@Pasha's banner p

Pasha

Defend Kebab

1 follower   follows 4 users  
joined 2022 September 05 06:58:22 UTC

				

User ID: 481

Pasha

Defend Kebab

1 follower   follows 4 users   joined 2022 September 05 06:58:22 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 481

The level of evidence needed for the US government to convince the “international media” for aggressive foreign policy against Russia is on par with Iraqi weapons of mass destruction. Might be even lower nowadays.

The state will likely pay for it, sadly

They already are. Amounts in the range of tens of billions are already flying around trying to plug the holes. But it is about fundamental real scarcity, so money printing can only shift the affects. I don't expect to literally freeze in the winter, but more likely to become unemployed. I find the focus on warming the households pretty insane when we seem to take it for granted that half the industry will just casually go bankrupt. Another artifact of being ruled by the laptop class?

Just heat one or two rooms instead of the whole house this winter etc

This winter?. Lets say we manage to barely get through this winter with severe rationing of the stocks. Then what? LNG infrastructure will take years to build and it will deliver much more expensive energy anyway. Building nuclear is out of question and takes forever in any case. Renewables are a joke.

If the frontline stabilized, putin was removed and his successor said, 'we just want peace and to keep crimea, Ukraine can join nato',

And then they would attempt to take Crimea anyway? Did you see any hint at all on the Ukrainian official's side that they are willing to let it go?

More importantly, if things got so bad for Russia then why would the Americans just stop with a territorial reset? US hasn't spent close to 100 billion dollars on this war because they love Mariupol. Why not force Russia to pay massive reparations? Nuclear disarmament? Ejection from the UN Security Council? Another series of separatist rebellions in Caucuses? Kazakhstan in NATO? The possibilities are truly endless.

You are keeping to a faulty assumption that all that happened in the last year was some senseless invasion of some shithole Soviet factory towns. The US senses real blood in water to take down Russia as an opponent forever. This war has become truly existential for Russia and they might very well lose it. There is no easy exit Russians can take anymore.

And this can be presented as the work of some rogue factions. Possibilities are endless when you control the flow of information to the extent the US government does. Ukraine has no shortage of neo-nazi militias or oligarch private armies to heap the blame on if the necessity arises.

You'd have to go pretty far down the pro-ru rabbit hole to believe germany is close to reopening

Or I can have a look at my energy bills. These events aren't some far away theoretical debate. Just received notice that my bills are likely going to go up 50-70% in the coming months and then who knows what. It is not even cold here yet.

Anyway, the original point is, if germany is insignificant, then so is their non-functioning pipeline.

Direct German support is irrelevant, but European sanctions on Russia are definitely very very relevant. Selling gas and oil to Europeans have been massively profiting Russia since the war began and allowing them to fund the war as well as an economic transition towards the East. Getting rid of this lifeline is crucial for Ukraine otherwise they are fighting a war of attrition where the other side just makes more and more money from the situation.

Did ukraine blow up the pipeline to give russia no way out, weakening the russian peace party, so they can kill more russians ?

You make a strange assumption here and then base your whole next paragraph on this assumption. Ukrainian hardliners do not want any peace that any Russian leader can put their signature and survive. Such a thing does not exist and they know it better than anyone. What "peace party" are you imagining that can sign away Crimea? Ukrainians know that the only way to really achieve their aims is the maximalist way. Russia must be thoroughly destroyed economically, socially and politically. There is no other way out.

Also attacking an EU and NATO country isn't exactly going to be positive for the support of the rest of them or probably even the US.

I suggest you take a look at this page.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Liberty_incident

A country that has enough pull or support in American foreign policy and intelligence establishment can get away with virtually anything. Some evidence surfaces against Ukraine? It will be dismissed or classified. The media will basically ignore it and allude to Putin propaganda. Anyone who still remembers any of this will be seen as conspiracy cranks after 1-2 years.

The other problem for Ukraine attacking is that it would be rather hard for them to pull off.

I find this line of argumentation very irrelevant. Ukraine doesn't have to send some warship from Odessa to circumvent Gibraltar and drop depth charges. It is a very lean operation and this sort of underwater infrastructure is notoriously quite fragile. Pretty much the entire area is full of CIA black sites and countries that hate Russia and the Nordstreams at least as much as Ukraine. If there is a will there is definitely a way.

Why does Germany need to force Ukraine to an unfavourable peace to open the pipelines?

The pipes are nowhere near Ukrainian territory. The only obstacle to opening NS2 while the war was going on was the political pressure on the German government. That political pressure could shift massively as the costs of no gas are realised in the coming months. I want to iterate once again, German politicians fought tooth and nail to keep NS1 gas flowing 6 months into the war. It was Russia that closed the flow.

You are massively underestimating the probability that the pipelines would have reopened sometime in the close to mid term future. These aren’t some expandable moral signalling devices for Europe. Our industry pretty much depends on cheap Russian fossil fuels and now those firms are simply going to go bankrupt or move abroad. Germany has spent the last 6 months trying to get Russia to resume the gas flows through Nord Stream 1. It also constructed Nord Stream 2 as a deliberate policy choice knowing how much it angered Poland, Baltics, Ukraine and ultimately the US. I don’t know why everyone is so hell bent on forgetting what Biden openly said about the pipeline not that long ago.

It’s also pretty weak how you dismiss Ukraine as a harmless incapable country which cannot anger Germany. Well why not? What’s Germany going to do? Stop supplying helmets? Ukraine is an American client state now and is fighting an existential war. The Ukrainian military aid from the US likely exceeds the whole yearly Russian military budget since the war started. German support is insignificant in comparison.

