JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
Not too long ago - and Putin thinks himself to be their rightful heir and the person whose destiny is to restore it. Yes, East Germany was part of the Soviet block too, but the historical links to that territory for Russia is virtually non-existant, so right now nobody cares about it and nobody has any designs on it.
It was a part of the Russian Empire and of the Warsaw Pact. And everything there was considered "Soviet Territory", ask Hungary and Czechoslovakia if you don't believe me.
In short, many Russian hawks believe that far from being a careful long term aggressive planner with a strategy for seriously threatening NATO, Putin is actually a cautious and incompetent leader who has never been willing to confront the West in a serious way until he had a bit of a change of heart sometime around 2-3 years ago
I largely agree with that (an interesting question may be what exactly happened 2-3 years ago that made him change his mind, but let's leave it alone for now). Putin is pretty cowardly person (remember his 1km table) and he usually attacks when he does not expect serious resistance, and that's what he expected in Ukraine - token resistance and quick settlement. But that ship has sailed and now he is in the action. So the question is - how far he will be willing to take it if he feels his political survival needs more and more bloodshed?
The only part I disagree is that there's no "what it would really take to succeed" - there's no realistic scenario that could "succeed" in a way that the above people mean - i.e. capture most or whole of Ukraine without destroying Russia on the way. The best case scenario is what Putin is rooting for near-term - freezing the current battle lines and keeping what they captured (maybe minus Zaporizhzhya - I don't think anybody wants Russian troops loitering around the biggest atomic power station in Europe) and rearming for the next round, while expecting (quite reasonably, given the history) Ukrainians to start squabbling between themselves and tearing themselves apart in the quest to steal the most of Western "reconstruction" money.
In any case, I think that Poland is almost certainly out of the question. The Russian army has barely managed to take the relatively small parts of Ukraine that it currently controls and simply does not have the strength to take on Poland's military in open combat while at the same time fighting Ukraine.
Oh of course. I imagine the Poland question only become relevant if one of the "peace" plans - involving freezing the current situation and letting Putin withdraw most of the forces from there without losing the territories. And even then it'd take quite a while - it took Putin 8 years to get bold enough to attack Ukraine even after he occupied Crimea.
But I think it’s beyond clear that Poland couldn’t be conquored by Russia
Whole Poland? Probably not, at least not in the near future. But some borderline territories, for starters? Say, the corridor leading to Königsberg, now known as Kaliningrad? Why not. Do you imagine President Ocasio-Cortez sending the best US troops into the harm's way to defend places with names like Szypliszki and Stańczyki, which no CNN commentator could even pronounce - especially if it comes with the risk of global nuclear war? I think a lot of people would object to that.
Poland must be “reminded” its western territories were “gift from Stalin”, says Putin
Lukashenko claims Poland is trying to annex Ukraine, Wagner troops want to invade
Just a reminder where Putin's eyes are looking at when/if he's done with Ukraine. We've been through this scenario before, where Putin prepared the invasion of Ukraine for 8 years, absolutely in public, never hiding his intentions, always claiming Ukraine is a fake state, ruled by illegitimate regime and must be liberated - and yet everybody was so surprised when the invasion actually happened. And yet, lots of people are lecturing me all the time about how Putin didn't actually want to do any of that and was forced to do it by "Western meddling". I don't expect many people to change any of their conclusions from this round of saber-rattling, and I don't also expect Putin to invade Poland tomorrow (or this year, or anytime before Ukraine situation has resolved one way or another), but the time may come to be oh so surprised again, because literally nothing pointed to this next move by Putin. And I am sure if that happen, the "meddling" will be blamed again. I certainly don't want to see this happening, but as things are going now, I am afraid I might.
I still see "please mask" decals in many places in California. Nobody does. I've seen maybe one or two persons wearing a mask in the workplace, like in reception, but it could be the case where they had some medical reasons. Haven't seen any maskers on the streets, in the stores or in public transport for a long while. For a Californian, having signs about something everywhere and totally ignoring them is routine, see prop 65.
Well, colonialism and fascism certainly have meanings, but as sure as that, you will find people using it as a general pejorative having nothing to do with the specific meaning. I don't think this can be helped - but I also don't think that automatically makes the word useless.
Also, I think it makes sense to separate colonisation - and colonial status - as an objective classification of relationship between two countries, and "colonialism" as an ideology, which may be useful in some contexts, but many colonial relationships have not been driven by the same ideology and in fact could follow from a wide variety of circumstances. I'd be much more careful in using "colonialism" versus "colony" or "colonisation".
