@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

In that conversation, you were saying that if some body of myth won out in the public consciousness, it must have had the most merit. You were making the "might makes right" argument, as in "those narratives won, so they must have been the best." That is not my criteria for whether a narrative has merit:

Okay? Who cares? If people enjoy Superman more than conan the barbarian, if anti-hitler arguments win out in the court of public opinion in New York 1945 as well as in practice in Berlin 1945, if ‘jewish science’ produces better results than ‘purely aryan science’, then that is a far better test of their worth than to try to divine the ulterior motives of the creators through their identity. Everyone has an identity and ulterior motives.

Notice you concede the argument "everyone has an identity and ulterior motives." Yes, they do. So why not try to understand them when it comes to something like Captain America or Superman? You are saying the ulterior motives don't matter, all that matter is that they won in the marketplace of ideas. But why did they win? Because they created effective propaganda that was memetically powerful, not because they were "right." What is right does not always win in the court of public opinion, which anyone here should admit.

I don't think there are many postmodernists here. There are reactionaries and modernists predominantly.

In these terms, I would describe myself as a post-postmodernist. What exactly does that entail? That's the question that's up for grabs (it's not libertarian, it's not reactionary, it's not conservative, it's not progressive...).

I have no shortage of criticisms of postmodernism, but "postmodernism ruined modernism" is not an argument I make, @2rafa has emphasized this point in the past and I agree. If modernism led to postmodernism, how is going back to modernism any sort of solution? Postmodernism is a continuation and extension of enlightenment rationality. How can it be anything else?

Insofar as you describe postmodernism as a critique of grand narratives, I can get behind that high-level description, I am certainly not critical of grand narratives and believe them to be central to collective consciousness. Postmodernism is itself a grand narrative, post-postmodernism is ultimately about crafting a new 21st century grand narrative, not going backwards to the 1950s or wherever you think enlightenment rationality was best before it was subverted.

If "racial homogeneity" and "supererior aryan genetics" really are the be-all end-all of success how was it that the "hopelessly miscenginated" and "distinctly lacking in Nordic warrior spirit" US was able to out produce the Reich not just in absolute terms but in per-capita terms as well?

Why do you keep repeating this nonsense? The Anglo-Saxons are a Germanic people, English is of the Germanic language family! They were every bit as Aryan as Germany even by the standards of Hitler- the Nazis regarded the term "Aryan" as a pan-European designation, even including Italians and Poles under the umbrella according to the racial laws of the time, the "Aryan means blonde hair and blue eyes" is purely post-war propaganda meant to straw man what was a pan-European racial concept (one that has been vindicated by modern genetic analysis).

The diaspora and colonizers of the British Empire lacked the "Nordic warrior spirit", that is just so hilariously backwards. You know they conquered the continent right? They were the greatest examples of such a spirit, leaving civilization to conquer savages, tame the wilderness, and build a new civilization...

You openly deny and despise what were their greatest qualities.

If I'm being accused of something, I'm going to explain why the accusation doesn't hold. If they want to say I didn't respond adequately, I'm going to point out- yes, I did, I cited primary sources to argue a specific point that was completely ignored in favor of a baseless appeal to emotion.

Funny enough I'm being accused by Amadan of "quietly fading away" when pressed, so yes I will talk about Holocaust revisionism in this thread to show that charge, also, is not true- if I'm pressed on the topic.

Here is Yad Vashem's description of the origin of the Victim's Database:

On May 8th 1999, under the auspices of President Ezer Weizman, Yad Vashem initiated a well publicized world wide media campaign to collect Pages of Testimony. The public response was overwhelming: a call center with 20 phone lines and 90 staff members working double shifts was established to handle the large volume of incoming inquiries in real time. During the months of April and May alone some 147,000 Pages of Testimony were received, amounting to a total of about 380,000 by the end of 1999. The aftermath of the campaign was felt in 2000 as well; an additional 70,000 Pages of Testimony were collected. Although the names collection campaign was targeted also to Jewish communities around the world, around 85% of the Pages of Testimony collected had been submitted in Israel. Surprisingly, more than 80% of all incoming pages actually contained names of victims that were not previously recorded at the Hall of Names. This statistic reinforced the great significance of the campaign at that point in time.

