TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
Depends drastically on your mindset. If you're already in an incredibly negative space and feel stuck with no way out, psychedelics can be the best thing that has ever happened to you. That's my own experience, and the experience of many friends who've also dabbled.
Yep, this is the answer. It's not that individual people are cynically trying to better themselves, although I'm sure there's a small group of those in the non-profit space. Having read a lot about this and talked about it quite a bit in EA circles, the problem is that these non-profits tend to select for people who are passionate and socially skilled.
Honestly in the NGO space, social skills and ability to be pleasant to talk to are the #1 selector, far more than most people think. This means that non-profits by their nature raise people who are socially skilled and passionate to the top, and it's quite rare to find people with actual talent in that position. Usually because talented people will sort into other fields where they can make more money or have more of an impact.
For those of you who have experimented with mescaline or whatever else, have these experiences changed you deeply and permanently? Would even taking small amounts grant you clarity or creativity without some terrible drawbacks?
Yes and yes. I'd recommend reading How to Change your Mind to get a better idea of the history and how these substances operate.
I would echo Jung's warning, and make sure you go into the psychedelic experience with the right mindset. You can absolutely 'see God' or 'experience the divine' while on these substances, but the conclusions you make about your experience are often wrong, and less important than the experience itself.
A good frame to think about psychedelics is that they increase the randomness or chaos of your mental states. This can be excellent if you are 'stuck' in a mindset that you do not like, such as depression or anxiety, and desperately need a new perspective. The most positive thing about the experience lies in the fact that these drugs can show you what it feels like to see the world in a new way.
For instance, if you've always been depressed, you can get a brief glimpse of what it's like to see the world without the grey cloud hanging over you. It won't fix your depression automatically, but it can give you hope and motivation to change your own mental state, and periodically help you course correct.
Roman concrete? Although I think we recently cracked that one.
Greek fire?
Argues that there are things the ancients can do we still can’t reproduce today? Asks if any modern writers are as good as former ones? Etc
@HelmedHorror @curious_straight_ca @FCfromSSC @fmaa @sun
This article does a great job of making the point that the past is important.:
If there are axioms in Silicon Valley, at the top of the list must surely be the belief that we’re making onward and upward progress. Spend any time in a non-catatonic state in any cafe or popular hangout on University Ave in Palo Alto, or in Sunnyvale, Menlo Park, or Mountain View, and you’ll quickly realize you’re in a culture that’s entirely focused on the future, and thinks technology, or “technoscience” is what counts, and not much else. (Full disclosure: I was an entrepreneur in Palo Alto, and to be fair, obsessing about the future is what entrepreneurs do. But this is not what I mean here.) The mindset is ubiquitous. Even advocates of what I’ve called “Fearesome AI” (as opposed to “Dreamy AI”), who worry about the existential risks of AI run amok, are really just the flip side of the exponential progress coin. They’ve bought into the myth of exponential progress, too. Techno-futurists and increasingly a confused media and public simply take for granted that we’re on a rocketship to technological wonders, which somehow also equates to a theory of history and human progress writ large.
One terrible consequence of this pervasive thinking (besides being totally wrong, as I’ll explain) is the short shrifting of all things historical. As Renaissance thinkers like Petrarch well knew, the past is a treasure trove of not just human folly but human greatness. Chronicalled in the past are civilizations surviving and thriving for millenia, and artistic and engineering feats that in some cases remain unrivaled today. So, why are we so cocksure about 21st century progress? Can anyone today write like James Joyce or Leo Tolstoy, or Virginia Wolf? Who rivals Leonardo Da Vinci in their understanding of figure and form? Where are the orators like Cicero? The essayists and humanists like Montaigne? The philosophers like Plato, or Aristotle, or Lucretius or Epicurus? Or, for that matter, Alan Turing and John Von Neumann? We have our own talents, to be sure, but this doesn’t cancel the great talents of the past, or somehow render them obsolete and otiose. Yes, we do build on the past. But we also learn from it.
