice. Of course, it should have likely been done on day 1, but given as anything he does will be presented in worst possible light anyway, it doesn't matter too much. Will Trump's new appointee be better? Hard to say, the history gives equal chance both for a competent worked and a complete disaster. We'll see.

I guess really my question is, if US economic and public health guidance is no longer seen as trustworthy

Never had been. Only now, because Trump, it's being highlighted, and once the other side takes the power again, it will be deemphasized again. The quality of data will not improve from that.

how do you get the right decision makers to use the right data to make sound decisions?

Welcome to the basic problem of socialism. Yes, capitalist countries aren't free from it too, no more that airplanes are free from gravity. The data is dirty, and will probably get dirtier as the partisan politicization of everything continues. Would I like for it not to happen? Sure. Do I have any hope it is not going to happen? Nope. One of the reasons why I have no hope is that almost nobody speaks about it in terms "destroying the integrity of research is a problem". It's always "Trump destroying the integrity of research is a problem" - and once it's not about Trump, then there's no problem, right? And the other side, predictably, adopts the mirror stance, so now both sides are hard at work destroying it and everybody pretends it's somebody else's fault.

Will doctors no longer be allowed to administer medications even though they know they would work

That has long been the case. There are a number of medications which are approved in Europe but not in the US, for example.

Well, that's an interesting questions - e.g. banks use deposits to issue loans, but what Coinbase is doing with its 2 mln bitcoin deposits? This is a valid question but very different from the assertion @Tree was proposing. Looking at https://data.bitcoinity.org/markets/volume/30d?c=e&t=b the trading volume in BTC is in around tens of thousands of coins traded daily, which is of course small part of overall bitcoin mass but still a respectable volume as it seems to me. Over a longer period of months, the volume is in millions, so I don't think it'd be right to assume the BTC market is so illiquid that the prices are substantially caused by lack of liquidity. Of course, I am not an economist, so if somebody more qualified could point out an error in this assessment, I'd be thankful, but that's what it appears to be to me.

It's an interesting question whether Coinbase is already qualifying as "too big to fail". I'd say probably not yet, but could become before this decade is over. Of course, massive regulatory interventions would accompany that.

My theory of crypto value is that most of the coin gets stolen every few years.

If by "the coin" you mean bitcoin, it's not true. Currently, about 20 mln bitcoin is outstanding. Known bitcoin thefts, as far as can see, over all history, amount to under 1.5 million, and significant part of it has been recovered. Of course, some thefts may not be discovered until the funds are moved - if somebody knows your keys, you wont know it until they move the coins. But then it doesn't make any difference on the pricing. As I see from reports, e.g. https://river.com/learn/who-owns-the-most-bitcoin/ most bitcoin is owned by individuals, and the largest custodian of bitcoin is Coinbase, which holds around 10% of the supply. Which puts it in roughly the same position as Chase bank (the largest US bank) has in dollar economy.

If you talk about shitcoins, anything is possible, it's a wild chaos and pretty much any wild claim could be true for some subsets of them.

There‘s only like 6 bitcoin left in circulation, that‘s why they are getting bid so strongly.

That's hilariously far from truth, Coinbase alone has over 2 millions, and since it holds the keys for every single one of those, it can trivially recover coins that are known to be stolen. And if they are not known to be stolen, again, there's no difference in economic effects - if the original owner did not intend to move them and also the thief doesn't move them, there's zero effect. One can only wonder - why would anybody bother to steal anything in order to never ever use it?

I still don't understand the economy. The volume of this can't be large - I never actually witnessed anybody buying anything, I assume that somebody does, but not that frequently. The clothes themselves seem to be pretty standard ones, similar to what I see in every store, not some junk or second hand ones, so they must cost something? How these costs are covered? How are they ensured against loss or theft? How much can they be sold for to make it viable - I mean, I can just go to the store and buy the same, so it has to be significantly cheaper than in the store, but it's not that expensive in the store already. I mean, I can buy a shirt at Costco for something like 10 bucks or less, if price is what I'm after, how much lower can they go and still be profitable on low volumes?

