MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
Also that "autonomous trucks before 2050" has been the way to bet for more than a decade now, meaning that it is an unattractive career for young people to enter because of the high probability of being laid off and replaced by a robot.
The last 2 are changes which have had long-lasting effects that Carter would presumably have wanted given that he was a Democrat. Whether they are good decisions is a fairly straightforwardly partisan issue, then and now. But from the point of view of Presidential legacy, successfully changing policy in your preferred direction in a way that sticks is an achievement.
The Carter transport deregulations are all good because they significantly reduced costs to individuals and businesses.
The actual policy legacy of the Carter administration (as opposed to Carter's personal reputation) held up pretty well given that we are now 45 years out.
The unambiguous successes include:
- Volcker as Fed Chair, inflation tamed primarily through monetary policy
- Deregulation of interstate trucking, airlines, etc.
- The Camp David accords between Israel and Egypt
- Transferring primary responsibility for defending South Korea from North Korea to South Korea, where it properly belongs
- An unusually clean White House
Things Carter changed with impacts decades later even if conservatives don't like the result:
- The Chrysler bailout
- Setting up the Education Department
- Government recognition for Asian-Americans as an identity group
- Head Start
- Modest tightening of environmental laws
- A deal with Panama which allowed US shipping access to the Canal while avoiding the expense of maintaining a garrison in the Canal Zone.
Things which still looked like a success after 10+ years where we probably shouldn't blame Carter for his policy continued beyond the point of usefulness:
- Supporting the muhajadeen to quagmire the Soviets in Afghanistan
- Normalising relations with Red China (including the continued-to-this-day policy of informal recognition of Taiwan).
- The Superfund law for dealing with the worst cases of land contaminated by industrial pollution.
Good ideas which Carter couldn't get past Congress, but is right with hindsight:
- Spending discipline, and in particular the idea that the Executive should identify specific wasteful spending and ask Congress to cut it.
- Natural gas deregulation (Congress took so long to pass the legislation that the benefits were felt after Carter left office, but with hindsight this is Carter's greatest achievement)
Because if the person running the Biden WH was serious, they could have issued an executive order ordering the National Archivist to promulgate the amendment as ratified.
The wider your roads, the more the logic of efficient land use pushes you towards deep, narrow lots (in order to get as many square feet of lot per square foot of road as possible). Nathan Lewis points out that the US has had very wide roads by international standards since before the invention of the car, and therefore deeper and narrower lots for most of the late C19/early C20.
After car ownership became widespread, the US avoided the problems of wide roads and deep, narrow lots by insisting on lots which are incredibly large for the size of the house. Levittown mostly consisted of 800 sq ft houses (not counting the garage) on 6000 sq ft lots.
Biden was trolling re. the ERA. I think Trump is serious about ending birthright citizenship, in the sense that he wants what he is doing to have actual consequences up to and including deportation for the people he is taking citizenship away from.
Having thought about this, I think the most likely plan is not to enforce the executive order (there will be a temporary injunction in place against it within days), and then to do things properly by legislation in the unlikely event that SCOTUS find that the Constitution does not protect birthright citizenship. This moves faster because you can start the (slow) litigation process immediately, whereas doing it by legislation means that the litigation doesn't start until the legislation passes Congress. And the litigation is the important part of this.
As I predicted, the order strips citizenship from all children of illegal and temporary migrants regardless of when they were born, but allows the government to continue issuing passports to people born before the order enters into force. At least in terms of intent. The order as actually worded tells the government not to issue documents to the newly recognised noncitizens born more than 30 days after the date of the order, but is silent about newly recognised noncitizens born before then. On a literal interpretation of the executive order, the general rules against issuing passports to noncitizens apply to the people allegedly grandfathered.
The scope for mischief if anyone wants to create it is obvious.
I agree. But that is easy to do by legislation and hard to do by executive order.
Abolishing birthright citizenship by deeming the 14th amendment never to have applied to children of illegal immigrants will create a lot of practical headaches because it means that there are a bunch of non-citizens with valid passports and social security cards, as well as a bunch of likely citizens who can't prove their citizenship (because nobody knows what their parents' immigration status was when they were born). These problems arise from the combination of no birthright citizenship and no citizen register - a situation that is currently unique to the UK (post-1983), Australia (post-1986) and New Zealand (post-2006).
In theory it blows up almost everyone's citizenship - unless you can trace your ancestry back to someone with a documented statutory claim to citizenship that does not rest on birth in the USA (such as naturalisation), there is technically the possibility that nobody in your family was ever a citizen (or a legal immigrant - people who were incorrectly believed to be citizens never filled out immigration paperwork, so they would have been illegal). Your parents' passport doesn't help, because reinterpreting the 14th amendment means that the a passport issued before the change is no longer proof of citizenship - the whole point is that the US has been issuing passports in error to anchor babies.
