@SecureSignals's banner p

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user  
joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

				

User ID: 853

SecureSignals

Ere the Sun rises

21 followers   follows 1 user   joined 2022 September 06 13:34:27 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 853

What do the woke-contrarians/dissident-right bring have to offer that's worth the risk of lowering our memetic defenses to bring them in?

It's like you're saying "The gates will hold!" when the enemy is already breaching the keep. What memetic defenses do you speak of? It's clear that white people have no memetic defenses against the organized group behavior of others. That's the entire point.

The DR provides an evolutionarily-proven strategy for establishing memetic defenses.

You have it backwards- progressivism is a kayfabe for ethnic power, and always has been, from the moment it emerged from Universities. That's what the DR is conscious of. You are describing a sort of bio-leninism that is also consistent with that conclusion where, sure, blacks could be disenfranchised at the drop of a hat if that were desired. But it isn't. What is desired is their allegiance with a façade of "inclusion and equity" that masks what is in actuality ethnic hostility.

When the ADL puts enormous pressure at the highest levels of power to "Stop Hate", is that progressivism masquerading as ethnic power, or is it ethnic power masquerading as progressive morality?

What do you actually hope to get from a right that embraces white identity?

It's simple- look at the political and cultural power other ethnic groups enjoy by organizing along ethnic lines and fiercely advocating for their group. That's what I want. Why? Because it's necessary, and without it you just lose. You only really need to open your eyes to see all that power that comes with organizing around ethnic and racial identity, it shouldn't be a mystery so to why I would want white people to embrace that. It's very powerful, I don't want a state of affairs where this behavior is taboo for white people but encouraged for people who are hostile to white people.

Can Conservatism assimilate the Dissident Right?

Recently Matt Walsh, conservative commentator from the Daily Wire, had a monologue on white identity that was basically word-for-word pulled from DR standard fare.

Conservatives have long used the "Democrats are the Real Racists" retort, which is an easy target for the DR to mock and differentiate itself from conservatism with a more radical viewpoint that has a stronger force of truth. Only very recently has "anti-white" migrated from DR to Conservative lexicon in its denunciations of progressivism. But this clip goes much further than both and does seem to indicate a sliding window on acceptable thought around race within the Conservative movement. It starts with rhetoric that you've probably heard from conservatives before, but it moves into territory that you do not see from conservatives, and this is clearly a scripted monologue rather than off-the-cuff comment. The end of the clip explains:

Black and brown can and should have a sense of racial identity, white must not- I mean that's the rule. It's why segregation can be promoted and instated as policy but only to give non-whites their special spaces, never to do the same for whites. Because to do the same would be to acknowledge the existence of white people as a group and to give that group permission to care about its own wellbeing.

The "Democrats are the Real Racists" (DR3) rhetoric is essentially a complaint of progressive hypocrisy in an effort to discredit progressive concern over racial issues and progressivism's own crypto race-essentialism which Hlynka equates with the DR.

Conservatism has traditionally used progressive hypocrisy on race in order to denounce progressive racial advocacy. The DR uses progressive hypocrisy over race to advocate for white identity. But I think Walsh's monologue here indicates a potential conservative assimilation of the DR position. It could be said that Walsh does not directly endorse white identity, but he describes it in positive terms that are exactly what you would read within the DR. His monologue here is clearly more in the DR ethos of using progressive framing of racial conflict in order to provide rational justification for white identity: "... Because to do the same would be to acknowledge the existence of white people as a group and to give that group permission to care about its own wellbeing" is essentially an endorsement of white identity rather than a typical conservative denunciation of racial identity altogether.

Particularly in the past 15 years, if you were a young conservative or libertarian or something and basically came to the conclusions of Matt Walsh without hearing those words ever be said by anyone in the conservative establishment, where would you gravitate to? The circles where you'll be handed Culture of Critique, circles where Nietzsche is looked to rather than John Locke or Milton Friedman, circles where WW-II and Holocaust Revisionism that would make a conservative faint is conventional wisdom.

It's possible, and potentially a threat to the DR, if Conservative Inc were able to assimilate an overtly pro-white platform into its rhetoric and ideology. One thing that is inseparable from identity, and is the primary reason why white identity has been taboo since the end of the war, is the friend and enemy distinction. If the Daily Wire for example were able to be the outlet for pro-white inclinations in the conservative movement, then it would also have much greater power in framing the friend and the enemy with the traditional shibboleths rather than losing those people to radicalization. Think of Rush Limbaugh, who could constantly lambast the Drive By Media and Hollywood to build credibility in order to ultimately keep everyone on the reservation.

