@Opt-out's banner p
BANNED USER: Ban extended for arguing in edits
>Unban in 48d 05h 00m

Opt-out


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2025 December 16 18:23:20 UTC

				

User ID: 4089

Banned by: @Amadan

BANNED USER: Ban extended for arguing in edits
>Unban in 48d 05h 00m

Opt-out


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2025 December 16 18:23:20 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 4089

Banned by: @Amadan

Do me a favor and don’t accuse me of supporting things for reasons I have clearly expressed are NOT the reason and that I am acting in good faith. My beliefs here are not due to “tribal conflict”. I actually believe homosexuality is bad for the individual and a net negative to the commons.

I don’t support firing people from government jobs for being gay/pregnant. Though religious institutions should have a choice.

I do though have no problem with schools choosing what books to give to students. End of the day they costs money and someone has to choose what to buy. Someone has to tell children what to read. But they can buy whatever they want on Amazon. Or we can go 100% voucher system.

I am also making no claims that the culture war doesn’t exists. It has to exists. All societies have cultures and they have a huge influence on the wealth of the nation and the happiness of the civilization.

99% of the population still agrees we shouldn’t have an elementary school showing a pornographic video of a 40 year old man having sex with a 10 year and how the student should handle that encounter. All societies have cultural lines. Greece taught their young men how to terrorize their local peasantry so civilization has had all sorts of norms.

Sample size is a bit of an issue here especially since a few of the examples have cultural/historical reasons. Russia has been authoritarian for centuries in large part due to institutional memory of invasions. China has always been somewhat collective because I think the theory indicates necessities of what worked for rice farmers. It could be why they chose communism and communism not being the cause. Russia though I would list as just authoritarian due to history. N Korea would have some of the issues with China but obviously they are even more extreme for Asians. Japan obviously has some of the “harmony” attributes.

Maybe some people really are just better?

The rise of mental illness and reported happiness surveys would seem to strongly support that some people really just have better ideas/values.

I don’t believe gay people were ever banned from jobs or banks. I don’t believe their speech was restricted back then.

Also your saying it’s ok to torture kids (hopefully not having a mother is just mildly). Society does have responsibility for the vulnerable.

I also have not once said anything about being bitter. I think homosexuality is bad for society. I’ve never once said I am a libertarian so there is no hypocrisy. I do think society has a duty to protect the commons. If something is bad for society then we should want LESS of it.

But the difference between the 1980’s and today is I don’t believe the 1980’s tried to take offer communication systems so that debate ends. I don’t think they banned the POTUS from mass media. Or put him in jail. Etc.

To be fair to my argument. They actually did believe creating a moral society was good for the gays. I still believe that 1980’s culture was better for the gays than 2020.

In one area it seems most certain to me is with respect to children. Would Sam Altman be happier in the closet sneaking off for gay sex twice a month but with a loving wife raising his children or with the motherless child from a surrogate. To me it’s fairly obvious the former is better for him.

And obviously the children are effected.

I think at this point we can all agree if you lose a culture war - you mostly can not just go live your life. Not in 2020.

I do think it’s an interesting question whether you a gay could just live their life in 1980. Probably not in pro sports. Elite investment banker you were probably mostly fine.

The conservatives haven’t crossed that rubicon. They mostly did things like uphold ObamaCare though they likely had strong legal arguments to axe it if they wanted to. They’ve ditched horizontal precedence which I think is fine for something like Roe where I think most people felt it was a bad ruling. They haven’t gotten rid of Obgerfell which doesn’t appear to have textual support. Largely because it’s popular and the politics bad.

I’m proposing they should consider adopting theories to make the Court a Senate because that’s what the left has done, but they are no where close to doing that. Robert’s has largely acting as a politician and not an interpreter and he’s acted as a politician in favor of the left.

