SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
No bio...
User ID: 84
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
21hr ago
for not having a permit or not having an ID card, it granting people these things is still a violent act.
Ah, but here's the important bit: said ID card is entirely optional (around here). It's one way to identify yourself but not even the most common one. There are no negative consequences to not having one (in fact mine is past its validity date by a year or two). Nonetheless the police are the ones that grant it (because they have the means and existing infrastructure to verify the person's identity securely). If you claim that asking for an ID is an act of violence, does that mean the delivery guy who wanted to see my ID before giving me the parcel was violent? I don't think anyone reasonable would support that.
A claim that police is definitionally violent and that "every single thing the police do is something being done against the will of the person it is being done to", is like trying to prove a negative. Any counterexample invalidates it. In the case of an ID card, the thing being done is verifying that I am in fact me and it is done at my behest, not against my will. Likewise if I were to end up in a minor traffic accident, I'd call the police to witness the situation so that the other party can't make outrageous claims. They are not there in the capacity of violence (nobody is going to get arrested) but to act as impartial witnesses.
It may be that the police in US has degenerated so much that they are only capable of violence but that's a peculiarity of that particular style of policing, not a definitional feature of the concept of "the police".
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
23hr ago
Nonetheless, the act of granting a drivers license is not remotely ”definitionally violent” and to even suggest that granting an ID card (for those rare situations where a drivers license isn’t accepted as an ID) is violent is completely ridiculous. The claim was that ”every single thing the police do is something being done against the person it’s being done to”.
Police do many things, some of which are violent, but police in the US leaning so heavily on that side does not mean that police is definitionally violent.
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
1d ago
I wasn’t aware that having my passport and ID card renewed or being granted a drivers license was ”definitionally violent”…
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
1d ago
I remember when blue hair was associated mostly with anime
Was that ever really a thing outside extremely online / fan circles?
I live in a place that luckily isn't excessively contaminated with anime culture and I'd say that before "purple haired girl" became a known concept, people would have pattern matched it to punk-adjacent weirdos. Ie. definitely not politically neutral.
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
2d ago
probably to advance a devious scheme of human gene theft
I assume this is conducted by organic means to minimize suspicions?
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
2d ago
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
2d ago
I recently binged on This Magical Girl Is Mine on Royal Road and it has awakened a monster in me. I figured I can't be the only degenerate in this wretched hive of scum and villainy of ours, so...
Y'all got any more of them Yuri romances?
No, I don't mean lame hentai. I'm looking for the really filthy stuff, with hand holding and kisses and pining for her true love and other such sugary lewdness that's definitely not fit for polite society (although I gotta admit I probably wouldn't say no to good hentai either). Cute stories where the boy girl gets the girl and they hopefully live happily ever after. None of that eternal "will they or won't they"-bullshit and the less said about "disabled autistic BIPOC social outcast" awards bait the better. Cute girls doing things such that just reading about them probably risks giving you diabetes. Doesn't matter if it's slice of life or if they have to save the world from evil as a side quest (but horror, litrpg and traditional super hero stories aren't my cup of tea).
On a more serious note, that story is actually quite good if you're fine with the twist on magical girls (it's rather more complicated than it first appears) and the main character being willing to sacrifice everything for her unrequited love (not-so-plot-twist: things evolve). Generally well written except the author can't seem to decide exactly how to write the love interest's name (is it Sophia or Sophie?)
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
2d ago
The UK
The UK has a different legal tradition to Continental Europe and of course rather notably isn't part of EU. They are in general not representative of the rest of Europe in anything when it comes to laws (anyone using UK as an example of European laws almost certainly has an agenda to grind and isn't participating in good faith).
Here in Finland there was a notable case involving a blog post (written as and literally titled "a bait to the chief prosecutor") which in the end lead to a trivial fine and the author getting voted into the parliament and eventually becoming the leader of the then second largest party in the parliament (because of the resulting large publicity). A rather different outcome from "throwing natives in jail over tweets".
SkoomaDentist
The Greater Finnish Empire
4d ago
Five - the advocates deal mostly or even exclusively with trivial codebases and have invested so much of their self worth into "being good at prompting" that they insist anyone who doesn't deal with similar boilerplate easy-mode tasks "is just using LLMs wrong".
The secret is a highly detailed claude.md file, having a code base which is hyper standardized from the beginning with standards for function naming, variable names, types etc and having a code base that is somewhat repetitive. [...] Claude breaks down when features get more complex, when there are edge cases and when the business requirements are complex.
Which is a fancier way of saying that Claude works for simple repetitive standardized boilerplate (a fact that's not very controversial).
What makes me despise LLM advocates is their persistent gaslighting that anyone whose job doesn't involve writing such code that is inherently easy mode for LLMs "is using them wrong", as if you were only ever allowed to write code where the requirements neatly fit into such narrow box.
TypeScript [...] Java and Csharp [...] python
Yeah. I don't use any of those languages other than sometimes Python when I need to fix tools where you need a true human+ level AGI to decipher WTF the inherited / third party code is even supposed to do (and no, it doesn't involve APIs or stack overflow snippet friendly code).
Here the police are the ones that issue me the ID, not any other agents of the state. IOW, the police have multiple duties, some which aren't in any way related to their monopoly on violence.
The claim was notably about the police / law enforcement being definitionally violent, ie. police anywhere and everywhere is always violent which is very easy to find counterexamples for that invalidate the claim.
Granting that (entirely optional) national ID card for one. Another is acting as a witness in various situations (eg. someone hits your car and you or they call the police to take written statements and observations on the spot so that it isn't just your vs the other guy's claims two months later in court about who has to pay damages). Guiding traffic (as opposed to observing or giving tickets) in case of major disruptions (eg. an accident requires redirecting traffic to prevent further casualties). Taking criminal complaints. Handling lost and found goods (a typical example would be finding some person's lost wallet and taking it to the police station).
Yes, one of police's duties is to enforce the state's monopoly on violence but that's far from the only thing they do. It may be that it's the only thing they do in some places but that's not part of the definition of police, just a feature of policing in that specific place (the way police behave in US vs Europe differs massively and unless I'm severely mistaken even the difference between the police in US vs Canada is striking).
More options
Context Copy link