TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
I add things to my bookmarks if I want to reference them later, or pop them in a draft writing doc in Obsidian.
Might want to look into IUDs, although I'm sure you probably have. My understanding is that they're even more effective than vasectomies.
But the "homeless problem" as most people understand it isn't about people couch-surfing or living in their cars or even illegal immigrants making camp near Home Depot; it's about the drug-addled street shitters who make life miserable for everyone else. And you can't fix that with homes; you can give those people homes and they'll wreck them in short order.
I see it as a nuanced problem with more than one solution. Ideally we strictly police the defectors ruining the commons, but at the same time we tackle the issue that is creating them in the first place.
Personally I'm for stricter policing of public spaces, crackdown on illegal opiate/meth dealing, and building more housing. Just because we do one doesn't mean we can't do the rest.
Thanks for your perspective, voted for AAQC.
This perspctive is what I agree often gets missed when we talk about homelessness. It's strange to me that even when a strong study is presented that says hey, maybe homelessness is about, you know, HOMES, so many people here immediately jump to drugs and shitting on the street.
The real problem is that housing, a basic human need (maybe right depending on your beliefs) is denied to many because they simply cannot afford it. And this isn't a complex problem like many try to make it out to be - as others have said, if we just stop artificially constraining the supply the market will help solve the problem. It won't fix it entirely of course, but not shooting ourselves in the foot repeatedly is a good start.
The modern west has rejected any sort of religious or moral system and replaced it wholesale with individualist, materialist nihilism. It shouldn't be a surprise that many people act this way.
So maybe WFH is not the silver bullet I thought it would be to raising a family and both parents maintaining a career.
WFH is indeed not the silver bullet, although it does help. What's more interesting to me about WFH is what it allows for in terms of new possibilities.
The only real way to make raising a family make sense economically, without massive economic surplus or redistribution, is to live very closely beside people you trust enough to take care of your kids, and vice versa. Due to the fracturing of cities and dense communities into suburbs, as well as the hypermobile youth culture in the U.S., many young parents lost this close and tight knit group of fellows.
However with WFH becoming more standardized, it is far more feasible than any time in the past to have groups of like minded adults move into a neighborhood together, and build some of these communities. It will be difficult perhaps to convince like minded adults without some sort of coordinating framework like religion, but it is certainly possible. If birth rates continue to crater I suspect this type of situation will be the only way that non-religious cultures will survive the next century or so.
the 1% having stolen all the economic growth of the last 40+ years for themselves
I think part of what @2rafa is getting at is that it's more complicated than this. Yes economic growth in real wages has stagnated, but things are even worse than that because while economic growth has stagnated, social ties have also fractured. This means that especially for those who want to raise a family, the economic picture is not the whole story.
There are plenty of articles and well-sourced studies complaining about the economic disparity, but the disparity in time and help when it comes to raising children and starting a family is much more hidden and illegible. It's important to call attention to this phenomena as well.
Quality contribution right here. Love it.
Sidenote, anyone know where you can stream this nowadays?
I mean name one
Jesus Christ. ;)
Perhaps if you take an extremely broad sense of 'judgment' sure. But I absolutely believe there have been many enlightened figures over human history that have been able to suspend the vast majority of judgment.
Communal responsibility and egregores absolutely exist, and are important to factor in. However if we want to tackle those problems, then yes we need moral people to band together and build systems together.
Another way to phrase what I'm getting at is that it seems to me we have a lack of capable, moral people, especially young men, who are able to band together and build these systems. Could be a coordination problem, or a supply problem.
Of course it's good to encourage being a good person, but if the system is set up to incentivize defection, the defectors will rise, even if they are a minority. There are game theoretically unstable situations that are not amenable to solving via scolding and calls to be better.
Who creates these systems that set up incentives? Beings from another plane? No, humans do. The point I'm trying to make is that at some level it all comes back to individual responsibility. We need strong, moral people in order to take power and build better systems, if that's what you see as important.