A fundamental problem with your “debating” court is even if you say it’s fine provided they remain internal consistency they still get selected thru a political process. Which means they can be selected for the ones that will do policy for what the left wants. Not a big concern now because the left probably won’t get to pick judges for 30 years, but it is a long term problem. Venice had a weird political system where leaders were picked thru multiple rounds of voting that was indirect Democracy of elites. The SC has essentially become that where they get to make policy thru some very indirect Democracy.

Your argument would be stronger if you focused on gays instead of atheists. I have no recollection of atheists facing any discrimination. I can 100% understand they thought the moral majority people were annoying but there are not any big everyday life frictions.

Gay potentially. But they did successfully lobby to keep gay bath houses open, during the AIDS pandemic. So they were not lacking political power.

I am also moral majority. Don’t be gay. It’s bad for you. Just find a nice wife.

Did you ever feel like your fellow Americans hated you? Maybe I’m being histrionic but I guess 2016-2024 I just need knew fellow Americans were capable of doing things they did to me then. Like evil. The America I grew up with was united. Muslims hit us and we would all go kill them together. But 2016-2024 we were enemies with each other. It’s like losing my innocent. A civil war I never saw coming. And it honestly feels like we almost lost and America was over.

I guess I agree with the policies they want. But do you actually think they are the same as what we saw 2014-2024? Sure they did politics. And I could see how someone would find them annoying. But SPLC would basically ban you from the internet, maybe take away your job. Annoying family value rallies just doesn’t seem like the same thing.

What did the Reds do in the 1980’s? Is this the war on drugs or banning some swearing? I guess we had LATAM commie death squads but that seemed like both sides were down.

I don’t think anyone else can run this playbook again. It worked because most firms were looking to play ball so they would only need to get a few renegade scalps. Without everyone else playing ball then there are too many renegades to target at one time.

So they basically ran the same playbook as AIPAC? Neither has crazy high funding - though SPLC more than I knew - but they were extremely good at targeting a few firms. AIPAC would chop off anyone who didn’t fund Israel.

Reading that it surprised me how much SPLC had by getting themselves attached to some financial plumbing. It almost feels like a true dictatorship had stepped in. If you control funding and access to the online world then perhaps that is absolute power today. We don’t have church groups or the neighborhood pub anymore. If it’s banned online then maybe that’s game over. I always thought SPLC (and the ADL) were just bloggers. I didn’t know they essentially had the fingers in the piping.

Did Trump and Musks save the world? Trump for being insane and getting sued a gazillion times and then getting shot in his head and he kept coming. Musks because he bought Twitter and freed one of the algos.

To me it’s not surprising guys like Catturd popped up now. You had to be an old stubborn bastard to have survived the days and probably unemployable. For the rest of my days I think I’m just going to be a stubborn bastard because there are some unknown powers moving the string.

If the Trump/Musks axis didn’t form I am not sure what saves us. The right didn’t know how to play these games. Now the right has some unbreakable institutional control. Larry Ellison has begun making his own machine. The left turning on Israel if they had still occurred is the only block that may have been able to build a media ecosystem. Otherwise it does feel like complete control of social media plus financing plumbing had been accomplished. It’s quite possible though that internal enough people were getting pissed off at the SPLC game that it was bound to collapse under its own weight. Zuck never struck me as someone big on censorship.

Did we need great men or was this all going to collapse on itself due to being deeply against our notions of American culture.

I trust McKenzies tone because he vibes as a lefty. So if they pissed him off and the whole censorship state then I’m guessing many on the left were looking to get off that ship.

I guess I feel safe for the rest of my life. Musks seems to have his own values and plenty of no-fucks given. I think the average mind is based when exposed to it. So as long as Twitter is free we are safe.

Also never ever talk to the FBI. Lying to a fed is the easiest way for them to nab you.

Is the soda diet? I probably drink 4-6 glasses of water a day. Maybe more. You would be running 1k+ calories per day on mostly sugar water if it’s not diet pop. Unless you are 6 years old I can’t see someone have the metabolism to handle that amount of calories from beverages. Sugar water of course tastes phenomenol but that is primarily because it’s dense in calories and humans evolved in often starving conditions. In a world of plentiful food and sedentary lifestyle we just aren’t designed for abundant sugary drinks.

