@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

My experience is that programming is like 98% fiddling with infrastructure stuff though…

Virology experts as a fourth estate? Or is that closer to fortieth?

It's more like Scientists as a fourth estate. Scientism has rushed in to fill the void of a lack of religion and faith, which is ironic because science is supposed to be above all that. Unfortunately once you turn science into an ideology/religion/cult whatever you want to call it, it loses the vast majority of its explanatory power.

Maybe we'll see a 'fundamentalist' turn in science, where scientists insist we have lost the true path and return to our roots.

Oh, absolutely. Speaking Truth to Power is no longer fashionable - it's illegal and demonized. As @official_techsupport mentioned elsewhere, the fashion is now to speak Power to Truth.

Status signaling is a sacred cow in rationalist spaces, and while important rationalists tend to way overblow how much you can boil down to signaling. Zvi himself admits this when condescendling talking about wanting the "MacGuffin":

But let’s not take that too far. That’s not all such things are about. Y still matters: you need a McGuffin. From that McGuffin can arise all these complex behaviors. If the McGuffin wasn’t important, the fighters would leave the arena and play their games somewhere else. To play these games, one must make a plausible case one cares about the McGuffin, and is helping with the McGuffin.

Otherwise, the other players of the broad game notice that you’re not doing that. Which means you’ve been caught cheating.

Robin’s standard reasoning is to say, suppose X was about Y. But if all we cared about was Y, we’d simply do Z, which is way better at Y. Since we don’t do Z, we must care about something else instead. But there’s no instead; there’s only in addition to.

A fine move in the broad game is to actually move towards accomplishing the McGuffin, or point out others not doing so. It’s far from the only fine move, but it’s usually enough to get some amount of McGuffin produced.

Ultimately status signaling doesn't work as a fundamental explainer, because some people really must want some things some of the time, or the whole thing is nonsense. This reduces the explanatory power of the framework by a massive amount.

I tried reading the Art of Raising a Puppy but it's less of an instruction manual and more of a preachy diatribe about how stupid and bad most dog owners are. Kind of frustrating.

It's like come on, most people are probably reading this book because they already know they have messed up and are looking for guidance. You don't have to rub it in guys. It's written by monks in New York so go figure I guess.

Yep I mean, this is weirdly the framework I took when I decided to look more into Christianity. Strangely somewhere along the way it worked and now I... actually do believe in God for the first time. It's quite confusing and I try not to spend too much time thinking about it.

How the heck do you people program all day without pulling your hair out? I've spent 5+ hours just trying to clone a jupyter lab notebook from GitHub and open it, and good lord even with GPT's help it's like pulling teeth.

If zero Covid is impossible, what are the implications for humanity if we truly do get a pandemic with a high mortality rate?

I think that a lot of pandemic preparedness scenarios are for that exact situation, so many of the existing plans were way over the top for something weak like Covid. That being said, even a totalitarian state's failure to prevent the spread despite massive measures is quite frightening.

Well said, it is truly outrageous how much was justified on such flimsy evidence and outright lies.

I am surprised that right wingers in Florida and Texas haven’t been grandstanding more about being right though.

I’d argue the dying out of Covid fanatics was a mix of quite a few factors:

  • As you discuss, Omnicron and general Covid dispersion
  • Social contagion effects, where being sensitive to Covid became a moral panic due to the easy signaling via mask (the signal lost its value as it became more common)
  • Left wing resentment over Trump’s tenure dying out after Biden won
  • Massive worldwide economic effects being felt after almost two full years of lockdowns
  • Ordinary ‘rank and file’ progressives no longer being able to stomach not seeing their family & friends two years running
  • General fatigue with imposed authoritarian demands like testing, restaurants closing etc (many people knew folks who lost their business due to lockdowns)
  • Lack of trust in the medical establishment as it became clear they lied and/or massively exaggerated the risks posed by Covid and the effectiveness of masking/vaccines

The list can go on, but there was far more depth to the situation since it affected almost the entire world, quite quickly, and let to massive changes.

I’d imagine the history books will have quite a lot to say about the reaction to Covid, and how it shaped trends moving forward through the 21st century.

What about life extension or ideological capture, or a thousand other things that could change? Birth rates aren’t everything, you cant just use them to predict the future so confidently, even if it fits your preferred narrative.

Why do you think this philosophy is so attractive to Christian westerners?

Is it a lack of responsibility for good deeds compared to Christianity?

Maybe a lack of understanding of the philosophy? Or just a rejection of Christianity and Hinduism is the easiest outlet?

If he had just added two sentences at the end about how white liberals tend to find Hinduism attractive for x and y reason it would be fine. He even mentioned that in the beginning.