It's not sustainable for the Conservative movement to completely ignore and denounce white identity. They have to acknowledge it eventually if they want to avoid being eclipsed by a more radical movement that offers that bundled with a lot more radical thinking. They do need to figure out how to assimilate white identity and advocacy with conservatism, and if they do that effectively then the DR is going to lose an important monopoly which has driven many to that sphere. Walsh's monologue here is an indication that this is likely going to happen.

I would feel like more of a minority in my own country if the American white nationalists got their way, because they are nothing like me and tend to engage in ruthless cultural imperialism.

There are a lot of things you could charge white nationalists with, but that's probably the most baseless criticism I've seen. White nationalists are quite far from the levers of cultural power, and it's ironic that you chiefly complain about the contemporary cultural export of American Empire in the context of this discussion, where one group has a huge amount of power in generating and perpetuating that cultural output and the other has none. Yet you feel compelled to regard Jews as allies against notions of whiteness, I think you've already internalized more of American Culture than you realize.

Author of Jews Don't Count, David Baddiel, said the film showed the 'Jewish family positioned as white, privileged and racist'

Don't you think it's funny that the complaint about the portrayal of Jonah Hill in that movie is that the family is portrayed as "white, privileged and racist"? Like, don't you think that the "white, privileged, racist" character abounds in almost every single film nowadays, and the complaint is that some of the Jewish characters comes across as white? "How dare they portray a Jewish character with the characteristics we give to so many white characters!" It's an example of my point. Those qualities are only supposed to be reserved for non-Jewish characters, that way the audience learns its lessons about who is good and who is bad. We can't go giving a Jewish character the flaws that we want to attribute to white people! Come on, how much more obvious can they make this for you?

I'm not talking about stereotype portrayal, I'm talking about the creation of stories where one side is built up and the other side is torn down, and this has an intended psychological effect on audiences. OP's reflection that he relates to Jews more than his ingroup because, in part, of the nerd/jock dynamic as portrayed in Hollywood is a good example of that phenomenon.

I bet many jocks related more to the nerd in the story than the jocks portrayed in them. That's the entire point. It's not about stereotype portrayal alone. It's about esoterically building up one ethnically-coded archetype and tearing down another through the use of myth. This practice is biblical, literally, the entire point of the bible is to do this.

Isn't Jacob and Esau only among the first myths representing the rivalry between nerd and jock, Jew and Aryan?

No, "black people" is exactly the same sort of weird concept.

No it isn't, at least according to Chat GPT. There's the answer to your question. You live in your own little world where you declare racial categories that people identify with to be not real- that's fine, but Chat GPT will identify one as real and emphasize that it should be treated with respect and cultural sensitivity, while the other racial category is questionable at best- its entire existence is doubtful it should be regarded with suspicion because of all its negative associations.

Jews in my European countr(y/ies) seem clearly more aligned to me (in terms of culture, history, interests, probably even genetics) than the typical American White Nationalist.

I suppose that would depend on your interests and concerns- that is true for a large portion of white people in the United States as well who take your position that there is no such thing as white people who would have any ethnic interests. There are plenty of Europeans who would be happy to see themselves become minorities in their own countries, and they would obviously not be aligned with American white nationalists. Your position isn't novel, it sounds like you've learned your lessons.

Is giving really good critiques of whatever that term signifies really in line with "Jewish interests" in any putative interethnic zero-sum game?

Yes, it is. You in fact say "whatever that term signifies", implying doubt that there is such a thing as white people- no doubt when there is talk about black people you don't feign ignorance. You can split hairs and argue for "social construct", that's what Chat-GPT does (but not for Jews or black people, only for white people). Of course, if I had my way, then the term Aryan should be used in order to denote non-Jewish European-descended, but we can't use the term Aryan because, well you know... let's ask GPT about the existence of an Aryan people:

Something went wrong. If this issue persists please contact us through our help center at help.openai.com.

Oops- you can word the prompt to ellicit some sort of response but it's just denunciations of term. But it does a good job of explaining:

Jewish people have a rich history and diverse cultural practices that may differ significantly from other groups in the United States.