Doing this all by statute allows you to fix most of these problems - the simplest way to do this is by making the change prospective only (as the UK did when we abolished birthright citizenship in 1983 - and even so the only reason we don't have more practical problems with proof of citizenship is that the vast majority of British citizens have passports). You could also say that birth in the US to a parent born in the US grants citizenship regardless of the parent's status. (Most ius sanguinis countries do this).
An EO can tell the executive branch who to issue passports to, but it doesn't change who actually is a citizen. So it would leave much of the US operating in a legal grey area where their de facto citizenship derives from an executive order, not the law.
Is circumventing the US FOIA a crime? I couldn't google an example of anyone being prosecuted for it, and 5 USC 552 doesn't contain any criminal penalties.
[Circumventing the UK FOIA is a crime, but it is almost never prosecuted and the maximum penalty for a person is a £5,000 fine]
Compare and contrast the operative text of these pardons (e.g.):
BE IT KNOWN, THAT THIS DAY, I, JOSEPH R. BIDEN, JR., PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES, PURSUANT TO MY POWERS UNDER ARTICLE II, SECTION 2, CLAUSE 1, OF THE CONSTITUTION, HAVE GRANTED UNTO GENERAL MARK A. MILLEY A FULL AND UNCONDITIONAL PARDON FOR ANY OFFENSES against the United States, including but not limited to any offenses under the United States Code or the Uniform Code of Military Justice, which he may have committed or taken part in during the period from January l, 2014, through the date of this pardon arising from or in any manner related to his service as Chief of Staff of the U.S. Army or Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
with the Nixon pardon, (from Ford's online Presidential library):
Now, THEREFORE, I, GERALD R. FORD, President of the United States, pursuant to the pardon power conferred upon me by Article II, Section 2, of the Constitution, have granted and by these presents do grant a full, free, and absolute pardon unto Richard Nixon for all offenses against the United States which he, Richard Nixon, has committed or may have committed or taken part in during the period from January 20, 1969 through August 9,1974.
So this looks like the standard form of pardon for pardoning a pattern of behaviour if you don't know what specific crimes it could be charged with. These pardons are actually narrower than the Nixon pardon, because they are restricted to acts taken in relation to specific offices held. (So if the Trump admin is determined to do that, they could go after Liz Cheyney for campaign finance violations or some other three felonies a day bullshit).
The argument about the political wisdom of the Nixon pardon is a pot-boiler, but AFAIK nobody has ever challenged its constitutional regularity.
In terms of the wisdom of this one, the Fauci pardon seems an obviously good idea - I don't know why the anti-lockdown movement has chosen to make criminal charges against Fauci it's preferred strategy for relitigating COVID, but Fauci didn't commit the substantive crimes - the lockdowns etc. were ordered by other people (mostly at State level). Prosecuting advisors based on technical disagreements over the quality of advice is a bad idea. Prosecuting advisors based on how other people used their scientific advice is a very, very bad idea if you want honest advice. This applies whether Pam Bondi can find a three felonies a day process crime he is actually guilty of or just uses meritless criminal investigations for process-is-the-punishment reasons.
The whole thing about prosecuting the members and staff of the Jan 6th committee is silly, including the pardon, but I think the pardon is reasonable given the Republicans started the silliness. A moron in a hurry can see that the business of the committee is protected from criminal prosecution by the Speech and Debate clause.
The pardon of the witnesses is mildly improper, given that the only crime it could plausibly cover is perjury, which is inexcusable. But no more so than the Iran-Contra or Scooter Libby pardons.
All in all, these seem fairly low down the list of bad pardons.
I am noticing that Yarvin has achieved high social status by being good at being a Jewish nerd in a society run by philosemitic merchant elites, and that warrior elites are generally unsympathetic to nerds and Jews.
A world where the natural warrior-elite of the USA (whoever that is, and even if it even exists) re-emerges and becomes a functioning warrior-elite would not be a world a Jewish nerd like Yarvin wants to live in.
One thing I noticed about reading the "American Castes" essay when it first came out is that it was an obvious oversimplification (in the same way that the 4+1 caste model of the original Hindu caste system is a massive oversimplification of the various jatis and varnas). There are a number of groups that don't fit into Yarvin's 5 castes, and the career military (and in particular people from multi-generational military families) - as opposed to people doing a short stint and expecting to get out after 4-8 years, who remain in their original caste - is one of the more obvious ones (unless they are Optimates by birth). There is definitely a hereditary officer corps in the American military, but it isn't where most officers come from. I don't know enough to comment on whether it could be a functioning warrior-elite in the future.