By the year 2000, the initial computerization project and media campaign resulted in the creation of a database containing close to 2.5 million names of Holocaust victims at the Hall of Names. Founded on a sophisticated technological platform the names database was updated and upgraded. Advanced search capabilities including soundex and synonym searches were developed in order to enhance retrieval possibilities. On November 22nd 2004, the Central Database of Shoah Victims’ Names was launched and uploaded to the Yad Vashem website offering the general public full and free accessibility to close to three million victims' names in English and Hebrew. In 2007, the option to consult the names database in Russian (Cyrillic characters) was also made available.

Does a call center collecting names from over-the-phone testimonies to add to their database, 60 years after the fact, seem to you a scientific way to build a database of murder victims? In any other context, building a database of murder victims containing no evidence that the people you are adding to the database were murdered would get you laughed out of the room. Of course, in building a database like that, proving the person existed with a document is not the most important part- providing some sort of evidence that the people in your database were murdered in the way you are saying they were murdered would be expected in any other context except the Holocaust, where an Israeli calling a hotline and giving a testimony listing names of people he lost contact with 60 years later is good enough to prove a series of murders with absolutely no physical or documentary evidence that such murders actually happened.

This is not a scientific source, it's a cultural and propaganda project.

I still don't know what your hypothesis is, aside from "a name and a passport is not proof."

My hypothesis is that this isn't a scientific source, it's not a database of murder victims. It's a post-2000s propaganda campaign meant to fill the gap in the physical and documentary record with a crowd-sourcing approach of uncritically collecting testimonies and names 60 years after the fact.

I don't think the artist is alt-right, but I do think there is an interesting parallel with Nazi propaganda... take this 1932 propaganda poster titled The Negro-isation of France in 100 years, captioned "the last non-colored French form the main attraction of the Paris Zoo"- there's a similar aesthetic with Peterson with the predatory black figures looming over the white people. This Nazi poster and Peterson's work are both interesting to review in context with the current race riots in France, although I do not for a second believe Peterson has the same interpretation of this as the Nazis.

My falsifiable claim is that there is no evidence those 4.8 million people were murdered by the Germans during the war. The database is a collection of names and documents with no evidence, investigation, or verification of murder. This is not a legitimate database of murder victims, as any database of murder victims would require some sort of investigation and verification that the entries are people who were actually murdered.

Is an adequate response. It is not a database of murder victims as there has been no investigation that names registered to this database are actually real, unique names of individuals who were murdered in WWII. A name and a passport is not proof that someone was murdered in a gas chamber. Likewise, taking a transport list and assuming that all the people on the transport were murdered and adding them to a database of murder victims, and then later citing the database as evidence that the people on the transports were murdered, is circular reasoning that is void of evidence.

When it came to OP's concrete claim that 70,000 Jews were sent from Lodz to Auschwitz in 1944 to be exterminated, I showed there was no evidence for that, there is in fact substantial evidence disproving that, and he did not respond to that challenge. "Here's a bunch of names and passports in a database" is very different than justifying an assertion like "70,000 Jews were sent from Lodz to Auschwitz in 1944 to be exterminated" and OP ran off right when I challenged him on this point.

In what other world could you just say "70,000 people were sent here and killed" with no expectation of actually having evidence for that claim? It's only in this topic where you can get away with making claims like these with no evidence, and then you just point at a passport in a database when pressed for evidence.

His appeal to the Yad Vashem database also allowed him to conveniently sidestep the primary sources I was citing to disprove his claims about the extermination of Lodz Jews, while he was citing a database where any name can be added to it with no actual proof that they were murdered. Reading that I don't see this thread as evidence for what Amadan is complaining about.

I'm bemused that you think this is "vaguely hinting."

It is, because you won't put into words what you are actually complaining about.

Well, first of all, if you were actually discussing whether or not you were right, it might be more legitimate, but I have observed you get absolutely shredded over and over again by people willing to engage with you point by point, and your tactic is to simply do a quiet fade and then come back a few days or a week later with a slightly altered version of the same argument.

Can you cite any examples? I get a lot of replies, and I reply to a lot of them. Sometimes I let people get the last word if the conversation has gone on. I do not think I've gotten "shredded" on any of the topics I've talked about, and if you can point to a thread we can use as a reference for what you are talking about, that would be helpful for everyone.

