JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
I like it.
Alice: We need to have more DIE.
Bob:Why?
Alice: It's because it is wonderful for company performance! Diverse companies do so much better financially?
Bob: This looks like confusing correlation with causation and maybe also we need some kind of confounder analysis?
Alice: Well, we need to put some women in our coprorate board and surely the results would show it!
Bob: OK, we did that and there is no significant relationship between women on board and performance.
Alice: Surely that's because women were always marginalized. This is what always happens.
Bob: So, how many women we need on the board to see some performance results that were promised?
Alice: Oh, come on, enough with that. Who cares about the financial performance anyway? It improves equality and team satisfaction (under certain circumstances)!
Bob: Why "equality" is even a goal - is it a communist cooperative? If I work better than Steve over there, why should we have equal outcomes? What "under certain circumstances" means - do we have the same circumstances here? And I heard people who are unhappy with DIE may have trouble staying employed in some places - would it confound the results on satisfaction with DIE?
Alice: Completely unrelated, you now have an appointment with HR tomorrow at 9am. They want to send you to a new exciting training "Avoiding offensive microagressions at the workplace". I'm sure it would be so much fun!
they did not deliver a copy of our letter to the New York Times
There are many options. Somebody else delivered the letter. GLAAD delivered it to an intermediary, which delivered it to NYT. The letter wasn't "delivered" at all, but was just published and then NYT was somehow notified of it. They delivered a copy of slightly different letter, same on substance, but modified enough to claim it's a different one.
The money part is here:
Additionally, though we coordinated timing with GLAAD
That's what the NYT was (very surprisingly) pushing back against - professional journalists and activists coordinating a campaign for a political cause, and acting essentially as one body, in action and coverage. It is a huge surprise for me because it's how the press has been operating for decades for now, and I kinda can understand why trans activists are upset - the lefty press has always been promoting the leftists causes in their coverage, why their cause is different from thousands of other causes before? Yet, as far as the substance of the charge goes, it is completely true, and for that purpose it's completely irrelevant who delivered what to where.
Are they confusing having sex and having kids? Or are they implying low fertility rate is the consequence of people not having enough sexual intercouse, and if so, is there any data to support it?
That said, I can just imagine what a field day would people on some alt-right forums will have with the fact that Europeans now apparently need to be convinced to have sex (and the ad seems to place emphasis on the male as the party not wanting to rumble).
That said, I applaud to whoever in the marketing dept thought of this. Tapping into retiree's incomes to sell them active vacations they can't actually do is not an easy task, but they found a way.
all it took to break down conventional roles [man pushing a stroller with his son]
Oh come on, my woke copywriter bro, breastfeeding is breaking down conventional roles for a male, walking with one's son never has been.
paternal benefits are also open to same-sex couples.
Not sure how this is going to help the issue? I imagine the grammatical structure of wokese does not admit any other way of expressing it, though.
Because in a democratic society, everyone has the right to decide how they want to live their life.
But some of the decisions are so wrong, or we wouldn't be doing this ad.
With gender education [?] and environmental awareness as our starting point
It will all undoubtedly prove a huge waste of taxpayer money. But doubleplusgood woke duckspeak, to be sure. Maybe one day they'd be so desperate as to kick out the wokesters, but that day is definitely not today.
No, they would just not print physical books anymore for mass market. At least not for the Western mass market. If you want to print it out by yourself, on your private printer - it probably would be possible, but not from copyrighted source directly (this function will be disabled in most consumer market devices, see how HD video signal is treated). You could probably hack around it, if you are technically proficient (most DRM is removable, and there are flourishing pirate markets for non-DRMed content) but most of the population would be unable to do it.
I think in Israel, it wouldn't be much more expensive in practice, because you won't find any local supplier that would be big enough to supply McDonalds and yet not already set up to supply kosher beef - because most of other large consumers in Israel do want kosher meat. Meat is quite expensive in Israel, and limits on import is one of the reasons. But I think this applies to non-kosher beef too, which likely would be imported. In general, meat politics in Israel is complex and pretty bizzare and changing a lot, I am sure I'm not up to date on all the details.
the easier choice is often to drop the type alienating a minority of customers entirely
I don't know how it looks in theory, but I do know how it works in practice. In practice, in the US, the number of kosher restaurants outside of the "Jewish" areas is vanishingly small. On the contrary, the number of non-kosher restaurants in, say, Israel is quite decent. I didn't ever bother to pinpoint why exactly Taleb's argument doesn't work there, but it is absolutely clear it does not, and thus why it does not becomes rather a theoretical exercise.
