@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

What makes you say that? Haven't actually seen sources for that.

Can you summarize the article? I started to read it but it was quite dry and I lost interest hah.

My cocktail party idea recently has be introducing (or re-introducing) slight psychedelic substances to the Christian Eucharist, or other similar religious traditions. Not enough for a full blown trip, just microdosing to get a little bit of enhanced sensation. There's even some slight evidence that this was done historically.

I'd also like to add WAY more holidays, and make them longer. There should be at least four week-long feast holidays, in my opinion. The ancient world had a lot more brutal material things to deal with than we do, but their social fabric was way richer and more fun. I mean come on, for the Romans they had holidays where priests would whip naked women running through the streets, there would be public drunkenness and masks, servants would order around masters, et cetera. I have no idea why we got rid of awesome holidays (even the Christians used to have a ton, see Orthodox Christianity) but it was a huge fucking mistake! Bring back the celebrations!!!

Another one would be to force psychologists, before getting their degree, to drop a huge dose of acid and go through some ritual basically. Maybe anthropology would make more sense here. But damn our modern rituals are so defanged and boring they might as well be skipped. Most people are bored at graduation, and just go for their parents. That's so sad! These rites of passage used to be the highlight and pride of people's entire life!

So what, specifically, is it that’s been lost? You don’t seem able to actually describe the option that young men today don’t have that they once did.

What has been lost is the true belief in God that compelled people to have hope that such a drastic move could lead to a better life. Remember that the majority of the settlers were Christians who were so devout they were willing to cross an ocean and take incredible risks, leaving behind everything they've ever known to go to a new land. There's a reason those people were selected.

There are parts of the Bible that echo the same ideas. I don’t see it as complicated to adapt, nor does the core idea need that much updating.

I think the problem is that we don't have as much real suffering as we did in the past. It's hard to get people to follow Stoic teachings etc when their lives are relatively cushy.

My only standard is whether its true, and the believers haven't brought me around nor are they likely to until we make gods ourselves

No worries! I don't want to stop ya in any way of your transhumanist dreams to be clear. Heck, I may still even join you. The jury is out.

I just want to convince you and your fellow machine gods to spare the poor humans who want to stick to their physical bodies and worship some sort of God.

Incredibly well articulated. I agree with pretty much everything here, although I do hold some reservations about:

But (I think) no Gods exist or have ever existed,

Nor sure how to articulate a rebuttal myself, but personal experience has convinced me to seriously question this denial. Guess that's faith.

Perhaps when I say we don't need a new prophet, a clearer distillation of my point is that we have a lot of work to do preparing our society we recognizing and accepting a new prophets message. As we are now I fear scientific rationalism is too powerful to defeat unless we chip away at it's grip on the world.

You do a neuron-by-neuron gradual, conscious replacement of everything in your brain

That's the point of this caveat. IMO it's still a huge gamble, but as @self_made_human discussed above, if there's even a chance it works it seems like a good gamble to make. I'm conflicted about the spiritual repercussions though.

The young man doesn’t leave because, by being born an American, he has already won the lottery of life.

God bless America. Sometimes I forget how damn lucky I am. Thanks for reminding me.

To put it bluntly, I think "true transcendence through a more spiritual realm" is nonsense, or at least cope, and what's worse, it's outdated cope, when we finally have the tools to do better.

I'm sad you think this way. Whether it's an artifact of the way human minds have evolved or whatever the case may be, there is definitely something there. We can argue about whether there's an actual big old God sitting outside of time somewhere, but mystical experiences and relationships with the divine are as real as it gets. These experiences of something greater than ourselves are really what binds all human civilization together. It's what lifted us out of the murk and gave us consciousness, as far as I can tell. That's something worth worshipping.

Of course in reality it’s all bullshit, space colonization is one of the greatest wastes of resources imaginable.

Man does not live on bread alone. Space colonization is and always has been about presenting a compelling vision of the future, stretching our capability, captivating our imagination and giving the human race hope. That's the best reason I can think of to do anything.

More to the point, we already have a beautiful planet with an atmosphere, water and abundant resources - shouldn't the utopian impulse make us redouble our efforts for poor old Earth, instead of giving the glad eye to some ugly red rock? Of course both are possible but you do have to wonder about distracting focus.

Part of what you seem to be missing, which is core to the transhumanist philosophy, is that most humans are dull, weak, and most of all stupid. The transhumanist vision sees Earth as a trap, because it's only a matter of time, from their perspective, before we all destroy ourselves. They may have a point, but that is the primary motivation to go to space. Even if it's often hidden behind other motivations in the public sphere.

Also, Im puzzled why people want more than the allotted 80 or so.

