@JeSuisCharlie's banner p

JeSuisCharlie

Sumner, Hebdo, Kirk

0 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2025 October 22 22:56:43 UTC

Formerly "SandwichWarrior" and "The Upright Man", may or may not be feral, is most certainly quixotic.


				

User ID: 4009

JeSuisCharlie

Sumner, Hebdo, Kirk

0 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2025 October 22 22:56:43 UTC

					

Formerly "SandwichWarrior" and "The Upright Man", may or may not be feral, is most certainly quixotic.


					

User ID: 4009

I'm only a few paragraphs in and already getting strong "we wrote the conclusion first" vibes.

The repeated refences to disparate impacts and constant waffling between "children referred to CPS as infants", "children referred to CPS multiple times", and "all children referred" strike me as massive red-flags.

Without diving deeper into the raw data I bet that the actual situation on the ground is something like this; Close to 30% of all kids will be referred at least once in their lives. For most of kids who get referred it happens only once and it ends up going nowhere. However If MeeMaw is callin' cause no-good baby-daddy just got released from prison, or her daughter's off the wagon, and she's worried about the baby. The odds say that MeeMaw has called CPS before, and the probability of this referral going somewhere is much higher.

The conclusion of course is that CPS is racist and should stop trying to protect underclass children

Especially in context of the fact that the agriculturalists were demonstrably more evolutionarily fit.

I don't think it's fair to label the guy "a shitty dad" over one tweet but the this tweet displays exactly the sort of behaviors I had in mind when I described the post-modern liberal ethos as "incompatible with forming healthy relationships and families" in last weeks thread.

Neuroticism, extremely short time-preferences, hyper-feminization, lack of emotional regulation, pre-occupation with one's own validation/gratification. These are not healthy qualities to have in a partner but they are endemic (and often celebrated) within the liberal striver class because they are the qualities celebrated and promoted by the philosophies of "Emancipation", "Self Actualization", "Deconstruction", "Breaking down barriers", and "Following your bliss".

It is trivially true that there are downsides to having kids.

We currently have a new baby in the house which means I have been getting less sleep than I would like and I have been getting less sex than I would like. I also have a lot less time and energy to pursue my own interests than I would like. Additionally, the former baby has noticed that he is getting less attention from mom and dad than he is accustomed to, and has been acting out a bit. We have had to rearrange the house to make space for the new arrival and reinstall a bunch of the "baby-proofing" we had previously removed which annoys me, it annoys the kids, and it annoys the animals. Every living thing in the house is annoyed. The thing is that these sorts of issues have been a fact of parenthood for as long as human beings have been making babies so complaining about them has the same energy as complaining that the sun rises in the east.

My point is that it is ok to feel tired, or bored. It is ok to not always be enjoying everything all of the time. What is not ok is to be a grown-ass man with apparent emotional maturity of a toddler. In that sense I suppose I am echoing @iprayiam3 and @PokerPirate user, irrespective of the kid aspect, if you can't handle 10 minutes of tedium or delayed gratification that's really something you need try and fix about yourself.

To come at the issue from a different angle. Are there downsides to being physically fit? Yes absolutely.

Do you think I like eating leafy greens more than I like doughnuts? Or that I like drinking water more than wine? Do you think I "enjoy" doing cardio. Do you think that there isn't some part of me that would just love to throw back a half-pint of tequila smoke a bowl and do a bunch of shrooms right now?

Eating healthy, working out, and having to behave responsibly are all very clear and significant downsides to staying in shape so why stay in shape?

Because despite all reason and logic to the contrary, good things are good.

It is good to take a kids bunch of kids and dogs to a park and play "kick the ball". It is good to catch your romantic partner looking at you like you're a snack.

Good things justify themselves.

Honest answer, It's an interesting story that raises legitimate questions about the the nature and value of consciousness. At the same time there is a certain sort of person who is going to interpret the narrative not as a thought experiment but as a blueprint and/or instruction manual because they are autistic

Hablo Espanol?