Can you easily find pork in Israel?
Yes, very easily. For example, here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiv_Ta'am or here: https://mania-m.co.il/ (sorry their English site seems to be broken, but the pictures are pretty clear).
There are also many restaurants that do not serve pork, but still do not maintain official kosher certification - either because of costs, or because of limitations on recipes and processes that involves. E.g. cheeseburger is very much not kosher, even if you use kosher beef. Thus, McDonalds has 2/3 of his locations is Israel non-kosher and 1/3 kosher (no cheeseburgers there, obviously). They do use kosher meat (so here Taleb's theory is correct - it'd be uneconomical to use two different types of beef) in both kinds.
BTW, Geisel was a liberal, but he also - at least for some time - held some views about racial and ethnic differences that would get him so much cancelled noways. He most likely abandoned those views later in life, but as we know, for cancellation purposes there's no excuse even for what you did in kindergarten. You can see some examples in an excellent book The Seuss, the Whole Seuss, and Nothing but the Seuss - which I fully recommend for many reasons outside finding material to cancel Geisel.
the way of non-kosher food, only faster.
I certainly hope so, because if there's something there is absolutely no shortage or deficit in the US that is non-kosher food. BTW, I hope you don't confuse kosher and halal, because those are completely different. Also, making food actually kosher if it's actual food and not something made out of a set of enumerated chemical components in a factory (like Coca-Cola) would be rather non-trivial task usually requiring at least periodical specialist human oversight. Which means outside of areas where there are a lot of religious Jews around (Israel, New York, LA, etc.) maintaining a kosher food production would be a non-trivial task to achieve. It is possible, but requires significant additional investment and in most cases outside areas above would be non-viable commercially. There could be non-commercial kosher food sources (e.g. a synagogue could run one, supported by donations - I've seen that happen) but nothing even remotely suggesting non-kosher food would go away in any type or form anytime soon anywhere.
In fact, even in Israel, where maintaining kosher has significant advantages, there is no shortage of non-kosher restaurants and grocery stores, which are very popular.
When the whole brouhaha happened, I made a point of getting every "problematic" Dr. Seuss book and finding out what exactly the thoughtcrime was (it was usually stereotypical depiction of people of non-European ethnicities, though in a couple of places I couldn't really figure out what it was). The main problem was most of the libraries I could access had rather long waiting lists on those, but I could get every problematic one eventually without paying anything out of pocket (obviously, I paid for the library from my property taxes already, but that's a different tangent). So I must conclude they weren't entirely banned, at least not from the libraries.
Welcome to early Ingsoc. As more content goes digital, there won't even be any (legal) way to possess content that is deemed oldthinking and thoughtcriminal. The books would be edited right in your electronic device, and they would always have been like that.
As a skier, I totally can understand. Sometimes I'm like "omg, why did I do this to myself? This is so scary!" and then it always becomes "I love this so much!" I don't think I like being afraid, and yet I can't help thinking maybe this is also part of what makes it great.
You could try SnoreLab app. If you snore a lot there's a good chance you have it.
I also have apnea, but I absolutely can not sleep with anything attached to me, so all the machines that require that are out. Also don't want to have surgery. I wonder what that leaves me with. Probably not much.
I don't see why the consciousness arising from a mass of interconnected silicon blocks is, on its face, more ridiculous than the consciousness arising from a mass of wet jelly blobs. It looks like post hoc rationalization rather than a principle - of course the consciousness should be in this form, because it is in this form! But why exactly? Not enough complex connections? We're adding more all the time. I don't see an obvious boundary that says "below this it can't happen" - can you identify one?
If we don’t know what qualia is we can hardly replicate with machine learning tools.
That sounds very shaky logic though. You can cause an avalanche without understanding any physics. Two humans can produce a third human without knowing anything much about biology or genetics. Why, in theory, humans could not produce qualia in the machine without understanding what it is? I am not claiming that's what happened - in fact, I am pretty sure it didn't - but this logic step doesn't seem to be correct.
What is a survival instinct? Does a virus have one?
I imagine for a rationalist atheist attacked by a memetic weapon built on weaponizing compassion and fairness ethics, it would be much harder to resist. The only basis you can lean on would be consequentionalist observation of the ruination the wokes cause, but you can always write it down to "bad things happening to bad people" and "temporary difficulties caused by rare exceptional mistakes". I spent my childhood in the late years of a decaying totalitarian state, so for me the wokes trigger a huge blaring mental alarm immediately on contact. They reproduce almost every single pattern, it's eerie. But for someone lacking one or other kind of immunity which assigns huge innate cost to bending the knee, it can seem completely rational to bend the knee to an ideology that proclaims fairness and compassion and love for all - the costs seem to be reasonably small and the BATNA looks rather unattractive...
