@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

People who understand both betting and polling (of whom Nate Silver is the most prominent) are saying that the prediction markets are entirely consistent with the polls - Republicans doing well enough to hold onto 50 senate seats would require correlated polling errors* within the published margin of error, which is entirely consistent with a 28% probability. (As was the case with the 2016 and 2024 Presidential elections). Republicans holding the House would imply a polling miss of world-historical proportions. This should not be a 5% real-world probability, but it is well known that 5% implied probability on a sportsbook does not correspond to 5% probability on the real-world measure because (i) gamblers overback longshots and (ii) backing a sure thing at 19-1 on/1.05/-1900 odds isn't as profitable as it looks because it locks up a lot of money.

Polling isn't (and never was - 1992 in the UK remains infamous in the industry) good enough to call close elections, and the 2026 Senate election is close.

* The difference between Nate Silver's measured bullishness on Clinton immediately before the 2016 election and less numerate poll-driven pundits thinking that she had it in the bag was that a lot of stupid people didn't understand why polling errors are correlated by default.

I bought into "Trump is not paid off by, and is rich enough not to need to be paid off by, the Saudi-Israeli Axis of Idiot, and will therefore pursue a saner foreign policy that may lead to less Salafi jihadism" in 2016. Hilary Clinton seemed to me to be unusually close to the Saudi influence machine, which I thought was more dangerous (in terms of corruptly influencing the US to pursue policies contrary to the national interest, and potentially in ways which would increase my personal risk of being blown up by Salafi jihadists) than the Israeli one, though the two machines were (and remained until the current Iran war started going wrong) sufficiently aligned that this may be a distinction without a difference.

Given the amount of Saudi (and Israeli? not sure) baksheesh the Trumps took in his first term, I didn't find this argument particularly credible in 2024. I also don't understand how anyone believed "Kamala is likely to do a forever war for Israel" strongly enough that "Trump won't" became a viable campaign message rather than a Captain Obvious kind of thing.

I think we're using different definitions of "closed".

Pre-Pao Reddit was not noticeably less censored than dial-up era Compuserve or AOL, and nobody thought they were the open internet (except in so far as people used them to access the open internet). The internet pioneers definitely thought that "open internet" meant "interpret censorship as damage and route around it", not "the corporate censor is in a generous mood today".

it will be because agentic 'great men' made it so

If you are talking about Musk buying Twitter, he isn't trying to open up the internet - the best case is that he is trying to ensure more ideological diversity in the range of curated walled gardens that exist. (The worst case is that he was being serious when he said that he wanted X to be a tool of totalitarian domination modelled on WeChat). X plays less well with the open internet than Dorsey's Twitter did - particularly in terms of suppressing tweets with links.

The most important item on the Democrats' positive agenda, arguably going back to Clinton, has been "fix healthcare". Their problem is that this is popular in the abstract but that any particular concrete proposal is unpopular - particularly because most sick people are covered by Medicare, which works in every respect except cost control.

But you are right that the Democrats' agenda in 2026 is mostly-negative (and popular for it) - basically "stop Trump making things worse" and "do not use our electricity and water to build the Torment Nexus".

(with a minor problem of the Iran war)

Apart from that, Mrs Lincoln, how was the play?

Any political movement that isn't explicitly liberal is going to trot out "freedom from speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences", "the first amendment only applies to the government" etc. as soon as they enjoy even a little temporary, local power over the culture.

Woke cancel culture was a Thing in the left's own spaces since 1990's PC, and got a lot worse starting in the early 2010's (I think the turning point is the failure of Occupy and the collapse of economic leftism as an activist outlet, other people think it is Barack Obama's re-election campaign). The interesting question is why corporate America (including but not limited to Big Tech) went full woke during the first Trump administration.

We don't have good Star Wars 7-9 because the left ruined it.

I think Disney corporate could have ruined Star Wars VII-IX without politics. For that matter, George Lucas could have ruined Star Wars VII-IX, and given the way he ruined episodes I and II that would be the way to bet. The problem is the existence of the plot holes (most obviously Rey's backstory) that Disney tried to fill with woke politics, not the woke politics.

I think politics made movies worse by suppressing criticism of movies that were bad anyway, more than by causing people who could have made good movies to make bad ones.

I'm with Orwell on this - I think they are equivalent in substance and differ only in coalitional politics. If you didn't already know, would you be able to work out which of "National Socialism" and "Socialism in One Country" was the fascist slogan and which was the communist one?

They did like Mort, though, and haven't tried other Ringworld novels yet.

I bounced off Discworld at 10, and came back to it slightly older and fell in love, as all true geeks do.

Foundation is a collection of longer short stories, anyway. Foundation and Empire and Second Foundation are each two novellas republished in a single bound volume.

For me, it was Narnia and Dark is Rising. The MiniSTEMLord bounced off Narnia, though it is probably worth trying again.

Don't worry about the disclaimer - we need to index on both things simultaneously, so we know how difficult it is.

