@JarJarJedi's banner p

JarJarJedi


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


				

User ID: 1118

JarJarJedi


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 10 21:39:37 UTC

					

Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation


					

User ID: 1118

Can you just "reject" a SCOTUS ruling? I was under impression that's not how things are usually done in the common law system, but who knows, these days...

I have yet to encounter a person who seriously quotes the "fire in the crowded theater" thing and also can answer what was the actual case about. Because if you know that, you'd likely to shy away a bit from quoting from that case, where the court basically decided anti-government speech is a crime. That's usually not what many people want to sign under (give it time, I guess?)

and that reassured him he was not “mad or delusional

Protip: If you need to be reassured in that by a chatbot, you are mad and delusional. Also if you have sexual (or any other) relationship with a chatbot.

The Donald Trump-appointed judge’s move could undo years of efforts to enhance coordination between the government and social media companies.

They are saying it like it's a bad thing or something.

It's like taking drugs - sure, some drugs can inspire creative breakthroughs, if you also do a lot of creative work. But if all you do is taking drugs and looking for drugs and talk about which drugs to take - there would be no creativity coming out there. I think you need a solid foundation and maybe a little crazy to make it not boring. But if you have 100% crazy and none of the foundation - then it's just chaos.

Freedom of religion and freedom of speech are completely different issues with completely different jurisprudences.

I don't think they are. First of all, if they were completely unrelated, it'd be weird for them to be mentioned as part of the same constitutional amendment. After all, it's not like the framers wanted to cram everything into a single amendment - they had ten of them initially, they could have eleven. It's more likely that they did consider it all part of the same issue - the freedom of one to live out and speak out their own conscience.

Of course, the caselaw concerning each parts is different - but that's natural for big issues, within freedom of speech there are also a lot of subdivisions, and sub-sub-divisions with its different law framework. Of course, when considering a specific case, one needs to understand that - e.g. not to try and apply commercial speech precedent for religious speech question, or something like that. But they are not entirely unrelated.

permissible scope of a law that protects LGBT rights, it is not entirely inaccurate either.

If one likes, the case can be formulated as "do 'LGBT rights' include the 'right' to force certain person to speak in certain ways because the person doing the forcing identifies as LGBT" and fortunately, it was decided that the answer has been "no". I am a bit disappointed that the actual answer had to involve religion, because I don't see why it would be more permissible to force an atheist or an agnostic to speak against their will than it is for a Christian, and why should I hide behind a crucifix to not be forced to perform speech I do not want to perform. The mere fact that the speech is not voluntary should have ended the deal. But I guess a small win is still a win.

In the case of the state, to ensure security — of all kinds

Especially of the kind that means "we are secure in our power, and nobody can oppose us, whatever we do".

In the case of big organizations to (i) learn about the user so as to improve the product

Where "improve" may mean "extract more value from the user".

So, if the intentions are good,

That's one towering "if" right here.

They cannot admit to surveillance/collection of data

If you can not admit what you are actually doing, you may not be in the good guys territory anymore.

The cached meaning of 'surveillance' in the minds of the people is ... erm ... not good. They need to invent a new phrase.

The term for this is "euphemism treadmill". It's not a new thing. If you started to call crap "candy", the crap doesn't stop stinking, but the word "candy" would start stinking.

Cc: 'global warming' needed to be jetissoned for 'climate change'.

And that changed everything. Wait, it actually didn't. It changed nothing.

Well, we can see from their reactions that Harvard et al. interpreted it exactly as "you can assign points for being the same race as other people who experienced hardship and bigotry, if you write an essay about it". Just mention "systemic racism", and it's done. So at least until they are successfully sued for it - again, they'd try to keep on doing the same thing.

I covered some of it here: https://www.themotte.org/post/550/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/114107?context=8#context but if you're lazy, you could make it easier - "Diversity and inclusion is our strength!" is pretty much enough to signal what policy is expected, but I am not sure it'd be easy to win a lawsuit claiming "diversity" is an inherently racist criteria. Of course, there could be one or two employees in the admissions office who would not understand that "admitting diverse applicants" means "admit less whites and Asians" - but these could be identified and targeted at the next round of right-sizing, until everybody knows how the system works.