Secondly, you have admitted that your purpose here is recruitment (boasting about all the people DMing you for more info)

Again, can you point to anything I have said where I admitted that my purpose here is recruitment? If you are accusing me of something like this you should provide some sort of proof. I think I mentioned people DMing me once to point out that my own experience- receiving a bunch of comment replies and messages about a topic, seemed to stand against the "nobody wants to talk about this" narrative which was being pushed to chill discussion on Holocaust Revisionism. It seems a lot of people wanted to talk about it, and that was my point, no such nonsense about recruitment.

These accusations are not fair without specific examples of this behavior you are accusing me of.

You also ignored my question to you, which is what is "one specific topic" you are talking about? Are my posts about the ADL press campaign, and the other post about Superman both "one specific topic" within the context of your complaint? If so, why?

Similarly, we're having trouble with people who want to post about one specific topic.

Can you make your point clearer about what you mean by "one specific topic?" Mods here frequently sneer at discussion surrounding "Da Joos", and that hurts their credibility in my view when it comes to vaguely hinting at something they don't like. If you have a specific complaint in mind, why not just say it and be clear? I can see @Amadan confirm the complaint is directed at me, so I ask for clarification on what you want me to stop doing.

I can't seem to find an easy way to filter for top-level comments, but browsing my history for the past 6 months suggests that most of my top-level comments are not related to "one specific topic". My top-level comments include the most upvoted top-level comment in this community so far. My second-most upvoted top-level comment is indeed about Da Joos in that it was about the ADL's propaganda campaign intended to pressure Congress for more federal DHS funding.

Would you consider that post about the ADL and my recent posts about Superman/Captain America to be posting about "one specific topic"? I don't think so, any more than posting about some propaganda campaign by a BLM organization and then analyzing the cultural influence of Rap in another post would be posting about "one specific topic." By the way, anybody interested can compare my analysis there of Superman to this coincidentally-timed Rolling Stone article about the first Jewish actor to be cast as superman- I thought about posting a top-level comment in order to elaborate on my thinking surrounding the connection between cultural myth-making and collective moral consciousness, but I decided not to due to the growing complaints from the mods directed at me, so you can count me as at least partially-chilled even before you made this post.

Lastly, the complaints about "Da Joos" are begging the question. If I'm right about the things I post about, then they are clearly worth frequent discussion in a community dedicated to the Culture War. By saying the topic appears too much is asserting that it isn't a topic worth the weight it is currently given in community discussion, which like Hoffmeister said is not overwhelming by any means.

It presents a concrete political objective. A pan-European radical right movement to reform the EU constitution to actually serve European people would have to aim high and dream big.

Far-right parties on the rise across Europe.

That's a headline we've all read many times in the past decade, is now really different? There are many clips around the internet of the race riots in France, with this Reddit thread showing a compilation of some. It's hard to gauge how serious the riots are, or if it's relatively isolated to a few blocks in a couple cities and these compilations make the situation appear worse than it actually is. The words of Eric Zemmour paint a dire picture:

We are in the early stages of a civil war. It’s an ethnic war. We can see clearly that it’s a race war. We see what forces are involved. We need someone determined and firm. … The problem, above all, is the number [of immigrants].

The reason I think the BBC article is noteworthy, most of all, is because it observes that contrary to the previous bouts of nationalistic populism that inspired Brexit and Euroskepticism, this surge in far-right political support seems to be dovetailing with support for the EU:

While at the same time, a number of far-right parties in Europe have intentionally moved more towards the political centre, hoping to entice more centrist voters.

Mark Leonard cites far-right relations with the EU as another example of their 'centrification'.

You may remember, after the UK's Brexit vote in 2016 that Brussels feared a domino effect - Frexit (France leaving the EU), Dexit (Denmark leaving the EU), Italexit (Italy leaving the EU) and more.

Many European countries had deeply Eurosceptic populist parties doing well at the time but over the years those parties have felt obliged to stop agitating to leave the EU or even its euro currency.

That seemed too radical for a lot of European voters...

Polls suggest the EU is more popular amongst Europeans at the moment than it has been for years.