That's exactly why I said "not your keys, not your coins". If you keep the keys, none of the blowups can hurt you, ever (well, if you keep away from shitcoins and NTFs, of course) - whatever happens, if you owned 1 BTC, you'll still own it as long as you have the key (and nobody else does). If you play speculative games (like, trade shitcoins, etc.) then well, it gambling, and you may lose all your money at any moment. So coming at it, decide if you're there to invest or to gamble. Both can be done, but the way they are done are very different.

What do you think of "gym muscles"? Referring here to the idea that musculature bought in the gym is less effective than muscles bought by manual labor.

Less effective doing what? Manual labor? Well, yes, you'd do best what you do a lot. And yes, the guy who spent years hitting, would hit better than the guy who spent years lifting metal things, but never actually hit anything. But yeah as others noted, if you work out, you'd get stronger and better in other things where strength matters, even if training for those things specifically would have made you even better.

Coinbase accounts are custodial accounts, which means they hold they keys and you just see the numbers on the website. You don't actually own any crypto, you just trust them to own it for you. Which may be ok for many people, but if that bothers you then you should get a real crypto wallet and hold your own keys. The danger here is that if you mess it up you could either lose the coins completely or get them stolen from you. Coinbase Wallet is one example of non-custodial wallet, though I am not sure how good it is (I personally prefer offline hardware wallets).

What is the boring approach do that

Dollar cost averaging. Takes time though (and of course the time to start were like 10 years ago :) You can either buy regular BTC (combined with cold-wallet storage, that protects you from certain third-party risks, remember - not you keys means not your coins) or if you're only interested on hedging and not owning actual BTC, then ETFs of course. There's a bunch of them from reputable providers now (I don't use them but I've heard about them). Look at the feeds - some ETFs for some reason have insane fees, over 1%, which is totally not warranted given they don't do anything but holding BTC. I see no reason to use those, use cheaper ones instead.

Has anyone discovered a way to let it be openly known that you don’t agree with the group problematizing social norm, while still being accepted into the group

This is literally impossible. Not going to happen. If they are into culture where you know what your running club members think about current politics, and on top of that that they belong to a totalitarizing purity-obsessed ideology, you are not going to change their minds. You can either suck it up and learn to make a mysterious face if you don't feel comfortable openly lying, or you find another group to run with. There wouldn't be "just running" with them.

If you can't find any group that is not infected, the only advice I can have for you is to move. There's a lot of life outside of woke clusters, and a lot of very nice, interesting and different people. You are not going to change the culture but you can choose which culture you're part of.

I've been to LA recently and I wonder if anybody here knows the answer to this: one thing I noticed there is a lot of people selling clothes (and other things but mostly clothes and shoes) on the street. And I mean right on a random street (maybe not random, but looked random to me), not even a tent, nothing, just some hangers or tarps and clothes and shoes on them. A lot of those.

Who are they? Why are they doing it on the street? Where these clothes come from - are they stolen? I have hard time imagining legit wholesaler giving people their goods to just sell randomly on the street - but maybe I'm wrong? What is the basis for this business, how that works? How people wouldn't just steal all the clothes if they steal massively from regular retail shops - are the criminals providing security for them? Or maybe corrupt cops? No regular cops for sure since I haven't seen a single policeman around for all the time I've been in LA.

I've never seen such a thing in any other major city that I can remember. I've seen kinda grey marketplaces or genuine street markets, but those are always in certain designated places and usually have at least some infrastructure, not just randomly deployed on the street. Why this is specifically in LA?

I used to love bookstores and libraries. But now there's like 90% chance that when you enter the establishment the first thing you would see a huge trans flag and a bunch of BLM slogans, if not pro-Hamas agitation. And whatever books are emphasized are selected accordingly. Which kinda spoils the mood quite a bit. So I still go to libraries - and local libraries where I live, while usually hosting a lot of lefty types, are not as aggressive in pushing politics - but I no longer think any bookstore or library is the place I'd feel welcome and comfortable.