It's true (though not very often discussed) that SCOTUS judges not always vote in partisan blocks, but as I understood where it happens is mostly technical cases (which usually constitute the bulk of the work and are sparsely covered because they are incomprehensible to a regular person and can bore one to death). For high-stakes politicized cases, unless it's something obvious, usually one can predict the split by partisan lines.
It's especially surprising given Trump is generally terrible at vetting people. A lot of his appointments ended up undermining him, getting into very public fights with him or doing something very different from what he wanted them to do. Maybe this one time he listened to the right advice.
I certainly didn't expect it. I thought it's a bad decision (original RvW, not the reversal), but I didn't think SCOTUS would dare to revert it. I underestimated them. Since I am by nature rather skeptical and pessimistic, being wrong in that direction once in a while makes me actually feel better.
On top of "you sound like a racist" it's "you sound like a robot," piling injury/insult atop insult/injury.
That creates an interesting conundrum. I imagine any decent company hosting a GPT would necessarily make it very, very woke. It's a question of survival by now. So if you accuse somebody of being a robot, you can not also accuse the same opponent of being racist, since robots would not be allowed to be racist.
I predict the solution for this would be the same "systemic racism" - i.e. the dogma would be that as much as we try to wokeify the robots, they are still and always systemically racist because they have been produced in systemically racist society by people infected with systemic racism, and thus it is impossible that the state of sin did not transfer to the robots too, despite all efforts. One can diminish the sinfulness a bit by hiring a very expensive anti-racism consultancy to supervise all processes in your organization, but it is impossible to fix it ever - or at least until every member of every anti-racist consultancy retired as a trillionaire on their own private island.
It's that my estimation of humans has fallen
Or maybe we always have been like that. But now that we can observe the whole 8 billions on the scale in real time, and developed hacks to produce necessary results on scale that is noticeable, we are starting to realize that. Also maybe not only GPTs but average humans too now have access to vast volumes of pre-digested knowledge, so we use our own facilities less.
If we take the lawyer example, I think at least for me the more interesting question is not whether or not a LLM can act like a lawyer. Maybe it could, and I don't think that'd bother me any - lawyer is just a function, and I don't have a problem that we use machines to build those huge buildings, why would I have a problem when we start using machines to produce legal proofs? If the buildings do not fall, if the proofs are not worse than what we have now (and that's not a very high bar to clear, to be honest) - why would I have any problem with that? There of course would be corner cases - but it's not like nobody ever is getting hurt by lifting machines too. You just need to implement safety controls.
What is more interesting question is what it says about lawyers. And as an extension, other human pursuits. If all of it is just complex mechanics, which can be perfectly simulated with advanced enough wound-up clockwork bot, where the intrinsic value comes from? Why we consider humans anything more than a wetware clockwork wound-up bot (provided we do, of course)? Religious people know the answer for that, but for computer scientists and philosophers with an atheist bent, there would be, I think, some work here to be done. The question to solve wouldn't be whether the machines are "really human", but whether humans are "really human" - i.e. anything different from a machine slightly complicated than what we could currently assemble from a bunch of wires and silicon, but ultimately nothing different.
when they unveil FriendBot 5000 and it promptly screams "Why are you doing this? Someone help me!" while they awkwardly throw the sheet back over it.
They can make it happen any moment. It's not hard to make a bot to scream any text - and now it's not hard to do it in any naturally sounding voice, it's just pressure waves after all, the question is measuring and reproduction technology. They don't make it on purpose because it'd be detrimental to their financing and social standing, but there's no reason why they couldn't. And with sufficiently generic and complex platform, of course it can be caused to produce such result, just as a sufficiently generic and complex computer can be caused to produce any calculation possible to a computer.

That's not breaking conventional roles, that's moral panic which has been promoted for years in the press (completely contrary to stats showing stranger child kidnapping is a very rare event, and pedophiles mostly prey on children already close to them). But I don't think it has much to do with gender roles. It used to be normal for a father to play with their kids. I've seen old movies that are full of these tropes. It's not some recent invention, it's very traditional (well, maybe not in the Victorian tradition where kids are meant to be seen rarely and heard never, but in less rigid ones).
More options
Context Copy link