Alas, the ahistorical bubble we’re currently living in not only doesn’t look back but seemingly can’t look back, as if it would stall progress and mire us in bigotry and irrelevance rather than provide insight, knowledge and wisdom. It’s a profoundly simplistic and troubling view. We are not just building “on top of” the past like legos, we must continuously return to it to get our own bearings. There’s a cyclical nature to progress. In this spirit, I’ll be developing the theme of “the return,” or as the Italian Renaissance thinker Giambattista Vico called it, the ricorso. (My next book is titled The Return: Why the 21st Century Looks Like the Past (so far), Not the Future We Wanted. More on this in future posts.)
Wow, here's my daily redpill. You're saying all those cop shows don't accurately predict the process of law enforcement? :'(
That’s a fair point, I am stretching into middle age at this point so it probably has something to do with the effects. Aging really is a bitch, isn’t it?
I am aware of no progress in human thought since the invention of writing. It does not seem plausible to me that such progress exists, or even that "progress" in this sense is conceptually coherent.
I think that assertions to the contrary are artifacts of deeply irrational social consensus, and dissolve if subjected to even a cursory examination.
Please write a book. I'm begging you.
In the same way, the fact that we can treat some forms of madness does not change the nature of madness itself.
Hell I'd argue they were better at treating madness back then. Seeing it as a demon and casting it out probably works better than the bullshit psychiatrists get up to.
God damnit man, you are SO BASED! Can you write a book on this topic please? I would read every word.
Damn, sorry you had to deal with the bar shit. I’ve never liked drinking at bars myself.
I’m curious though, did you like eavesdrop and hear them talking shit or catch it through the grapevine? (An incredibly apropos saying for this situation)
Now in the workplace I do the same with my coworkers, "oh, this deal won't happen if I fuck this up", "what am I going to say to client if they call and ask where this is", "how upset is the MD going to look if I fail to complete this by tomorrow morning". In many cases they wouldn't even care that much, but I need to weave these narratives to be productive, essentially tricking myself into thinking my situation is a lot more desperate than it is.
Wow it's interesting to read such a similar internal monologue to my own. I've consistently spent my young adult/adult life basically internally shaming myself into working.
Luckily I'm slowly managing to get a healthier relationship to my emotions, but it's a hell of a process to go through. Seems like you're okay with it though I guess, so that's good?
Truth be told, the idea of heading for the UK alone scares the shit out of me, I'm scared I don't have my act together to the extent required to subsist as a lone adult without anyone to fallback on. Guess I'll have to bite that bullet at some point, I'm not getting any younger.
Wait you're going to the UK alone? Since when?
Aww yeah. Will do this and post results in a bit. Also 2nd percentile on conscientiousness? That can't be right for someone like you who has literally written an entire novel.
Extroversion: 92
Emotional Stability: 13
Agreeableness: 71
Conscientiousness: 72
Intellect/Imagination: 96
Guess I'm just super smart and perfectly well rounded! Except for the emotional stability...
So just a quick note - I quit drinking alcohol daily, and my life has improved drastically. I would never have called myself an alcoholic, but I did like to have a few beers and/or a glass or two of whisky after the work day.
I quit drinking daily mostly on a lark, and partly because I was trying to cut back on expenses. I'm shocked at how many benefits I've seen.
It's far easier to write. Focusing in general comes to me much more easily, even things like focusing at work which I found difficult.
I've lost about 10 pounds and gotten to my goal weight without any outside effort (in fact I feel like I eat more to compensate for not drinking) but still.
On top of that, I'm much better able to regulate and feel my emotions. Despite not getting drunk very often, alcohol apparently still had a large numbing effect on me.
For any other casual drinkers who are thinking of stopping, I'd recommend it. I still plan to drink here and there with friends or at social events, but I had no idea how much of a negative impact my couple drinks a day was having on my life.
in part because I have issues with my ears that make very fast descents harder
Is the issue about the pressure buildup in your ears? That's what I was talking about with interoception. It's a skill that can be learned!
A lot of what our medical society claims is immutable, like overbites or herniated spines or whatever, can be changed with focus and attention to inner muscles.
