OliveTapenade
No bio...
User ID: 1729
I think you would struggle to find much biblically that implies that it's all right for a married man to go and sleep with prostitutes. Biblically I think there are basically three categories for righteous women - virgins, wives, and widows. Whenever prostitution or harlotry are mentioned, it is always with a very strong negative valence.
That said, that is a nitpick not particularly germane to the point. As you say, Jensen Huang's various affairs were with married women. There is no way to justify Huang's affairs as being compatible with any kind of traditional Judeo-Christian sexual ethic.
In that light I stand by what I said - if a person is inclined to overlook or tolerate small sins or crimes simply because of the existence of larger ones, that person is the one being taken for a ride. Porkpiehat labels his position as "against degeneracy". If you forbear criticising a small degeneracy because of a large one, you're allowing the Overton Window to be dragged in the direction of more degeneracy.
The whole thing reminds me of the absurdity of 'conservatives' defending Hugh Hefner when he passed away, as if he were some sort of example of healthy straight male sexuality. It wasn't hard to see the real underlying motive, i.e. progressives don't like Hefner, so defending Hefner annoys progressives, which is what we really want to do. Ross Douthat ably criticised that approach, and the same applies here.
Hefner was not an example of healthy male heterosexuality. Neither is Jensen Huang. Bad things are still bad, even if there are also worse things.
I don't think it's conservative or remotely defensive of traditional values to tolerate what is, explicitly, a violation of the Ten Commandments, just because... other violations also exist.
Just on a tactical level I think you're wrong - tolerating ordinary adultery is part of what eventually legitimises things like OnlyFans, pornography, prostitution, and so on. If they can make you overlook small sins by committing large sins, they're winning, and are dragging you over in their direction.
All sin is bad, and if you tolerate adultery because you think some OnlyFans huckster is worse, you're the sucker.
Nobody believes it because they still wouldn't trust AI with their tax returns. Most normies don't trust an AI book to remember it's plot, an AI legal filing to not contain mistakes, or AI managing a transaction not overspend or get their account banned.
Would you trust a bot with a tax return or to make a legal filing? To make decisions about your money? To write a novel?
I wouldn't agree with that, but before explaining why, we should distinguish serious thinkers from impactful thinkers. 'Defining the age', or having a large effect on others or on the world, do not make a thinker serious. A serious thinker might be someone no one has ever heard of; a very influential thinker might be a superficial fool.
Now in this case I don't think Yudkowsky actually qualifies as either, but to be clear, I meant seriousness, not impact. The case is fairly self-explanatory in terms of impact - for all that Yudkowsky was and is a self-appointed 'expert' on AI, the industry as it actually came to exist has not been shaped by his ideas or prescriptions. The AI safety movement itself largely fails to meet the bar of effectiveness or impact, but even if it did, it does not function in a particularly Yudkowskyan way. I'm not sure what you mean by 'the age', but I do not see any significant way in which his ideas have shaped the world. Yudkowsky is a mildly famous blogger. That's all.
Still, my criticism was of the merits of Eliezer Yudkowsky Thought (and Nick Bostrom Thought), rather than of them as activists. Let me put it this way. What are their philosophically interesting ideas? What insights would you attribute to them? I'm not sure where to start, really - the Sequences are large, rambling, and turgid, and I would say not philosophically interesting, in the sense that very little in them is new or insightful.
I wouldn't say that Data is on par with Claude. Data is clearly a person. He has memories, desires, persistent self-awareness, and so on. Though Data claims to not have emotions, like Spock before him, he clearly does. Data is a human-like intelligence. Claude is not an intelligence at all.
From the writing perspective, I think it's fairly straightforward? Data is first and foremost a character. He is written as a person who happens to be made of metal, much as Worf is a person who happens to be a klingon. The ship's computer is not a character. It is a tool and presented as such. Everything about what Data is or how he functions is downstream of Data as a character,
"AI capability is a function of accumulated research, and if that function's growth rate isn't slow enough then after AI can do any AI research y'=f(y) blows up" ... simple enough to squeeze into two clauses (for anyone who's had Calc 1; for "most people" maybe add a second or third sentence too), sure.