I watched it a long time ago when it came out. Pretty decent TV as I remember.

Minority? Maybe? Extreme? Don't think so. There are a lot of women who reject the concept of traditional family and gender roles, and it's not considered "extreme" at all, it's "feminist" and "empowering". I mean, a woman thinking like that would not be considered crazy and would not be socially shunned in any but the most narrow circles. Not everybody would agree with her, but in no way that would make her a social pariah.

Once this is rejected, the position of preferring hot and exciting, even if short-term, partnerships to a long-term investment with a lukewarm partner at best, from which the women does not derive any pleasure - seems only obvious. It's like if I asked you, do you want to get excellent tasty meal every day for free, or a pile of gooey tasteless slop for which you must work for hours, what would you choose? Eventually, an abundance of fancy food may lead to some health problems if you're not careful, but while you're young and healthy, is it even a choice really?

There's no snark there. By USSR laws, a lot of minor acts were criminalized - like being late to work, or any unauthorized usage of kolkhoz property (which was just forcibly taken from the farmers) - e.g. the infamous Law of Three Spikelets so a lot of people that were convicted under supposedly "criminal" articles weren't actually bandits, rapists or bums - they were average citizens trying to survive in the hellscape of total terror. "The data" (which btw you neglected to support with any evidence) can't tell you that, you need a little knowledge about what actually was going on.

Israel strike kills Al Jazeera journalists in Gaza due to allegations of his leadership of a Hamas cell involved in rocket attacks.

Corrected headline: Israel strike kills a Hamas leader and his subordinates, engaged in active warfare with Israel, and those people have been also employed by Al Jazeera.

Israel faces growing global condemnation over its plan to take over Gaza City

Corrected headline: Leftist activists who have consistently opposed every single thing Bibi has been doing since he became Prime Minister now are opposing yet another thing Bibi is planning to do. People who have consistently condemned Israel for every single thing Israel has been doing since its establishment are now are condemning Israel for this thing too.

Yemen's Houthis say they launched 3 drone strikes inside Israel

We launched three drones in the general direction of Israel. They have been shut down, as usual, before they got anywhere near anything interesting in Israel, but hey, we got a headline!

Iran arrests 20 Mossad spies, executes nuclear scientist for providing classified information.

Likely none of them are actual Mossad spies, and now they have one nuclear scientist less (and probably a lot less people willing to become one). Keep going, guys, you're doing great.

I would love to read a regular "weird court cases" topic.

Two hard problems in computer science...

"Since Trump's return to the White House" is a temporal mark. Since Trump's return to the White House I've lost five pounds, but Trump didn't really help me do it. The assumption that Trump personally controls every Prince's operation is quite ridiculous. Which is par for the course for an "expert" from "Geneva-based" NGO, but including this nonsense in the article is on Reuters. And of course no private business needs prior "consent" of the government - that's the opposite of how this works, the government is only supposed to intervene if something is wrong, and if nothing is wrong, the "consent" is implied. US govt, undoubtedly while rolling their eyes very hard, confirmed that they had absolutely nothing to do with it, as expected. Overall it looks like Reuters went to ridiculous length to mention Trump here.

Wait, I am confused - does this have anything to do with Trump or journos are so addicted that they are just unable to report any news, no matter what they are, without mentioning Trump somehow?

Setting that aside, I think that's pretty much what Russians, including the infamous Wagner, had been doing in Africa for a while? And in general some state hiring mercenaries to keep the order - this seems to be a common picture for millenia (Carthage did something like that, and probably more ancient examples exist) though I guess it has been out of fashion for a while, but never really went away.

Obviously I am considering Jews to be a single race in this context, just like Israel does.