I've lost faith that longevity will meaningfully increase in our lifetimes, but fear of death is pretty rational imo. I'm always puzzled as to why people are afraid of eternity. I mean sure life is full of suffering, but if you can grow up a bit and handle the shit in your life, you'll see that you can outgrow what your younger self thought was possible. I want to keep growing as long as I can.

I just don't see the appeal to this idea, and the fetish around changing sex or being something other than what you are already. It seems like a dystopia to be so focused on the surface aspects of Self when we could imagine a world where your sex is less relevant.

A theory others have discussed here that I'm finding more and more credible is the idea that the trans-urge is less of a fetish, and more of a denial of self. It's a sort of attempt to destroy the current self and be reborn as something new, coming from a fundamental place of self-loathing.

I'm sure there's more to it than that, but I find that explanation much more compelling than the fetish side of things.

In the past, things like religion and stoic philosophy had a much better track record.

Agreed. While @Nantafiria makes a good point that things have changed and we may need different answers to give people spiritual and mental health, I don't think humans have really changed all that much.

Before the last century or so, we just took the religious traditions we had and interpreted them in a new way to accomodate new environments. If that didn't work, then a messiah would come along and bring in a new religion to help cope with the societal issues of the day.

Unfortunately, the discovery of Newtonian mechanics gave us far too much hubris. We, well really a small intellectual elite, decided that humanity had learned so much we were as Gods. We no longer needed the wisdom of these ancient traditions, we didn't need any tradition of wisdom whatsover; who needs wisdom when you have 'unfathomable' power?

And now us, the descendants of these fools, are trying to pick up the pieces. I hope we can weave back together some sort of wisdom-conferring tapestry from the broken pieces before we kill ourselves on the alter of Moloch. Only time will tell.

LMAO. Thanks for the correction. Will edit.

A psychologist himself, Adam Mastroianni proclaims: I'm sorry for psychology's loss, whatever it is.

I found this post on the slatestarcodex subreddit. The main article discusses how the replication crisis really isn't as bad as most people think, because:

Gino's work has been cited over 33,000 times, and Ariely's work has been cited over 66,000 times. They both got tenured professorships at elite universities. They wrote books, some of which became bestsellers. They gave big TED talks and lots of people watched them. By every conventional metric of success, these folks were killing it.

Now let's imagine every allegation of fraud is true, and everything Ariely and Gino ever did gets removed from the scientific record, It's a Wonderful Life-style. (We are, I can't stress this enough, imagining this. Buzz buzz, I’m bees.) What would change?

Not much.

Basically this idea can be boiled down to 'well most modern psychologists don't do anything that's even remotely important, so why do we care if these studies don't replicate?' I'm very wary of buying this type of argument. One reason is that over $2 billion dollars went into psychology research, in the US alone, way back in 2016. I'm sure it has increased since then.

On top of that, as psychologists themselves have acknowledged, many public policies get based on psychological research. In the light of the replication crisis, this is perhaps the largest and most under-discussed mistake of the 21st century. The majority of our politicians are basing their decisions, and public justifications, on a field of science that has been proven to be mostly fake. To me, that's not something we can just throw up our hands at and say is trivial.


Another interesting point, which I won't go too far into, is that many of the replicable studies in psychology are just completely ignored. Here's a highly-upvoted comment on the SSC subreddit:

Psychology has nothing interesting left because all of the rock-solid empirical results with tremendous real-world consequences were buried due to being politically awkward.

Psychometrics, heredity of various personality traits, innate gender differences, etc.

So you're naturally left with irrelevancies (monkey prostitutes) and lies (growth mindset, power posing, priming, multiple intelligences).

It's almost enough to make me empathize with Gino and Ariely. The modern discipline is all about garbing feel-good falsehoods with vestments of science. Their only crime was taking the more direct path to that end, rather than undertaking the standard rituals of plausibly innocent methodological infirmities (p-hacking etc.)

I'll leave it to the reader to decide whether or not Psychology deserves an equal place among the rest of the sciences.

Depends on the time frame. I'm talking in the next 200-500 years, not trying to give any serious prediction on the near term.

They don’t look physically fit or seem to care much about conventional appearance. I am judgmental about that sort of thing.

I signed and up am interested to try it this year, but god damn the pictures on this site give me the willies: https://nanowrimo.org/about-nano#ourstory

That's a fair point. I was a bit fired up when arguing with @zeke5123, I should probably tone it down a bit.

That being said, I'm more worried about the shift towards short form, mindless content than long form mindless content.

Thanks for replying! Didn't realize I was one of the most frequent commenters here, I should probably scale that back a bit.

Deranged”, “annoying,” “crazy,” “angry,” “hate[ful],” etc. are all too typical labels lobbied onto wrong-thinkers, as a shaming tactic and an attempt to poison the well

Totally fair point. I get personally annoyed by the argument you put forward because I fell fully into it for many years, and it ruined many of my closest relationships with people which I will never get back. It also turned me bitter and angry at the world for a long time.