And so far right parties now speak about reforming the EU, rather than leaving it. And they're predicted to perform strongly in next year's elections for the European parliament.

Paris-based Director of Institut Montaigne's Europe Programme Georgina Wright told me she believes the far-right renaissance in Europe is largely down to dissatisfaction with the political mainstream. Currently in Germany, 1 in 5 voters say they're unhappy with their coalition government, for example.

Wright said many voters in Europe are attracted by the outspokenness of parties on the far-right and there's tangible frustration that traditional politicians don't appear to have clear answers in 3 key areas of life:

  1. Issues linked to identity - a fear of open borders and an erosion of national identity and traditional values
  1. Economics - a rejection of globalisation and resentment that children and grandchildren aren't assured a better future
  1. Social justice - a feeling that national governments are not in control of the rules that govern the lives of citizens

I do not agree with Mark Leonard that far-right relations with the EU are an example of the centrification of the far-right, it rather represents a change in strategy.

I've seen it asked here, what would be the pathway for political or cultural victory of the radical right? This is it- these energies being transformed into a positive and ambitious political project that surfs the wave of globalization and European integration. In hindsight it seems like such a bad strategy for the far right to advocate stepping away from a project like this, and the failure of Brexit to produce any meaningful change is, along with Trumpism, proof of the failure of petty nationalistic populism. If you blame the EU for immigration you don't leave the EU, you go for European parliament.

Journalists have spent many years hand-wringing over the Euroskepticism being influenced by right-wing politics, but I think they will find the prospect of the EU being reformed by a pro-EU radical right to be much more worrisome- and effective at bringing real change.

Edit: Police Unions are also describing the situation as dire:

Faced with these savage hordes, asking for calm doesn’t go far enough. It must be imposed.

Re-establishing order in the republic and putting those arrested somewhere they can do no harm must be the only political signals to send out.

Our colleagues, like the majority of the public, can no longer have the law laid down to them by a violent minority.

This is not the time for industrial action, but for fighting against these ‘vermin’. To submit, to capitulate, and to give them pleasure by laying down weapons are not solutions, given the gravity of the situation.

They said: “Today, police officers are at the frontline because we are at war.” And they warned the government that, unless officers are given yet greater legal protections and more resources in the future, “tomorrow, we will be in resistance”.

Dude, you made a very, very broad claim: that "influenc[ing] the perception of children towards the LGBT movement" is somehow illegitimate.

I have no interest in speaking in terms of legitimacy or democracy, what I said was:

but the statement means they intend to influence the perception of children towards the LGBT movement in defiance of their opposition.

Where did I say it was illegitimate? I said it is affirming the behavior that conservatives are denouncing when they use the word "grooming." When conservatives are talking about grooming, they are not merely talking about "people who oppose laws that restrict drag performances or classroom discussions of gender identity" they are talking about people who want to influence their children into embracing or even identifying with LGBT culture. That's what they mean when they use that word. The "we're coming for your children" is meant to provactively admit that, yes, this is what they are trying to do- although they of course see nothing wrong with that.

With dogma like this, the cultural victory condition is not to win the debate it's to have no debate- to debate is to lose even if you win the debate because you make something an issue that is supposed to be a non-issue for the dogma to work. There was the same dynamic of the Christian x Internet Atheist debates of the 2000s. It didn't matter who won the debate, it mattered the debate was happening, and that portended something significant.

The smart move for someone who wants the dogma to persist is to not signal-boost Turkheimer, it's to ignore him because there is no debate, it's a non-issue is the only stable state for such dogma.

Conservatives use the word "grooming" to mean that they are trying to bring children into the fold of that culture, which they are openly admitting to here.

You can argue all day that this doesn't fit some dictionary definition of the word, and of course it's foremost propaganda, but then again so are all the accusations of "-phobia" which actually have actually acquired social credibility as weapons against someone's reputation. It's pure culture war, the dictionary has no weight in matters of culture war.

"You can't call me transphobic because I have first Amendment Rights", yeah try that one out for size. These words are used to energize the side you are on and demoralize and smear your opposition, I find it completely laughable that the LGBT community, which is quick to smear everyone who does not agree with their ideology, is now complaining about being on the receiving end of this tactic.

Assuming:

  • It's harmful for children to become transgender, i.e. they have worse psychological, health, and social outcomes if they identify as transgender.