I've read an article a couple of years ago (unfortunately, link long lost) about how they did it in California (where explicit racial discrimination is banned). They hire a set of "evaluators", which evaluate the candidates and rank them by their acceptability (I don't remember the exact details of ranking mechanism, but it's largely irrelevant here). They have the training program, which never explicitly mentions race of anything like that. The most they get is the standard "we value diversity, inclusion and treating everybody in the most inclusive and welcoming manner" spiel. And they have a set of supervisors, which oversee the training. The training is done as a set of fake (or maybe real, from past years?) student profiles, which the candidate evaluator has to evaluate, and then the supervisor reviews it and tells the candidate where they may be wrong, if they are. The author of the article was one of the candidates. The supervisors, again, never explicitly mention the race or any prohibited criteria, but if the candidate evaluates certain profiles not in the "correct" way, the supervisor suggests they may want to reconsider - maybe they didn't take all the necessary factors into account, or overlooked something? They may remind them to re-read the policies, etc. That is repeated, until the candidate "gets it" - and starts producing the results that satisfy the supervisors - or the candidate "doesn't get it" even after a set of repeated suggestions, and then it turns out their services are not required at the present time. The author of the article was one of the latter.

If you see similarities to some other, currently popular, area of research - it is probably not coincidental. But it's hardly possible to prove that any racially discriminatory criteria were used. Of course, somebody has to train the supervisors, but it's California we're talking about, Berkeley could supply thousands of such supervisors which wouldn't need a word of discoverable explanations to produce the correct results.

Like what exactly are you solving for if you think that you should just accept the most meritorious students?

  1. Probability of successfully graduating and acquiring knowledge and skills defined by the curriculum

  2. Establishing a social environment where one is among high-achieving peers which would support each other in achieving (1) and is able to establish networks that would help them post-graduation

  3. Allow professors to teach on a level that is suitable for high-achieving students instead of being bogged down by the need to cater for the lowest common denominator - which will also allow access to higher level of teachers

  4. Establish a basis for at least part of the graduates to become superstars, adding their prestige to the prestige of their alma mater

  5. Establish a lifelong relationship with a large number of highly successful people, who would support the college financially, socially, organizationally and culturally.

If you accept a bunch of random people, some of which drops out and some barely graduate with a bunch of C-, none of this works well. For some colleges, the "gimme money, I give you the papers" model works, but Harvard obviously wants to be more than that.

It probably bar them from explicitly instituting a policy that mentions race. But it won't ban something like "if you come from a community that previously experienced hardship and bigotry, and is under-represented in higher education, you get +100 points", while the determination of the "community" is such that nobody white or Asian would ever qualify.

The President has much more free hand there than a rank-and-file bureaucrat. It'd be very hard to sue the President for not nominating me to Supreme Court because I am a white male. It's a very exclusive unique position, and it'd be almost impossible to argue - even if I were an accomplished law scholar, which of course I'm not - that I deserve that particular position, and while the racism here is indeed brazen, formulating a legal policy that would prevent it while not unduly constraining the President's choices would be very non-trivial. On the other hand, university admission or hiring practices or any other governmental action applied en masse is easier to regulate, since it requires some rules, procedures, official criteria, etc. It won't be sustainable if Harvard president had to personally decide on each case. There would be institutional procedures. That's where you can look for discriminatory policies. Of course, it's possible to hide them, and I am sure Harvard will try their best to do just that, but at least they couldn't do it in the open anymore. It's not the victory over racism, but it's a step in denormalizing it, with is a necessary precondition to victory.