At the same time, there was a lot of truth in it. I learned to be more confident and the importance of actually contributing to the world instead of complaining.

I suppose I am, to a similar degree to which I worsen the problem of relationships between job seekers and employers, investors and financial advisors, tax-payers and government, by providing advice—or recounting a summary of my personal experiences—on job-seeking, investing, and tax-minimization here, elsewhere on the interwebs, or in person. I've not promoted the Wonderfulness of employers, financial advisors, and governments.

I would (with some caveats) generally say the employers, financial advisors, and governments are made up of people who have good intentions. I think the tendency to act as if they've all defected and there isn't a single good employer our there is indeed 'toxic,' in that it's an unhealthy mindset which will only lead to more suffering. Same goes for women.

Yes, the mature response is to just be a Decent Person and a Real Man, continue to cooperate in the face of defection, and win hearts and minds by kindly walking women and their allies through issues as if you’re their “boys”, brothers, fathers, etc.

This is a caricature of my position, and I'm pretty damn far from any sort of actual 'enlightenment,' but you're not necessarily wrong. I'm generally a fan of more civil strategies. In terms of actually doing this it doesn't look like being what you would call a 'nice guy,' it instead looks more like being a stern father. The ability to be truly kind and help others requires a relationship with anger, which I find to be the central issue with redpill esque arguments.

I know I came across as a bit of a dick in my post, but I am genuinely sympathetic to your position. I believed in the same things you believed, once.

My point is that short form or long form can both be good or bad and choosing which one is dependent on what needs to be communicated.

My point is that I agree with you, but because long form writing is an endangered species I'm more than happy keeping it alive here.

Over the years I have grown a skill to find my own stopping points in web serials. Usually at a point where "too much is fucked" for the author to ever recover in a satisfying way, or "enough is wrapped up" that I can tolerate a few dangling storylines for the sake of a feeling of completeness. But this skill wasn't necessary for threadbare.

This is actually why I don't like webnovels for the most part, compared to more traditional fantasy series. While they are fun and well written a lot of the time, it irks me to no end when a story just kind of fizzles out because the author didn't know where to go with it.

Cool I'll check out practical guide to evil, it's finished! Woo

And if the red pill is a response to anything at all, it's a response to the fact that said anti-male cultural trends have been allowed to go on for so long without any significant correction. Even if their defection is anti-social, it's a reaction to incredibly dysfunctional social conditions that they did not create. You can't make situations that resemble a boot stamping on a human head forever and expect people to never chafe under it and never create their own compensatory rhetoric - this is just a classic example of "You reap what you sow".

Would I like to see better sexual relations? Yes. Do I think things are headed somewhere bad? Absolutely. But the redpillers did not start this, they don't have institutional power, and in accordance with this they are not the ones upon whom I place the obligation to change first.

Well hey man, I actually agree with many of your points here. I feel a lot of sympathy and pity for the anti-social men who turned into red-pillers.

But I think the mature response is to accept the truth, buck up, and work to change it. Change people's minds, especially women, not by hating them but by walking through the issues and appealing to their emotions like their boys brothers fathers etc.

Now is this path much more difficult than just posting angry screeds about sexism online? Absolutely. But it's more effective overall, and much less likely to lead to actual bloodshed or societal upheaval.

Gotta say, these comments are a beautiful breath of fresh air after all the complaining in the CW thread about bare links and such. I really appreciate these monthly write-ups, they help highlight very directly the excellent writing and discussion that still happens here, despite all the complaining and detractors.

Ut motte vivere in aeternum. Or something.

In terms of Gender War, it's hard to predict. The Progressive zeitgeist seems to be losing a bit of steam, but it has seemed like that before and it always plows forward relentlessly.

Frankly without a major disruption to the global tech economy, a major war or political backlash or something, I see us sliding pretty directly into Automated Gay Space Luxury Communism. Technology will get more and more apt at changing our bodies until we can change sex at will. No idea how we will handle families and reproduction, we may just make humans immortal and have reproduction be something we do for fun, or as we need to handle population levels.

The tension is caused due to the historical juggernaut of European Christianity discovering the unjust cries of the victim, and over the millenia slowly trying more and more to prevent harm and abuse in any and all ways. This historically unfolding process has been going on for far longer than most here think.

Ultimately we're going to have to learn to have a stable society without oppressing people, either that or have a nuclear war that sends us back to pre-Christianity, and hope that people don't come up with a similar philosophy. Personally I'd vastly prefer the former option, but sadly it seems many here see the way women act nowadays and just want to burn it all to the ground. I'm sure there are other options, but the binary is clear to me.