I think that's already overcomplicating it. The mathematics isn't important. What you're trying to get across is the idea of a learning supercomputer, and I think that's easily comprehensible by most people on the street.
Don't be distracted by the acronym 'RSI'. All 'RSI' means is "a computer that gets smarter very very quickly". I think that concept is both very simple and very well-understood.
yet it's surprisingly hard to find people who were taking this seriously who didn't get there via Bostrom and Yudkowsky.
I actually don't rate Bostrom or Yudkowsky as serious thinkers to begin with.
This isn't my read on things. Average and dumb people can understand the concept just fine. They might not like it and the changes it brings, but they absolutely recognize the threat; it's been communicated by, if nothing else, pretty simple and direct sci fi stories that they've seen on the big screen.
Right - I think the OP comes off a bit too much like "most people aren't as smart as me", whereas I suspect that most people understand the central plot point of The Terminator.
"We build a superintelligent computer and things go badly" isn't some sort of weird esoterica. It's been a theme in popular media for over half a century. You don't need a high IQ to understand, "Maybe we build a computer and the computer improves itself and then the computer destroys us".
Charitably, maybe the OP means that most people don't think that's likely in reality, or that most people don't understand the specific mechanism that he posits for it. I think the former is probably true and the latter is probably false. I think most people don't expect Skynet to appear, but most people probably can understand the concept of a computer that makes itself smarter. It's really not a very complicated idea.
I dislike the tactic, and realizing that I'm piling on, but I think the message is straightforward: "Our tribe is stronger. We will murder your tribe. Watch as we attack and you do nothing."
Pretty much. It's a radicalisation tactic, surely? It's a variant of the Extremist's Gambit - a visible, violent action forces onlookers to pick a side. Joe Biden is an extremely visible, prestigious individual. Openly attacking him displays your strength (especially cultural strength) and forces onlookers to pick a side, either allowing the action or taking a stand against it.
In Greer's words, polarisation is intentional. The attack is on the uncommitted middle ground - either you're with the (genocidal) establishment, or you're with the (righteous) rebels. There must be nowhere to hide.
It's hard to find a perfect, 'control' scandal. Profumo just sprang to mind as the most famous example of a sex scandal bringing down a politician.
This ties in with the ambiguities of morality. I predict Mr. Huang will recover. He will remain in good standing with the public and the media despite this. Yet had he been revealed as using a sock puppet for posting "badthink" online, well, this would be much worse in the eyes of the public. Indeed, Patrick Stewart had 2 affairs and it amounted to a footnote in media coverage of his passing.
The public and the media don't particularly care about sexual morality, the sanctity of marriage, or the like any more. A consensual affair is generally treated as a private matter, with no public regard for the victim, that is, the deceived or betrayed spouse.
I am reminded of Barnaby Joyce's affair a few years back, and the debate over whether this was an appropriate thing for media to report on at all, or whether it was in the public interest. While politicians do have some right to privacy, I would have thought that whether a major political figure (he was deputy prime minister at the time, the Australian equivalent of vice president) can be trusted to keep his promises, even on the most sacred matters, is of public concern.
We are a long way from the Profumo affair, when adultery was still seen as a significant offence.
As I've said before, one of my convictions is that I will never support an unrepentant adulterer for any political office. Jensen Huang does not have an elected office, so I don't need to make an assessment along those lines, but I am willing to conclude, "Yep, he's a bad person".
Now that said, I suspect that most tech leaders are also terrible people, whether because of adultery or something else, so I don't think that Huang is uniquely bad. But adultery is bad, from Jensen Huang to Patrick Stewart.
It is plausible that the order matters.
'Hostile to pleasure' seems like an odd description of a party that instituted policies like Strength Through Joy.
That's largely been my feeling on the Fermi 'paradox'.
Or, well, I have two feelings on it.
The first is that I'm annoyed that people call it a paradox. It's not a paradox. It's at most a question, or a mystery. A paradox has to involve a contradiction of some kind. An observation that seems odd is not a paradox.
But that's just pedantry. My second feeling is that it just seems pointless, to me? We don't have enough data to plausibly speculate as the prevalence of life in the galaxy, or the prevalence of advanced technological life, or any kind of life that might be visible to human civilisation from Earth. The answer to, "Why haven't we seen evidence of extraterrestrial life?" is "We don't know, and we don't have enough information to do anything more than speculate".