I think the academia has been preparing for this for years, moving from "objective metrics with AA bias on top" (like SAT scores, but the passing score is different for different races) to "plausible deniable 'holistic' judgements" - where one can't really prove any bias at all. Yes, if you measure by any objective merit criteria, the bias is apparent, but you see, we're not using these criteria, we are using "holistic view", which does not explicitly name race as a factor, good luck proving in court we're using it heavily. They'll just start being more careful about that and develop a newspeak that ensures discrimination is called something else. If academia is consistently good at anything it is at producing impenetrable jargon.

That's some vile bullshit. NY governor - and others - directly caused deaths of thousands by their policies of forced admittance of sick individuals in the nursing homes with healthy ones. But if I want to go to a beach - alone - and swim in the sea, I am killing the elderly. Elites dined in large luxurious companies, maskless - but if I go to a store, I can not buy anything beyond pre-approved list, because I am killing the elderly. Politicians called to go to the Chinatown and hug random people there because this would show I'm not racist, politicians condone mass riots smack in the middle of pandemic because "fighting racism is more important for public health" - but if I meet two friends for a glass of beer, I am killing the elderly. Screw that. I would consider accepting the baloney about "sacrifice" if the people who demand sacrifices from me behaved like they think it is serious. When they proudly stood maskless in front on masked servants, this is not "sacrifice" - this is showing that they are the patricians and we are the plebeians. When they closed down businesses, but had them private open for them on the down low - this is not "sacrifice", this is oppression. When they destroyed thousands of small businesses while "disappearing" tens of billions of dollars of "covid fund" - this is not "sacrifice", this is fraud.

There was reason for lockdowns and they saved lives

No they did not. You can worship this idol however you want, you can believe that dances with tambоurinеs, sacrifice of chickens and wearing special religious garments and performing elaborate rituals is the only thing that keeps the world from collapse. That's you religion, and I won't say anything about it, it's between you and whatever gods or other entities you worship. But when you try to force me into your religion, when you deny all empiric evidence and logic in service of your religious dogma, and when you lay all the atrocities that fellows of your religion committed - at my feet, I have nothing to say but "screw that". Your attempt at emotional blackmail failed.

people on this site tend to deny that

People on this site deny that too: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(23)00461-0/fulltext

Mandate propensity (a summary measure that captures a state's use of physical distancing and mask mandates) was associated with a statistically significant and meaningfully large reduction in the cumulative infection rate (figure 3B), but not the cumulative death rate

In other words, mandates help lowering infection rate among low-risk populations, but did nothing for high risk populations. In more mundane words, all this destruction and fascism was so we could have the cough a couple of months later than otherwise, with no change in outcome.

Although, yes, the details of their implementations were often idiotic.

Oh, sorry, I forgot - true socialism has been never tried. Maybe next time.

"In your interest" is very vaguely defined. Is being perceived as a cool dude in your interest? For myself, I don't really care for it, but many other people behave, like they do. Can I deny them their agency and claim that their true interests lie elsewhere? I think it's be presumptuous. If they say they want to be cool, then they want to be cool. And then consuming brands that are perceived as "cool" would be in their interests.

There's also the third one - capture the territory for the brand in the cultural space. In fact, most of major brand's ads are like that. Coca-Cola ads don't advertise where you can get your sugar hit $0.02/bottle cheaper than usual. They advertise that drinking Coca-Cola is part of the American culture and by drinking it, you're being a good member of society, and all that. When I was in market for a car, I read a ton of articles, discussed on forums, read manufacturer sites, signed up for various deal groups, etc. One thing that was absolutely, 100% useless for me was any brand's ad campaigns. Local dealers, which do run campaigns sometimes, and those could be either 1 or 2 - sometimes gave useful information about actual deals. Brand's ads are almost always "Driving is cool, do it!". Sadly, though completely useless for me, ads of this type seem to be pretty effective overall.

Designing ads that do not disrupt UI or UX, but instead align with the default context within which they exist. Cc: Reddit and Quora's native ads.

Better data collection to improve relevance.

