Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
@CapitalRoom deleted his account here and on Tumblr, I hope he's alive.
No, I finally got banned off Tumblr — apparently for a link to one of Kulak's Substack posts.
Why?
Yeah, I was too hungover to remember the underscore in your username here. My bad.
As for why I hoped you didn't give in to your suicidal ideation, it's because I consider death negative, and I'm grateful for some of your insights I regularly think about: the quote about Puritans considering literally everything instrumental including personal correspondence, the point how it's not a team sport so that a political party which maintains its relevancy by moving away from the desired policy is an awful outcome, the extended series on how democracy truly means the results chosen by the people if they had been properly guided by the enlightened teachers and doesn't mean the results as what they currently choose.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Tumblr is gone, but @Capital_Room is still here.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I know we have some home LLM enjoyers here who use LLM-agents for personal projects. @ThenElection I think you mentioned you did.
Have any of you tried these two papers on your home-swarms? LatCom & LatentMAS I'm actually very curious on their claims, I think these could be fascinating, but I'm still in the process of buying GPUs/parts for building out my own system.
More options
Context Copy link
Know what I haven’t been seeing in the lead-up to these midterms? Fraud predictions. Two years ago, lots of people were claiming that the Hated Enemy would subvert/fortify the election. This time, not so much.
Did it fall out of the Overton window, or am I just out of the loop?
It's just Trump fatigue.
More options
Context Copy link
Good point. Couldn't tell you why - it feels like that tack is more common during presidential election cycles
More options
Context Copy link
Seems like this would be appropriate in the culture war containment thread.
I’ll take that under advisement.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
For the panic-buying-inclined, what's the currently recommended AR upper to go with? BCM used to be the classic but I hear rumors that their QC went downhill. That usually comes with the caveat that they're still the best mid-range uppers.
Just get PSA and chill
This comes with the caveat that the potential panic-buying reader does not want an entry-level bargain bin AR. As far as I know PSA really has serious QC problems with their regular guns. Unless you're talking about a PSA Sabre upper, which I've seen some support for online.
...I mean, no? I'm fairly sure that the idea of PSA having QC issues is just Old News - PSA is basically the 'good enough' of the AR world in terms of grabbing a quick SHTF rifle to have on hand(with plenty of ammo. You are training with your rifle alot, aren't you, anon?)
People have been fucking around with PSA uppers for a long time specifically due to being so cheap, only to find that they're actually... reasonably good?
I mean, it's no Bear Creek Armory, but...
If you're really tied to cost=performance, just upgrade to something like an M&P. Or a Daniel Defense. But you can buy 3 to 4 PSAs(depending on your taste) compared to one DD or M&P, so...
Speaking from personal experience, I think it's good for everyone firearm enthusiast to have atleast one really cheap AR, as you learn really quick that you'll treat a really cheap gun radically different compared to something alot more rare or expensive.
Now, having said all that... I'll give you fair warning; when you start getting into optics, that's when you're going to start encountering an existential crisis when you realize most optics actually worth a goddamn will be more expensive than your actual rifle.
Huh, I have consulted with other sources and they did not disagree with you. Maybe I got my impression from watching PSA's failures in other areas, like the JAKL, the PSA AKs, and very recently, the PSA 570.
Edited to add, my optics are going to be a pretty humble red dot with flip-up 3x magnifier, so hopefully it doesn't end up costing more than the gun.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
How is everyone's experience with janitorial staff post-COVID?
I work in a hospital that any US physician would recognize by name but half the time I show up at work in the morning and the staff bathroom looks like a bomb went off. Thankfully clinical areas are better, but it's unacceptable. Is this one of the classic hospital problems or is stuff still shittier in say, the Google offices too?
If a job isn't performed correctly, that's an employee issue. If a job is consistently done incorrectly, that's a management issue.
More options
Context Copy link
It depends entirely on the building and how much the owners are willing to pay its janitorial staff.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Help me decide how to vote tomorrow on the most interesting ballot question in my state: MA Question 3, which would replace Massachusetts' current conventional party primary system with a "jungle primary" in which all primary candidates of all parties are on one ballot, and the top two vote-getters advance to a runoff in the general election. This would apply for all state elections.
My main goal in this decision is to promote competitive elections, if not necessarily in terms of party then at least in terms of substance. My instinct here is definitely to vote "yes", because the Republicans are so rarely competitive at the state level here anyway (yes, I know Charlie Baker wasn't very long ago, but it's hard to see that happening again in the remotely near future given national partisanship) that the current system often results in the Democrat nominee running de-facto unopposed. An election between a "left-wing" and a "moderate" Democrat would be much more competitive than one between "whatever Dem wins their primary" and "some GOP no-hoper", at least in theory. And this could force the Democrats to actually focus on the full electorate in their primaries, instead of only their own voters -- since they nearly always win anyway this seems like a plainly good thing.
Also, both parties have spoken out against this ballot question; since I dislike and mistrust them both, I've taken this as a small piece of evidence that I should go with a yes vote.
The only thing that really gives me pause is that the biggest state which uses this system is, of course, California -- which is not exactly a model of good political or governmental practice. The other example, Washington, is not much better as far as I can tell. It doesn't really seem that implementing this system has made their elections more competitive (unless of course it has? the counterfactual CA government would still surely be de-facto one-party Dem rule, and perhaps they would be even more extreme and even less responsive to the voters). Now, for all the flaws it does have, MA is not nearly as dysfunctional as CA. But maybe going to this type of system really would result in less competitive elections than the classic Dem vs Rep framing? I don't really see that happening, but hey, that's why I'm asking the question here -- maybe we have some election nerds who can weigh in with arguments I haven't considered.
This and question 1 are the only results were I seem to agree with the electorate.
More options
Context Copy link
Why not use the "primary" to select the top one candidate to put on the ballot instead of the top two? It might be the Canadian in me, but using a special pseudoelection to kick people off of the real ballot feels horribly undemocratic.