This sort of thing isn't inevitable, and it's frustrating as hell to always see everyone here arguing that it's basically done and dusted. That pessimism is another major reason things are in the shitter.
The only real way to do something like this in the modern world seems to be mandatory military service, or something like it. Otherwise our lives are just far too devoid of any real suffering, especially the physical kind.
I do think that the Overton window could shift back enough towards responsibility in our lifetime to make mandatory military service a possibility. The best shot we have at getting Westerners back to some semblance of maturity is in my view instituting a sort-of UBI, but requiring 2 years of mandatory military service to obtain it.
With this system, if you're a criminal and poor or something, well you can either go to prison or go to the military. Tough luck if you don't want to.
Of course within that service there would have to be competence tests, physical trials, etc. but there are decent templates like South Korea. A commenter on an open thread in ACX here recently mentioned that in South Korea the TV dramas tend to have quite a common theme of older folks putting youngin's back in their place. We need more of that energy as well - Rob Henderson does a great job here of explaining how utterly ridiculous and backwards it is that adults now seek the validation of children. Even and especially in universities, where professors really should know better.
But even if you can actually figure out what's happening, you are an individual, and the forces in operation are not individual forces.
Groups are made up of individuals. Being a morally upright individual is the key here. If you're a model for others, they may choose to follow in your footsteps.
Giving up the individual responsibility of being a good person is why we're in this mess in the first place.
So you think that there is no human ever that has actually stopped casting moral judgment?
Oh I totally misread the question OOPS!
Because democrats want to incentivize illegal immigration, for some reason.
The real answer is that immigration is one of the hottest CW issues and has been for decades, so nothing gets done and the byzantine system that grew out of bureaucracy is entrenched as hell.
Amen brother! I wish first world countries would just pull their heads out of the sand and start importing massive amounts of smart foreigners. The possibility won't be there forever, and the longer we wait the worse things get.
Hell we could even just make it easier to get smart white people in here. IQ over 105? You're in!
Strongly agree. Also in a counterpoint to @ymeskhout's recent cross-examination post, I think video or spoken content makes it much harder to catch errors. A lot of obfuscation can hide in tone, pitch, volume, rapidity of speech, etc.
This problem is even worse in longform video!
It should be noted that there is no reason that these fictions need to be theistic in nature, at least none that I see.
One reason is to motivate groups of people to live out their chosen meaning together. Which is much more powerful than choosing a particular one for your own, in my experience.
One of the rare times I agree wholeheartedly with you. Outside of Kuhn what are some other good writers in this vein?
Historically science flourishes best when you have motivated scientists that can devote multiple decades to learning everything about a problem.
Forget the name but there’s a book about one of the guys who ran Xerox PARC who talks about how this was his strategy. Just find scientists that seem brilliant and guarantee them 20 years to devote to a project, then sit back and let them do it.
The current scientific establishment is almost the opposite of this - in order to compete you have to publish quick and publish something important. And I don’t blame the scientists, most of them will lose their livelihood if they don’t get grants, and they typically don’t have skills to fall back on. Or much of a backup plan in general.
There’s the FODMAPs system I’ve heard works for other folks with acne.
You could also just try the whole 30 approach of only eating Whole Foods and slowly adding stuff in. Although it sounds like you tried that.
It could also be stress levels in your life, which is related to acne.
???? Give me this secret!!!
This is an interesting point, although I haven't seen too many people abroad living like kings on low salaries.
Another giant cost that you don't mention is cars and housing. Owning a vehicle is usually the second most expensive thing for a household in the U.S., after housing. Housing in the U.S. is artificially driven up in cost by all sorts of things.
Plus, people are just far less willing to live with roomates/family in the Western world if they have the means. I haven't seen stats but I wouldn't be surprised if the majority of folks in the developing world live with at least two other people.

The root cause is something close to personal responsibility and lack of religion, in my opinion. I hope to fix that too. But again, you're reducing me to one view.
We can do all of the things I mentioned above and also push for personal responsibility and the importance of religious belief.
What do you think the root cause is?
More options
Context Copy link