@magic9mushroom's banner p

magic9mushroom

If you're going to downvote me, and nobody's already voiced your objection, please reply and tell me

2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 10 11:26:14 UTC

				

User ID: 1103

magic9mushroom

If you're going to downvote me, and nobody's already voiced your objection, please reply and tell me

2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 10 11:26:14 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1103

Something can be obvious to 99.999% of people and it can be wrong. Or do you have some belief that as long as something is obvious to 50%+ of people than it makes it true or something? OR maybe you have some additional criteria: it counts as "obvious" for everybody who acknowledges some presupposition (e.g. secular humanism) or who has IQ greater than 120 or something?

You are still on a wild goose chase. There are zero propositions that I have asked you to accept on the basis of obviousness. I do not believe that popularity makes truth. I have said this already. I am not interested in litigating a point that we both already agree on based on your continued ascription of a position to me that I do not in fact hold. If you keep bringing this up I will have to conclude that I am unable to communicate what I am and am not claiming in a way that you can understand, and withdraw from this discussion.

presuppositionalism

I still am not sure I understand what you mean by this word. Could you explain it?

To claim that and then say "and that is why it is bad for people to steal" is no sequitur. You did not ground good or bad inside this cosmology. It is invalid move, you borrow from other traditions to make moral statements. Inside this monistic materialist paradigm a billion kilograms of children falling into black hole is just bunch of atoms doing stuff - in fact it is what happens to everybody, we all end up as particles in heat death of uniform and everything smooths out to some cold cosmic structure. In that state nothing has any meaning, suffering, bliss or anything else is meaningless. Without objective yardstick in God, these experiences are subjective and they can be good, bad or neutral even from the standpoint of the same person depending of how she feels when she wakes up.

You can have a useful moral discussion even from a subjectivist standpoint, if all involved have similar subjective assessments - and humans do. "If you seek X, you should do Y" is conditional, but still valid.

Okay, sorry for pushing so hard.

So you're not accusing me of making excuses to cover up a case of Judenhass?

(Ethiopia seems like more of a charity case than Israel, much as Ukraine does, but yeah, I did notice Jordan when I was looking this up prior to my first post. What's the story there, do you happen to know?)

You've gone to a lot of trouble in this thread to insinuate that people who want US aid to Israel cut just hate Jews. My point is this: all you need to get to "cut foreign aid, Israel biggest offender" is:

  1. to think aid to Ukraine is useful
  2. to think aid to Israel is not useful.

That's it. Israel is AFAIK #2, so once you accept those Israel is indeed "the biggest fish [worth frying] to fry first", no special animus against Jews required. This is of course much less true once you get out of US politics, as the other Western nations do not donate large sums of money to Israel every year (I have recently argued, offsite, that banning Palestine Action was essentially required to preserve the British social contract - although arresting the thousands of people who whined about it was not).

If you're wondering why I chose to drop into this thread (beyond the part that brought this thread to my attention i.e. "you got reported and I volunteer every day" :V), it's because I do think that Israel sticks out as an unusually-(large-and-undeserved) recipient of US charity which means you're accusing me of false pretence (and, y'know, also accusing me of subscribing to anti-Semitism, which... okay, I suppose I'm supposed to feel horrified by it, or something, since I'm part Prussian Jew and all, but honestly I just find it stupid and tiresome; Jews are white, the end, shut up already).

But I think we should do that with many other countries, and I don't think Israel is particularly bad. I cannot help Noticing these isolated demands for fidelity. It's all about ethics in international politics, right?

If you could name a country that both a) you believe the USA should cut support for, and b) receives more US aid than Israel does, that would go a long way toward proving your claim that opposition to support for Israel is indeed (in the USA) an isolated demand for rigour. Otherwise, this would not seem to be obvious motivated reasoning but simply a case of "tackle the biggest pointless money sink first before the smaller ones".

(In the rest of the West, this is a very-different kettle of fish, of course.)