The People should be able to vote for any serious candidate, where the criteria is:
(As a sidenote: The Longest Ballot Committee candidates fail the first criteria, and the change from requiring 100 eligible residents to sign their nomination form to requiring 100 distinct residents for each candidate closed that loophole.)
Aside from that, it's internal party decisions, and if they want to strategize (or torpedo their chances), they're free to do so. The obvious (and nigh-universal) strategy is to hold a primary and put forward a single candidate from the party with all others "voluntarily" stepping down, but I don't feel that should be enshrined in law. I value free association enough that I think parties should be able to choose whatever method they want to put forward a candidate, including banning straight white men (they'll lose my vote, though).
EDIT: in jungle-primary states, is there anything stopping the parties from running an internal pre-primary election, then promoting a single candidate to run in the "real" primary? If not, it seems like an effective way to concentrate votes and increase the odds of getting on the ballot.
More options
Context Copy link
The purpose of doing this is to eliminate any transparency in opposing what one of the two parties want, and an attack on the opposition's ability to attract human capital.
There is no 'your donations will go towards opposing progressive-stupid' if the only candidates that can win are those who caucus with progressive-stupid in the first place. So your donations, if you don't win in an inter-party struggle of what to implement, have still gone directly into progressive pockets even if the progressive-stupid elements lose.
And there is no 'rival political organization that could take over if things got bad enough' if there is only one party institutionally capable of governing (as that's where the mid-to-good human capital tends to migrate, since it's the only one whose candidates matter).
The ruse is pretending that "sure, an R candidate could get there". But MA Ds believe themselves, and perhaps correctly, to be able to field 'Turbo Jay Jones' and 'Jay Jones Lite' (where R is very clearly 'not Jay Jones'. Having clear opposition to back means 'Turbo Jay Jones' doesn't get any resources if she loses, and means 'Jay Jones Lite' is in a worse position even though she might win 100% of the time).
What I believe you should do depends on why you believe D issued the statement (Rs have a different incentive)- was it the moderate wing that forced them to say no, or the progressive wing?
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
YA SF recommendations wanted!
The Mini-STEMlord of this thread is 10 this week and we are still trying to get him to read books. Based on the films and TV he likes, his preferred genre of fiction is SF, with a mild preference for harder SF. He has asked for the books of Dune and The Martian after watching the movies, but found them too difficult.
Apart from going old school and introducing him to the Heinlein juveniles, I have no idea what SF is out there for younger readers. Mini-STEMlord has a reading age of at least 14 and can handle science concepts at an A-level to first year undergraduate level. (In terms of maths, he has mastered algebra but hasn't started trig or calculus. He was able to follow a 1st-year undergraduate biochem course on MIT OpenCourseware when he was healthy and rested but not when he was tired or had a cold). But he has no reading stamina - with one exception the longest thing he has read is a Wikipedia article. I don't know if that means anthologies of short stories would be better than novels.
Any advice appreciated.
He can handle Asimov short stories. Classic short stories in general are a great SF introduction. I wouldn't go full Heinlein because of the weird sex stuff.
Good idea. There is some pretty good collections out there; The Hugo Winners, The New Hugo Winners, The Super Hugos, The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume One, The Science Fiction Hall of Fame, Volume Two, and The Collected Stories of Arthur C. Clarke would all make excellent reading.
It is said that "the golden age of science fiction is twelve", but if the kid is precocious ten might be just fine.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
This is going to be a bit of a weird take, but have you considered fanfiction? Some of the best sci-fi I have ever read has been fanfic: Friendship is Optimal/Caelum Est Conterrens, Changeling Space Program/The Maretian, Message in a Bottle, Luna is a Harsh Mistress, The Moon's Apprentice, Stardust, To the Stars, r!Animorphs: The Reckoning, etc. Fanfiction is usually much easier to read than original fiction, because you already know the characters, so it could be ideal for building reading stamina.
Alternatively, you may want to take the advice of Eliezer Yudkowsky. From "Frequently Asked Questions about the Meaning of Life":
See also his "Bookshelf" and OKCupid for more specific book recommendations. And while you are at it, Scott Alexander's fiction recommendations, too.
More options
Context Copy link
Philip K Dick wrote a lot of short stories that are quite fun.
Probably need to filter through them for adult themes tho.
More options
Context Copy link
I think there are two angles you can push on. One is see if he goes for some easy slop, on the theory that he's gotta get comfortable with the mechanics of reading, sitting still for a good few hours, etc. The other is to point him at harder things to see if he goes for the challenge. Since he's asked for and bounced off Dune and The Martian, maybe go for the first.
Matthew Reilly writes paper action movies, but he might need to be 1-2 years older for those? Animorphs is a good read but gets dark later. It can also be a vector for weird-kid-ism and the fandom seems to attract a lot of trans and furry elements. Most of the great YA I can think of is either non-SF and/or is for a couple of years in the future (e.g. Tomorrow series). Maybe easy fantasy would be good?
Also, 10 might still be young enough to enjoy some reading aloud with the parents. You could read the harder books with him and then you can answer his questions before things become too frustrating.
More options
Context Copy link
I stand by my previous recommendations, but after some thought ... it might be worthwhile to focus on stamina-building reading before worrying about quality reading. If my kids hadn't gotten into the habit of devouring guilty-pleasures series when they were younger, they probably wouldn't have been up for more thoughtful things to read when they were 10. "Can read at a high level" and "can read without noticing any effort" are two different virtues, and there are all sorts of voluminous book series designed to make sure kids develop the latter. My oldest daughter's favorite was probably "Warrior Cats". I think mine was "Choose-Your-Own-Adventure" back in the day. Don't even sneer at comics! "Calvin and Hobbes" has something to think about at every level. "FoxTrot" was my kids' gateway to Star Trek TNG. Even "Garfield" (okay, you can sneer at this one, but sneer respectfully when around the kid) isn't worthless if it gives the kid motivation to binge read something for hours on end.