I don't dive but I have snorkeled. Seems fun.
I've been interested in free diving, less as a way to enjoy leisure and more as a way to hone my interoceptive ability.
Treat this fully as a hypothetical, but what if the next time BurdensomeCount got banned, you also received a one day ban? Would it still be worth it to keep them around?
I would be totally fine with this. Heck, even a one-week ban I'd be okay with. Part of that though is my personal feeling that I spend a bit too much time here, and could stand to bow out a bit more so take it with a grain of salt.
With regards to Count, not sure how to articulate my feelings but I much prefer his sort of snobby disdain to other posters here who I won't name. I don't see the mod queue and I get that if someone is a repeat offender it's problematic, but I am far, far more concerned by all the people here who regularly call for violence and talk about how violence is the only true right man has and how the only method for change is to purge your enemies with a sword. That's the most concerning rhetoric to me, even if they say it nicely.
I know this goes against the whole ethos of the Motte in that you can say anything as long as you say it the right way and play nice, so perhaps I'm biased and don't necessarily agree with the rules 100%. I'm glad I'm not a mod - I doubt I could be impartial enough.
Anyway, not sure if this adds much to the discussion and I generally support the mods so if you think he deserves a permaban, I won't go on an anti-mod crusade. Just figured I would weigh in.
I will also come down asking for a temp ban - Count often toes the line but I think he adds a quite unique perspective here. I would hate to see him perma-banned.
I had basically no limitations. I had access to the internet, and my parents mostly had no idea what I could get to on there. I don't think I would have appreciated any kinds of limitations.
Yep I grew up with the same 'parenting' approach. I regret it every day, and truly wish I had more discipline and was forced to do something other than spend 12-14 hours a day gaming during my youth. It has caused me no end of problems and issues to work around.
I'm glad a lack of limitations worked for you - I'd argue that it's a total abdication of parental responsibility, and while every now and then we get a gem like you cjet, the majority of kids that grow up with no guidance or limitations have an extremely difficult road to climb to become mature adults. @guesswho, I would caution you that it is possible to live in a sick culture. If a culture will teach your child to be weak, to never develop, to stew in anger and blame others constantly for their problems, it is absolutely better in every conceivable way to shield them and instill good values in them.
Hah don't worry I have a 60 inch TV that and controllers etc. I can't go back to gaming on a tiny desk monitor anymore I'm too spoiled.
Interesting. If I go to a microcenter will they take my old PC and put new parts in? I thought they only built new PCs for ya.
Edit: Don't have a microcenter near me anyway. RIP.
IMO, see if you can afford the step up to the latest Ryzen 5 series processors or a current gen gpu. I'd wait for the RX midrangers like the 7700 XT myself, they just launched and seem like decent value.
I mean I definitely can afford it, I'm just generally allergic to spending more money than I have to on stuff like this. It's a fun purchase for me basically.
I suppose it's an investment in the future, but it's like hmm do I really want to spend an extra $300 or so just to get some slightly fancier hardware?
There's also the sunk cost of if the rig breaks before the end of it's usefulness, which IME is likely, it ceases to be a good investment to get better hardware. (Well not actually with modular parts but I'm lazy and hate to fix things)

It's interesting calling it a placebo. To my mind it's less a placebo, and more proof that personal transformation can happen, and is directly experiencable/achievable. In this day and age of 'nobody ever changes' that can be invaluable.
How real is 'deep love for years'? We have such a poor understanding of love, our culture barely even discusses it outside of a purely facile sense. The ancients believed that in the right circumstances you could fall in love with someone on the spot - but only a certain type of love.
The notion of love is far more complicated and multifaceted than we give it credit for. Is the type of love engendered by MDMA the exact same as the type of love between an old married couple? Probably not.
That being said, is it still a valid and meaningful type of love? Absolutely.
More importantly - can it lead to a deeper love for the other person, or even yourself? It's hard to say but results seem promising.
Even if you think it's all bullshit, is there not some deep value in experiencing these powerful and beautiful states? What if someone has never felt it before, don't they deserve it?
More options
Context Copy link