Israel does nothing of the sort, Israel does not have racial policies. You completely invented this, out of nothing, and you pretend this is "obvious". It's not obvious, it's you saying things that are not true. Stop doing that.

just like South Africa was a very racially diverse country under Apartheid

No, much more diverse actually. Which you would have known if you knew anything about Israel beyond a bunch of fourth-party packaged woke slogans, but you don't, do you?

Still, the laws of Apartheid made it a country designed first and foremost around the well-being of white people

And Israel doesn't have laws like that. Which again is very easy to learn, if only you tried.

they do not have civil marriage

They do. Ask me how I know? That's how I got married. The marriage in Israel is a bit complex topic, but it's not too hard to learn about it. Again, you didn't even try.

And of course it is completely unreasonable to expect Israel not to take Syrian land that is just there for the taking,

Syria is at war with Israel, and repeatedly refused to sign a peace treaty. When you start a war and lose it, that's what happens. When you are dumb enough to continue the war after losing it, that's going to happen to you again. And yes, it's completely unreasonable to expect from Israel to not act as they deem necessary to protect their borders. If Syria didn't like it, they should have signed the treaty long ago, when Israel offered it. They wanted to keep the state of war instead, because they were unable to admit being defeated by filthy Jews. They are now living with the consequences of it.

This tired talking point about double standards being applied to Israel is the most worn out argument that is just based on playing the victim.

"Tired" is not as strong an argument as you may think it is. If you're tired of hearing the truth, keep being tired, the truth doesn't change from it. Israel has been and continues to be attacked by Arabs - from Hamas to Iran to Husites to Hezbollah to others. All those people eventually find out the dear and grave costs of such actions. Israel does not need to "play" anything - Israel can defend itself very well, it's you and other Hamas defenders who are whining and crying and claiming they are victims - fresh after murdering thousands of Jews and still keeping hostages in Gaza. What they are suffering is the direct consequence of their behavior.

Israeli Arabs are excluded from conscription, so they are not equal.

Yes, they have the privilege of benefitting from all services Israeli society has to offer, without having to risk their lives to defend it. Still, many Druzes and Bedouins serve, and I am sure if a particular Arab citizen wants to contribute voluntarily, he will be afforded this opportunity. If the inequality consists of having less chance to be murdered by other Arabs, then I don't see it as a huge problem, and neither see the Israeli Arabs.

Driving people together is a typical precursor to cleansing.

Nobody "drew them together" to Gaza - they went there voluntarily and they resist all efforts to relocate them anywhere - except, of course, capturing the territory of Israel and cleansing it of the Jews. And their population grows by 2% every year, which is faster than Israeli population (1.5% a year). That's some shitty cleansing.

I have a hard time believing that you are arguing in good faith if you equate a free nation state to a ghetto.

I do not, you do. You said there are "ghettos" - I say they do not exist, what existed in Gaza was completely autonomous self-rule by Gazans, with complete and full withdrawal of any Jewish presence and Israeli control. And the only thing that was asked from them is to please stop trying to murder us. Gaza answered to it by trying to murder Israelis even harder - and succeeding to murder thousands and kidnap hundreds on October 7. That was completely voluntary action from their side, and now they are suffering the consequences of it.

I have seen no poll that shows that all Palestinians are in favor of killing all Jews

Not "all", but 80 to 90 percent. Look up any poll on support of Hamas. You are trying to construct a ridiculous sentence by claiming every Arab in Gaza, including just born infants, is in favor of killing every single Jew. Of course in this ridiculous form it is not true. But it is true that overwhelming majority - about 80 to 90 percent, usually, though it varies with time, but is never not overwhelming majority - of Gazans support Hamas, and their goal of destroying Israel as a state, capturing its territory and murdering as many Jews as they can while doing it. It's their official and well known goal, they have never hidden it, they have gleefully filmed themselves doing it, they have bragged about it repeatedly, and they promised to do it again as much as they can. Israel knows that, and the result of it is what you see now in Gaza. In fact, Israel repeatedly, multiple times, for months, asked Gazans to do one single thing - let the people they kidnapped go, let those Jews live and be free - and they always refused. They will find out there is a price for such actions, and will keep finding out until one day they decide to do what other, more smart, Arab populations decided - that the dream of murdering the Jews and kicking them out of Israel is not worth the pain they will suffer trying to fullfill this dream. That this is no longer the goal they want to spend their lives achieving. Then we will have peace.