  • The LGBT community intends to create propaganda geared towards children that will influence more children to identify as transgender.

The Conservative movement is completely justified in using the "grooming" accusation and viewing this propaganda as an attempt to harm their children.

Which, unlike child molestation, is a perfectly legitimate goal in a democratic society. Just as those who lobby for or against teaching all sorts of things do all the time.

Right, so the Conservatives who said that this entire thing was about reaching their children were correct. You can say "it's a legitimate goal in a democratic society", whatever that means, as if social propaganda isn't common to all societies everywhere. But the conservatives saying "if we allow gay marriage next they are coming for our children" were right, and it took less than 8 years from the Supreme Court decision. We apparently could not allow gay marriage without our children shortly thereafter being inundated with LGBT propaganda, they were right.

Our nanny is great, we go through dozens of books at the library and let them pick it out. She comes from a place and is of a generation where this propaganda would be unthinkable and she lets her guard down occasionally. It's no big deal, she puts the book aside when she sees where it's going.

Just because the "Jews will not replace us" chant was meant to be provocative, and even playful on some level, does not mean it wasn't saying something meaningful- it was. The ingroup doesn't interpret it the exact same way as the outgroup, but it was still a slogan that spoke to the relationship between demographic change and Jewish cultural influence as interpreted by the people who were saying the chant. Likewise, "We're coming for your children" is saying something very real... no, the people that said that aren't all trying to physically abuse children, but the statement means they intend to influence the perception of children towards the LGBT movement in defiance of their opposition.

Imagine you go to the library, pick a book that is ostensibly about the adventures of the cute pig on the cover, only to get home, start reading it to your children, and realize that the message the story is... Jews will not replace us. I can say it has now happened 3 times our nanny has brought home a book from the public library that seemed completely innocuous on the cover, only to turn out to be LGBT propaganda geared towards toddlers.

They are coming at my children with their propaganda, there's no denying it, all you can do is hope they won't be influenced by it despite the mounting social pressure. As of two days ago, Obergefell v. Hodges was only eight years ago when the country was very much still divided on the question of gay marriage. The present state of the culture proves that all those decades of conservative tropes were correct, and yes, they are coming for your children in order to influence them positively towards that culture.

the French, for not opposing the German remilitarization of the Rhineland of 1936, which would have been easily justifiable legally and carried no risk.

Disallowing the militarization of your own territory is the definition of not having sovereignty... Maintaining this arrangement in perpetuity was neither possible nor reasonable. Even if they scared the Germans away, they could just do it again and again whenever the French let up pressure. "We are going to go to war with you if you put military in your own country" was never going to be a stable arrangement, it was always going to lead to a showdown.

Soliciting external sponsors with domestic elite support is revolutionary, but attempting to find external sponsors with no elite support is being a traitor. It's concern-trolling to say that if right-wingers actually believed in the gravity of demographic change then they would become traitors for no strategically beneficial reason, and that nonsense should be denounced as it is among many in the DR.

Fostering radical politics within the inertia of European political and cultural integration is the right course of action for Right-wingers. You aren't a traitor if you work to foster pan-European ethnic consciousness because it aligns with the basic nature of the EU and NATO. Does petty nationalism and local populism, much less civic nationalism, have any credibility at this point? 2016 and the failure of Trump and Brexit show that's a dead end.

The liberals are taking on the headwinds of political and financial integration of Europe, the institutions capable for the task are being built for us. The Right wing should not turn traitor for no reason, they should say "Evropa!"

Unfortunately the "dissident right" is so broad, it's not accurate to attribute a single position on this issue to that sphere. FWIW none of those screenshots from "prominent" DR figures are accounts I have heard of before. There is a variety of opinion among the DR, ranging from immediately and vocally pro-Ukraine (Richard Spencer comes to mind) to "no more brother wars"/general neutrality, to, yes, support for Russia and Putin on an absurd "enemy of my enemy" angle, with Nick Fuentes as the worst offender on that front. I can't say I've seen the DR at all obsessed with the Hunter Biden stuff as you say, that seems to me Boomercon-coded and outside of 4chan threads nobody in the DR cares or talks about Hunter Biden.

