@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

The problem is that 'reason' does not provide any sort of moral imperatives on its own. The ultimate state of 'reason' is something like extreme libertarianism - treating every human like homo economicus. Unfortunately (or fortunately depending on your perspective) as we all know, humans are not like that. So you have a situation where reason tears down Chesterton's fence after fence, and ultimately starts to eat its own tail.

The only reason reason was able to go so far and become so successful at understanding the world was the high trust religious backdrop it developed in, Christianity. When you have reason on its own without a higher end than itself, bad things happen.

When I think about what this place was supposed to be, the phrase that most comes to mind is "Suppose They Gave a War and Nobody Came". It was this utopian vision of curating a rationalist garden of eden where nice people were nice to each other and came up with solutions to problems rationally, and promoted pro-social norms of continuing to be nice and solve problems rationally.

This is definitely not true, and if you had those inflated expectations then clearly you haven't been paying attention to the history of the Motte. This place has always been a haven for witches, and the mods and long term folks have been very clear eyed and open about that.

This has clearly failed, and the rules have become the boot on the neck of people trying to find actual workable solutions, because people have weaponized our empathy against finding solutions.

You're being extremely dramatic here. Sure the Motte could be bigger, have better discourse, etc etc. But you're still here aren't you? Where else on the internet can you have the same quality of conversations, be able to tell the truth without worrying about being banned immediately?

I'm sure there are other pockets of free speech and truth-seeking on the internet, but the Motte is still one, and an important one. What we're doing here is worth it, and again if you truly felt like this whole endeavor has failed then I don't think you would be here.

I absolutely agree. Postmodernism and the idea that there is no objective Truth is probably the most pernicious thing that has happened to our society. It's difficult to stop however, precisely because the postermodernists define the entire battlefield.

I think that something like Jordan Peterson's view is the right way to fight back, although I also believe we can build a lot further on his basic ideas. He claims that even if we can't tell there's objective good, most people aren't willing to bite the bullet and will call the Nazis, or Japan's rape of Nanking, or other horror stories objectively evil. From there, even if we can't necessarily agree on what's good, we at least have an idea of what not to do.

And if you take evil being a real force seriously, that means that every time you tell a lie, even to yourself, you contribute to the downfall of us all. You push us back towards the concentration camps, the torture, madness, and genocide. Truth is what keeps us from those things, and as you say charity cannot become an end in itself. Like rationality, it's an excellent tool but a malevolent master.

Somebody here recommended The Leftovers to me, a show on HBO Max. It's pretty incredible. Not sure why, but it's a very fascinating look into belief and miracles and how they interact with the modern world.

Having charity and kindness being rules here was a mistake.

Not sure what you mean by this. Charity and kindness in debate have been norms that have been useful for far longer than wokeism, even if wokeism is taking those rules to the extreme. Baby and the bathwater, and all that.

I think I can. I'd also ask like half of the people I play Blood on the Clocktower with regularly and they will probably agree and we will make it.

Are we playing with the same clocktower group? Good lord we would all kill each other day 1!

Who is the next big evil to be contained in your view?

Well yeah I think this is pretty obvious, at least at first. Someone still has to build those machines and send them out into space in the first place though. Or do you think that will be done by machines as well? (serious question)

Jungian Collective Unconsciousness strikes again.

No idea. Are any of them actually pro nuclear? That was the big thing for me.

Eh too lazy for that. Maybe like end of 26?

Why do you think so many of the recent aristocratic scions have been utter failures?

Oh shit, I would totally bet $100 that Starship reaches orbit by, say, 2028. Never done an online bet before but this is one I would take in a heartbeat.

Hah, agreed. When I heard him talk about energy independence I almost stood up and started clapping. He's got the techno-optimist rationalist policy slate down pat.

There's a reason he said "God exists" besides actually believing it, it's the idea he could have said without lying: "The Christian Church was foundational to modern civilization and remains the moral basis for all popular discussions of ethics, including those among individuals on the left whom espouse belief in obligate Christian treatment of others and not only sin but original sin and the perpetual atonement thereof. I forever reject their Godless branch of Christianity."