As much as I enjoyed the book, my feelings about Peter Watts echo my feelings about Ayn Rand. Like on on one hand I get it, on the other I can't help but think that the popular lessons taken from this story are not the lessons you should be taking from this story.

There are two novels that can change a bookish fourteen-year-old’s life: The Lord of the Rings and Atlas Shrugged. One is a childish fantasy that often engenders a lifelong obsession with its unbelievable heroes, leading to an emotionally stunted, socially crippled adulthood, unable to deal with the real world. The other, of course, involves orcs"

for the record, I dislike you as well.

^ Seconded and endorsed.

While the organizational center may have moved from the country club to the local steak house or climbing gym, the organizational structure and underlying principles have not changed.

It's kind of hilarious how many people in this thread are telling me I'm just being lazy...

They aren't wrong though. Doing a google search or asking ChatGPT is only a calorie or two removed from doing nothing at all. It is quite literally the bare minimum of effort a person could possibly expend.

I am genuinely trying to help you, and I am pretty sure @Dean, @Turniper, and @Thoroughlygruntled are as well. You need to understand that this is not some "Giga brained ploy" it's a core component of the culture you are trying to make contact with. The people you want to meet are not going to respect someone because they say they are intelligent or motivated, what they do respect is people who demonstrate agency. Something that Richard Nixon, Donald Trump, Elon Musk, and Kyle Rittenhouse all have in common. Similarly the people you are trying to meet do not "lack an understanding of how political organizations are built" so much as they are implementing a different organizational model. The Republican Party is not a top-down technocratic organization and expecting it to behave like one is only going to lead you astray.

I honestly want to thank you because what you're suggesting is that not all is lost and maybe I have allowed myself to become too "black-pilled".

However, at the same time, if what you are saying is true, I feel like it only reinforces the lesson that I ultimately took away from that experience. An understanding that the trappings of nobility and "elite human capital" are more often than not orthogonal to nobility of the soul. Credentials do not make a man worthy of respect, choices do.

Millienials woke up to the grift and Gen-Z seems to have been born nihilistic. They know the boomers looted the store and then stuck everyone else with the bill. They, rightfully, are enraged by this but only a small fraction has eaten the bitter medicine and realized "ah, shit, we're going to have to fix this ... and it's going to be hard for a while."

This tugs at a thread that I wanted to bring up in response to @DoktorGlas and @Botond173's earlier posts on fertility and gender-dynamics but was struggling to find a way to do so without it being immediately dismissed as being uncharitable, or drawing broad generalizations about the outgroup.

I think there is a very real sense in which the post-modern liberal ethos of emancipation, self actualization, and the maximization of one's earthly/material material conditions and status is simply incompatible with forming healthy relationships and families. Having a family means accepting that you are no longer the main character in your own story and that is bridge that a lot of people today are hesitant to cross, a painful truth that many recoil from.

As I mentioned in one of those earlier threads, our first child was not planned, and if you had asked me at the time if I was ready I would have said "no", but in hindsight if my partner and I had waited till we we ready, we may never have had children at all, never mind enough children to justify multiple car seats. Both my partner and I have had friends and family who asked us why we didn't just get an abortion? What they were really asking is "Why would you (a presumably rational and intelligent person) willingly accept an inferior quality of life?". I never really had a good answer to that question, at least not one I could articulate, beyond "I choose to". But I feel like there is the outline of an answer in your last two paragraphs.

The future belongs to those who show up. So if you want to have a future, be one of the people who shows up.

Ah, your previous comment had me primed towards the racial angle.

Yes it was pretty much the same attitude.

As a first step? yes but again fieldcraft.

Imagine you join such a group or attend one of their vigils and notice that 3 out of the 8 men there all go to the same gym and very specifically not that other gym.

A lot of high level planning and wrangling used to happen over TeamSpeak which has since been largely displaced by Discord and Signal due to better mobile integration.