The big rift between the DR is currently between petty-nationalism and pan-Europeanism. The former oppose EU and NATO as institutions of globalization and want those institutions to be undermined by a credible adversary. The latter see globalization and Imperivm as inevitable and desirable and do not oppose EU or NATO even though they obviously seek to realign them with a European race consciousness. The former, in my opinion, are greatly discredited by this affair and the latter, who have supported Ukraine, are vindicated.

since gentiles are apparently too stupid to have legitimate opinions.

It must be nice to beat that straw man, of course I'm not claiming omnipotence, I'm recognizing the power of propaganda and myth.

The Jews have been so successful in that arena not, foremost, because they are smarter than us, but because they are more racist than us; they actually worship their own race and even secular Jews frequently hold their ethnic identity in a regard that is completely psychologically foreign to white people. Their content can be decrypted, its meaning can be discerned and it can be countered, it's not all-powerful.

if ‘jewish science’ produces better results than ‘purely aryan science’, then that is a far better test of their worth than to try to divine the ulterior motives of the creators through their identity.

It didn't produce better science, it didn't win because it was smarter or more empirically-minded or better for society, it won because the most influential thinkers involved were consciously thinking about opposing anti-Semitism with the ideas they were promoting, and they won with academically authoritarian tactics we are all familiar with today.

You are an avid practitioner of their critical theory and standpoint epistemology.

I think there's value in some of their ideas even if I disagree on how they are applied. Certainly the Dissident Right itself is adjacent to ideas in critical theory like the Culture Industry.

That's why the DR is actually avant-garde. Conservatives just whine that Critical Theory has rained on our parade and they want to wind back the clock on collective consciousness which is neither possible nor desirable. The DR is taking the ideas that have merit from the Critical Theorists and applying them against the prevailing culture. That's a feature and not a bug of the DR. The way out isn't backwards, the only way out is through and that does mean using Critical Theory's tools that have merit against the prevailing culture.

The other LW article I've seen takes the same approach of trying to distance the embryonic selection from eugenics:

In my view, the term “eugenics” should not be used to describe embryo screening. In most people’s minds “eugenics” conjures images of government-sponsored sterilization efforts, genocide, and racist pseudoscience. I understand the technical definition is just “good for genes”, but this is not what comes to mind for most people when they hear this word.

Even worse, most of the horrible things done in the name of “eugenics” in the past were in fact not eugenic at all! The entire Nazi theory of genes was based on a fundamental misunderstanding of how genes worked. They believed that non-aryan peoples were “contaminating” the “pure aryan bloodline”, and that only by purging those who were unpure could they make a perfect master race. Which is of course not just a morally repugnant theory, but also wrong.

If you want to have a productive conversation, I would suggest using the term “epilogenics” to describe non-coercive means of improving genes that are in line with what we expect those affected would want. There are of course still some concerns with epilogenics (increasing inequality for example), but they are decidedly NOT the same concerns that people have about eugenics.

From what I've seen, they want to use the technology to selfishly give their own offspring a leg-up over the rest of society, they don't actually want to approach social issues with eugenic-minded thinking- they still denounce that. Supporting embryonic selection won't even make a dent in dysgenic spiral, and good luck being saved by gene editing when even they are too afraid to openly associate with eugenics and don't seem interested in challenging the bad arguments against it.

I used to love WWI/WWII movies when I was younger, it scratched that Star-Wars-esque heroism itch. Now I avoid them unless I'm willing to end up demoralized watching Hollywood dance on the grave of Europe. Some are really good and worth watching like Dunkirk, but it's a genre where my interpretation of the films has radically changed from adventure-heroism to tragedy.

Advocating for this technology is ultimately an admission that genes matter, of course it's a eugenics technology. The essence of the eugenics movement is social concern over the gene pool, and that is exactly embodied with this technology.

But embryo selection is indeed highly limited, and if proponents of this technology are going to hide behind "we just want healthier babies", then indeed why stop there? If we want healthier babies, way before we care about embryo screening shouldn't we foremost care about a eugenic mate selection which is always going to be more impactful than embryonic screening?

I can say that I honestly want healthier babies in terms of physical strength, IQ, beauty, but I am keenly aware that even most proponents of this technology would consider that evil beyond their opportunity to improve their own offspring.