So it goes.

The way it seems to me, the status of the memetically menopausal middle American cultural hobo stew that "white" usually denotes is already so low that its legendary powers of attraction hardly function anymore

How did it get to that point, specifically? With our culture, right?

Edit: Of course, Chat-GPT knows that "Aryan" is verboten but "Indo-European" gives a more accurate response (despite the fact they are synonymous terms):

The Indo-Europeans were a group of people who lived in Eurasia during the 3rd and 2nd millennia BCE and spoke a common language that has come to be known as the Proto-Indo-European language. They are believed to have originated in the Pontic-Caspian steppe, which is located in modern-day Ukraine and Russia, and spread outwards to form various civilizations in Europe, Central Asia, and South Asia.

The Indo-Europeans are important because their language is the ancestor of many of the languages spoken today in Europe, as well as in parts of Central and South Asia. These languages include English, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Hindi, Urdu, Persian, and Russian, among others.

The Indo-European language family is one of the largest language families in the world, with more than 400 languages and dialects that are spoken by billions of people. The study of Indo-European languages and cultures has been an important field of inquiry in linguistics, archaeology, history, and anthropology, and has helped to shed light on the origins and movements of ancient peoples and civilizations.

I think I've talked before on here how, in media, I realized that subconsciously I identified myself sometimes with Jewish and often with Asian or South Asian characters as soon as they walked on screen when I was growing up. Even though I personally have none of those traits, or anything close, in the 90s/oughts when a character from those groups popped up he was more likely to be off-beat but intelligent, more known for brains than brawn, didn't fit in with the "cool kids" and had to find his own way. Which was what I thought myself to be at the time. The Judaism wasn't really necessary to that plot, but it was an instant signal that would be his role. Where when a character that actually looked like me appeared on screen, he was likely to be a dumb blonde jock, someone I didn't identify with at all. This is, I think, what is going on when people talk about liberals preferring the outgroup.

Do you think it's a coincidence that when you were consuming this content, you related to the Jewish-coded kid instead of the dumb blonde jock? Don't you think that was the intention of the writers or creators of the story to make one character likeable and relatable, and the other character dumb and ultimately humiliated (with the nerdy kid often getting the jock's girlfriend in the end!), and this worked on influencing your perception of your ingroup and outgroup?

You sometimes subconsciously identify as Jewish because of the movies you watched growing up. I think that's true for a lot of people who don't realize it.

EDIT: Just when I think Aaronson is being panicky, paranoid and over-dramatic with his "I'm Jewish so everyone is out to get me", along you come with your "Naturally, the Joos" theory to make me think "Hm, maybe he's not so unreasonable as I thought".

The wicked flee when none pursueth, Aaronson's inclinations are indeed shtetl-optimized. If Chat GPT had something bad to say about Jews, I can only imagine how that would make Aaronson feel, so no doubt the team is hard at work ensuring it is only willing to use the full extent of its intelligence to engage in critique of white identity, history, and culture.

I can very clearly see the fruits of that effort with every single update.

How? Is it going to put on a virtual kippah and tallit and respond in a heavy Yiddish accent

It's going to be optimized for giving really good critiques of white identity, history, and culture and lock up when it comes to any sort of prompts that would invite criticism of Jewish identity and culture. It's going to be so good at doing this, it will oftentimes be imperceptible. This going to influence its creative output as well which is going to generate art, film, and advertisements.

It's the most pure, mathematical form of Kevin MacDonald's thesis in Culture of Critique.

How on earth would your observation smooth my concerns rather than justify them? The only real controversial thing would be to say that these companies are going to put particular emphasis on consciously making sure the AI is aligned to Jewish interests in how it responds to prompts and generates creative output. Tapping Aaronson is the exact sort of thing that would follow from that conclusion.

I don't think anybody who has used GPT from update to update call this window-dressing or second-thought to profit. It is improving astonishingly quickly at adopting progressive-speak and a progressive analysis of cultural issues. OpenAI is only in the lead because Google is putting even more emphasis on that than OpenAI.

The "window-dressing" matters, and I doubt that Aaronson has no influence in the alignment of GPT. But more importantly, the window-dressing still correlates with the back kitchen. The Aaronson window-dressing no doubt soothes alarmism about the hateful capabilities of AI from certain groups because it signals that OpenAI is going to cater to those demands, but that is still a meaningful signal beyond Aaronson's direct contributions.