Besides Ukraine certainly doesn’t shy away from other risky spy action: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/05/us/politics/ukraine-russia-dugina-assassination.html. Even if Russia somehow “proves” this, so what? Russia is horribly bad at getting even the most basic talking points out to the western world and it will just get dismissed as Putin propaganda.

For me the biggest possibility by far is that Ukraine (or certain factions of Ukrainian military) has done it either with tacit approval of the US or relying on the American cover after the fact. Intelligence agencies are infamously factional and incoherent so it’s likely some parts of CIA knew about this and assisted in the operation.

The immediate affects are very clear and there is no need to play 4D chess about Putin palace politics. Europe (Germany) has no option of deescelation anymore no matter how tough things get economically. It’s entirely reliant on LNG supplied by countries broadly in the American camp in the coming decade to survive.

Yes I agree. That’s exactly what I mean by new narrative fracture.

Some people are very upset and will remain so. Majority doesn’t even remember anymore and will consider those people obsessive loser conspiracy theorists. The political actions and rhetoric of this small group will stay incomprehensible to the respectable members of the society which will create all sorts of strange political and societal tensions which is pretty obvious if you have a memory longer than a goldfish but the media will somehow be totally unable to decipher. We have been seeing this dynamic with many contentious issues in the west for decades.

The point of a nuke is that mainly the others know you have it and can use it so they shy away from aggression. Ukraine said nothing to the effect, Russia attacked clearly not expecting them to have nukes and Ukraine hasn't used any.

Ukraine was a fully trusted member of the Soviet Union

This is not how the Soviet Union worked at all.

But now they're submerged in Ukrainian immigrants. It's not the end of it either.

"Refugees", almost entirely female and children, with a very legitimate and widely accepted claim, whose male relatives are fighting right across the border until they return. I am not very sympathetic to Ukraine personally but I can't comprehend how someone can't understand why Europeans are generally quite supportive of this refugee wave.

Also to mention one aspect which is often hushed (or unknown to Americans maybe), Ukrainian women have long been the number one source of white female prostitutes around the continent and beyond. In my native language of Turkish, the word Ukrainian is practically synonymous with prostitute. Until 10-20 years ago it was Russians who filled the same niche and the phrase "going to the Russian" was universally understood to visit a prostitute.

I am not writing this to be insulting but it is worthwhile to realize that this is one of the big reasons why the images of millions of poor Ukrainian women flocking to their countries is often not perceived as something threatening by the locals.

This sub got a little bit too invested in the Ukraine war. It is shocking to me that the claim "CIA was involved in (a very favorable) regime change in country where American foreign policy has serious interests" now brings up several heavily upvoted "rebuffs".

Yes Ukraine was very corrupt and mismanaged by pro-Russian politicians. It was also very corrupt and mismanaged by pro-Western politicians. Majority of the countries around the world are very corrupt and mismanaged. Virtually no CIA takeover ever comes out of nowhere. Grievances on their own rarely bring down regimes. The Soviet Union used to be well-known for leveraging the political problems in foreign countries to force regime changes favorable to themselves, and they would use basically the same arguments to justify their behavior. Interestingly, the Americans would use the opposite arguments to justify military invasions of said countries to restore the aligned regimes.

Just change CIA to KGB and Ukraine to Vietnam or Cuba and somehow you can write this entire discussion in reverse with the same arguments.

Good chance that Ukraine has working nuclear weapons

Do you have any source for this incredibly far-fetched claim?

We are likely going to get a new serious narrative fragmentation in the Western discourse between the minority who were on the receiving end of the apartheid and will remember this for a long time, and the majority who did what they were told and did not even notice that the McDonalds they were eating was banning 20% of the population for no good reason.

Almost everyone I know is in the category of "did what they were told without much fuss" and they have already binned the events of the last 2 years almost entirely in distant weird times category.

Whatever you decide to call it, it’s undeniable that the “current social/political/economic order of the West” is a peculiar thing and deserves a descriptive name. Capitalism has meant a million different things in the last 200 years and arguably isn’t the best definition as the current society would be utterly alien to a 1890s capitalist. But it’s definitely better than “Moloch”. If you can use a word to describe both 2022 German society and the Mayan society than it’s not a good word. If we didn’t decide to loathe intellectualism as a civilisation we could probably come up with a better one and stop relying on 19th century definitions for everything.

I have recently realised this due to German immigrants to the Netherlands(!!) complaining about the unwokeness of the country and falling over each other to use the latest woke language inventions that even Dutch people don’t know about. They seem to be pursuing this new religion with the methodical zeal typical of Germans. It was all very bizarre.

Would you be willing to share where you are from? Is this another Anglo country?

What streaming service has ads?

I have just seen someone watch (quite focussed) an entire minute of woke sportswear ads before a song started on their youtube tab in the library. If this is how the average person reacts to ads we are all so screwed

Reddit career advise is just horrible. 95% of what you read is written by either total losers or students who are just repeating doomer shit they heard from the aforementioned losers.

Have you ever been on party drugs? I always found events very boring and fake until I tried. Then everything suddenly started making sense.

I believe a meaningful fraction of the world population catches different competing strains of flu every year.

I would be quite surprised if multiple three letter American agencies (and some sort of counterpart in basically every country) didn't actively plot such things.

Where the Social Democrats always called just S? Or did this start after the Swedish Democrats took over the SD

Spoiler tags might be a good idea here :)

Oh it is quite cynical for a show about Danish politics. The episodes about the CIA torture black sites or Danish soldiers in Afghanistan come to my mind. Really a good depiction of the type of challenges small country politicians face in the periphery of the American Empire as well.

Would be pretty funny if that was the case actually. But in this day and age I don't believe there are many terrorist groups left in the world not sufficiently infiltrated by one or more governments.