Allied occupation of Western Germany less bad, but what exactly makes the one colonialism but the other not
Allied control over Germany was much more short-lived. I think the first election had been held in 1949. And yes, one could split hairs and claim this election was influenced etc. - and it probably was, to some measure - but if you are to seriously consider it, Germans were managing their own affairs, even though with some influence from the US, pretty soon. In fact, even in 1949 elections almost 1/3 of the votes went to the socialists, and another 5% to communists. Soviet Union created GDR in the same year, and East Germans never did independently manage their affairs, while GDR existed, and the examples of Hungary and Czechoslovakia showed what would happen if they tried. You can argue that until 1950s, West Germany was a US colony, but this period is so short it doesn't really matter.
Eastern Germany probably yes.
Out combined income is about 175k
I'm quite happy to tell my colleagues that I can't afford to go to lunch with them.
This makes me feel maybe you are overdoing it a bit. Unless your colleagues regularly lunch in Michelin star restaurants, you should be able to afford a lunch. You may choose not to go, still - though I always found it's good for team relationships - but you should be able to do it without having your budget ruined.
I think there are two issues at hand here. First is "keeping up with the Joneses", with the Joneses being your wife's family. I think it may be a good thing to talk about how comparing their lifestyle with yours is not a good idea - they do their thing, and your family does yours, and the only two persons that should have a say in it is yourself and your wife. If you both think something is ok, the others should not have a voice to call her a "miser" and she should not feel obliged to live by their standards.
The second question is what your wife wants. You should come to agreement about what are your goals, and you should talk about how wasteful spending makes it harder for your to achieve these goals. Don't make it "you bad, me good" conversation, make it "how we can make it happen" conversation. And yes, it may create some resentment, at least initially, and if it proves hard for your wife to follow through with what you agree - there might be a moment where you have to choose - either you risk a conflict by taking more control over it, or you find means to increase the budget so you don't have to do it. Only you can make this choice.
Well, not as much as Africa, of course, but it was in a subservient position and it was a huge hit to the national pride. Of course it's different, but I think there are also a lot of similarities.
I think this is the stage of "true socialism has never been tried", only ANC/SA flavored, and the reason this "socialism" isn't true because not enough random whites were tortured in enough graphic ways to satisfactory atone for all the past wrongs.
believe that he did not do enough to create structural changes that would lift the fortunes of the country’s Black majority.
In a way it's true. But "taking revenge" surely won't get them anywhere near where they want to be. On the other hand, maybe somebody could suggest them to look into the history of Japan? I think there are a lot of similarities there, with regard to being colonized, being an economic underdog, and restructuring the society to become an economic superpower. I'd recommend not repeating the part where they go into war with the US and get nuked, of course.
But this indirect exchange reminded me that when the culture war pendulum swings back, I should be prepared for the petty tyrants and fools on the religious right to reassert themselves.
I expect exactly that to happen. The proposition would be "you wanted freedom from us? you got trans kids and child drag shows. Make your choice - do you want your child in the welcoming embrace on Mother Church or do you want his dick to be cut off while an old ugly guy dressed as women dances almost naked before him". Not being a Christian I'm not super happy about this binary choice, but I think it's exactly how it would be presented once the inevitable pushback happens.
“rooted in the belief that if you change your body, you will no longer hate yourself”
This certainly sounds like the staple of what is being promoted by trans campaigners, especially to the vulnerable children. It is very common to fell anxiety, alienation and confusion when growing up. And the campaigners - who often are in a position of authority and trust towards children - have an explanation ready: the feelings that you have are there because your body is wrong. If you take these chemicals and cut off these parts, and become a trans, it will fix all that. From the reports, it is certainly looking like what is happening. Of course, the reports could be wrong or distorted, but so far it matches pretty well.
I view Putin as a rational actor with his own motivations and goals, and you seem to view him as a cartoon dictator who walked straight out of Inspector Gadget.