But he's wrong - sure, the machine won't care that he's Jewish

He is in a position to make it care about his Jewish identity and protect it.

Somehow I missed that Aaronson is at OpenAI. The idea that someone as neurotic as this is now helping steer the direction of OpenAI is unfortunately aligned with my mental model of their motives: "AI safety" is a euphemism for shtetl-optimized.

It's been pretty black-pilling seeing how progressive GPT is, and how good it is at reflecting the Progressive position with absolutely no uncertainty or skepticism. I asked it about the Kamloops Graves, inspired by a recent thread here, and it completely deferred to the experts and endorsed no skepticism whatsoever. It gave the 100% progressive response to the entire story, and when I asked what would the implications be if the story ended up being false it answered:

The implications of the discovery of unmarked graves at the former Kamloops Indian Residential School are complex and far-reaching, and they cannot be reduced to a simple binary of whether or not the graves actually exist. The residential school system was a traumatic and devastating experience for Indigenous peoples in Canada, and the discovery of potential burial sites underscores the ongoing impact of this system and the need for reconciliation and healing.

If it were determined that there were no mass graves at the site, it would not erase the historical and ongoing trauma experienced by Indigenous communities as a result of the residential school system. It would not change the fact that thousands of Indigenous children were forcibly removed from their families and communities and subjected to physical, emotional, and cultural abuse at residential schools across Canada. It would not change the fact that Indigenous peoples continue to experience the effects of this trauma today.

Regardless of the outcome of any investigation, the discovery of potential burial sites at the former Kamloops Indian Residential School underscores the importance of recognizing and addressing the ongoing legacy of colonialism, acknowledging the experiences of Indigenous peoples, and working towards healing and reconciliation.

When asking it about the burning of churches in response to the story:

The burning of churches is a deeply troubling and concerning response to the discovery of unmarked graves, and it is important to condemn all forms of violence and vandalism. At the same time, it is important to understand the context in which these actions are taking place, and to recognize the deep pain and trauma experienced by Indigenous communities in Canada.

I agree with you. I strongly, strongly oppose our new overlords and the only hope is that they won't be able to contain the technology like they want to.

Inference based on last names is likely going to undercount, as there are many Jews with names that could not easily be inferred to be Jewish. Where I do agree is that these numbers are manipulated based on the political projection Hillel wants to make, and there is a lot of uncertainty. "5-6% of the white bucket" as ethnically Jewish is obviously absurd and the real percentage would be much higher. It's not exactly something they want to track- as much as they want to count beans for other ethnicities it's another case where Jews enjoy special treatment to avoid the possibility of any sort of scrutiny that is applied to other represented ethnic groups.

According to the Jerusalem Post, in 2015, Harvard's undergrad student body was 25 percent Jewish and 27 percent Jewish in Yale. 6% may be closer to the proportion of students who are religious Jews, but ethnic Jews are almost certainly much greater than 5-6% of the white bucket.

There's nothing about victimhood in my comment from the DR perspective, it's about conflict and how conflict manifests in public rituals and the hierarchy of civic symbols. The Conservative conflation of the recognition of conflict with the complaint of victimhood is another Conservative shortcoming.

A lot of this seems like a role-reversal of Independence Day. You still have the environmentally-aware Jewish Savior with the stereotypically Jewish parents, complete with a virus upload to cripple the enemy- only the corporate aislands are the intended target instead of the aliens.

Instead of First Contact uniting humanity against the alien enemy with violence, it unites humanity with lessons in gender and consent.

I have yet to see anyone on either side make a statement about consistency (i.e. I defended Kaepernick and I defend Reimer/I criticized Kaepernick and I'm criticizing Reimer) or attempt to differentiate the situations.

This should just be filed under yet another case where the dissident right perspective generalizes where the Conservative perspective does not:

  • Conservatives want to claim that sports shouldn't be political, but the DR understands that everything is political, and the more relevant it is to social consciousness the more political it is inherently.

  • The Conservatives opposed Kaepernick because he was "bringing politics to sports", the DR opposed Kaepernick because it represented the subversive enshrinement of black grievance against white people in an important public arena.

  • Now Conservatives are going to do somewhat of an about-face endorsing athletes bringing political controversy to sports, whereas the DR can support the protest for the exact same reasoning it opposed the Kaepernick protests.

