BANNED USER: Ban extended for arguing in edits
>Unban in 50d 09h 35m
Opt-out
No bio...
User ID: 4089
Banned by: @Amadan
We both know amendments are not getting passed anymore.
Who needs to pass the amendment - proponents of birth right citizenship? They could pass an amendment clarify that jurisdiction means anyone born on US soil.
Absent either side passing an amendment the SC I guess has to make a decision on the meaning of jurisdiction. When laws are not clear you can almost make an equally strong argument that the executive has authority to define what a word means.
When I look at historical context I think I feel 30% justified saying it was just slaves and 70% jurisdiction refers to more people.
To pass an amendment you need 2/3 of the Senate. Simplifying here today you would need 67 Senators to pass an amendment. We have different numbers today but let’s say 60 Senators voted for it believing “jurisdiction” including more than slaves and 7 Senators voted for it thinking it just meant slaves. In this case the majority of yes votes view Birthright essentially how it has functioned now but the decisive votes on the Amendment thought it just meant slaves.
So then what definition of “jurisdiction” would an origionalists use - the majority or the decisive vote?
I have no idea. My gut says a lot of people voting on the amendment were probably just voting on slave kids get citizenship.
I would include procrastination. Which is a bit of both of your responses. You get the motivation to do the actual hard work when you have a deadline to get it done.
I think a pragmatic libertarian would begin to believe that the constitution can’t protect libertarianism. I am probably too into the weeds on hbd but I do think core personality traits differ by race because of their evolved environment. Demographic change will kill the American experience.
Demographics I believe is the main reason Thiel has moved into Argentina. I believe he still counts as libertarian and most of the old libertarians have gone down the road to fascism to save liberty.
If it’s conscious then it’s probably happy. Evolution seems to evolve organisms to be happy when they are doing their job well.
One thing bugging me about the dragon show and perhaps the biggest thing in the whole series that makes no sense is how did the Targaryen’s remain in charge for 129 years between the last dragon and Robert’s Rebellion. They didn’t heavily intermarry or have a lot of people related to them. They were basically aliens who lost their special ability. I would expect them to last like 6 months without dragons.
Are there any historical parallels? The Europeans to the new world were few for a time but maintained better technology and most likely 10-15 IQ points higher intelligence. The show gives no indication targs were smarter.
I feel like Robert is a pragmatists and knows the world is changing. I don’t think he’s the type to create a precedence that can’t be undone later to deal with the modern world. If he maintains birthright citizenship he’s going to lay a path for a future court to get rid of it. Something like how he protected ObamaCare where he didn’t get rid of it but let the legislative branch deal with it. Which may be why they are doing it slow.
There are a lot of very good reasons to get rid of it in the modern world. From guest workers to selling American education America needs ways to let people in the country without always attaching Citizenship to it. If the right is in power with birthright on the books then the correct number of Visas to issue per year is essentially 0. Tourism, education exchange, farm labor, etc should not include citizenship.
The parity would completely change if they did 5 or 7 game playoff series. Yes you can catch someone sleeping but you won’t 7 times.
My gut says a pro soccer team would rarely lose in 1 match to a top level developmental team. But it may be more than American sports.
Notre Dame has lost to Navy which was sort of semi-pro versus completely amateur but it’s in a 1 in 40 event.
World Cup in many ways is like the first game of the year in football before teams develop chemistry and figure out strengths weakness and adapt. So that adds variability.
So I think a lot of the variance you describe would disappear over bigger samples and after teams have played more games together. Alabama might beat Jacksonville if Alabama was in mid season form versus Jacksonville playing essentially their first preseason game (a month of training camp).
I agree. Origionalism is a loser philosophy sides pick when they do not have power in the SC to try and limit the power of the SC. When in charge you want liberal philosophies of law that let you choose the meaning of words to shape society how you believe is best.
I use to be an Origionalists when my side was not in power. I now believe in Common Good Constitutionalism now that my side is in power.
Most 2A legalize is based on pragmatism versus wording. We could easily go down that path with birthright citizenship and the Constitutional argument that birthright is limited is a lot better in my view than any of the limits they’ve put on 2A.
The non-obvious part of Birthright is clearly that “subject to the jurisdiction” needs to mean something. And that phrase can mean anything a reader wants it to be because it’s not defined anywhere and if your intellectually honest you do some kind of historical analysis or you can just not give a shit and define “jurisdiction” in the optimal way for your view.