My grandparents had a bunch of the collections when I was a kid, and I used allowance money to buy the rest. I couldn't even estimate how many times I read them. Those and The Far Side collections probably explain much about how I am now (perhaps not a ringing endorsement of the comics).
Are you me??????
I bet, well actually I know, there are a number of people on here with bizarrely similar biographical details. There is a distinct type of late Xer/first millennial that is drawn to the Motte like moths to flame.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Ray Bradbury has a lot of short stories, but they aren't super hard SF at all. Still, lots of classics in there.
I'll second the Ted Chiang recommendation, too.
Greg Egan is too heavy for a ten-year-old, his characters are almost all adults with adult problems like death and taxes.
Maybe try some Lem. Like The Cyberiad and Fables for Robots.
More options
Context Copy link
Well, I read Ender's Game as a 10-year old and loved it, but I wouldn't exactly recommend that as an intentional parental choice, lol. I was also a giga-bookworm as a kid though, so it's a bit of an exercise to put myself in opposite shoes.
I'd say Starship Troopers but the dated language might put him off if he doesn't already like reading. That kind of thing can make old books more of a challenge, or chore, for kids then many well-read adults probably realize... lots of words to look up and unfamiliar sentence structure. I-Robot could also be a great choice, but probably the same caveat -- and it sounds like he'd bounce off of something like Foundation. Frankly I think a lot of the suggestions downthread are great for a precocious 10-year-old who likes books, but would not convince one to like books.
The first Hitchhiker's Guide book, maybe? It's very funny and fast moving, although there is some adult humor in there.
If he likes Star Wars there are a number of quite good YA-ish book series from the older Expanded Universe. Obviously more space opera than "real" SF, but that's not necessarily a problem. For a kid I'd probably suggest the X-Wing series. They're very fun and fast-paced mil-SF books, with the focus on soldiers and dogfighting rather than Jedi mysticism. Lots of action but nothing too bloody, a touch of romance but nothing explicit, and the good guys always win in the end -- great for a kid imo. I believe I started reading those around age 10 myself. For something more kid-oriented there's also the Jedi Apprentice books (which are basically short stories/novellas, and so might be more up his alley), I started those a little younger but definitely still liked them at 10 and beyond. They're not high literature or anything but they have good characters and engaging plots with real stakes, iirc, and could be better suited for a kid who doesn't want to sit down with a 200+ page novel.
Animorphs is much-beloved and should be engaging reads, I was never really into them but lots of people have fond memories.
I have a vague half-memory of reading some books in what I believe was the "Young Tom Swift", or something like that, series (a modern reboot of the classic adventure novels) around that age as well... can't properly endorse something I don't really remember, but they were pretty quick reads and very gadget and invention oriented, which could be fun for a kid with more of an engineer-type brain (although maybe not so much if he's really into the hard science side).
I also want to second the post that mentioned Percy Jackson and Harry Potter. They may seem like basic choices, and they are fantasy rather than SF, but they're famous for a good reason. A whole lot of kids seem to get very rapidly hooked by these, and he is just the right age.
Seconded Hitchhiker's. I read the first one when I was about that age and loved it.
Yep, I think I was a year or two older when I first read it but no more than that. Still one of my all-time favorites.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I would recommend not only Asimov's short stories themselves, but also the anthologies collected by him and Martin H Greenberg as "The Great SF Stories N (year)".
I was probably older than him when I started ripping through my father's collection, but I loved seeing how stories from different eras felt, and it was a good way to find other old sf authors you might like.
More options
Context Copy link
This is my third dip, but have you got access to the Scholarship exam papers used by Eton/Westminster/Winchester? They (used to) emphasise strong mathematical reasoning skills and problem-solving over rote regurgitation of skills, and they're aimed at 13 year olds. If your son still needs mathematical enrichment, you might find them valuable.
More options
Context Copy link
"Apart from using a jack, I have no idea how to hold my car up while I change the tire."
But I guess if the correct fix is one-time-use then it does make sense to ask what to move to afterward.
My kids all loved Heinlein, to the point that the little ones have demanded weaker (in my opinion) Heinlein like Orphans of the Sky first over better novels by other authors, and got more variety mostly via a mix of "my insistence" and "running out of Heinlein". I haven't let the little ones touch his adult-adult novels yet, but he's got one aimed at adults that was totally appropriate for kids: Double Star is a major favorite of theirs.
There are also some adult SF novels that are appropriate enough for kids with a little Parental Guidance (and/or outright censorship; there were a few books that I'd insist on reading out loud with the 10yo so I could do that, despite letting a 13yo read them himself). I'd have put The Martian in this category, though, and it's possible that some of my other suggestions are also too hard for a 10yo? From Heinlein, aside from Orphans, I'd say Starship Troopers, The Puppet Masters, and The Moon is a Harsh Mistress really deserve context+discussion. From Weir there's also Hail Mary. (Artemis was so disappointing - a young-adult sort of story with inappropriate-for-kids text was exactly the opposite of what I wanted...)
The "Crosstime Traffic" by Harry Turtledove has a half dozen (self-contained; it's a series because it shares the same worldbuilding but there's different characters each time and no reading order is assumed) young adult novels that range from good to great. They're more educational than the Heinlein juveniles, too: hard SF of the "One Big Lie" variety, where aside from the sideways-in-time-travel all the worldbuilding is either real history or plausible-alternate-history from a PhD historian whose fiction specialized in that. With Heinlein there's always a mix of stuff like orbital dynamics working out on the dot versus "Total Conversion" (without antimatter) and "Martian canals" where we really knew better by the time he was writing and the last nails went into the coffin a decade or two later.