If you see Israel for what it is, a society that aims to be racially pure,

That is of course a complete nonsense. First of all, anybody who ever set foot in Israel knows Israeli society is incredibly racially diverse - Jews come from Europe, from Middle East, from Africa, from a huge number of places. And of course Israel is full of other religious and ethnic groups - Christians, Muslims, Bahai, Druze, Bedouin, Circassian, I could be here all day. If Israel ever intended to be racially, ethnically or religiously purified, it is the most crappy purification job in the history of humanity. If you want any concept of ethnic or racial purity, Israel is the last place you want to look at.

It is just torturing the definition of "race" to describe a completely normal and common thing - a national state. Israel is the state of Jews in the same meaning as Japan is the state of Japanese, China is the state of Chinese and Greece is the state of Greeks. True, not all states are national states - for example, in Europe some states gave up on the concept of national state and decided that territorial jurisdiction is all they need, and some states - like the US - have been built on a different model of nationhood. But nation state is still the most common example of how states come into existence, and there's nothing different with Israel - except that somehow Israel is held to insane and impossible standards never applied to any other nation. Even though Israeli Arabs (of which many do not identify as "Palestinians" at all and do not want to live under Hamas rule) have exactly the same rights and citizenship as everybody else, every commonplace economic inequality - which is extremely common in every diverse country, there are minorities which are more or less statistically successful - is looked at under the microscope and taken as proof of "second class citizenship", every common neighborhood quarrel between two loudmouth politicians is taken as the definite evidence of impending extermination of racially impure, even though it never happens, but the liars continue to lie.

then it is absolutely no surprise that the only solutions that it is willing to accept are permanent ghetto's, ethnic cleansing

You can't even keep it straight in one sentence. You can't accuse Israel in both ghetto-ising the Arab population and ethnically cleansing them - it's the diametrically opposite actions. In ghetto, you put the bad people into a confined space, in cleansing, you remove them from the space. Of course, claiming that Israel ethnically cleansed Israeli territory is utterly ridiculous - there are millions of Arabs living there. Claiming they are cleansing Arab territories is even more ridiculous - there's literally nobody BUT Arabs living there, and millions of them too. Now, if you said Gaza is a ghetto, where the Arabs is forcibly kept and prevented from leaving - what would be the solution? Of course, it would be to let them go. But this is exactly what they are vehemently opposed to! There was a lot of proposals to sponsor free migration of Gaza citizens to any place they like - except not a lot of places want them, and for those that do, they don't want to go there, and it'd be ethnical cleansing to allow them to go, right? This is a good example of how idiotic are the demands from Israel - if you let Arabs have their own territory, rules by themselves and completely cleansed from Jewish presence, that's a ghetto, bad thing. If you let them move whereever they choose, except of course eradicating the existence of Israel - that's cleansing. Heads I win, tails you lose.

Of course, the solution to this conundrum is simple. And you don't have to look far and wide for it, you just ask anybody in Gaza what they want. They will tell you - they want to "free Palestine" from Jews. They want Judenfrei from the river to the sea. Not equal rights with the Jews but the Jews dead. It's not some "consequence of the occupation" - it has been like that for over a hundred years, way before the State of Israel existed (look up Hebron massacre of 1929). Is has been always the consistent policy since they started to formulate policies. That's their reasonable solution - that's their only acceptable solution. The final solution is the only solution for them. When you realize that, everything else is easy to understand. This is not all Arabs - those who do not subscribe to the final solution project, live peacefully as the citizens of Israel. Or moved on to live in other places. Maybe there's even some of such people in Gaza too, but the tiny minority. The majority identifies with Hamas project and their final solution. And until they stop doing that, they will be suffering the consequences of their choices.