Mini-STEMLord loved the Ender's Game film - I refused to buy him the book on the grounds that it encouraged megalomania in gifted children. I do not want my son to see himself as the next Peter Wiggin. But I might be able to relent on that. Rather scarier was that his 6-year-old younger brother also understood and enjoyed the film.

I have not had sex with Aella, and would have no interest in having sex with Aella even if I was not happily married to someone else. I believe AI poses a threat to the human race for broadly the same reasons that the people who have had sex with Aella do.

YA SF recommendations wanted!

The Mini-STEMlord of this thread is 10 this week and we are still trying to get him to read books. Based on the films and TV he likes, his preferred genre of fiction is SF, with a mild preference for harder SF. He has asked for the books of Dune and The Martian after watching the movies, but found them too difficult.

Apart from going old school and introducing him to the Heinlein juveniles, I have no idea what SF is out there for younger readers. Mini-STEMlord has a reading age of at least 14 and can handle science concepts at an A-level to first year undergraduate level. (In terms of maths, he has mastered algebra but hasn't started trig or calculus. He was able to follow a 1st-year undergraduate biochem course on MIT OpenCourseware when he was healthy and rested but not when he was tired or had a cold). But he has no reading stamina - with one exception the longest thing he has read is a Wikipedia article. I don't know if that means anthologies of short stories would be better than novels.

Any advice appreciated.

And that is before you consider the faction of the Republican party that thinks private-sector companies in strategic sectors should be required to give large equity stakes to the government as a condition of being allowed to operate.

Between MAGA communists and DSA communists, I think the percentage of Americans who favour the state seizing the means of production is at least 20%. I would guess the equivalent figure is >30% in most western European countries, and >50% in France where both the Gaullist right and the mainstream left have particularly strong communist traditions.

there are two sides to this conflict

There are two sides to the conflict between Good and Evil. One of them is Good, and the other is Evil. Similarly, there are two sides to the conflict between someone trying to go about their business and someone trying to kill them for no good reason, although there is no guarantee that the innocent victim in this case is actually Good.

The fact that Trump frequently acts as if he wants to align the US with Russia and against its traditional allies is part of the problem, yes.

I think one of the biggest reasons the neocons made policy mistakes is that they assumed that because the various unpleasant Arab/Muslim factions hate Israel more than they hate each other, they must hate us more than they hate each other.

In fact the secular Arab left (in so far as it still exists post-USSR and post-Saddam), the Sunni Jihadis and the Shia Iranian Mullahs all hate each other more than they hate us, and Israel is the only thing that comes close to uniting them.

Or to put it another way, I agree with JD Vance, Matthew Yglesias and the median American voter that the proper America First policy on the Israel-Palestine conflict is "not my circus, not my monkeys".

In the UK, where British government policy mostly has been "not my circus, not my monkeys" in my lifetime, anyone who makes Israel-Palestine central to their politics has either dual loyalties (if they are ethnically Jewish or Arab) or no brain (if not) and should be bozo-binned on that basis. I have some sympathy for the situation the current government is in given the specific problems Labour is having on their left flank, but the current round of moral grandstanding over West Bank settlements, while justified as a matter of morality, is not in the national interest.

One of the key insights of MMT is that a country that borrows in its own currency (like the US or the UK, but not individual countries in the Eurozone) can't suffer an Argentina-style bankruptcy because they can always print enough money to pay their bills. MMTers who also understand Econ 201 know that what this means in practice is that the endgame of excessive deficit spending is Zimbabwe and not Argentina, and have some modest but sensible ideas about how this changes the optimal monetary and fiscal policy. In particular, smart MMTers think that deficits matter even less than Krugmanites do as long as there is significant unemployment such that deficit spending isn't competing with the private-sector economy for real resources. MMTers who think MMT is a substitute for understanding mainstream economics think that it means that deficits don't matter ever and that printed money can buy all the real resources you could want from Sugarcandy Mountain.

You could probably function as a carpenter without knowing trigonometry, but you need it to pass the exam for journeyman status.

The Nagorno-Karabakh conflict (including the Azeri invasion, conquest, and ethnic cleansing of the "Republic of Artsakh" in 2023) was fought within the internationally recognised territory of Azerbijan. They may have committed genocide (I don't give a shit, because the victims were Russian stooges and I have friends in Salisbury) but they didn't commit aggression under international law.

Up till 1945, yes. We (by which I mean the UK, USA and USSR) unestablished it in pretty spectacular style in Normandy, Kursk, Hiroshima etc.

Based on the official government numbers at ForeignAssistance.gov, about half (more under Trump I, less under Biden) of the total US aid spend (excluding extraordinary support to Ukraine since the start of the Russian invasion) was either aid to Israel or aid to Egypt and Jordan which is basically Danegeld paid on behalf of Israel. I don't know how this changes as a result of Trump's cuts to USAID, but I suspect the proportion is even higher now.

Except wartime Ukraine, Israel is by far the largest single recipient of US aid, despite its small population and first-world standard of living.

So "stop funding Israel" and "end foreign aid" are kind of the same cause, just spun to appeal to different audiences.