Fred Pearce's Peoplequake wrote about rural-to-urban migration as a majority-female phenomenon almost everywhere in 2011. As well as pull factors (modern low-end manufacturing is pink-collar work, cities have more mid-level administrative jobs) there is the important push factor that some women are fleeing patriarchal rural and small-town communities for the obvious feminist reasons. Most women really don't want to end up as a farmer's wife*. And if you are betraying your religious parents by moving to the city and adopting a feminist lifestyle then the marginal cost (pre-Brexit, at least) of moving to London over Frankfurt is low.
Most of the young German women I meet in London are Bavarians from conservative CSU-voting families. (Though I suspect the real skew there may still be post-WW2 occupation era war brides.) Most of the educated Polish women I meet in London are running away from social conservatives in rural and small-town Poland.
* The Instragram tradwife trend isn't about being a farmer's wife - it is about being the wife of a man rich enough to buy you a hobby "farm".
"Head of Office" is used in the UK where Americans would use "Chief of Staff".
Chief Executive of a British council is equivalent to a US city manager - they are a permanent employee who runs the city under the direction of the majority leadership of the elected council. Total population of the City of Westminster is 211 thousand.
So in US terms the position being advertised is deputy chief of staff to the city manager of a municipality with a population (within municipal borders) of c.200k in the core of a large metro area, with the appropriate pay adjustment for a high cost of living area.
My impression is that the pathologies of locally high-status men engaging in dubious pussy-chasing are basically the same in other contexts and this isn't specific to conventional celebrities. Gamergate happened because Zoe Quinn looked like she was cheating on her boyfriend with someone locally high-status in the indie game community, and the community seemed to think there was nothing odd about this. This kind of thing is absolutely rife in academia - probably more so than it is in Hollywood, although the press doesn't cover it as much.
Encourage deviant behavior to the point of basically making it mandatory (you don't have an open relationship? You're not a square are you?), then make it socially and legally risky to engage in outside of party-aligned social institutions.
The actual life path followed by Blue Tribe elites is to fool around a bit in your twenties, then to get married (to someone of your own social class, naturally) and stay married. The idea that polyamory and swinging are standard for married couples in prog circles is absurd if you have spent time with them - this is the whole point behind Charles Murrays "the elite should preach what they practice" thesis in Coming Apart. Even though the official prog position is that there is nothing wrong with swinging if everyone is consenting, it has always been the case that a male public figure who did this kind of thing and got caught was liable to be hauled over the coals by feminists for bullying his wife into it.
Blue Tribe opinion-formers promote sexual deviance because promoting deviance of all kinds feels like rebellion against oppressive authority. But the actual rules enforced by Blue Tribe morality police have included things like "don't engage in drug-addled casual sex" since the feminist backlash against 60's libertinism. And banging women of a significantly lower social class than your own (including whores) has always been mildly low-status behaviour for elite men, even though it is common. If the libertine techbros had thought that drug-fueled orgies were normal for Blue Tribe elites then they were making the classic mistake of believing what the NYT says and not watching what the sort of person who gets published in the NYT does.
The decline in social connection has happened across the first world, whereas the takeover of public space by derelicts is mostly US-specific. So that is unlikely to be a major contributor.
Why is it wrong to ask for quid pro quo?
Under libertarian ethics, it isn't wrong to hire a sex worker on mutually agreeable terms, but it is wrong (because dishonest) to hire an employee for some other job and then after she has resigned from her previous job, relocated etc. pull a bait-and-switch and tell her she is now your sex worker, and the door is that way if she doesn't want her new job. You can't be a good person if you are going around saying "You fucked up - you trusted me. Learn the lesson and don't trust people like me next time."
It is noteworthy that a lot of right-on-right arguments about whether a woman who is sexually harassed in the workplace is a victim of obnoxious behaviour come down to an argument about whether some particular job counts as sex-work adjacent (such that the implicit employment contract does include putting up with this stuff) or not.
Doing this to your employees is a type of wrongdoing that the US has (unusually from a global perspective) decided is beneath the notice of the law in the case where sex isn't involved, but is tortious when sex is involved.
Ah, the days of TVIX. One of my most interesting experiences in finance was the presentation by the risk manager who had stopped my then-employer from offering a TVIX-equivalent explaining just how XIV and TVIX died.
Agreed. I favour long-drop hanging or firing squads (I would also include the guillotine, except that it's French) on the basis that they kill cleanly and reliably, avoid excessive pain, and make abundantly clear that what we are seeing is authorised violence, which it is.
Capital punishment is not a medical procedure and you shouldn't make it look like one. Capital punishment sometimes is a show, but it shouldn't be optimised for entertainment value.
I never heard of no ‘don’t screw the babysitter’ rule.
