BANNED USER: Ban extended for arguing in edits
>Unban in 50d 09h 19m
Opt-out
No bio...
User ID: 4089
Banned by: @Amadan
You only need 50 Senate votes. And yes it’s time to get rid of the filibuster. The legislature should doing more legislating and the courts less.
I think Robert killed any chance the texturalism will be a future legal theory. Robert’s declared birthright isn’t texturally therefore unless GOP drops birthright (I believe it’s doubtful) then we will likely see a litmus test on Birthright for future GOP judges and it’s tough to swap a recent precedence so they will be likely adopting new legal theories to justify their views.
No they will not be tan white people. They will either be nearly identical to native Europeans or be servant class. That is how it works in Mexico. So the most likely path is they will be tan people who clean your table and home.
I’ve found upper caste Indias (and Pakis etc) as probably the group that easiest assimilates to the US. Especially in the upper class. We have right-wing Indian politicians in the west.
There’s basically zero East Asian or non-European Latinos in power in the west. Caste probably significantly matters for Indians and Muslims. And a wider variety of outcomes.
Why would you be happy about this ruling and then say the US would essentially be a different country. The US or Rome is the great country the world has ever seen - why would you want that dead? There is nothing more important than preserving the US.
In modern America you amend the Constitution thru the Supreme Court. I guess you could call that a common law system. And it’s still a hard thing to do.
I think it would be fair to just call this 5-4 so I guess this is still in play. This is probably 9-0 or 8-1 in 2018.
This might be worth Trump ignoring the court and challenging their authority which has always been an important balance of power. He could just lose the citizenship paperwork.
The question now comes down to how long does Sotomayors health hold up. Birthright is dead if anything happens to her and the GOP holds the Presidency.
Yep wrong. But was like 95% of being upheld on prediction markets. Already being at 4 to strike it down I would have thought got Robert’s in play.
Barrett was a mistake.
My expectations I guess were wrong on birthright especially with already having a 5-4 vote. I thought Robert’s would jump on Kavanaughs view and give the legislature a crack at it. On one hand you only need to flip 1 vote how to get rid of it, but it’s Alito and Thomas who get appointed next. Barrett will be around for a long time. Kavanaugh is in favor of striking it down but will he break with precedence now on a 5-4 vote. Basically can retry this if the right justice dies soon.
I guess I get a small win on predictions being one of the few in the camp it was in play.
She said they should have found another argument to enshrine an abortion right and it was the wrong case. So there was still a desire to find a plausible argument that made abortion a right.
Presuppose Roe was decided correctly. But we still had 30% of US population voting to overturn it anyway as single issue voters. Is that good for society? It’s better now people can vote on it.
2A already has been butchered. Maybe it’s good maybe it’s bad. But status quo is a court that isn’t being textualists on 2A.
You have admitted yourself theirs plausible cover to rule either way. Slaves paid global taxes to US. Migrants do not etc.
I think the Robert’s court is pragmatic so I think they find a way to give a flexible ruling.
I want to place a bet on birthright. I care basically zero about the legal arguments and I don’t think Robert’s primary instinct is choosing the best legal argument.
Simplistically I don’t believe Robert’s will want to create the next Roe v Wade that lacks a legislative solution and ends up creating a voting block that only votes for repeal of Roe. I will consider voting only for candidates who will appoint judges who will repeal Birthright if Robert’s removes the ability of action on the issue outside of the SC. I think both legal arguments to go either way are intellectually coherent so you can just pick the legal theory you want.
My gut says he upholds most of birthright but finds a way to let congress make the rules in the future. This may be the weakest legal theory to just punt to congress but it feels like it fits with Robert decisions. And this includes deciding the Fed is special today. It’s usually better to punt controversial things to congress instead of locking change into multi-decade SC battles.
Everyone knows amending the constitution is impossible now so amending the Constitution just comes down to change the Court membership. Getting controversial things out of the court hands has value to maintain the Court legitimacy. You don’t want a different court in 20 years reversing tomorrows decision.
IMO an amendment guaranteeing Fed Independence would be worse than the disease. The Fed can do Coups. They do have the technology to cause a Depression. You would essentially give the Fed the power to hold the rest of government hostage. That is not good. As it is now if Trump does something bad he can lose the next election.
They did not do it on purpose but they basically caused the Great Depression.
For Mexico that changed sometime post 1980. I think it was post WW2 Mexico wanted remigration because they wanted the labor to industrialize.
But yes I can agree remittance etc is a strong argument for a country to refuse remigration.