Armchair speculation can be fun. Maybe life is very rare, so it's just that we're the only one out there. Maybe life is more common than that but we just happen to the first one off the mark. Maybe there's some sort of 'Great Filter'; technological civilisations destroy themselves, or all lose themselves in virtual worlds, or for some reason don't leave traces of their presence. Maybe extraterrestrial civilisation deliberately conceals itself. Maybe we're some sort of technological outlier and we don't know how to look. There are just too many possible options and with a sample of exactly one, Earth itself, we can't calculate any plausible probabilities.
I just don't think there's a paradox or even a particular puzzle here. Thus far we have not seen any signs of extraterrestrial civilisations. That's not a paradox. That's just an observation that we don't yet know the explanation for.
I agree that he's not as crazy as Candace Owens, but I think he's still around, say, the Hasan Piker level of crazy. That's not maximally unhinged, but it's still across my threshold for describing someone as a loony conspiracist.
If Fuentes is over your bar for insane conspiracism, the bar might be in a bad place...
What would it mean to be 'actually' non-binary? Human beings are binarily gendered. Do you mean people with various intersex conditions? People who use medication and surgery to try to achieve an androgynous appearance? Something else?
For what it's worth, in my experience I have met two types of non-binary person, which I think of as (and I am aware of the irony), male NBs and female NBs.
Male NBs are usually straight guys who don't want to be fully trans, but in some way want to defect from or signal that they're not participating in conventional masculinity. (Pa)trick Weekes might be an example of this, but I have met some in person. Generally they look like ordinary men, maybe with a pony-tail, or maybe with painted nails, or something trivial like that.
Female NBs that I've met are generally just lesbians. They're just lesbians. Usually a bit of a butch affect, short hair, tomboyish, etc., but if you round them off to lesbians you won't lead yourself far wrong.
I always find the comments like this interesting because they do seem to show that the woke progressive and the white supremacist share a very similar worldview. When this is pointed out it's usually to criticise the progressive ("don't you realise how racist your position is?"), but the same also applies in reverse, where I'm inclined to say to the white supremacist, "don't you realise how progressive you are?"
The funny part is that both sides can accuse the other of a hypocrisy while ignoring the fact that their own position entails the same hypocrisy.
I just think it's absurd to try to split hairs to draw some sort of 'victory' out of a national project that clearly failed to achieve its goal. All military action occurs within political constraints and for the sake of political goals - if a military force was unable to achieve its goals within the political constraints it inhabited, then that's a failure. The most famous example, the Tet Offensive, was a failure for North Vietnam in the sense of taking territory or inflicting casualties, but it was a success in the sense that it meaningfully contributed to and helped achieve the political aims of North Vietnam.
This is, I suppose, a semantic dispute. We use phrases like, 'military defeat and political victory', or 'tactical defeat and strategic victory', or the like, to try to communicate that. We would all agree, for instance, that in Afghanistan, American troops generally defeated Taliban (and other) troops when engaging them directly, but also that, overall, America failed to achieve its goals and the Taliban did achieve theirs. Of course differing levels of political will or commitment to the fight are key in explaining why the Americans withdrew and the Taliban kept fighting, and I think that's just part of war. Level of political support or commitment is part of the mission profile, and it's something that each combatant has to manage, shoring up their own suppport as well as degrading the opposition's commitment.
At any rate, it doesn't sound like we disagree about any specific facts on the ground. I just get grouchy about this sometimes because I am mildly annoyed by Americans saying things like "the United States has never lost a war", a claim which is only possible to sustain by redefining the concept of 'losing a war.'
These distinctions have always been cope. The purpose of military action is to achieve a political goal.
There's a sense in which one can identify immediate or battlefield success even while acknowledging that it may not have successfully contributed to a larger goal. We say that Hannibal was a brilliant general even though he did not achieve any of Carthage's political goals.