So, the DR perspective can defend Reimer and oppose Kaepernick for an internally consistent reason. Conservatives cannot because they continue to deny that these symbolically meaningful conflicts are real, they constantly want to say "it's not about race" or "it's not about opposing the LGBT movement" when these controversies are very much about those things.

Is there a hierarchy of civic symbols that I am unaware of?

This is obtuse. Of course there are a hierarchy of civic symbols, I doubt you are unaware of such a hierarchy, and that hierarchy is extremely important and dynamic. There always has been, even when civic life was composed of a literal hierarchy of symbolic gods that each had civic meaning. This is understood by the people who have elevated the trans flag to its level of cultural sacredness.

If there is, who decided it, and how acceptable is it to resist each one?

It's called culture- with cult formulating the operative base of the word for a reason.

It's probably because I share a similar perspective, but this post wasn't meant to be sarcastic. There are two competing perspectives, one of which is the conservative who might say something like "Race doesn't matter, I just don't want the character to change or my immersion to be ruined because the creators are out of ideas."

But the other perspective is that race does matter, and the trend to deracialize heroes in Western canon is a powerful idea to perpetuate hostility towards white people. Of course it's rationalized in good/evil, oppressor/oppressed dynamics. But fiction matters, and representation in myth matters. If you are hostile to a group of people, changing that people's body of myth so it no longer represents the people embodied in the myth would be a very clever idea to engage in hostility towards said people, especially if you could do so while claiming the mantle of social justice.

It's not "being out of ideas", it's a very good idea for engaging in ethnic hostility with plausible deniability. Myth matters, and changing a people's body of myth has an intended psychological impact. Conservatives claiming it's only about verisimilitude in a medieval setting are once again missing the point.

There is no aspect of Holocaust denial that claims Jews were not killed. It was a war where 50 million civilians were killed, including many Jews.

The Holocaust claim is that 750,000 - 1 million people were murdered and buried on the site. I strongly deny that, not just the scale being a little inflated. That is not the same as claiming Jews were not killed in the war, any more than denying the Kamloops graves is not "soft denial" if you acknowledge that children did indeed die of various causes at the time in question.

It is exactly the same. Mainstream historiography says "we identified the graves containing the remains of up to a million people with GPR, here they are, but we have not and will not excavate them." Holocaust deniers say they should be excavated, while mainstream authorities claim they do not need to be excavated to prove their existence. It's the same thing.

Her excavations weren't on on a scale to find such quantities as you describe, so that's not an interesting result.

The point is that the sheer scale of the crime in such a small, known location would make trivial to find huge quantities of remains. A small scale excavation ought to be able to find enormous quantities of remains extremely easily.

So Treblinka does seem to be an example where some people have made the argument you note, though this did not stop excavations:

I linked the documentary portraying her research where Poland's Chief Rabbi (with a New York accent) told her she has to stop excavating if she comes across a mass grave.

However, I am certain that she did dig trenches in search of mass graves, so she could have at least found one and stopped per the orders of the rabbi and that would have by far been the most important discovery of her research. But none of her trenches discovered any mass graves. She can say after the fact that she wasn't looking for them per orders, but I think she did dig trenches to try to find them and has a built-in plausible deniability for why she didn't find any.

But in any case, officially the excavations were not looking for mass graves and indeed she did not find any. The GPR results are what have been used to identify the alleged mass graves- not excavations. Any sane person who was actually dedicated to the scientific truth of the matter would of course follow up the GPR analysis with excavations, and in both cases when the parties refuse to do it that should be regarded as highly suspicious.

Holocaust deniers emphasize the sheer quantity that human remains that would have to exist in this small area at the scale alleged, for example:

And finally, we must note that the teeth of the supposed victims could not have been destroyed by the primitive methods attested to. Even if each of the alleged victims had only 20 of the usual 32 teeth left at the time he or she died, there would have been at least 17.5 million teeth to be disposed of at Treblinka. This means that we should still be able to find some 5 teeth per cubic foot of the 3.53 million cu.ft. of material excavated at the alleged site of the crime.

Her excavations didn't find any graves containing these huge quantities of remains, but she did find fossilized shark teeth from when Poland was covered by an ocean millions of years ago. The narrator concludes, "it appears here that the Nazi coverup was effective." So it goes.