It is obvious only if you have a presupposition that debate has any meaning.

You keep using the word "presupposition", which seems to elide the difference between two different acts:

  1. Asserting that X is true;
  2. Assuming that X is true.

My proof there is that any useful debates that are to be had, have the assumption that there's no Cartesian Daemon. I don't assert it, I merely assert that all truth-finding value of discussion or contemplation is in worlds where that assumption is true. Hence, we should either assume no Cartesian Daemon when discussing, or not discuss at all (and do something else instead).

One just cannot say that "X is obvious" and automatically win a debate.

You have misinterpreted me and are on a wild goose chase.

I thought that this...

Essentially, if a Cartesian Daemon is messing with your mind, contemplation (individually or in groups via discussion) can produce arbitrary answers with no relation to what is true (a Daemon that wants to ensure you conclude X, or wants to prevent you concluding Y, can definitely do so by messing with your cognition).

So, let's break this down into cases.

Case 1: Cartesian Daemon. Discussion intended to achieve truths (which philosophical discussion - philosophical meaning "loving of wisdom" - is) will fail, so we might as well not do it.

Case 2: No Cartesian Daemon. Discussion might achieve things, but since there's no Cartesian Daemon we don't need to discuss that particular possibility.

Morton's Fork: both Case 1 and Case 2 imply that discussing Cartesian-Daemon scenarios is pointless, so since one of them's true this is true unconditionally.

...was so obvious that my vague allusion to it...

There's just obviously no point in discussing that scenario or even contemplating it, so we might as well act as if they're not.

...would suffice for you to immediately regenerate that proof in your head, and as such didn't spell it out (because spelling things out unnecessarily can be interpreted as condescension). Apparently, it was not obvious to you, so I did spell it out. At no point did I make a claim that obvious things are true; I merely used (apparent) obviousness as a criterion for elision, as a matter of debate etiquette.

Who cares about psychologizing, if - in your mind somebody believes something because of psychology. It is just pure ad hominem. I can invent any psychological story of how somebody believes something because of their mother and father and trauma or whatnot. But is it True?

No, premise 2 is false. Arianism (i.e. Christianity minus the "1 = 3, it's a divine mystery" bit) can account for all those things. Islam can account for all those things. Zoroastrianism (which is at least sort of polytheistic) can account for all those things. Deism can account for all those things. Materialism can account for all of them except objective morality (which may not exist, and does not seem necessary for debate since a shared subjective morality can lead to shared conclusions).

The conclusion that the Christian God exists might be right or wrong, but premise 2 is clearly false; I can grant that it might seem true to someone who'd only heard of Nicene Christianity, materialism-without-natural-selection, and Hinduism, but that's not us. (Premise 1 is worded in a fashion that I don't know exactly what is meant by it; premise 3 is true, but the argument does not function without premise 2.)

It's just incredibly frustrating to repeatedly ask someone to explain what they mean, and to basically get back "lol u are retarded, u can't read" each time, when they are objectively failing to use the language coherently.

I agree. Guy was not responding reasonably. As some of the mods have told you, though, you did have the option of saying to yourself "I can't keep a lid on myself when dealing with this guy" and ghosting him. There are times I get sufficiently pissed-off to ghost, or to go into anal-retentive "check every single word for hostility" mode. I did the latter here, for instance; I caught that I was hopping mad at Hlynka* for third-personing/bulverising me (checking offsite records, my first response, though I didn't post it, was "take a swim in H2SO4") and carefully stuck to dry factual corrections (and, IIRC, checked them again for hostility before posting) because I did not trust myself to engage him in a broader and more-genuine fashion while keeping to the rules.

*TequilaMockingbird was Hlynka, although I didn't know this at the time; the fact that he's banned (and confirmed as at least partially trolling) is the reason I'm willing to specify all of this, as posting that one thought about telling somebody to torture himself to death is not all that different from telling him to torture himself to death

If he knew that he was selling restricted chips to China, and he knew that he was covering for a spy by lawfaring the probe into Megaspeed, that's definitely treacherous (if not technically treasonous under the very-narrow US definition - the Rosenbergs weren't tried for treason).