No, that's not true at all. Of course he has his own motivations and goals. And these motivations and goals can be easily seen from his speeches, his state propaganda and his actions. I mentioned some of them (though yes, the long comment was long, so maybe you TLDR it) - for example, his desire to restore the Russian Empire with him at the helm, and his view that he is in the existential struggle with the West. Once thing that is needed to consider them rationally though is not taking them as true factual statements. When he's saying his goal is to liberate Ukraine from the Nazis - it reveals a lot about his motivations and goals, but it does not mean he actually thinks Zelenskiy is a Nazi and he wants to liberate anybody.
to be annoying enough that I just do not think continuing to engage with you on this topic is worth my time
Always your choice. For me, it is equally annoying to be confronted again and again by Russian propaganda templates taken at face value and presented as facts, even when it can be easily seen they have nothing in common with easily observed realities. It is equally annoying to encounter again and again a myopic worldview where everything is blamed on "meddling" and no critical analysis is even attempted. I guess each person has their own pet annoyances. Yet I took the time to explain where, in my opinion, you went wrong. Of course, you don't owe me anything here. Good luck.
Our machines can't do FTL. Machines of the civilization that can do FTL probably would be just as far ahead of ours as a ballistic missile is ahead of a spear. With similar chances of mounting a resistance.
Not Aztecs, but other American tribes adopted horses, guns and other nice stuff pretty quickly, I think, so I don't think they had any serious conceptual barriers with it. One thing when you have a big house that floats - I'm sure they had boats and rafts on the rivers and lakes before, same thing, just bigger - another thing is when this thing flies and drops a volcano on your head. The latter would probably be much harder to deal with.
I think that what they want is a balkanisation and breakup of what is currently Russia into multiple competing breakaway republics which have a series of constant low-level conflicts.
That would be a very nice thing if it happened, and would lead to much rejoicing among Russia's neighbors, but the Deep State explicitly does not want it and is doing everything to avoid it. It even sternly reprimanded Ukrainians not to try and take advantage of the clownish Prigozhin's aborted coup, back when it wasn't clear that it is a clown show. Because last thing they want is to Putin's throne to actually shake and even more horrible, collapse.
They do in fact need to kill Putin for this, or his successor, because he's one of the factors keeping the country together.
Nice theory, except their behavior conclusively proves they want nothing of the sort.
my position is that Putin is someone who the MIC/"deep state" wants gone
Again, literally every action of the US government - which right now can be considered functionally identical to the MIC/"deep state" - suggests the opposite, not only they don't want Putin gone - they don't even want him substantially weakened. And, paradoxically, neither does the alt-Right, who pretend to be the mortal enemies of the Deep State. Very strange situation, but it is what it is.
Putin hasn't been emboldened by anything, this conflict has been a problem imposed upon him by the US that he really would have preferred not to deal with.
This is not only absolutely false, this is very obviously false for anybody who has even a passing knowledge of Russian political and propaganda (which is one and the same) scene for the last decade or so. The most sacred event of the Russian national myth is the Great Victory in the Great Patriotic War (that's WW2 for the Western heathens) and the most cherished dream of every true patriot is to repeat that sacred event again. Putin has been itching for a conflict with the West for a very long time, and has been considering himself in war with the West since he decided he's going to be Peter the Great 2.0 and would re-establish the Great Russian Empire. To his chagrin - and to some feelings of contempt too - the stupid Westerners didn't even realize he'd waging war until he finally sent tank columns to Kiev. Nothing short of that was enough for them. Yes, he didn't just want the conflict - it was his most cherised dream to be the leader of the New Great Patriotic War against the West. And every Putin supporter - there are thousands of them online and they are very very verbose - shares that dream.
Some feeble-minded American conspirologists think because their immediate, closest enemy is the US Deep State, everything in the world, especially - everything evil - is caused by it and nobody has independent agency but their Big Satan. Like in a children's tale, where the mice thought the biggest, strongest, most powerful monster in the whole universe is their house cat. Because that was the limit of their conseptual universe. But we can - and should - do better. There are a lot of forces - and evil forces - that have independent agency and aren't caused by the Deep State. The world is dark and full of terrors. Sorry to disappoint. No, Putin's evil not caused by "US meddling", whoever sold it to you lied to you.
He has already taken the territory that he cares about and nobody outside the most committed partisans believe that it'll be returned - Crimea
No he didn't. He wants the Russian Empire in the long run - yes, the whole thing, as much as possible - and Ukraine as a wholly owned protectorate at the short term. And he has almost achieved that - if Russian generals were a little less of a gang of thieves, if Ukrainian field troops were a little more of a cowards, if the money allocated for buying Ukrainians was not stolen 99% but only about 60%, if Ukrainians wavered in 2022 like they did in 2014 - Ukraine would have Medvedchuk or some other puppet as a premier minister and the war would have been in Karpatian mountains, mopping up disorganized guerrilla troops. What he has now is what he had before the war, plus a bit of useless ground where his army already stole everything movable and ruined everything that could not be stolen. Now, when his goal, which seemingly has been so close within reach, is completely outside his grasp, he may pretend it's exactly what he wanted, but it is a lie, he knows it is a lie, we know it is a lie, and it is belied by his own and his comrades' own words many times over.