Nonetheless I think we understand that it would be absurd to say that the Second Punic War was a military victory and political loss for Carthage (even notwithstanding Zama). It doesn't matter how many battlefield victories you can list if you cannot achieve your overall political goals. Local military victories are possible, but a war is, ultimately, a project whereby a state attempts to use military force in order to accomplish particular goals, and if the application of military force does not accomplish those goals, then it failed.
The United States was defeated in Vietnam. The United States was defeated in Afghanistan. It looks like it may well have been defeated in Iran. Whining along the lines of "we beat them every time we met them in battle!" is absurd.
Clearly my lack of political vision and ambition. I need to nurture the Slytherin inside myself and dream larger.
If we’re not getting Hitler 2.0 then let’s just do managed decline
As opposed to...
Presumably Hitler 2.0 would be immediate and catastrophic decline that leaves the country a bombed-out ruin?
In my experience, restrict-voting-to-the-educated proposals mostly come from right-wingers, though I would be unsurprised myself if the effects of such a proposal would end up favouring Democrats.
It is, of course, possible that someone might sincerely, for principled reasons, support a reform that would harm their own side.
(My opinion is that these proposals are misguided - they inevitably hand a huge amount of power over to whoever it is who gets to decide the criteria for voting. I can understand the intuitive appeal of the idea that you should understand the political system and have a basic ability to analyse problems before you can make a choice about it, but in practice I don't think it can be fairly implemented. Moreover, I also tend to think that interests often matter in voting more than intelligence does. I don't expect insert-stupid-demographic-here to be more capable of analysing problems than insert-smart-demographic-here. I do expect, however, the stupid demographic to be more motivated to vote for their own interests than people outside that demographic, and so their voting forces politicians to take that demographic's interests seriously. There is a cut-off below which people are too intellectually handicapped to vote (e.g. someone with dementia, someone with severe development retardation, etc.), and I'd agree with excluding those people, but I don't think that illiteracy, lack of English proficiency, an IQ of 80, etc., should be disqualifiers.)
(In this particular case I think it's interesting that IntoTheWind's screening test is about English language proficiency. I assume he intends it as a proxy for mental acuity in general, but I think its main effects would be to exclude people with low English ability and people with small vocabularies. I might suggest that verbal agility, though, is a skill that one associates more with educated demographics that skew left, so it might not have the effect he wants.)
You can’t say both “a lot of people libertarian by nature” and welfare is broadly popular.
He didn't. He said that conservatives are like libertarians-by-nature, i.e. very rare.
If I had to guess 95% of voters are conservative by nature but differ on what they want to conserve.
This is not a meaningful category of voters. Yes, pretty much everybody is 'conservative' in a strictly etymological sense. Everybody has something they want to conserve or protect. In the same way pretty much everybody is 'progressive' in the etymological sense, i.e. having something they want to progress or advance. But 'people who want to conserve something' and 'people who want to progress something' are not demographic you can appeal to.
In practice we understand that when we use the words 'conservative' or 'progressive' in a political context, we refer to groups of people with particular ideological visions.
When SophisticatedHillbilly says that 'conservatives' are a small group, well, I think there's room for some debate around what the word 'conservative' specifically refers to, but in broad strokes I think he's undoubtedly right. Whether we're talking about movement conservatives, social conservatives, economic conservatives, national conservatives, or any other term, it's clear that these are small tribes that can win only by finding a place for themselves within a larger coalition. That coalition then tends to limit what they can do.
2rafa is correct that there is a kind of left-leaning civil infrastructure in Western countries that shapes and defines what's politically possible, but notwithstanding, Hillbilly is correct on the larger point. The reason that 'Western conservatives' in 2rafa's top-level post are unable to achieve lasting transformations of the country is because they really don't have that much support. They can join winning coalitions, but if they try to pursue transformative agendas, they run into not only institutional but popular backlash, because their goals are genuinely unpopular.
Enough to impeach him? What's the process there?
- Prev
- Next

You said:
I think this is in effect excusing or overlooking a smaller crime because larger crimes exist.
Moreover, as I said, from a tactical perspective it's not even effective. Criticising Jensen Huang's affairs is the same cause as criticising OnlyFans, pornography, and prostitution. They are related. Abandoning moral consistency is not only in-principle wrong, but pragmatically wrong as well.
More options
Context Copy link