@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Sorry wrong comment.

And because I'm Orthodox. ;)

I see someone also reads N.S. Lyons.

I have to admit, the foxes versus lions lens was actually very helpful. Explains a lot of what's going on.

I didn't say it was irrelevant! I just said we could pick and choose as we pleased based on what's convenient at the time. :)

But fair, I'll get schooled. Yeah I mean a lot of it depends on patristic interpretations and such.

Do you also think that Christians shouldn't be fruitful and multiply, or enjoy the beasts of the field and plants as food?

Not in all situations, no. And in fact many Christian saints have been vegan, and many Christian sects over the years have eschewed childbearing and focused on individual salvation.

Modern atheists have an unfortunate tendency to equate all of Christianity with the beliefs of the most vocal, modern evangelical Protestants. I should know, I used to do the same thing.

This is a clever idea. Me likey.

This would be interesting in industry too. Maybe we put a cap on full time, but let older folks come in as consultants or advisors or something and cap em at 10 hours a week.

Maybe a pension system where it can't be raided to fund overseas wars and other things? Or I don't know, a system where instead of going into a big government account, the money goes into an account you actually personally own?

I'm not saying it's a terrible idea, I'm saying that the implementation is beyond fucked.

Sigh. Such a terrible system. But I guess this is just the world we're in.

How would a society where this system actually worked even look?

Not sure how you get around this one.

Extremely easily. That's Old Testament. Jesus fulfilled the Old Testament and so the old covenant no longer applies.

Please don't write so arrogantly when you are unaware of one of the most basic concepts in Christianity. It's unbecoming.

???? He sounds totally normal to me here, like he always does. Not sure what y'all are picking up on

How do you feel about social security?

Any discussion here needs to start with the actual federal budget. About 60% of which is Social Security/Medicare/Medicaid/Military. Cutting the DOE down to 0 would cut ~10% off the deficit. You could eliminate a solid majority of federal government departments and still not arrive at a budget surplus. Most of them are tiny relative to the size of the deficit.

Yeah, man social security is such a screwed up situation. Really unfortunate for all around.

TBH I think creating social security may have been the #1 political blunder of the last century. Just an incredibly awful decision. I can understand where it was coming from but oof... it has crippled us economically.

I agree. I mean personally I'd hate to see it anyway because I think Musk's other companies are extremely important and someone else hopefully could cut the budget. We'll see.

I listened to it and didn't really notice. He came off as more casual but I wouldn't say he was slurring.

During the conversation on X between Musk and Trump, they floated the idea of Musk leading a 'government cutting commission' or basically a setup where Musk would come in and cut the fat from the government.

This idea fascinates me, and while I'm sure there are all sorts of reasons it may be terrible, I fear that financially the U.S. may need to do something dramatic like this in order to get the debt under control, etc etc. Also I, along with many other mottizens, am just pretty bearish on the efficacy of most government. Especially federal officials.

The question for me is - how would this work? Which areas do you think would get cut the most? (education was mentioned here specifically) Which areas are critical and should remain mostly untouched? (post office?)

On top of that, if this were to happen, what would be the primary blockers? Do you think Elon is the right man for the job without political connections? Are there ways in which the President can be prevented from firing large swathes of the federal admin? Potential disasters that could happen if critical employees are in fact fired?

Just restarting Jung's Modern Man in Search of a Soul. It's good.

No no I'm worried about purity and such. I've read a lot of supplement companies are terrible with quality.

where do you order vitamin D supplements from?

I meant like company to order online from, jeez.

Lots of companies in the supplement industry have vastly different quality.

hah I meant supplements rip

Which place in the US has the highest quality vitamin D?

I think virtue is a balance of the two, or at least a balance is necessary to become virtuous. Therefore if someone is more right-brained in a left-brained society, they are likely closer to virtue.

That being said just being right-brained on it's own isn't virtuous.

In terms of historical human life, we are skewed far towards rationality. We aren't, in fact, entirely left-brained because as you point out, we tend to make decisions in a right-brained way anyway. Ian McGilchrist's book The Master and His Emissary talks about this, but basically the right brain is the more emotional center, and emotions tend to control our decision making no matter how rational we think we're being.

But when you try to force everything into a rational lens, you end up with a lot of problems.

Okay this is totally fair. Bog standard was a bit too much.

But this strain of eugenics type thinking has been around in intellectual circles for a few hundred years. Intellectual weren't always in charge of the elite class though, you're right.

I'm surprised by how many people assume you're posting in bad faith. Maybe it's because we've talked one on one, but I'm pretty convinced these are your real opinions.

Also, just for some context, these opinions are pretty bog standard for the vast majority of elites in the West over the last few hundred years. So it's not like they're crazy beyond the pale. Although I'll admit they're stated provacatively.

All that being said, I strongly disagree. My main disagreement stems from the way modern society is set up. When you create a distinction like 'elite' versus 'stupid peasant' there's an inherent assumption that the way we currently order society and assign social status is somehow correct or right. I strongly disagree with that assumption.

Our modern world order vastly overweighs 'rational,' left-brained, rules-following, logical types of intelligence. While at the same time totally disregarding and not rewarding intuition, vibes-fluency, social skills, grasping of the gestalt, right-brained thinking, religious thinking, et cetera. This situation is extremely problematic.

As others have said, if we had a society that promoted a more balanced, virtuous person to elite status, that would be cool and elitism would be more justifiable.

And while yes left-brained type thinking leads to extreme power over the natural world, it's all useless as hell if we can't actually get along with each other, or live happy productive lives. And right now most can't. I think that the vast majority of 'peasants' actually are much more in tune with their intuition than the majority of elites. They have to be because they don't have the intelligence to rely on. And the vibes are shit right now, my dude. Mainly because those in power don't care about the vibes at all and think they're pointless BS.

Anyway, while I can sympathize with your point a bit, I think you're missing a big part of the picture.

You don't think he genuinely means this?

I remember watching this like 10 years ago and it blackpilled me hard. It's fascinating how far I've come since then hah.