Someone's already brought up Asimov's short stories, which (if you pick the right anthologies; his later short stories were weaker) I agree with. Niven and Heinlein also had a few great short stories, and Niven's got a few shorter adult novels (World of Ptaavs, Protector in particular) that one of my kids enjoyed. Asimov's Foundation may be too dull for a 10 year old, but The Caves of Steel might not be. The sequels to that one get less age-appropriate fast, though, and even in the first book my daughter disliked the main protagonist.
If fantasy is an option too:
I loved Pratchett's The Amazing Maurice and his Educated Rodents ... though none of my kids did. De gustibus non est disputandum, I guess. They did like Mort, though, and haven't tried other Discworld novels yet.
I'd say that Mother of Learning would be the ideal way to build up reading stamina ... except that it has a slow start; my kids might have given up on it if I hadn't insisted they make it past chapter 4 first.
Oh, I almost forgot to bring up Percy Jackson and Harry Potter. Those answers seem "too obvious", I guess, but the former is probably what got my kids doing the most reading in total, and the latter took more than one of my kids from "reluctantly willing to let mommy or daddy read a chapter of something to them before bed" to "finishing hundreds of pages on their own because daddy doesn't read out loud fast enough" in no time flat.
I bounced off Discworld at 10, and came back to it slightly older and fell in love, as all true geeks do.
Hah, I did type "Ringworld", huh? I'll edit that. My oldest daughter liked the first two Ringworld books but I warned her that they go downhill fast from there.
I'm ashamed to admit that, when I heard of the "Discworld" books after having already heard of Alderson disk worlds (probably from Niven, the author of Ringworld, partially explaining my mental short-circuit above), I thought the whole "you know, like flat Earth, but for comedy" thing sounded like enormously disappointing worldbuilding by comparison. It was probably 15 years later before I realized how wrong I was.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
It's a bummer that those two were too steep, The Martian is at that YA borderline IMO.
What about Animorphs? Actually kind of dark, but I did enjoy them as a kid.
More options
Context Copy link
I was a mini STEMlord, but I guess all my reading around that age was fantasy. My usual recommendations for kids based on what I enjoyed are the Prydain, Redwall, and Dark is Rising series. The non-fantasy ones are the Great Brain and Swallows and Amazons series, but neither are SF. Odd to realize in hindsight.
For me, it was Narnia and Dark is Rising. The MiniSTEMLord bounced off Narnia, though it is probably worth trying again.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I think short stories are a good bet. I'd recommend Ted Chiang.
More options
Context Copy link
If he likes animals, the Willard Price books ("Undersea Adventure" and the like) are also perennial classics.
More options
Context Copy link
If he's never read Hatchet, it's not SciFi, but it's all about a boy solving problems and refining his solutions to overcome challenging situations (his plane crashes in the wilderness and he survives for 54 days with little more than a windbreaker and a hatchet and then things he makes).
I found it a page turner at 10 or 11.
If you aren't put off by the language of Twain, Pudd'nhead Wilson is somewhat high tech for it's time (leading to the titular character's nickname). I thought it was very funny and ends up with a central theme of nature vs nurture and behavior. Dialoge is written phonetically, which might not be enjoyable for a modern reader.
Star Wars film or extended universe novels were another set of books that I really enjoyed at that age. Particularly, the Thrawn trilogy.
More options
Context Copy link
I was a mini-STEMlord myself as a kid and if the longest thing he has read is a Wikipedia article, short stories probably work for you, and they don't need to be YA. Ted Chiang's stuff is evergreen and I imagine they would be rather accessible; Story of Your Life and Exhalation are two good ones he may enjoy.
Some Greg Egan ones may work too, though I may not recommend whole short story compilations from him since some can get heavy. But Learning To Be Me is particularly accessible and very haunting.
DISCLAIMER: I may be overindexing on the "was able to follow a 1st-year undergraduate biochem course on MIT OpenCourseware" part and failing to properly factor in "is literally 10", so maybe use your own judgement.
Don't worry about the disclaimer - we need to index on both things simultaneously, so we know how difficult it is.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Ender's Game has a child protagonist, but the violence might be a bit excessive for a ten-year-old.
When I was that age I read this collection of Philip K. Dick stories and don't remember any of them containing anything too objectionable.
Ender's Game has a tweenage protagonist because it's a book intended for any tweenager for whom Ender would be an appropriate self-insert.
I don't think the book would be any good for young adults (it is not very subtle): read it when you're 9-12, or don't read it at all. (If you're not capable of reading it at that age, it's probably not for you.) I believe it's too easy/simple/unsubtle for a teenager or adult, especially one for whom the book's themes would have resonated had they read it at the appropriate time in their life.
10 year old me found the level of violence in the story rather low. When explicit, none of it was particularly gratuitous (the weirdest instance being both virtual and somewhat cathartic helps in that regard). The fights happen because they need to happen; kids aren't being constantly beaten to a pulp for no reason.
10 year old me found the level of sex in the story age-appropriate. (The enemy race was a sexual epithet for a reason, and the best one that could have been used [and definitely a term at home at a boarding school anyway], though its significance was lost on me at initial reading. Would have worked better in the '80s. The movie did technically censor it, but in fairness Ender discovering the nature of the enemy was also cut for time, so the obfuscation was superfluous and was OK to edit.)
10 year old me was also very well aware that parental/authority figures in the book are either completely useless or actively hostile (their machinations are made explicit at the beginning of every relevant chapter- tweenagers need that actively explained, adults don't). [It's made very clear that his similarly-capable sister is the only one capable of reaching him.] Again, realistic (for the reader for whom Ender is a self-insert), but is something parents who are as useless and outmatched as Ender's are very likely to have problems with (and any parent who thinks vetting books for their 10 year old is reasonable is in this class).
I disagree on Ender being an appropriate self-insert for teenagers and "read it when you're 9-12, or don't read it at all".