I wouldn't say it's "the norm" but it is in no way surprising.

As I brought up in my post from a few days ago, the the US Republican party isn't really a national organization in the way that our European commentors would naturally assume upon hearing the words "political party" or even in the way that US Democratic Party is. It is more a loose confederation of state, municipal, and regional parties who's individual scope, resources, and levels of engagement can vary wildly. This distributed party structure was baked in to the party's founding as a cross-regional cross-social-class coalition focused on a small number of specific core issues, and has persisted to the present day both out of cultural inertia and as a defense mechanism against subversion by the forces of "liquid modernity".

Speaking of which, you don't survive as a sincere conservative (as distinct from edge-lords posting on X) in this post-modern age without developing a level of reflexive fieldcraft. Advertising yourself as a young conservative seeking other young conservatives is a good way to get yourself canceled by both sides. Another way to think about it is that the first part of the entrance exam for joining the resistance is "can you find them?". This ties into what @Turniper was saying below about how the functions where the actual connections are made and work gets done are not going to be discoverable via a simple google search and how this is by design.

As far as actionable advice, all I can really offer you is "go where the conservatives are" but remind you that as an educated urban youth who's posting on a site like this one, where you think they are and where they actually are, may be very different.

By way of example, my introduction came through the fandom of a sports team.

Shades of the Gibson's Bakery case?

No, the students in question were overwhelmingly white and middle eastern, while the local population was substantially black.

The key thing to understand is that it really can be any group. I went to a prestigious school and one of the biggest pieces of culture shock for me when I got there was just how endemic cheating, fraud, and petty theft were. If you weren't trying to game the system in innumerable little ways you were viewed as a rube or a mug. If you called out a fellow student for shoplifting from the corner store or rifling through an unattended bag you'd get a reputation as a scold. I was actually told once by a TA that I was "hurting myself" by trying to do my classwork honestly instead of taking advantage of available "opportunities".

In my experience "it's perfectly fine and indeed our right to pluck the pigeons among 'them' who we owe nothing to at all." describes the attitude our elite just as much as it does our underclass.

Meanwhile, I'm in camp "Yes rationality, punctuality, hard work etc... are in fact "White Supremecy". As such Clarence Thomas is clearly "white".

isn't there a real faction of the left which is actively opposed to competent center-left government on the basis that a reactionary backlash creates the necessary conditions for their own ideology to succeed?

This is basically the thesis of Lenin's book What is to be done.

I can also think of a historical example where in a band of revolutionary socialists embedded within a wider workers movement were able to execute Lenin's plan to great effect. Unfortunately for Lenin and his movement, the socialist affinity for back-stabbing reared it's ugly head and the wider left has spent the intervening decades desperately trying to convince both themselves and everyone else that the evil mustache man was never a true leftist to begin with.

Yes, and not just fuel them but justify them.

I do believe that there is a tipping point where "pettiness" becomes a pro-social response.

Poliver: Are you really going to die over some chickens?

Sandor: Someone is.

To clarify, my concern here is more that the electorate might throw a larger brick, or perhaps a Molotov cocktail, through the establishment's window.

Yes, that is a bit more concerning. But I also see that as something that is largely outside Trump and the MAGA Movement's control.

I think it depends on whether our resident technocrats and anti-populists choose to adapt or double-down.

The real trick is figuring out how to do it without effectively doxing myself or getting bogged down in current events because a lot of the players are still in the game. And yes they should have listened, a major theme of the story would be how establishment attempts to "tamp things down" instead contributed to the eventual crash.

As for what comes next, that is a legitimate concern, but for my part that concern is tempered by the fact that Trump is the kind of guy cares about "legacy". Characterize it as narcissism and self-aggrandizement if you like. He does seem to be genuinely concerned with how future generations will remember him, and the sort of world he is leaving to his kids.

I agree that this is probably at least part of it.

The important thing is not to elect "the right people". The important thing is to make it profitable for the wrong people to do the right thing.