TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
It's a secret held onto by my clan for generations, I'll share it with you for some Essence of Draconic Might. Or some cocaine.
You just reject it because it's too despairing
Saying that your argument is good because of my emotions is bad form, and rude besides. I'm perfectly aware you think the left is impossible to beat, I simply disagree. Every regime and ideology fails over a long enough time horizon, whether now or in centuries. Besides the modern left is a new beast in many ways, and vulnerable near it's birth given that the values are still necessarily messy.
Dude, that granny's arm in the first pic is SWOLE. Damn granny.
Hah well I appreciate your forbearance.
Don't worry about your chakras man, you just gotta believe in rights. Everyone knows the path of Human Rights will give you a far stronger foundation and easier cycling than the path of Yoga. Duh!
I hereby declare that it's a Human Right to be free from the tyranny of gravity, if not Israeli occupation. Look, I don't float, at least not without a rocket.
You sure? I just tried it and cracked levitating. Maybe you aren't believing strongly enough.
Jokes aside, I think 'objective' morality is an incoherent concept, because objectivity is an incoherent concept! Jordan Peterson has some great discussions on how everything bottoms out to morality - basically related to relevance realization a la John Vervaeke and how there are so many facts out there (like impossible numbers) that you have to have some a priori framework to get them down to a manageable size to make decisions on.
There's also Hume's is-ought gap, if you're looking for the steelmanned version of what I think @drmanhattan16 is trying to argue.
Hah, thanks for this little aside about @The_Nybbler. You've redeemed him a bit in my eyes. :)
Absolutely agree about Peterson. He's at his best when talking about Jungian stories and archetypes, and getting into the idea of perception needing a structure of value that is outside narrow scientific and 'rational' frameworks.
I've learned the basics of encaustic (the medium used for the Christ Pantocrator of Sinai icon),
That icon is beautiful, and thanks for calling out the method. My girlfriend really likes to sew and knit, do you know any icons or methods that are made in those ways?
I can agree with this take, at least anecdotally. It increasingly seems like the economy is only perceived as good because of number shuffling by fancy finance grads with creative statistics. Whereas the reality on the ground for poor folks is getting worse and worse in actuality.
It would track with the increasing amount of rage coming from the right as well, which I think is generally made up of poorer people than the left.
They're good at disseminating ideas into the population, but not into the halls of power.
I agree with this observation, but do you have any idea why this state of affairs came to be?
I'd idly hypothesize it's something about cities attracting more liberals, and conservatives generally being poorer over the last few decades while much of this 'high art' is expensive. That and the fact that high art has become increasingly decoupled from religion.
I'm curious to hear your thoughts though?
Lmao, why not both?! And hey, you can't rise from the dead and not expect to gather disciples. Come on now, you really should know better. ;P
I have a theory that the REAL reason for perpetual rabid copyright expansion (of which Canada is the latest victim) is because the Cathedral doesn't want new woke media to have competition from older works.
Eh, I'd argue it's more because creating new media better suits the capitalistic endless growth model. The more new things you have, the more products and markets you can sell, the bigger you can make numbers. That makes the alien god we have summoned and call 'market capitalism' happy with us.
I've genuinely come to believe that our society emphasizes 'reason' and 'science' or rational ways of understanding the world far too much. While it's not well articulated, I'd argue people on the right inherently value things like intuition and emotion more, they just don't have the words to explain it because, well, that's kind of the point.
To me the idea of Growth as something that can be judged by us is taken on faith as well. It's hard to articulate what I'm getting at, I'll come back to you once I've refined my understanding better.
In the meantime if we do achieve foom and you merge with the machines, I hope I've built up enough goodwill that you will take me in as the human serf to your machine feudal lord. And maybe some of my loved ones too ;)
Might make an interesting sci-fi premise, at least.
Fundamentally, conservatism and reaction are not really very appealing to intellectual and creative types. People with an inclination towards thinking, ideals, criticism, reform, improvement, progress, solving Big Problems will naturally gravitate towards a movement that embraces those things.
This didn't seem to be true until the modern era. I don't think it's a fundamental human trait, more that the fact that our modern mythos is one of Science and Progress, and so our stories and myths (i.e. media) attract that type of person. Stories that contradict the holy march of Progress are not as popular or accepted.
It's come up before here that the Right often struggles to articulate a positive vision for the future. This is, of course, true. Conservatives are not visionaries or imagineers, their goals are articulated in terms of things that actually exist and are possible. Maybe recreating the social and economic conditions of the 50s or 00s wouldn't be ideal, but at least it's something that was actually done before and could actually exist again. And to many conservatives, the lack of Big Crazy Radical ideas is precisely the appeal of the movement, though they might not phrase things in those terms.
I think conservatives do have a vision of the 'future', but we've come to conflate the idea of 'future' with increased technological progress. Without more and better tech, there can be no future. It's baked into the core memeplex of modernity.
Agreed! If you look at the religious side of things, Jews are the original People of the Book. They should be respected for that fact alone.
The Jewish religious tradition that birthed the Old Testament of the Bible acts as the fundamental moral, spiritual, and societal framework for the entire Western order. And frankly at this point much of the world. Their contributions made whiteness as a thing even possible, in that their religion birthed the religion that made whiteness such a force to be reckoned with.
I'm not a white identitarian, but I'm baffled as to why so many of your fellow travelers can't take the longer view on Jews and Judaism. Thanks for the reasonable take.
Yeah, the total erosion of any sort of privacy is one of the hardest blackpills to swallow for me when it comes to new AI.
We gain unimaginable wealth if successful, but we will lose so much in the bargain.
I'll jump in on the side of your interlocutor and just say that while I have massive respect for your hardline consquentialist views (you really play it to the hilt!) I tend to agree that morality has to come first.
Would you not agree that as a technocratic consequentialist, you take on faith things like Scientific Objectivity and Technological Progress as goods? Or of course 'Utility,' although it's such a vaguely defined catchall I'd rather use something like 'virtue.'
Truly he has obtained great powers since rising. I eagerly anticipate the next gospel.
Where can you easily find/access this older media? I'd imagine the majority of the reason people don't consume it is because it's much harder to seek out. Max has been pruning their selection of old movies, even. And they're seemingly the only streaming service that cares to have a lot of classics.
There seems to be an idea around many open discussions forums that the left has captured many cultural institutions. This perception seems so persuasive because certain leftist thinkers coined the idea.
While it’s undoubtedly true that many major institutions lean left, it’s also a convenient dodge from the right wing or conservative side in the culture war allowing them to avoid self criticism. In fact it seems that almost any time folks question why right wing values are not more represented in popular culture, the knee-jerk response by conservatives is that the left has captured institutions, so there’s no hope. When the reasonable point is asked as to why this state of affairs can’t be broken by right wing institutions or a similar capture by the right wing, I haven’t seen a good answer.
How has this state of affairs come to be the default? Why did the right lose institutions, and why is there so little discussion about how they can realistically take them back?
Smart phones are super stimuli that destroy physical, real time human connection. Which has been shown time and time again to be one of the most important predictors of human health and happiness.
It depends on whether you value inherent human dignity more versus human work and discipline.
The socialists have a strong point. I doubt they’d be so popular otherwise.
The Randian argument is hogwash to me. Objectivism and objectivity as a whole are flawed viewpoints. Religious systems are the only way we can make sense of the complexity of society. I’m simply arguing that the modern world has drastically decoupled wealth, power and status from actual virtue.

Just imagine Gandalf the White.
More options
Context Copy link