I've said before that if "longtermists" were worthy of the name they would foremost care about the gene pool and its direction. Their new advocacy for this technology shows that they want it for themselves without generalizing the issue as a social question, which it always has been and always will be.

They should embrace the label and recognize that the arguments against eugenics have always been bad from the very beginning. You can argue against something like forced sterilization, but the arguments against eugenics have never been good, so it's annoying seeing advocates for embryo screening try to distance themselves from eugenics rather than be brave and acknowledge that fact.

There were valid reasons to oppose nazi germany, aside from jewish ethnic solidarity

First of all, I do not agree, but that is besides the point. The point is that this is another example of:

  • The public has one strongly-held belief, like the practically unanimous consensus to not intervene in WWII against Germany.

  • The Jews in a position of strong influence have a much different, ethnically-motivated opinion.

  • The Jews write stories and create myth with the conscious intention of cryptically influencing the opinion of the public towards their own agenda.

  • The myths become popular culture, our own popular "religion" in a way, and slowly the audiences internalize the message such that they believe "Americanism as Captain America as punching Nazis" is simply what Americanism always has been rather than the ethno-political agenda of the mythmakers.

Even saying "there were valid reasons to oppose Nazi Germany" does nothing to challenge the point I am making here.

The last assumption that's needed is that Jews are better at creating myth, stories, propaganda, and social narratives that influence the Gentiles towards their preferred way of thinking, and this is largely explained by HBD.

Aside from the apparently deceptive mythmaking, they also heavily contributed to science.

Of course, they have contributed to Anthropology, where militant Jews agitated against eugenics such that blank-slatism became the basic premise of social science until this day, in a sharp u-Turn from the Protestant Darwinians. They greatly contributed to psychoanalysis, which used pseudoscience to justify ethnically-motivated ideas around the Authoritarian Personality and sexual liberation which form the basis for social revolutions and critique of Gentile morality. Critical Theory today which formulates the basis of criticism against "whiteness" is derived from the ideas Frankfurt School academics, which even Conservatives have picked up on at this point. In those cases there was an underlying ethnic motivation perceived by the contributors.

As in the case of Freud, he said that "Semitic Hannibal" Barca was his childhood hero, and he imagined himself as a young Hannibal swearing vengeance against Rome and described his own work as a mortal conflict with the Catholic Church. It's a very odd thing for an academic to fantasize about, viewing their own academic work as nothing short of warfare against their mortal ethnic rivals, it's not wonder empiricism took a backseat to Freud's own motivated ideology, as in the case of the anthropologists...

If you read Superman as metaphor for the Jewish experience.. the thrust of that metaphor is that Jews can be fully assimilated Americans.

If Superman were about the actual assimilation of our Kryptonian hero, Kal-El (the Kryptonian name of Superman), that would make for a very boring story. Of course Superman is not about that- he cannot assimilate.

The most he can do is adopt an alter-ego in his daily interactions with humans by changing his name from Kal-El, meaning "Voice of God" in Hebrew, to the Gentile name Clark Kent. He changes his appearance, puts on a suit, goes to work as a media reporter (!) with everyone else none the wiser to his true identity.

But when Clark Kent tears open the shirt, he affirms that underneath the disguise he was always Superman. He holds sentimental feelings towards humanity as his adopted family, but in his heart of hearts he is a diasporan son of Krypton and he will never be them- he is a superior being and he must protect them and guide them.

This is extremely sophisticated storytelling. It provides perceptive Jewish audiences with a sense of identity, and yes superiority, it is a myth that tells them they cannot assimilate even if they change their name and appearance such that nobody around them knows who they truly are, they will always be Kryptonian underneath the surface. At the same time, there is compelling content for Gentile audiences that internalize the Ethos espoused by the ass-kicking superhero.

Are you asserting that Siegel and Shuster in the 30s and 40s were part of a deliberate, conscious attempt to destroy 'white' American culture?

My point is that ethos is downstream from mythos. So those who have special talents in creating mythos likewise are in a strong position to influence the ethos of the collective consciousness. Siegel and Shuster's Superman telling children that being American means being anti-racist in 1950, not 30 years after the United States passed legislation intending to wind back the clock on demographics to the 1800s, is an example of this, as-is Captain America.