This is about as useful as saying "the solution for crime is not telling the criminals theft and murder is bad, and putting them in jail. The solution is to make people just realize they shouldn't steal and murder". Good luck with that, please tell me when you find out how to do that. So far all the ad industry is running - no, flying on super-sonic jets - in the opposite direction. I am lazy, so I tried to get by without installing ad blockers a couple of times when getting new phones/tablets. Nope. It's not possible. Ads eat so much CPU/memory/bandwidth that it is just intolerable to me. I'd rather stop using the device altogether then use it with ads. And the targeting of the most ads remains to be horrific. I'm pretty sure by now ad networks know about me more than I bother to remember about myself. But they still show me crap that is so dull, repetitive and annoying that it threatens my mental health if left unblocked. I get the role that the ad industry played in the spread of the free services on the internet and supporting independent creators. But this once useful function turned malignant, and now it grew entirely out of proportion and became evil. And I see no way to make it go back to benign forms.

Yes. I am seeing companies who didn't touch WFH with a ten-foot pole now opening remote positions. Once this happens, there's no stopping it - even if you ban WFH, people would just leave for a company that doesn't. Unless you pay fabulously well - which only a small percentage of companies does, and even for them it may be not fabulous enough to justify living in a place like San Francisco - you'd just get your market reduced, that's all. Only a total memetic blockade of WFH on the management level has been sustaining the "local only" model, but this has been broken and I don't think it's coming back. It can come back in certain companies, but not industry-wide.

Now, would you expect to gain insights on the complications and intricacies of their politics by reading western media?

By reading only Western media, you can't. By reading all kinds of media - including, but not only, Western - you can make some progress towards it.

Well would you be ready to say that all the Chinese people who deny these things or find them implausible are dirty liars?

If they are in China at the moment, or their relatives or family are - no, they are probably just afraid. Justifiably, I may notice, as we have examples of people persecuted for saying things the regime does not like. I wouldn't call a dirty liar a person that says something he knows to be not true, but also knows if he says the truth he'd risk his life and maybe the lives of others. I'll rather call him a victim. If they are outside China's control - I'd have to look into them further to determine whether or not they are liars, so it'd go on case by case basis. If they say there are no human rights violations in China - they are liars for sure, as there are documented examples of them. If they say the specific violation did not happen - it may be true, or they may be mistaken, or they may be lying, again - case by case.

Thinking one can answer these questions without any sort of reliable insider information source is delusional

Answer definitely? No. Get to a high degree of certainty? Yes. Just as it is done with all other things we can not observe or perceive directly - by carefully collecting, evaluating and filtering available pieces of circumstantial evidence, until a general picture starts to become clear. And then updating this picture once new pieces of evidence come in. Current picture suggests China is under a totalitarian fascist regime which has a complete disdain for anything called "human rights" in the West (I'm not sure there's such concept in China at all?), routinely prosecutes dissidents and anybody who dares to contradict the party line, operates concentration camps and performs multiple atrocities.

It might be if these tweets are dumb in a way that reflects a typical dumb thinking pattern. Which, unfortunately, it kinda does. I mean, I can get the catturd2's thing - ok, you don't care about anything that happens outside the border, fine (though what "proof" do you expect? All the proofs are known, and all the fixes are in, that's what you're getting, no refunds). But the rest is just dumb reflective "all this is lies" automated contrarianism. Very popular among certain circles, because it's low effort but makes you look stunning and brave. At least the opposite side has to dress up (and some even cut off their dicks for it) - these ones are as low effort as one can be.

has pressured Russia into developing better drone technology

No, their invasion has pressured them to do so.

What drone technology? The technology of buying them in Iran, repainting them and pretending it's Russian? I think they had this technology before.

why it was the smart thing to promote Ukraine entering NATO, rather than negotiating Ukraine as a neutral region

Because there can be no Ukraine "as neutral region". Russia sees Ukraine as part of the Russian Empire, detached from it by deceit and fraud. It wants it back. It will not respect any agreements or papers that would prevent that. They may say whatever it is prudent at the moment, but they will never respect it.