Do I wake up when I need to number 2 or do I need to number 2 when I wake up? This important philosophical question hit me this morning. Does waking up turn on a lot of biological systems that leads me to the bathroom approximately 10 minutes after getting out of bed?
IMO Willis 100% boosted the Steelers Super Bowl chances this year. The floor is lower but his ceiling is much higher than Rodgers at this point.
It’s nice winning 10 games a year, but you want championships and playoff victories. You do need to take risks to win big or some how get lucky and find Brady. The Rams have had bad years and Super Bowls. Same with the Eagles.
Some times you do need to bet on a 4 game sample size. The guy whose won MVP’s and are not on AARP are not available in free agency.
First Amending the Constitution we have a process for if an old part of the constitution is that far out of touch with modern society.
A crazy man is NOT what you are afraid of with causing mass casualties. I am thinking about by crazy you mean the street panhandling man with schizophrenia. He’s going to commit enough small crimes to institutionalize him first. By crazy you actually mean high agency but hates people like Osama Bin Laden who can accumulate arms and not commit other crimes. That may not change your argument but it’s still not a crazy person.
Your last paragraphs are not just speech. Paying someone to commit crimes is an act of paying people. They all lead directly to actions that are criminal. There is something going on that is more than just speech but directing physical actions thru speech.
Hispanic shouldn’t be a racial category. It made sense when Hispanics were mostly Northern Mexico border crossers but it makes no sense today. The broad Hispanic category should simplify to White, Black, Native American. Internally in their countries they have the same divides as America. If you go to a nice restaurant in Mexico City the people eating are whiter than Indianapolis and the servers completely Native American. An Argentinian is just a white person.
Edit: one interesting thing I remember from peak woke Hollywood is in the Latina Father of the Bride (2022) they didn’t race swap the Billionaire Groom. They made him 100% which is exactly how it is in Mexico.
IMO your data on where QB are drafted is dated. The last 5-8 years of drafts we’ve seen many more QB draft classes clustered with picks 1,2,3 QB if teams like them. And picks 8-20 be true second tier prospects. Good prospects are getting pushed higher up the board. Mahomes, Allen, Ben types aren’t going pick 10 anymore.
Willis is an example of a QB that needed time to develop. His traits are absolutely elite - rocket arm, 4.4 ‘40, Motte poster level Wonderlich score and IQ definitely matters at the QB position. Some reason he only played at Liberty University. Willis was bad in the NFL because he played as a rookie at Liberty which is a giant competition jump.
Elite Traits + 4 years development + 4 good NFL games is 100% an interesting background to bet on. And for the same money as Rodgers.
Steelers have 0% probability of getting a top 3 pick and a shot at a clean QB prospect.
Sorsby had a good shot at going first round this year and most draft prognosticators have him as a top 15 pick without the gambling next year. Not a third round guy. Allar with slightly worse arm, better tape, and far better legs.
I don’t bitch about the Steelers. A lot is well run. It’s just they need to take bigger variance risks to find a QB.
Of those gambling was probably the most universal. The local Italian that the cops mostly ignored running a neighborhood book likely wasn’t trying to run a lot of juice and the violence. He likely spent his days hanging out at the local bar taking small bets in the community. Knew every guy within a 10 block radius. A social creature of the community versus people just betting on their phones all day.
This is a frequent issue you see in society where “semi-legal” is better than “illegal” or “legal”. Most things we consider vices are mostly fine if the upper class does it but can be disastrous when everyone has access to it. Prostitution, drugs, alcohol, gambling, homosexuality, infidelity, etc all fit in these categories.
Paying players had issues on having a level playing field as some schools didn’t cheat.
I wanted the Steelers to take Sorsby in the supplemental draft. But I doubt they would have and instead will be floating in the our QB isn’t good enough to win a championship land. Also wanted them to sign Willis. They seem very reluctant to take the kind of risks you need to in order of finding a top 10 QB. Allar has potential with all the physical traits but he’s still a developmental QB who had bad coaching at PSU so maybe there is a 25% chance it all comes together. That is just not enough risks to take at a position like that. And they refuse to be bad enough to get a top 5 pick where you can land a great prospect. Which you can’t get to trading up if you start at pick 20. So they will end up drafting the 4th best QB in a strong QB class who generally has a major flaw.