Ender is an appropriate self insert for anyone because he is not a tweenager, he is written as a fully formed person. To quote Card on the matter
Ender/Peter/Val are not children, they are people anyone can see themselves as. (I hope) Everyone can see Peter and understand the ruthlessness that exists within themselves. They can see Valentine and know the compassion they are capable of. All while understanding the inner turmoil that comes from these two forces interacting (Ender). Without a desire for power they will be abused and taken advantage of. Without kindness their lust will consume them. I think of Card's quote from Speaker for the Dead about a tale of two Rabbi's.
I re-read the series recently (late 20's, having read it in the 9th grade) and appreciated Ender's Game and Speaker for the Dead far more this time than I did then. I think Orson Scott Card really captured fire in a bottle with these two stories (Xenocide and Children of the Mind are much more generic sci-fi) and being an adult I was able to grok the story in a way my previous surface level reading never did.
Children/Tweenagers are able to identify with Ender because he has the same shape as them. Adults are able to identify with Ender because he has the same spirit as them.
I'm having quite a bit of trouble figuring out whether you actually understand me. If you did, your syntax errors (like the above) had intentionality, I'm just not sure what that intention is.
I got the full picture on the first read as originally stated (though I do understand why most people do not). My opinion didn't change on the second read several years later, nor has my opinion on the matter more generally changed over similar timeframes.
Looking back on it, this book really ain't that complicated (especially if you're already familiar with Christianity, the concept of loving one's enemy leading to deliverance from that enemy, which this is a pretty good expansion thereupon- I don't know if that background is necessary, but I can't confirm that experimentally). It's a very cartoon-y way to write a book, I found (see the manipulations of the authorities at chapter start/end, see how that's dealt with right afterwards, repeat until out of Battle School).
Certainly more than can be said for anyone else in the story (other than I guess Petra, but that's different- pretty sure that was her name, anyway [and I guess Bean, but again, different ways]), with the exception near the end for Ender's mentor (who is a similar fully-integrated human being, just a little older).
Ever
readplayed the Mass Effect series, by any chance? One of the characters has some particularly interesting parallels specifically because he is written assuming that "child" and "fully-formed person" are not mutually exclusive [in the same way that those are not mutually exclusive for Ender]. I'll leave it as an exercise as to which one that is (and maybe I'll talk more about that if it's answered), but...No. Based on empirical evidence, they do not.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Mini-STEMLord loved the Ender's Game film - I refused to buy him the book on the grounds that it encouraged megalomania in gifted children. I do not want my son to see himself as the next Peter Wiggin. But I might be able to relent on that. Rather scarier was that his 6-year-old younger brother also understood and enjoyed the film.
The Shadow series might be better for him- Bean is too alien, Peter isn't a child anymore, and it's pretty consistent near-future science fiction with military plots unlike the mainline Ender's game series, which has thematicism that might be a bit much for a ten year old to really get.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I, Robot? It's old-school but there's the satisfying 'oh... that's how the laws of robotics go wrong in this scenario' that he might appreciate, and it's short stories.
Hmm, a tricky one. I would also recommend Asimov.
In addition, the humor is hit or miss by personality and only sort of sci-fi, but each entry in The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy series is reasonably compact and episodic. Has some amusing themes for an advanced 10-year-old to explore.
For some quick pulp fiction, the Animorphs series is very approachable. Might be too low of a reading level given the description, but in terms of getting volume in, there is a lot of very digestible material there.
Smuggling in my personal taste for naval fiction, David Weber's Honor Harrington series is more or less Horatio Hornblower with a sci-fi mask. A decent chunk to bite off, but not very difficult.
IMHO the HHGttG series is really heavily front-loaded - if you just finish the first book then you've gotten 80% of the value of the series from 20% of the reading.
Edit: I also recall the first book being more age-appropriate than some of the later books, which may be just as important in context here. To be fair, I'm not 100% certain in either judgement about the later books; I've reread the first book within the last few years but probably haven't reread any of the sequels within the last 20 years.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Second - Asimov generally is very friendly to the reader and has a large catalog of short stories, which I think are much less intimidating to an inexperienced reader.
More options
Context Copy link
Yeah, precocious 10-year-old is the perfect age to start Asimov.
Agreed, if you stick to the short stories and if you're careful to pick the best short stories (the I, Robot collection is a good place to start). I tried Asimov novels with each of my kids, and somewhere in between 10 and 13 seems to be where the first Foundation novel went from "too dull" to "fascinating" in general.
Foundation is a collection of longer short stories, anyway. Foundation and Empire and Second Foundation are each two novellas republished in a single bound volume.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Have you encountered the problem when you google for the likes of "how to disable X" you get many results on "how to enable X" when desired result doesn't even appear on leading few pages? I have. It seems to be a smaller issue with LLMs replacing search engines.
This and increasingly, when someone asks in a forum "how to do X?" the response is "why are you worried about Y?" I blame the ESLification of the internet.
What do you mean, that such behavior is endorsed in examples that ESL people teach English with?
Mostly downright misunderstanding the nuance of what's asked, or misinterpreting through a different cultural lens, or unfortunately just low IQ. Keyword: increasingly.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
What is ESlification?
ESL stands for English as a Second Language. The grandparent is talking about how the internet is increasingly composed of non-native English speakers.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
My amazing story with AI today. My order of the sinking star savegame was corrupted after opening my steam copy save with the pirated one which was on lower version. There was no backup and there was severe data loss. So I just described what kind of state the world was in and to try and rebuild it when recovery was impossible - and the bastard (sol 6.1 low) one shotted it.
We are in uncharted territory, and I just can't predict the way the dice will roll. So in which direction did your P(doom) moved this week?
Huh are you saying you had the ai write a save file for a game and it did it with just one prompt? Did you upload a reference save file or the game code or something with the prompt?