The only thing that can deter Russia is the perspective of the armed conflict with NATO. They are not deluded enough to think they can manage that. Thus, Ukraine in NATO means peace (with Russian seething but unable to do anything about it), and Ukraine being "neutral" means Russians are going to attack it sooner or later. And they did.

I have no idea how someone could consider it “appeasement”.

Factually. They wanted to take over Ukraine since Putin decided he's going to be Peter the Great 2.0. Once the decision was made, the question only was when they'd decide to try. They tested it out in 2014 and figured out weak and ineffectual sanctions is all the West can field. Adding commitment not to protect Ukraine would only reinforce this assessment. In 2022, they decided the opportunity is ripe - America's president is weak and senile, Europe's elites are weak and corrupt and lust after Russian oil profits, European militaries are largely a joke, US society is divided and half of the country thinks the other half is Russian agents - it's a good time to act. Appeasing them might only mean they decide the good time to act was earlier (maybe not under Trump - he's too crazy, may do something unexpected, better wait until he's out).

It seems to me that the worst case scenario has transpired: our continual pressure and influence in Ukraine has destroyed the country

Bullshit, there was no "influence" there that had anything with any of Ukraine's problems. It is true that corrupt US people meddled there (yes, Burisma), but it was only an opportunistic grift. Corruption in Ukraine has been endemic without any US involvement and much of it was instigated and facilitated by Russia. Mere presence of Russia next door - where corruption is ingrained in the state structure and which is economically towering upon Ukraine, so that anybody who joins the corrupt Russians may immediately wield immense comparative power in Ukraine - is a huge corrupting factor, but much of it remained from the Soviet and early post-Soviet times too. Only the war forced Ukrainians to clean up the house a little - and much of it still remains. It's not a good time to talk much about it, but nobody who knows what's happening there can not ignore it.

As for the choice of whether to go back to the bear hug of Mother Russia or become an independent nation, they made this choice in 1991, confirmed it in 2014, and it has been made irrevocable in 2022. Nothing about it had much to do with the West - in fact, the West has been kinda lukewarm in treating Ukraine in any but opportunistic manner, mainly because pissing off Russia too much - before 2022 - wasn't in anybody's plans. Too much money to be made on oil and gas. Germany is a shining example of it, of course. Having a hot war in Europe changed it quite a bit. But let's not project that changed attitude back to when it didn't exist. Europeans openly laughed at Trump's suggestion that the conflict with Russia is imminent - remember?

has finalized the alienation of Russia from the West,

That has been a done deal by mid-2010s. And the West couldn't do much about it, really.

has influenced Arab nations into cozying with Russia

Arab nations aren't idiots. When they see US is running away from Middle East, and Russia is ready to invest $$$, they know which way the wind is blowing.

What will we gain in five years from it all?

That depends on whether US will dare to help Ukrainians to actually win the war. If they do - weakened Russia that would temporarily sit within their own borders and not mess with anybody else. If they don't - bloodbath in Ukraine and ultimately Russian takeover of Moldova, and possibly attacking the Baltic states. Also kiss Taiwan goodbye, if Russian can do shit like that, China certainly would want too.

Except the general sentiment of "kicking the asses of Islamist fanatics can't be bad" I don't think anybody in Israel cared much about what's happening in Afghanistan. They have enough problems with Iran and bordering Muslim states to care about something so far away. It's small enough to not pose any threat, there were almost no Jews there (I think for a while there was two - and of course they didn't get along - but now there's none) - why bother?

it's ironically quite philosemitic to ascribe agency only to Jews

There's a joke about Rabinovich who was subscribed to every anti-Semitic newspaper there is (probably going back to pre-revolution times in Russia). When asked why he's doing that, he answers - well, you see, if I read Jewish papers - the Jews are attacked, the Jews are oppressed, the Jews are murdered... It only depresses me. But when I read these papers - the Jews run Russia, the Jews run America, the Jews run Europe, the Jews buy everything, the Jews always win... It makes me feel a bit better!