Eh, you seem to post about it a similar amount to me, and I'd call it a hobbyhorse of mine. Cut off any toes pushed across the line into the objectively-false, of course, but too much of a fuss about the subjective stuff is going to hit your reputation just as hard if not harder.

EDIT: And if, at any point, you want to actually cite where I was a "dick" -- you know, using evidence of my actual words -- then that might be a lot more effective than just throwing a tantrum in my direction.

K, here are some quotes from your side of that exchange that were "snippy":

This is gibberish.

Stop making stuff up.

I never claimed I did. Stop making stuff up.

No, I didn't. Please stop lying.

If you're going to be childish and rude, try actually reading the comment you're replying to.

No, I don't. Stop making stuff up.

I have no idea what you're talking about, and neither do you.

I'd love an explanation. A genuine explanation that doesn't hide behind using complicated words to disguise the fact that there's no actual substance there.

That's ok. Neither of us grasps it.

I don't know why you're incapable of admitting you're wrong or apologising for making up things about another user.

This is obviously entirely different to the way you used "works" in your facetious unicorn analogy, where you mean something like "telling this story accomplishes my goals".

I never said you did, nor would I think you capable.

You keep refusing to do this and pretending not to understand.

Ok, buddy. Maybe learn to spell, as a bare minimum, before accusing other people of being stupid.

Like, sure, the guy's obviously ESL and - if what I've been getting on the volunteer page is any indication - badly needs an explicit mod warning that he needs to respond to all the misunderstandings caused by that with apology instead of insults. I think Amadan erred by not giving such a warning in this instance and saying that he's been good the rest of the time - he is good a lot of the time, but this isn't the first time he's exhibited that specific pattern. But yeah, you were pretty snippy and kind of dickish (though not remotely to his extent).

may have told her his own company's private secrets

Jensen Huang was also an important Trump advisor, hence possible bad advice and/or passing on stuff Trump told him. And, yeah, chip smuggling.

although there is no evidence of it?

More correctly, you (and I) have not yet seen any solid evidence that Jensen Huang was knowingly doing the bidding of the CPC. (I do not believe we've seen evidence that he wasn't, either - the guy did spend years aggressively lobbying to sell chips to China, and interfered with a government investigation into a Chinese spy.)

I will also note that QF said that Huang might go down in history as the worst traitor since the Rosenbergs, which acknowledges that the Rosenbergs were worse (and that he might not be considered such a traitor, if for instance he was merely duped).

The second part is about the smuggling and espionage aspect, where the implications, if true, would be much worse, an actual criminal offense, than merely a consenting couple having sex (albeit involving the CEO of the largest publicly traded company in the world), yet the lax reaction by Washington is weird.

You're misinterpreting this as a "lax reaction by Washington". What it is is more correctly a "lax reaction by Donald Trump"; Congress is investigating. Donald Trump is probably relying on his "corruption isn't that bad" and "(almost) never back down" heuristics, presumably due to still not fully grokking the government world and/or early-stage dementia. As I said in the previous subthread, this could well get Trump impeached and convicted.

What does it mean obviously and no point?

are we supposed to decide what is true and worthy to pursue by obviousness and having point?

Can I say that Cartersia Demon obviously exists and thus there is no point having discussion, ending in some post-modern nihilism?

Essentially, if a Cartesian Daemon is messing with your mind, contemplation (individually or in groups via discussion) can produce arbitrary answers with no relation to what is true (a Daemon that wants to ensure you conclude X, or wants to prevent you concluding Y, can definitely do so by messing with your cognition).

So, let's break this down into cases.

Case 1: Cartesian Daemon. Discussion intended to achieve truths (which philosophical discussion - philosophical meaning "loving of wisdom" - is) will fail, so we might as well not do it.