No. Just codex in the cli. It could harvest whatever is needed.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I've been vibevibecoding, by which I mean issuing only a very general outline that the AI turns into a full plan for actual execution (after asking me questions). Then I tell it to execute steps of its plan and change things if I don't like the output.
Back in the day, you had to say in detail what you wanted and even if you didn't understand the code you at least knew what files did what. I had to manage the context of what the machine saw. Whereas now I don't look at the file structure at all.
This is really more for starting a project than finishing (that last 10% of polishing, detail, refinement takes 90% of the time) but you can get pretty far doing things this way. I recommend people, especially if they're on a $100 or higher plan, to write out a halfbaked 5 page plan, ask the AI to ask detailed questions, turn that into a real plan and then just execute. Then you see the true power of the models.
Also this just popped up, Claude Sonnet 5.5 fighting battles in Rome Total War. I thought Sonnet was a bit crappy in my own experience but it seems to be faring pretty well in warfare:
https://youtube.com/watch?v=Mhv8XwmA8R4
The phase change for me was around ChatGPT 5.5 (where I updated my take that was previously, "Yeah, this is useful for some things but is not generally good at solving problems independently"): I had a winning lottery ticket ($20) that I had stuffed into a pocket while it was slightly wet. Then it dried and kind of stuck to itself, and unfolding it ended up tearing some chunks out of the scannable barcode. On a whim I handed it to GPT 5.5 in Codex and asked it to find the actual payload using the information in the picture and repair the barcode. (No online or offline tool I could find could read the barcode even with some half-assed GIMP work to straighten it out.)
The problem was actually trickier than expected: the string above the barcode is in the barcode, but there's also a metadata prefix, so GPT's initial attempt to beam search through character permutations and check the generated code (which it identified as PDF417) wasn't enough. It eventually decided to reverse-engineer the error correcting modules and reconstruct the payload from that; this worked, though surprisingly
zintcouldn't be coerced to produce a precisely matching output (presumably the company didn't use zint to generate the barcode in the first place or were passing some exotic arguments) even though it could produce a valid PDF417 with the right dimensions and payload, so then GPT finished by just writing the bitmap rendering code itself and producing the perfect, repaired barcode as a png. Which I opened up in an image viewer and scanned from my phone into the lotto app, and it just worked.I can't even estimate how long it would've taken me to do all of this; it's obviously not impossible, but the 30 minutes I'd spent de-skewing and adjusting contrast and sending the image through random tools had already surpassed the effort it was rational to expend for $20. Implementing Reed–Solomon error correction alone would probably be a (not so fun) weekend project, and that's before actually extracting the cell data from the distorted image.
/images/17936624789209785.webp
/images/17936624791162748.webp
Yeah, they're very nice for small tasks. I built a little chrome extension for a friend, fixing an inadequacy in how Google presents data. Some translation of medieval french from pictures. Proofreading a long text. Or even running a bit of custom code on certain kinds of formatted documents, handling edge cases autonomously.
But large tasks too are getting increasingly fun to just fire the slop cannon at.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
So, what are you reading?
I'm reattempting Duncan's Romantic Outlaws, Beloved Prisons, an open access book.
A collection of essays, including The Will to Believe, by William James. That essay and Is life worth living? have so far been my favorites. I’ve been exploring Pragmatism recently, and I find the school a very useful way to determine how to determine knowledge given humanity’s limited ability to obtain certainty. A few key points that stick out to me:
James reminds me of a reverse Hume. Hume looked at principles like induction and said “we can’t justify this logically”. He tore down “rules” of knowledge and produced skepticism. James seems to do this in reverse; given that so much of what we “know” isn’t logically obligatory, we should attempt to see what sorts of “under justified” beliefs we really can and should hold on to.
More options
Context Copy link
Musashi, by Eiji Yoshikawa. A heavily fictionalized novelization of the life of Miyamoto Musashi, the "Book of Five Rings" guy. Yoshikawa originally wrote it as a serial, which shows as there are lots of tangents with side characters. It's obvious Yoshikawa just made a lot of stuff up, but it's great soapy fun.
More options
Context Copy link
I gave up on A Gentleman of Leisure about fifty pages in. It hadn't elicited so much as a chuckle.
Last year I bought my dad Steven Pinker's book When Everyone Knows that Everyone Knows..., about the concept of common knowledge. He enjoyed it and lent it to me. I wanted an easy read, so I started it on Tuesday. Richard Hanania's argument about the deficits of non-fiction books certainly applied here, and it did give the feel of being unnecessarily padded. In particular, even outside the chapter which was specifically about humour, there were an awful lot of references to sitcoms and jokes (I don't mean Pinker himself cracking jokes: I mean him reciting jokes told by other people to illustrate his points). I was also broadly familiar with most of the arguments he touched on. But for all that, it was absorbing enough that I'd finished it by Thursday evening.
Perhaps the only surprising part of the book came near the very end, in which, as part of a chapter about academic freedom more broadly, Pinker more or less outs himself as a HBD enjoyer. His argument, in effect, is that scientists should deliberately avoid investigating the question of whether there are differences in intelligence between the various ethnic groups, as it's simply something we don't need to know, and were it to be proven true, people would use that information to indulge their worst prejudices. I interpret this as a tacit admission that Pinker thinks that certain races are more intelligent than others, on average: if he didn't, why would he be advocating for intentionally burying our heads in the sand? This passage felt eerily familiar to me, and I realised that Scott (who wants to duel Pinker to the death) has already done the endorsing-HBD-without-technically-endorsing-HBD thing at least twice: once in Kolomogorov complicity and once in his review of Freddie deBoer's The Cult of Smart. (I'm curious if deBoer thinks scientists ought to investigate the question of whether races differ in average intelligence, and if not, why not.)
I received a gift, an adaptation of To Kill a Mockingbird in comic book form. It occurred to me I haven't read the book itself since I was in secondary school, so this might be a fun way to reintroduce myself to it. A snack between meals before my copy of The Camp of the Saints arrives.