His motivation for the conflict now is to make sure that Ukraine is a servile client-state that can never host NATO forces/missile interdiction systems
That's some computer-game style BS, his motivation in 2022 was to own Ukraine, and now his motivation is to not lose the war as much as he can. NATO forces are already at Russian borders, and any "interdiction" can be done from Poland, Romania, Baltic states, Finland, etc. On top of that, where these missiles would be aimed at? France? What for? It's a completely ridiculous scenario.
does not interfere with the flow of gas to europe
Before the war, the last thing Ukrainians wanted to do is to interfere with any gas flows. They made tons of money on it, and they were fine making tons of money of it during the whole lukewarm war of 2014-2022. If Putin wanted to ensure that, the exact thing he needed to do is - nothing. Ukrainians loved the gas money, Germans ecstatically loved the gas money, everybody loved the gas money. Putin sacrificed all of that for his Imperial Dream.
does not cause problems for the native Russian-speakers in the area/attack Russian territory
Nobody gives half shit about the "the native Russian-speakers in the area", In fact, most males of the military age that lived in that territory has been used as cannon fodder long ago. And the trademark way of Russians dealing with any built area is a massive artillery bombardment until there's literally no intact buildings is left. I'm sure "native Russian-speakers" that survive that by some miracle appreciate the protection. I realize not everybody knows the situation on the ground well, but some effort needs to be taken not to take the basest propaganda bullshit as truth. This has as much truth in it as Hitler's actions in 1939 were to ensure Czechs and Poles do not cause problems for the native German-speakers. I mean, one has to be real special case to really believe something like that.
He's most likely going to get what he wants too, no matter how many Ukrainians the Americans want to sacrifice.
That depends mostly on whether the Ukrainians prove to be smarter and better warriors than the Deep State thinks they are. Right now they are given as much weapons as needed to not lose, but not to win - exactly because the Deep State wants the conflict to be frozen and festering, not decided in anybody's favor. Putin, largely is now ok with that, because he could use time to re-arm, upgrade his military capabilities (for example - his drone game is shit, but he's learning fast) and turn the captured territories into hellscapes that would cost Ukrainians a lot to recapture - hopefully, to him, more than Ukrainians want to pay. As he is completely insensitive to losses, and Ukrainians are quite sensitive, it's a smart game for him. As I said, the only people who are not OK with this arrangement is the Ukrainians, but their task is not enviable - they need to do much better than the Deep State thinks they can, and fast, because otherwise as soon as the Deep State notices they win too much, shipments will start to be delayed and contracts start to fall through and all that kind of thing. I don't know if they can do it - it's up to them now.
Maybe more like between Aztecs then and the Spanish now. Modern technology - and modern military - has powers that for a pre-technological person would not be otherwise appear possible, such as clairvoyance, instant communication over any distance, power of flight, ability to deliver overwhelmingly destructive strikes at any point within minutes, near invulnerability to most weapons, etc. Maybe 16th century Aztec could conceptualize many of these things - in a way that we could conceptualize FTL - but they certainly wouldn't be able to even imagine how one could achieve such feats, and certainly any resistance they could put up to somebody who can do all that would be doomed from the start. But also, modern Spanish probably wouldn't attack them anyway.
Also one could imagine interstellar travel implies FTL, which implies access to physical principles beyond our current science or at least out current and prospective technology, and to energy levels well beyond what our technology is capable of. So I don't think there would be much use in "resistance". That said, I agree that it's unlikely aliens at this point of their development would have any interest or use of conquering humans. That's like human civilization mobilizing to conquer a particular patch of lichen somewhere in northern Canadian forests. What for?
The MIC really wants war, and their influence over the US government is strong enough that it reaches beyond partisan affiliation
That may be true, but the war they want is not destruction of Putin's regime. What they want is something like the current war in Ukraine - remote, long, expensive in money but not in American casualties, low-stakes as to anything pertaining to the US, and prolonged as far as possible to ensure return business, preferably without generating too many headlines that would promote changing anything. This has nothing to do with "Putin's skull" - if fact, if anything, that requires Putin to be in power, otherwise who'd the war be with?