Case 2: No Cartesian Daemon. Discussion might achieve things, but since there's no Cartesian Daemon we don't need to discuss that particular possibility.

Morton's Fork: both Case 1 and Case 2 imply that discussing Cartesian-Daemon scenarios is pointless, so since one of them's true this is true unconditionally.

I assumed (apparently falsely) that this proof was sufficiently "obvious" that you would immediately grasp it and thus I didn't need to belabour the point by stating it.

As for having point, um, yes, we should choose courses of action based on whether they achieve our goals? If you want X, and Y will achieve X, you want Y.

Whatever it is, it is your presupposition even in this naive and unexamined form.

Okay, look. There's this pattern I've seen you fall into with others, and you're falling into it now.

  1. Your interlocutor says X.
  2. You respond to your interlocutor as though he's saying Y, presumably because English isn't your first language and you honestly misinterpreted him.
  3. Your interlocutor responds that he's not saying Y, and is in fact saying X.
  4. You insist that your interlocutor is saying Y, and sometimes insult him (as I just quoted).

Steps 1-3 are fine. English not being your first language isn't your fault, so I can certainly make allowance for some degree of misinterpretation. But step 4 is not fine. That you occasionally misinterpret me isn't my fault either, insisting that I'm saying things I'm not saying is not productive, and insulting me is not justified. You need to understand that you are frequently misinterpreting others, and that the proper response to this is to ask for clarification rather than insulting us.

Sure, I can present it here in this context as there are more transcendental arguments for God, including Kantian one. I mean it in this sense.

Okay, thanks. Do you believe these premises? Premise 2 appears very obviously to be an error by Kant, due partially to his life being before the theory of natural selection was created by Wallace and Darwin and thus a materialistic explanation of 3/4 of those was devised, and partially due to privileging the Christian hypothesis over e.g. deism simply because there are more Christians than deists.

Mirror life itself isn't especially dangerous, and IIRC we actually do have the ability to build mirror bacteria. Life 2.0 is, however, extraordinarily dangerous.

They don't benefit the people cyberattacked by them!

(Also, they look set to stop releasing weights sometime soon; the cyberattacks are starting to make the CPC nervous.)

A mostly-innocent one is that Huang (at some point in the affair, perhaps when she asked where he kept the nuclear wessels) suspected he was being honeytrapped, went to his buds in the administration, and they told him to keep it going to feed her disinformation, and in fact did so.

That would mean that the administration thought that feeding Alice Huang disinformation was worth selling China $4.3 billion of contraband AI chips and following through on policy proposals that seem to have been CPC-approved. This seems both unlikely and scandalous in its own right.

Another mostly-innocent one is that the CIA knew she was a spy, Huang did not, but he was just screwing her and didn't actually give her any information.

Plausible, but doesn't absolve Trump for continuing to consult Jensen Huang; even assuming Trump knew that Jensen Huang was not actually pillow-talking and that he wouldn't start pillow-talking, there's the "she potentially tapped his phones" problem.

It's also possible Huang was leaking her some information, and the CIA found out much later... but now wishes to pretend they knew all along to cause China to doubt the information they got. In this case... well, you gotta sell it.

This plan would seem to necessarily include Donald Trump agreeing to play (secondary) fall-guy to the media. This does not match my model of Donald Trump.

In this argument you posit that debate is meaningless if stable reality does not exist and if it is fucked up by Carthesian demons and similar stuff. I assert that meaningful debate exists. Therefore meaningful and stable reality exists, and no Carthesian demon shenanigans are real.

No, that's not what I'm saying. There is some probability that Cartesian-Daemon shenanigans are occurring. There's just obviously no point in discussing that scenario or even contemplating it, so we might as well act as if they're not.

There is a difference between assuming something and asserting it. I assume that AI will not destroy the world when I'm making plans for the long-term. This isn't because I think AI will definitely not destroy the world (I think it's about 30% we all die); it's just that you can't actually execute on plans, or collect on investments, if you're dead, so that chunk of possibility-space is not useful to plan for.