Yes. 100%. Granted the law can be messy so translating the law won’t be a perfect science, but for Courts to NOT be legislatures they really did need to limit how far they take interpretations and keep to the text. They really did need to behave as close as possible to being mathematics. Few want to constrain their own power.

Now though is an interesting time. It does appear that the court will be conservative for my lifetime. Dems can win the POTUS but I have significant doubts they can also hold the Senate. So conservatives have a choice now of either limiting themselves to textualism or adopting their version of a living constitution. Living Constitution is much more powerful than textualism. For now they have limited themselves to undoing things down over the last 80 years. I do think Democrats have given them the blueprint to just do things because they think they are good for society and not limiting themselves to the text that was passed in congress.

Indians suffer from the general population defining all the world’s people into a half dozen groups. European descendants somewhat getting to be one of a half dozen groups Americans are more aware of. You can be French or Italian. Everyone else gets lumped into Asian, Indian, Arab, or Hispanic.

From what I can gather Indians are extremely diverse internally. Hispanics have fairly obvious boundaries internally that are similar to American racial lines. A lot of the Asian groups seem like they have a lot of similarities to me. Indians get lumped all together in the Western mind but have varied backgrounds internally of which you are far more aware.

Think you need to do some soul searching because I believe my reasoning is solid that your love of West Wing debate society was really just the loss of the rule of law in America.

Your last sentence:

“But in another twenty years there will be a fresh crop of military age males. And what will their formative experiences have been?“

This is one of those thoughts that sound true but is more often than not false. Just because they fought the US doesn’t mean the following generation will hate the US. It seems like high IQ countries can just flop their relationships. Japan doesn’t seem to have any lingering anti-Americanism. Vietnam which obviously remained control of their government is a friend today. It seems as though something else controls radicalism/military impulse in the next generation.

In that situation dogs win every vote and can vote against cat interests despite cats having 80% support among cat voters. So cats would probably prefer to live in a country that is filled with cat voters because then they can vote in pro-cat legislation.

This is a forum.

The funny thing with giving women the right to vote is now we have the evidence (partisan splits) that either women or men should not have the right to vote. One side has to be correct - right? Which means the other side shouldn’t get to vote.

Formerly niche high IQ movement that went a little mainstream with normies that crashed and burned

Girls are suppose to be empathatic in their role so become a liberal and having suicidal empathy fits with ideal female personality traits. I don’t think many men would not date a girl because she’s a liberal. Though they may question whether people with those traits should get to vote.

It’s game theory. I prefer both sides follow the letter of the law. Once one side has defected the optimal strategy is also to defect.

Sub-optimal outcome but I do not believe the left has acted in good faith.

No. I want conservatives to be the same as liberals. They turn the SC into a fantasy world or a Senate when they want to. I want the same benefits that liberals have. When they want gay marriage they make up law. When they want Roe they make up law.

Nothing you say is going to convince me that they’re not all liberal hacks with no respect for the law. I don’t care if they’re 160 IQ and write eloquent opinions or 85 IQ and just say they did something because they wanted to. To quote The Office, “It’s the same Picture”. A prostitute is still a prostitute whether she’s giving $10 hand jobs or getting $500k a night. A partisan hack is well Ruth Ginsburg because she wrote law which is NOT her job.

And Yes making up law when you control the SC is beneficial to your side. I’m down with that since we own the court now.

It’s only zero-sum because everything else is gerrymandered now. Which ya gerrymandering probably is bad. You can’t be carving out black districts in Southern states from a fairness perspective if you’re not also forcing California to carve out districts for their farming communities (or basically anyone inland).

I guess it’s fine if Blacks never fully assimilate and the probably aren’t capable of it, but future immigration we really do not want more groups that can’t just blend in. City-rural differences are just going to happen.