@SkoomaDentist's banner p

SkoomaDentist

The Greater Finnish Empire

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:08:00 UTC

				

User ID: 84

SkoomaDentist

The Greater Finnish Empire

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:08:00 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 84

Your problems with the book come from a few things. It essentially is just a collection of old Keyboard magazine articles written by a music journalist (with a journalist's understanding of technology) and the writer didn't spend nearly effort to be able to write any sort of comprehensive "This is what synthesizers are and how they became so"-overview. Quite a bit of the early behind-the-scenes history is at best accessible by managing to interview some still alive key figures in depth (and hope their recollections are accurate) but just about as often impossible to find out without resurrecting key people from the grave (Bob Moog, Alan R Pearlman, Dave Smith). Finally music journalists, even fairly techy ones, are woefully underequipped to truly understand the technology, nevermind being able to differentiate myth from fact (see eg. still persisting claims about "loss of bass" with Moog ladder).

Ultimately I suspect the set of people both qualified to write a proper study and willing to do so is approaching an empty set. Luckily there are at least modern youtube documentaries about various key figures which sometimes are even made with the right attitude (historical and factual accuracy instead of just propagating the same old myths).

Assuming your questions aren't strictly rhetorical, here are my best guess answers to some:

Why did so many of the big synth companies of the '70s (ARP, Moog, Oberheim, Sequential, Linn) fail in the 1980s, when synths were at their zenith in pop music? Was it that they couldn't keep up with rapidly advancing technology, that musical tastes changed, that they were bad at business, or some combination of factors?

A combination of being bad at business and a complete failure to keep up with advancing technology (ie. digital synthesis).

Why did Bob Moog's "East Coast" philosophy of synth design ultimately win out over Don Buchla's "West Coast" philosophy?

Because it's musical, the controls are fairly predictable and they map to how acoustic instruments behave. West Coast is much more avant garde, to the extent that it's still very difficult to find musical examples instead of weirdo noises.

Why didn't the composers associated with the RCA Mark II in the 1950s and 1960s, most notably Milton Babbit, seem to have any involvement with synthesizers after the technology became more developed?

I suspect this is largely because those composers could be counted in single digits and were experimenters who were more interested in the process than the results. The same way you don't see classical composers experimenting with 12-tone technique have the same impact as eg. John Williams or Hans Zimmer.

That’s my point: I don’t think people consider Dalton that horriible. At least he wasn’t considerd so back when I still watched the yearly Bond reruns. Lazenby OTOH was disliked by everyone I knew.

BPD: Not even twice.

Timothy Dalton? Surely you mean George Lazenby?

Isn’t that just called ”being Christian” as opposed to ”being Jewish”?

He didn't have to. He predicted something much more important: The need to develop and pour massive resources into the technology that has been the requirement for fast crypto, transformer models and countless other things and that nobody else has managed to reliably develop until years later.

CUDA came out in 2006.

It's funny to see how many people don't remember the history of GPUs. CUDA was a way to expose DX 10 mandated GPU computing capabilities in a sane way that actually works and that could be depended on for scientific computing (whether that is massive simulations or just accelerating algorithms with a midrange gpu). To this date it still remains the only way in many respects. Being able to do state of the art AI (for whatever era it was) has been a direct consequence of having CUDA in the first place.

I get a feeling that many American catholics are really quite like evangelical protestants with just some bits replaced by stuff taken from catholicism.

Reading comments on The Motte has made it clear how wildly different US catholics' views are from European or South American ones.

Sure, but this was a suite that generated automatic penetration / bug tests targeted at entirely novel Bluetooth stacks (the target market being companies doing BT stack / device development).

The internet / LAN equivalent would have been a tool that you pointed at a machine and it tried to find previously undiscovered bugs / exploits in everything from LAN packet handling up to sshd / httpd.

15 years ago when I was working in Bluetooth development, I chatted informally with a couple of guys who had a semi-automated (ie. human guiding the test battery) over the air penetration / bug tester. They were an established company so their tech probably existed 20 years ago already.