Transcendental Argument for God

I have not found you explaining what this is.

UK lawmakers are probably aware that some children will see porn from their adults' screen...but should be aware that some children will see their parents having sex, and the correct course of action is obviously not to ban sex, but threaten such parents with neglect.

This is Chesterton's Ruins; we know plenty of societies - literally the majority of humans that have ever lived - did and do allow this with nothing bad happening. It would seem pretty stupid to call exposing kids to something that won't hurt them "neglect".

Simulation hypothesis doesn't ruin everything as long as you're not being fucked with mentally and as long as the simulation is, like the Matrix, a full world rather than just a trick for you that doesn't model the parts you're not interacting with. Given those stipulations you can still come to conclusions about the simulation.

So, um.

Trump just admitted that he knew for the last year one of his top advisors was dating a Chinese spy, and that he doesn't regret his decision to neither ask Huang to dump Huang nor stop consulting him, and that he wants to continue using him as an advisor.

I can honestly believe that Trump is too inexperienced at this whole "national security" thing (or too demented, or a mixture of both) to realise that this is not how you're supposed to do things. But this seems like the sort of obvious NatSec breach that might actually get those 11-13 Republican Senators to vote to convict.

But we don't know what that looks like and cannot really tell a dyson swarm from ordinary interstellar dust that covers a star.

Yes, we can, actually. Look up Tabby's Star, where they found something like this and used the differential blocking of different wavelengths to prove it had to be dust and not macroscopic objects.

For example, if there were a civilization comparable in sophistication to Renaissance Italy 150 light years away from us, right now, how would we even know?

Renaissance Italy, maybe not (although we're making progress on our ability to detect even that). But "Renaissance Italy" is a tiny slice of time compared to the amount of time a civilisation could persist at Kardashev II (unless Late Filters are a thing, which seems like something we want to know about!), and K2 likely would be visible to us over much of the galaxy - Dyson Spheres are not stealthy and deploying them en-masse is even less so (antimatter rockets are also pretty obvious, although solar sails admittedly aren't).

A new paper is out(https://arxiv.org/pdf/1806.02404)

That paper is eight years old.

Also, this is one of the better papers in the "claims to dissolve the Fermi Paradox" genre (I remember reading at least three) in that its thesis, if proven true, would solve the Fermi Paradox. It's still not actually good; for one, their estimates are basically a lot of irrelevant set-dressing on "if you assume that there's a 40% chance abiogenesis is a universe-scale Great Filter and that there's no panspermia, you'll find that there's a >40% chance that we're alone in the universe" (yes, almost all of it is that one element), and for two, saying "the Filter might be abiogenesis" doesn't actually solve the Fermi Paradox - people have been saying that since before I was born, and I remember September 11. Solving the Fermi Paradox, for real, requires positively identifying the Filter, not saying "a Filter exists and it's probably either abiogenesis+no-panspermia or one of the increases in complexity between minimum-viable-lifeform and tool-users that can take over their planet" (note that "Earthlike planets are rare" used to be a live option, but we've proven that one wrong - this is what real progress on the Fermi Paradox looks like, and it involved a lot of fiddling with telescopes).

(Betteridge's Law strikes again.)

You need to put the word "(North)east" before "Asian" to be technically correct (I'm not saying that there aren't lookers from the rest of Asia, but there are definitely those I'd rate well below 8). I think white women can push a bit higher than that, also.

Perhaps I didn't make myself clear. There is a legitimate tradeoff for the programmer when deciding which language to use. It is sensible for people to pick one for some things, and another for others - and for this division to differ between people. A restriction one imposes on oneself cannot be unreasonable.

If there were some movement to arrest everyone who didn't program in Rust, that would be insane (within organisations gets more complicated; there are moral hazard issues), but @ZorbaTHut does not appear to have been ordered by anyone to use Rust.