@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Not sure about people having no power, but I'm with you in that it's very frustrating how willing people are to just forgive the massive, society shattering mistakes made during 2020 and the next couple of years.

We are only just beginning to see the negative effects play out, personally I think the fallout from kids losing socialization during developmental years will be massive.

Yeah once you realize how much volcanoes, earthquakes and other natural disasters fuck up the world, you realize maybe religions have something to their constant calling of the impending apocalypse.

How do you find trustworthy contractors?

My gut says this last, best hope for peace will probably fail anyway

Where's a Babylon station when you need one?

Dude moral high ground cake tastes better than you can even imagine. Have you tried it?

This is why people don’t like game theory and people who use it to justify asshole behavior. You can apply your fancy math stuff all you like, I’ll still think you’re a dick.

As others have said, I feel stimulants take away some of my creativity or presence or ability to connect with the world and people around me in a genuine way.

They do make you better at very rational, ordered thinking and clearly outlined tasks. But you lose out on some ineffable characteristics. I worry that if I was on adderall all the time I might, for instance, keep grinding in a career that’s wrong for me rather than taking a step back and finding a line of work that suits me better.

In other words I think stimulants can lock your mindset into short term repetitive gains as opposed to better longer term gains.

Oh man, I can’t even read all this because it’s so close to my own previous issues. I found a way out by listening to my heart or body or soul or whatever you want to call it instead of my head. Over rationalizing will get you nowhere.

Why do pragmatic arguments make you uncomfortable?

Interesting! I'd love to read more about it if you recall where you found that.

I have also read occasional accounts similar to that idea in reaction to the original PR firms from Edward Bernays. Honestly if I could choose one figure to erase from history, he is high on the list. That sort of instrumentalist thinking about how to turn propaganda into a fundamental part of a market economy is truly evil.

Let our mouths be filled with Your praise, O Lord, that we may sing of Your glory.

This is my favorite part of the liturgy. I think it also exemplifies what you're trying to say!

Thanks for this post! It's excellent.

There's another kind of reason to want to be rational. Maybe you have a skeptical temperament, and have an internal demand for a certain sort of rigor. Or maybe you have developed a kind of self-identification as a Rational Person, which has attached itself to a certain set of assumptions and ways of thinking. Or maybe you like to think of yourself as Intelligent and Rational, and there's this bunch of intelligent people you know, and they all say that thinking in a certain way, and believing in a certain set of axioms, is a prerequisite to being Intelligent and Rational, and theism and rituals and faith and religion is just Dumb Stuff for Irrational People and you don't want to be Dumb and Irrational, right?

(It should go without saying that this is a general You, not about TheDag in particular, but here I am saying it anyway.)

Hah well I can say that for most of my life I have absolutely been a caricature of the type of thinking laid out here.

This perspective really opened my eyes in terms of what I have been missing from the Christian ethos:

A lot of people have this unspoken idea that Christian ontology is essentially the same as materialist ontology, except that there is are extra entities which maybe don't follow the laws of physics, and one of them is "omnipotent" (whatever that means, maybe power level = infinity or something), and we call that one "God".

This is not the Christian ontology.

The actual Christian ontology is something more like this: The fundamental nature of reality does not look like atoms and the void, governed by laws of physics. Rather, the fundamental nature of reality is something which is in most respects unimaginable, but in which what we call personhood and will and morality and love and reason are fundamental attributes. This is God -- not another entity like a star or a chair or a cat or a human, only immaterial and superpowered, but rather, the Person at the heart of all reality, in virtue of which everything that exists (including, of course, the entire material universe and all its physical laws), exists.

Yeah he was a beautiful man. That's such an epic plot point. I should reread the book.

No. It's not better. Ads are one of the largest evils we endure in our society. Mass psychological warfare leading to a destruction of attention, virtue, and restraint for the chase of short term profits by a class that's already wealthy. I say we ban all but text advertising, and keep it black and white.

Interesting! I might give this a go later on once I've got the basics down heh. Thank you.

Beautifully said. That's the type of worldview I am moving towards.

Finally, plenty of prominent rationalists have beliefs that seem just as strange and unfalsifiable as my own religious beliefs; some believe that we're living in a simulation, some believe in panpsychism, some believe we inhabit a multiverse where every possible reality exists at once, etc. I don't see why Christianity is any less compatible with rationalism than these other weird ideas.

Yeah, I feel this keenly! It sometimes seems like more of a fashion thing amongst intellectual circles. Christianity is coded as old and dowdy and uncool. You can have just as crazy beliefs but they're new so people take them more seriously.

I'd love to hear your further thoughts sometime if you feel inclined to write them down.

Thank you for this! He sounds great.

Yeah but searching on YOUTUBE just gets you so much shit nowadays.

I will second that, his lectures as well as Jordan Peterson's actually helped lead me back to the Church.

I love it! I second @KingOfTheBailey. I would love to see more discussion of this type on the Motte. I think @coffee_enjoyer would be interested too.

ETA wait maybe it's a different coffee name. Idk.

What if I think, like Carl Jung and many other mystics, that true spiritual wisdom has to contain paradox?

Interesting. The serious religious intellectuals tend to argue that you can't have any sort of epistemic hygiene without a 'first mover' - or in other words that the modern scientific worldview is based on a contradiction given that the a priori assumption is that no belief is ultimately true, which is in itself an ultimate belief.

Anyway I get a bit confused by these super high order epistemological arguments, but that's the steelmanned version of the other side's argument as far as I can tell.

ETA: I guess this is what rehashing the internet atheist wars from the other side feels like... good lord.

What's the difference?

Thanks, but this guy is way more intense than I'm looking for. I'm hoping to camp for a couple days outside of a campsite and looking for advice.

Reading 12 Rules for Life by Peterson. It's actually quite good.