Here's Noam Chomsky doing the "let's not go there" bit in 1972:
IIRC Pinker quoted exactly this to buttress his argument.
So has Pinker genuinely not realized by 2025 that people flipped the argument around in the last decade into the form that since the existence of hereditary IQ differences is unspeakable, observed outcome differences are necessarily due to racism, or is he just playing dumb? Charles Murray spelled this out in Facing Reality back in 2021, making it the main thread of the whole book, and Pinker is probably pretty familiar with Murray.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Freddie at least claims to believe that genetic racial differences don't exist and all disparities are because of historical disadvantages and social inequality. I don't know what his answer would be to "Why shouldn't we research it" but I assume he would assume no good could come of it. Maybe because like Pinker, he secretly knows what the results would be, or maybe because he assumes the research would be done in bad faith and produce untrustworthy results.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Why does everybody walk so slowly? Come on, people, shake a leg!
But seriously, why do you all walk so slowly?
My casual walking speed just seems to be completely misaligned to the general populations baseline.
As a man of height I assume it's their diminutive, short, stubby legs that are only able to carry them barely faster than the expansion of the universe.
More options
Context Copy link
Past injuries and the uncomfortable fact that walking faster produces sweat and smell that many people don't like. Also, being depressed.
More options
Context Copy link
I lived in Manhattan for a while when I was in college and learned to walk really fast or I'd get run over. Then I went to Vienna and everyone walks so slowly it's like a contest to see who can be the most elegant and have the most free time and have the least to do and it's much more dignified. The older I get the slower I walk because howling at me at 21 works but howling at daddy makes you the crazy one.
More options
Context Copy link
And then you have the people on their phones while walking, going extra slow.
The ones going down stairs while watching Netflix I actually want to fall, just for learning purposes.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Patricians do not hurry about.
This passage stuck with me since I read the novelization of The Return of the Jedi as a young boy:
I don't know why that passage was so memorable - maybe it was my first real exposure to the concept of social signaling - but it came back to me frequently as I hurried - or saw others hurry - hither and thither.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
We're not walking. We're striding.
I prefer I nice mosey myself.
Every once in a blue moon, I've even been known to galavant.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Even voices skeptical of progress will often allow that one of the few unambiguous improvements in cost-adjusted standard of living has been in the realm of TVs. After years of a 14" Thinkpad, a $100 used iPad, various phones, and a couple of e-ink devices, I find myself in the market. Is there anything in the roughly 65" range for $250 that's more worth buying than the rest, or is it just a matter of whatever's on Amazon? Planning to use it as an output for a PC and never connect it to the Internet, generally in fairly dim rooms. Don't need above 60hz, but I have heard that adaptive sync or one of the proprietary versions thereof might be desirable for some of my intended applications (Zwift, lol). Thanks.
Make sure you measure the actual dimensions of the TV and, preferably, hold up a piece of cardboard in the wallspace you intend to use for it. A lot of times people end up with an absurdly large TV because shopping in store, 65" feels like a reasonable compromise position, only to get home and find it either doesn't fit or dominates a too-small room.
This. I come from a bigger is better tv family and the model I wanted didn't come in the size I wanted and it was WAY TOO BIG for my apartment. When I decorated my living room this year the primary goal was to balance the size of the tv (I used two identical tv stands that fit flush together with a lamp at either end).
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
pick up a used OLED. any brand will blow any non-OLED out of the water. in my market, you'd be at 55" at your budget.
Yeah I think that's probably where I'm at too upon closer investigation. Any important tires to kick for durability or botnet/privacy, when buying used?
find an oled burn in tester youtube video. I'm not a security conscious person, but you could ask Claude to fix anything weird going on after you bought it.
More options
Context Copy link
Just never setup internet access on the TV and you should be okay in terms of the latter.
Don't modern TVs quietly try to hop on any open WiFi network and to pair with any same-vendor IoT devices in the vicinity to get Internet access?
As far as I know there is zero evidence of this (ie your Sony Bravia parasitically latching onto the neighbors WiFi connection without ever telling you to transmit your data back to the mothership secretly) ever happening with any mainstream TV brand (or indeed any as far as I know). It’s internet hearsay, like claiming Siri or Alexa overheard you talking about your broken vacuum and then Google started showing you ads for a new one. Not only is it rare to find open WiFi networks with no login walls these days, but it would open TV manufacturers to a lot of legal risk.
To be fair, Sony did surreptitiously install rootkits on lots of people's computers that one time, and didn't face crippling legal consequences for doing so. I wouldn't trust their TVs without verification.
You’d probably have to go with some less well known brand like Magnavox or some distributor and manufacturer I’ve never even heard of. Maybe that’s a task for an LLM to do the research on; but the trend of the whole industry has been in one direction for decades now.
I would assume any non-mainstream, "legacy" brand that makes you think "huh, they still make TVs?" (Magnavox, RCA, Westinghouse, Phillips) or unknown brand is just some Chinese company's skinsuit at this point, so I would definitely not trust them over any other. At least there is the possibility of a large Japanese or Korean brand getting repercussions from fucking the consumer over. Yes, it rarely happens, but it could, which is probably informing their decisions. But Chinese brands operate outside of the West's ability to punish or regulate. Cheap Chinese electronics (not their prestige brands like Hisense or TCL with a reputation to lose, those are probably just as bad but no worse than the Japanese or Koreans) spying on people rarely makes the news because we rightfully go "well no shit sherlock", not because it doesn't happen.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
What's your Halloween candy kryptonite?
Mine is usually Reese's peanut butter cups or similar chocolate/PB garbage. I went over to a friend's house last night to help pass out candy (they live in a neighborhood that gets hundreds of kids trick or treating) and through superhuman effort managed to not eat any Reeses (or much of anything else). Finally, a win over the appalling sweet tooth.