The CW angle is clear in my mind, I think it just needs a tad extra exposition at the end. That being said it’s already far higher quality and more interesting than most of the other posts in the last month.

Oh, awkward.

I’ll accept it. This is the Motte after all ;)

Are you… sure you’re responding to the right comment? I don’t think you are understanding @2rafa’s point. If you truly want the “best and the brightest” then you can’t handwave away so much history of gentile whites.

As discussed in the comment you’re replying too, all the feminism and SJW identities etc that you’re so upset by were created by white people. This is a civil war within white culture, not a war of trad white men against all comers. Until that truth is acknowledged and dealt with skillfully truly smart and learned people will never join this movement.

I suppose from a certain historical distance it’s ironically funny…. But it’s distasteful to laugh at someone being brutally tortured in my experience. Most of us here are blessed to live in the developed western world where that’s not a realistic concern.

There’s usually one every week or two. Do you mean a top level thread?

I’m still working through Mere Christianity, not everything resonates with me but what does is quite powerful. Lewis is surprisingly relevant still today.

To say that Christianity says it's enough to adhere to the rituals and motions to be good is quite a stretch.

Yep I'm not claiming that Christianity says that at all. Like I said, pride is the worst and most pernicious sin for most Christians given that it's the sin of Lucifer. Pride in my view is very similar to status seeking behavior without real belief or sincere humility behind it.

Usually on an iPhone I have an option to just select all if I tap and hold.

People are too easily misled by "positive" language and symbols, and think that merely "identifying" with a word, a flag, a cross, is enough to be virtuous. I disagree, and despite the woke progressive liberal's claim that they have embraced secularism, they seem to fall into the same psychological patterns that characterize the (ostensibly) religious.

Yep, this ground has been trod quite a bit by rationalists under the name of status signaling. Christians would likely call it Pride, the worst sin of all.

It's not a new idea, I think the problem is most folks don't really care enough to self-reflect, or aren't challenged enough to ever have to think about how good of a person they are. I think we broadly agree.

I like the thrust of this post, going a bit deeper into the very surface level 'wokeism is a religion' idea. To me wokeism is a pretty clear continuation of the 'secular' ideologies that have become so prominent in the last few centuries - fascism, nationalism, communism, and of course capitalism. Wokeism at the highest level seems to be a way to square liberalism and the idea of equality with capitalism. People who believe in the ideology hook line and sinker don't want to necessarily throw away the wealth generated by capitalism, but also can't stand certain ideas about who have more merit or value.

Yet, how is the structure of their progressive thought any different from the very Christians they chastise?

I could do quite a deep dive here, but suffice to say there are major differences. The structure of woke thought is much more practical, much more 'temporary' so to speak. The best version of wokeism says that we must make society equal because we are quickly approaching a post-scarcity world. Once that happens, it's crucial that we are on a level playing field or billionaires/the multinational corporate class will eat everything. People will be segregated based on race, sexuality, gender, etc. We're at a hinge moment, and if we don't fix things soon we will lose our chance.

At it's core, wokeism is political and societal.

Christianity on the other hand is extremely individual and personal. To quote C.S. Lewis:

If individuals live only seventy years, then a state, or a nation, or a civilization, which may last for a thousand years, is more important than an individual. But if Christianity is true, then the individual is not only more important but incomparably more important, for he is everlasting and the life of a state or a civilization, compared with his, is only a moment.

Perhaps we will see a woke iconoclast to come in and set things straight - perhaps not. Either way, I see wokeism as a temporary political movement, and I'd wager most of its adherents do as well.

I'll echo others here - unless you need to support family, kids, or some other circumstance where you desperately need to make a lot of money, don't go into a career you don't like! It will wear you down, make you a shell of a person over the years. It's not worth it.

I’m interested in reading some high quality Christian apologetics. After having a bit of a crisis of faith with my vaguely eastern/agnostic spiritual tendencies I want to give the old J.C. another chance. Right now I’m on Mere Christianity by Lewis.

What are some other high quality, semi recent books for someone in my circumstances?

ETA: would anyone be interested in a book club or study group along these lines?

Sounds like you’re where I was at five years ago. I had all sorts of diagnoses from sciatica to nerve damage to hypermobility. Turned out it was all BS and I wasted years and tens of thousands of dollars on pointless medical interventions.

Check out any books by John Sarno, here is an article that gives a bit more depth. There are some other mindbody apps like Curable I’ve heard good things about. You could also look into the Alexander technique school of physical therapy.

I wish you luck. Chronic pain is not easy to live with, and as I’m sure you know most people simply cannot understand.