His religiosity would remain ambiguous, and were he an atheist it would mean he is not the sort of man to open a key political statement with a lie. "I'd totally vote for that [not-too-clever grifter]" isn't much for praise.

I'm confused here. Are you saying the second statement is what he actually believes and that "God Exists" is a way of representing it? Or that he would just say the second statement if he didn't actually believe God exists?

It'll be funny if he makes it, though. Imagine Vivek vs Kamala (as Biden declines further): total Brahmin victory. A tiny (there are, what, 2 million Tamil Brahmins?) subrace bred for verbally justifying their authority in a casteist society seize political power in an antiracist democratic society. What could be more surprising?

Oh man, this may be the most hilarious turn of events in history if it does happen. I love the narrative arc here, utterly ridiculous.

What would be even better is if he turns around after winning and goes full race-realism - says he won because he's genetically superior. It'll never happen, but man the irony there would be impossibly thick.

Really? I find him pretty charismatic. Maybe my grifter alarms are less fine tuned than others here.

That's a fair point, and I can see how the comparison might come off a little disingenuous. As you say though, we are still taxing the money from people. I know at least for many younger generations, the expectation that they will get any rewards personally out of social security is close to nil. I'm sure the vast majority don't even think about it though, and grumble about "taxes" in general.

So it shows that the tax burden can support a great amount. I'd love to replace social security with space flight, but that's definitely a pipe dream.

What other big ambitious projects would you want funded?

Well, the Baha'i faith is certainly interesting. Hadn't looked into that one before.

I actually think it could be quite well adapted for space exploration! Apparently divinity gives a series of revelations through prophets - why not have the next prophet tell us we need to go to space?

I'm actually surprised Baha'i hasn't caught on more, given that it seems like a much more coherent and serious distillation of the liberal perennailist Christian churches that I'm most familiar with.

Low Effort? Boo Outgroup? Antagonistic? Literally calling for violence and nothing else? Check check check check. Please don't do this, you write pretty good comments sometimes.

an oversimplification but this has culminated in the McMindfulness approach you see now.

Hah, I love this term! Definitely stealing it.

I absolutely agree with the Buddhism point, and it's something I want to do an effortpost on at some point.

The trouble is, traditions also lock in a bunch of stuff that genuinely does seem to be superfluous, and traditions also need to change.

I disagree with this. If you look at the Bible, for instance, every line has been pored over and it has been pruned over and over throughout the years. These texts also typically evolved in an oral setting, where multiple different versions were told and only the ones found the most impactful/useful were kept.

If you read something in a religious text and you don't understand it, odds are you're missing some context or you aren't thinking hard enough. I don't think almost anything in these texts is superfluous, it only seems that way because we moderns seem to think knowledge and wisdom can only be atomized, packaged rational 'facts,' and that fiction or stories can't carry genuinely important truth.

Ahh I see. Yeah I agree with that.

Realistically religious traditions essentially went through centuries and centuries of cultural evolution before they became as dense and full of wisdom as they are today. I'd be surprised if we can accomplish creating a new religion that has actual wisdom before we destroy ourselves with our hubris. Alas.

Can somebody write up a CW post about Jordan Peterson being required to take social media training by the Canadian Board of Psychology? Shit is wild https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/jordan-peterson-court-case-decision-1.6943845

Before then there was a LOT of infant and youth mortality, and I think that that changed things quite a bit. Germ theory was a game changer: African peasants have better health outcomes than Roman emperors and their children.

This seems to be saying that religion was basically just a way of giving people comfort and making people feel better because life sucked in the past. I strongly disagree with that framing, if that's what you mean.

Religion has always been about acquiring wisdom, understanding humans and our relationship to the world and each other.

Depends on your circles. The vast, vast majority of 'Christians' I have talked to, literally in the hundreds about this, do not believe Christ actually rose from the dead when pressed. These churches were generally more liberal/perenialist, but still.

You can call yourself a Christian until you're blue in the face, no matter what you believe. There are some weird sects out there. Unfortunately since the Protestant Reformation Christianity has been terrible at policing its weirder fringes.