Kalshi just raised at $40b valuation or half of CME. I wouldn’t invest because gambling has two bad business traits - there are a lot of firms competing and my vote in our Democracy would be to regulate it out of existence.
I would almost compare major college football to engineering. Not in terms of math but it’s a hard major. Even with an athletic training staff there is still a lot of discipline of actually doing the work. Understanding your role in the scheme can be complex. Some athletic geniuses can just be isolated but many positions require an intellect that’s as hard as basic accounting or getting thru a marketing major.
Someone like say Tommy Rees since a ND example was used above who was caught by the cops running from a keggar but managed to be a starting college QB is going to be a functional cog in any organization he ends up in.
IMO I would probably hirer a football player with a .5 gpa who clearly outperformed his athletic ability than the average college grad. Football is harder mentally and discipline wise than most college majors. And college majors rarely matter for what you do in business.
Political Violence is a semi-protected Constitutionally protected 2nd Amendment Right in the US which obviously disagrees with a lot of things related to having a functional society.
But I do think a bunch of rebels writing these words “ A well-regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state” has a meaning that is broader than everyone has guns so the British can’t come back. It’s also an idea that political violence is one of the checks and balances in the US system that checks the power in Washington DC.
How this applies to modern level technology I have no idea. But I do think actual political violence is within the Spirit of the constructs of the US Constitution.
The Counter I think is the Civil War meant something in a common law sense and has the power of an actual written Amendment that ended the day of America being a bunch of rebels. I have no idea what this means in a practical sense and most likely nothing but the US would seem to be the only government ever formed that built in rebellion as a right. In which case armed rebellion as a form of protest is culturally within the American culture.
It doesn’t matter. Maybe I am a cynic or narcissistic but we have to be honest that most people are NOT as smart as people here. There are areas where you need to be intellectually honest - I guess with high IQ elites etc trying to honestly debate things and then report them to the masses.
To me mass migration is the biggest risks to Human Civilization. Dark ages likely occur if we get this wrong. The point of 250k is it emphasizes the magnitude of the issue to the masses which is true.
I like that fact that India has extremely high IQ people but IQ testing seems to indicate low IQ averages. My instincts tells me that science just doesn’t happen in those type of societies. There are probably as money Vivek types in India as the western world has but some kind of agglomeration effect can’t occur in this society. If that happens to America then science dies is my guess.
And then maybe in 1000 years so very smart group develops somewhere. They have a lot of bloodlust and tribe by tribe they expand and kill the natives until they start to rebuild industrial society again. That’s my downside case for mass migration.
The 50% of European energy supply comes from a rough guess of European inputs that are shipped in by sea which the US dominates the high seas. The US can basically cut off all trade Europe does with any other country besides Russia.
I have zero idea what Europe provides US as an ally today. They don’t have any fighting men or tech we need.
I am using his name as a stand-in for great programmer then.
But he’s credited with developing MSFT originally software and had a 1590 SAT score back when that was rare and students could get into Harvard with 1300. If he’s not a stand-in for great programmer then I have no idea whose a great programmer.

I think he did think a lot about world building but there were either areas he forgot to tie up or couldn’t think of a way to tie things up. It’s not uncommon to have sci-fi to have holes that can not be completed.
Best I can come up with is the Targs without dragons would need to be rather poor. Where all the other houses would fight for the targs if another house tried to be king because the funds siphoned off by the royals was small and a new King would likely try and find ways to boost his income.
But overall 30 maybe 100 Targaryen blood people aren’t ruling a land without dragons. The British could rule India I assume because trade was very profitable for elites. The US ruled Afghanistan mostly with bribes (pre-invasion per capita income was $500/post invasion $1k). Not entirely sure how Britain was in with the Chinese but I’ve heard Heroin is a lot of fun. The Spanish actually fucked a lot the Aztec ruling class creating an elite and I assume had better weapons, money, and there was some religious prophecy. US, Argentina, and Australia didn’t have population centers. Ukraine is in this endless war because Poland got rich and is like 12x Ukrainian per capita income. Assad still had like 15% of the population his ethnicity pre-war and richer backers. The Jews who some say rule the world probably have average IQ a standard deviation above average and invented nukes and AI. Non of these seem to apply to what the Targs had when dragons died.
More options
Context Copy link