I really like Reese’s, although they have gotten so expensive that Whole Foods brand peanut butter cups are actually cheaper and they taste much better so I have switched
More options
Context Copy link
I will absolutely inhale butterfingers if they are around. Luckily candy is hella expensive and I don't buy it or have it around
More options
Context Copy link
Nerds, by a mile. The texture of crushing 50 million little pebbles plus the super intense sour/sweet is entirely irreplicable. Also, props to their food scientists for inventing the abomination of Gummy Clusters, they're genuinely innovative imo.
I realize this might be unpopular, but chocolate is bottom tier for me unless it's really rich. Hershey's has cut too many corners lately.
More options
Context Copy link
Dots. I never get them any other time, but all of the ones in the variety packs I buy to hand out and whatever my kids bring home are ruthlessly consumed by the Daddy Tax.
More options
Context Copy link
Reese's used to be awesome but it's all so much slop now. Even the scion of the family has written about it in protest.
If you want good ones, at this point it's Mr. Beast or other specialty brands.
The YouTuber?
Yeah he has a great line of actual quality chocolate products.
More options
Context Copy link
Probably, he sells a ton of consumer goods using the brand he built (essentially there's always a tiny chance you'll win some large prize).
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Peanut butter m&ms are mine!
I always forget that peanut butter M&Ms exist. Usually because they don't exist within 10 feet of me for more than 30 seconds.
Yeah, I try to forget they exist for the same reason!
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Peanut butter cups are GOAT, though I'll throw in an honorary mention for Take 5s and (perhaps relatively niche) chocolate-covered Paydays.
I am very partial to regular Paydays, but more for hiking, cycling, and so forth--melt-resistant, not so strongly flavored as to fatigue the palate but still tasty and with some agreeable textures, king size is just about right--but I would not consider them outstanding specifically as Halloween candy.
I don't think I've seen those in mixed bags sold for Halloween. I like them for hiking as a change from all the Snickers variants I usually carry.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
PBC’s as well. Always thought it was strange that my father loved Almond Joy’s (I hated them), and my sibling liked Snickers (I don’t like things with nuts). They also were big breakfast eaters in the morning (I almost never was), we were all big dinner people and I was a big dessert guy (they weren’t, save for my mother’s love of baking). Might contribute some part in explaining why I love Halloween so much.
More options
Context Copy link
Reese's is top tier. York and Butterfinger are also excellent. I'd actually put Heath bars pretty near the top, but nobody tends to buy those.
Good point. My friend had bought piles of mixed bags from Costco but none had Heath bars in them. I don't know if I could've resisted those.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Anybody out there use a trackball? Any advice on brands, essential features, designs?
I've been using a trackball as my daily driver at work for years. For a long time I used a thumb-operated track ball but eventually I came to prefer the two-finger style track ball and landed on the Elecom Huge from Japan. Amazon says I bought it in 2018 and it's been working reliably since then. If you're going the large-size two-finger ball, I'd suggest you want left-click on your thumb and right-click on your ring finger.
More options
Context Copy link
I had an L-Trac back when CST was making them (seems like X-Keys now does them?). Loved it so much I bought a second so I could have one at home and at work. Used both until the switches broke, have some switches on order to solder in when they arrive.
More options
Context Copy link
I've used one for almost 3 decades. Currently have a kingston expert that's decent but the buttons aren't where I'd want them. Still miss the old marble fx for its button layout.
Might try a slimblade next.
More options
Context Copy link
I started with the Kensington Orbit almost 20 years ago and switched to the Kensington Expert when it died and haven't looked back.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I remember this post (maybe by Scott, maybe not) discussing some SJ-aligned advice to doctors (essentially, trying to use conservatives' trust of doctors to push SJ framing of issues, I remember an anti-corporate point in there though I forget exact wording) and pointing out that this would merely cause conservatives to stop trusting doctors, with horrible side-effects. Can't find it. Anybody remember what I'm talking about?
It might be Sacred Principles as Exhaustible Resources, though the context was Trump and scientists rather than SJ and doctors.
I also enjoyed:
I don't remember enough about what the political environment was like in 2017 to remember if this is absurdly prescient, or if enough of this stuff was already in place to make it a pretty straightforward expansion of visible trends.
Any political movement that isn't explicitly liberal is going to trot out "freedom from speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences", "the first amendment only applies to the government" etc. as soon as they enjoy even a little temporary, local power over the culture.
Woke cancel culture was a Thing in the left's own spaces since 1990's PC, and got a lot worse starting in the early 2010's (I think the turning point is the failure of Occupy and the collapse of economic leftism as an activist outlet, other people think it is Barack Obama's re-election campaign). The interesting question is why corporate America (including but not limited to Big Tech) went full woke during the first Trump administration.
SJ escalated massively in response to the Trump campaign, and then again in response to COVID. The SJ-sympathetic personnel were already mostly in place by 2015 AIUI; Trump just created perceived urgency.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Definitely not the post I was thinking of, although there's a similar point in there. The one I was thinking of was specifically reacting to a memo to doctors advising them to frame things in a way that blames the people SJ wanted to blame.
Not prescient; I'd already seen an SJ forum go down exactly that path before 2017 (I know this, because I got politely asked to leave in early 2016 which gives a point of reference for my memories).
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I think post-COVID that ship has irrevocably sailed, at least for the generations that were old enough when COVID hit.
I will never forget when doctors signed a letter saying that it was OK for BLM to protest during the lockdowns because racism is a public health problem.
More options
Context Copy link
Among actual red tribers there's a straightforwards age regression- under about forty, and we no longer trust doctors after the virus. Over about forty and you're talking about people who believe a response was necessary but that it was overblown, by lying media as much as by actual medical professionals, and distrust in doctors is more driven by SJ.
More options
Context Copy link
The post might have been before then, yeah.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link