I think I may have learned it in the same kind of place I learned "don't use double negatives to express a single negative meaning in formal writing". It was one of the paradigmatic examples of behaviour which, whether or not legal (the minimum age to babysit in those days was about 13 and the age of consent was 16), was beneath contempt in the society I grew up in.
All the effect of these laws, the ‘real’ sexual harassment laws as you term them, is to ‘multiply crime’.
Compared to the previous system that actually works, there is a lot more space for licit sex. So it is only "multiplying crime" relative to a baseline which essentially nobody wants. If we are talking about explicit government prohibition here, and your argument is that historically quid pro quo workplace sexual harassment is the type of behaviour which, while socially unacceptable, is outside the proper scope of government coercion, it is worth noting that government regulations affecting both employer-employee relationships and illicit sex were old hat by the time Hammurabi got down to writing them down.
I have an old school understanding of rape:
The old school understanding of rape related to the subset of illicit sex where the man was wholly guilty and the woman wholly innocent, not to the boundary between licit and illicit sex. (The old school understanding formed at a time when the vast majority of sex was illicit, and most illicit sex was considered to reflect shared fault between both participants.) There has never been a society where the rules were "anything goes except rape strictu senso" and I would eat my hat if there ever was.
victim screams no, immediately goes to the police
So if you are dangerous or powerful enough that someone would reasonably want time to think things over before calling the police on you, you can rape with impunity and it doesn't count? In the instant cases (both "Caroline" and Pavlovich) the woman would have been unemployed and homeless within 24 hours of calling the police on Gaiman - that is something you need to make plans for, and making those plans can take weeks.
I just think women are people, and they have the capacity to say no,
The snarky response to this is that sometimes we decide we need to limit the ability to push the cost of saying "no" repeatedly onto the people saying "no", and that the same argument you are making implies that the laws against spam and telemarketing are illegitimate.
The serious response is that if you are a physical threat to someone (and almost all men are to almost all women in a one-on-one situation), or otherwise in a position to hurt them (let's say your wife, who will predictably take your side in a dispute, is their boss and landlord) it is really easy to make saying "no" difficult. When Luca Brasi asks you if you are going to sign the contract, he shouldn't need to say that "no" implies that your brains will be on the contract instead - under normal circumstances the threat is implicit, and forcing Luca to make it explicit is going to take a zero off the already-below-market price the Corleone organisation is offering you to release Jonny Fontane from his record deal. The same is true in more mundane contexts. If your boss says "Can you run down to Fatbucks and fetch me a coffee-flavoured double sugar-water with extra lard?" then you might be able to give an excuse, but a simple "no" is what Sir Humphrey would call a brave career move. Is it different when your boss asks you "Will you kneel down under the desk and blow me?" How confident in your answer are you, given that the political tradition who thinks we should be libertarian about this also thinks that people who are fired for not blowing the boss should be allowed to starve if they can't find another job quickly enough?
Gaiman had set up an environment where saying no was not just difficult - it was almost maximally dangerous. To say a woman should be able to say "no" is to say that a woman should be able to make a high-stakes judgement call about whether saying "no" will end badly for her - Pavlovich wasn't in a situation where saying "no" at the wrong time could get her killed (although you imply that you have no problem with deliberately creating and taking advantage of such situations) but apart from that the full range of bad outcomes were on the table - physical pain, unemployment, homelessness, community ostracism.
The "solve-for-the-equilibrium" response is to note that people remove themselves from situations where they repeatedly have to say "no" under unpleasant circumstances. Tourists stop going to cities which are full of unpleasant panhandlers. People stop using online services which are full of spam. Women stop going to the bars and clubs where they are pestered by men they don't want. The equilibrium in societies where quid pro quo sexual harassment is a normal incident of being a woman in the workplace is that women with options stop working outside the home.
I haven't met anyone who favours a more specific definition than "New Englander".
That said, when talking to Americans, I have heard "Yankee" used to refer to a widely-hated baseball team playing in the Bronx and its fans far more often than I have heard it used to refer to New Englanders. Given that the Bronx is not part of New England, I suspect it makes "Northeasterner" the more correct meaning to a descriptivist.
It isn't a reveal. The same allegations were the subject of a social media happening and discussed extensively on the Motte six months ago.

This is a "what does the Constitution mean?" issue. If you take the Constitution seriously, once the issue is on the table you want to get it in front of SCOTUS asap.
If US-born children with noncitizen parents enjoy citizenship revocable by executive order, then they don't really enjoy citizenship. This needs to be resolved in a way which allows some degree of legal certainty, and under the system as it has existed since 1789, that means a definitive interpretation of the Constitution by the institution responsible for doing so.
More options
Context Copy link