I’ve come across the Vietnamese argument before. I don’t personally know any but they seem like in the Houston/Louisiana area extremely well assimilated. That’s also an environment with a lot of similarities to their homeland. Even sharing some French culture for centuries.
This solution has been tried and failed in the US. We did school bussing. And affirmative action. And it failed to solve Americans original sin. We still have a large not fully assimilated ADOS class.
What is the reasoning for Somalia not wanting Somalians? I assume our Somalians are at a minimum somewhat filtered. They had to be smart enough to get the NGOs to fly them in. Is it just Somalia doing their own people a solid by refusing to let them come back?
I increasing believe personality traits differ amongst the races and it’s not just athleticism or IQ. You actually do kill a community by having diversity because every race finds the other ones annoying. White people are too loud for Asians. Blacks are too loud for whites. Everyone enjoys their neighborhood more when they just have their own people. The Tower of Babel was an underrated work of theology.
I’ve never had an actual bro that was East Asian. We have fundamentally different taste that makes that very hard. So even though many of them are the best immigrants they also tend to ruin the vibes. Nobody is going to a SEC school if they were 90% Asian. For all the hate Indians get a % of them can fully assimilate culturally. I’ve got plenty of Indian bro-friends.
Getting the political will for remigration is of course hard. Argentina found solutions to this a long time time ago and they a much less violent society than America. Sometimes you just need to do hard things.
Anti-migration is not a policy that is right or left wing. Bernie Sanders use to be anti-migration. It only became a partisan issue because everything has become a partisan issue in the US.
I just would not consider it heroic. Especially on interstate highways where going 80 is realistic. 16 hours getting close to 80 for long distance travel.
I guess you are stopping places so there is no need to do a lot of mileage but I don’t consider 800 miles in a day as a lot. I just had a friend leave Florida for Detroit to see family and he started at 3 am to avoid traffic.
Only a few western states would have a need for 800+ days when your not actually relocating etc.
You don’t need to work to have income. The US doesn’t tax a random German on capital gains. The US does not have this type of Jurisdiction.
That’s all we need to strike down birthright. You just need to show a type of jurisdiction the Feds lack versus the jurisdiction they had on slaves. Any differences give you legal room to end birth right.
Actually I don’t think it’s clear at all in our system that Courts get to create law when the law is ambiguous. Which is important for birthright because we do not have a definition for Jurisdiction. Courts would still have a legal author to make ruling when the law is clear so they still have a purpose. In the case of birthright I don’t think a Court should be able to rule either way. If the executive does birthright then the court can’t say it’s illegal to do it but they also shouldn’t be able to rule not having birthright is illegal since the statute didn’t define the meaning of jurisdiction. There are no wrong answers to the meaning of jurisdiction.
If you’re not able to enforce jurisdiction……you do not have jurisdiction!!!!!
This may be the key point in this debate. The US does not have the ability to enforce jurisdiction. Slaves we had enforcement jurisdiction.
The German Tourist doesn’t pay US taxes. So US lacks full jurisdiction. The undocumented migrant isn’t paying taxes on their savings account in Mexico. If you manufacture cocaine in Colombia the US claims jurisdiction.
This is why the 14th just meant slaves is a plausible argument on the meaning of jurisdiction. There are powers the US had over slaves that any of the other proposed groups the US does not have on them. The US is only going to have less jurisdiction over any of these groups than they had over blacks.
I don’t think there is a right answer here. Some of the people in the legislature voting on it with a broad understanding or jurisdiction. Some people voted on it believing the amendment was specifically referring to slaves.

I think Catholicism even to Roman times was a slave religion and Universal Church. I don’t believe you need say their helping out compatriots today in the third world to find the reasoning for why Catholics have a lot of trouble denying immigrants.
Things like HBD or if you just want to call it racism is just very hard to square with Catholicism. It’s probably not even easy to square with Christianity and other sects but American Christianity does seem to have evolved immune responses that is more difficult for Catholicism to pick up. There is too much theological baggage that just can’t be repudiated and still maintaining their the original and true Church because Christianity is fundamentally a slave religion. Which I think was perfectly fine for Europe when they just dealt with Europeans or war with Muslims. There is just a huge parallelism with turning away a migrant and baby Jesus being turned away from the Inn in the nativity scene. Catholics were useful for abortion battles but the same thing probably going to be bad for immigration.
Maybe is just doing copium but I think at a minimum there is a 50% chance or more that within 20 years birth rate is changed. The Trump administration didn’t build this case the way the judges like. It’s better to take small steps than the whole thing at once. Just keep working exceptions and yes you probably have to quit appointing Catholics to the Court.
More options
Context Copy link