That's why I object to the premise she wanted Putin's skull on the wall - Putin is a business partner for her, not a mortal enemy. True, in these spheres there are no friends and sometimes competition is very vigorous, but until Feb 2022, Dems did not even see Russia as a real opponent (the 80s called, remember?). And Clinton saw it as a regular business partner, among others. The war does not prevent that too - war is business too. Maybe not for Ukrainians (though for some there it is, unfortunately), but for Clintons it would be. And that's why it emboldens Putin - he knows that for the right prices, he can have Ukraine or almost anything else he wants - because it's just the question of finding the right deal. And he thinks he can afford the price of some hundreds of thousands of Russians being dead and some oil money spent - if that gives him what he wants.
it's not our fault that black kids in Baltimore can't read.
It's definitely not. And I agree both on the point that petty vindictiveness is petty, and that the left wants to go much further than banning the confederate flag. But I also can't help but wonder why one wants to associate with the confederate flag at all? I mean, they also (probably?) want to ban the Nazi flag, but nobody has any feelings about that, as far as I know. To me - and I'm not leftist at all - confederates were very much the bad guys, especially the ones that were in control at the time of the war (which was like less than 1% of the population, who owned pretty much everything, including vast majority of the slaves, as far as I read). Yes, beating the dead horse is silly, but why that horse is there to be beaten at all? Why it's the thing at all? That part it's not clear to me. I realize it's being used by the left to achieve their eternal purpose - power over everything - and that's wrong. But I also want to understand why Confederate thing is alive at all to be used too.
As for the good old days, I'd settle for the pre-2010s racial truce.
I'd do the same, but I don't think there's a way to unsail that ship... Recovering from all the "uniting the nation" and "healing the differences" of the Obama era and the following is going to take a long time, especially when half of the country wants exactly the opposite - they feel like they're winning so they want to push further and further. Why have a truce if we're about to sack their capital and pillage their homes?
Let’s be serious those people can’t do intellectual work.
That's not necessarily a problem. There are a lot of positions which require people who would be able to follow instructions, show up on time, do what they are told without rocking the boat and not go crazy from working in a boring plastic-covered cubicle for decades (or at least not too soon so that training costs would be recovered). The school grades used to do this function, or tests, but now the school releases people who literally can't even read their own diploma, so that went out of the window, and tests are racist, as we all know. So the college certificate guarantees the owner can minimally function within the social environment and do whatever motions are necessary to get the degree, ergo with high probability they can do the functions that are necessary to keep the job. Even supposedly "creative" professions nowdays produce 90%+ second-hand repetitive derivative crap. Plenty enough space for people with a diploma and not stellar IQ, especially if they speak the correct jargon - which is another thing the diploma would give them.
I actually think the modern world would be very confusing for people with an IQ well above there let alone doing intellectual work.
I have pretty high IQ (didn't really test since late teens but it's high) and the clown world is extremely confusing to me. But my work - which requires a lot of creativity - does not require me such levels of understanding, and arguable almost no work does. Most require you to be effective in a pretty narrow bounds.
This nitpicking petty vindictiveness against the smallest confederate symbols sounds silly. But the value that some of the reds attribute to it makes me think maybe it's not as silly as I think - maybe it does symbolize something bigger than a horse. And if it does, what exactly does it symbolizes? How much of it is just resentment feelings about being conquered and reconstructed, and how much there's a desire to bring good old times back and what does it mean to bring them back exactly?
but I do mean arguments other than moral ones like “people ought be able to retain the results of their labor”
Because societies where people aren't able to retain the results of their labor soon start to have toilet paper shortages, proceed to one half of the population putting the other half into gulags, and then the society collapses? Of course, the true wealth redistribution have been never tried. But the results of the wrong ones so far are not encouraging. Of course, pointing to taking $10 from Bill Gates and giving it to this hungry kid is easy. But once you try to make a system out of it, it somehow all ends up in no toilet paper and the hungry kid remains as hungry as before.
Are there any low-overhead charities out there where you can mostly-directly send money to poorer people?
All the national orgs I've used to donate over the years recently gone woke and I stopped trusting them. Probably a local charity would be the best bet. Would be happy to be proven wrong (though really no need if the local charity is enough).

Yes, I assumed it was more likely to be one of those.
More options
Context Copy link