@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Yeah this is my view to a T. It’s sad because I would love the comfort of unshakeable faith in a Christian or other type of God, but I can’t seem to take the leap away from facts required.

I’m a bit confused here. You’re saying the blank slate view makes social contagion acceptable?

Interesting article! Thanks for linking.

I've heard these comparisons, and as I've mentioned before I'm extremely bullish on the social contagion hypothesis for the majority of mental illness cases. It's an especially pernicious problem because once an illness becomes too 'saturated' like anorexia has been, the cultural cachet of the diagnoses plummets and the fad moves on. All that's left is hordes of people with broken lives and nothing to show for it.

I'm convinced that the modern world's turn away from religion is the main culprit here. That being said, I've been an agnostic for most of my life, so I don't think anyone is necessarily to blame when it comes to turning our backs on old religions. Unfortunately it's just extremely difficult to reconcile modern scientific knowledge with old religious worldviews. I think what many religious people, especially on this forum, miss is that for many agnostics or athiests it's not that they don't want to believe, rather that they find it practically impossible to believe in a religion which demands they lay down the rules of science and empiricism.

I'm not sure I buy it, but I've heard the argument that sex before marriage is bad for lifetime satisfaction. Kind of like delayed gratification.

Agreed! That's why I love the Motte, and rationalists more generally. Sometimes I do wish I could fall into the mindless dogmatism camp though. Being a contrarian skeptic can be quite personally difficult sometimes!

Lack of certainty is great for getting at the truth, but humans are much happier (I'd imagine) when they have certainty.

Fair point! They’re being convinced though.

Agreed, Noble Lies are a thing for a reason. Humans must rationalize and believe in fictions to escape the horror of knowing your own death is coming.

There's been a ton of bashing of immigrants and the idea of assimilation here recently. Lots of doom, not a lot of hope or true attempts at understanding. I'd like to briefly outline a positive case for immigration and assimilation, looking at three major groups throughout history.

First we have Rome. Famously Rome is one of the greatest, if not the greatest, empires an lights of civilization in the Western world. In many ways the Pax Romana and the heights the Romans achieved paved the way for the modern Western order. The United States' governmental system is in large part explicitly modeled on the Roman system.. How did Rome achieve so much success? Many scholars believe it was their ability to assimilate new peoples into their culture, and make them productive members of society. There's even a word for it: Romanization. (Or if you prefer, the less politically correct 'civilizing of barbarians.')

Going from their example, we have the many great and powerful Islamic empires. Now before everyone spouts off about how intolerent Muslims are, I agree. For many historic reasons Islamic states nowadays are the opposite of an immigrant loving place that's open to assimilation. Ironically, some scholars claim that:

How can the current state of political violence in Muslim countries be reconciled with the often-invoked tolerance of the past multicultural and multireligious Muslim Empires? One way to address this conundrum is to distinguish between toleration and tolerance. The former refers to the modern institutionalised protection of religious, ethnic, and gender differences through the rule of law, while the latter implies organic mechanisms specific to communities to accommodate differences.

From this perspective, Muslim Empires were tolerant, while modern-day Muslim states lack toleration. The past tolerance expressed itself in the regulation of the local religious diversity under the purview of the Islamic judges (qadis).

There's a lot of definitional games here, but Muslim empires were certainly notable for assimilated other 'People of the Book', i.e. Christians and Jews, which even their contemporary Christian states thought was insane. Many Muslim empires were much stronger than European nations at times, especially during the so-called Dark Ages.

Finally, we have America. I won't rehash this too much, as I think it's practically inarguable that America is a nation founded on the principle of immigration, religious freedom, and has levered it's ability to assimilate masses of immigrants to become the greatest nation in the history of the world.


The point of all these examples is to say that yes, immigration is difficult. And yes, modern Western nations may not be in a perfect spot to assimilate immigrants, there are many flaws with social programs and how immigration works currently. I'll concede all those points.

However, I think the reason immigration and assimilation is so attractive to so many intellectuals lies in the potential! If your culture can figure out a way to bridge gaps between different cultures, ethnicities, and groups, if you can truly make disparate peoples unite under one flag, one cause, one set of ideals, you can rule the world. The tail benefits of successful immigration policies are massive.

It's a major mistake to sneer at modern issues with immigration and say it's a doomed project when so much of our culture exists because of cultural plurality.

Why, not. In my view Jews are some of the best immigrants to join America, they’ve made the country incredibly great, and arguably won the second world war and established American hegemony. I can’t think of a better example of the strengths of multiculturalism.

Maybe you can, but you won't.

Such strong faith that it’s impossible to assimilate, yet again the greatest nation on earth achieved that status through immigration.

Obviously, it’s challenging. I am the same recipe that worked in the past won’t work today. But as many have pointed out, there have been multiple waves of American immigration, it’s not like there was one unique situation that led America assimilate a bunch of immigrants that will never exist again.

You may have a point for France, but for America at least this is hilariously backward. It denies the whole founding purpose of the USA.

May I remind you:

Give me your tired, your poor

Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free

The wretched refuse of your teeming shore

Send these the homeless tempest-tost to me

I lift my lamp beside the golden door!

Nations can be built and can thrive based on more than just ethnicity or “family” as you call it. It’s been done before, to more success than anything else in the history of the world, and we can do it again.

The greedy landlords are the ones that are stopping more housing from being built.

Yep, I've changed my position on Christianity, HBD, and various other topics quite a bit from reading the motte. It's part of why I'm still around.

Agreed @GuyOnInternet. At least run it through GPT 3.5 to make it more readable.

Anecdotally I've seen it stop being able to transform markdown text into hyperlinks for some reason. Haven't used it much otherwise.

I'm actually very curious about the Apollo device, I'm convinced that 'sending signals to our nervous system' or whatever is very powerful, due to my experience with chronic pain. Not sure I can stomach the price though. I hope these things go down in price soon.

This quote from the website slaps:

As a neuroscientist and psychiatrist, Dr. Dave has always been fascinated by consciousness and our inherent ability to heal ourselves from illness and injury. After dedicating his career to understanding the impact of chronic stress on our well-being over 15 years ago, he observed a core challenge that confronts every single one of us - healthy behavior changes will benefit us in the long term, but making those changes when we’re under chronic stress is really, really hard.

The reason? Chronic stress itself. Our nervous system is there to keep us safe. When we face stress, our brains tell our bodies the equivalent of “Hey, there’s a lion over there! Get out of danger!” That’s why we have trouble sleeping, low energy, and a hard time focusing - it’s like the nervous system is saying “run” or “fight” when we’re just trying to get through our day. We developed Apollo Neuro to restore balance to the nervous system, calming the body to clear the mind, and leaving us feeling safe and in control of how we feel.

Hah no worries. Glad to hear it was helpful for ya.

I think your points overall make sense, but you don't account at all for variability and social mobility. As @rae mentioned below, men tend to live higher risk lifestyles. Their appetite for risk is higher, so the rewards are greater and the failures are more steep.

On top of that, women tend to rely on immutable traits i.e. beauty, and to some degree the social network they were born in, to confer them status. If you're an ugly woman born into a poor family, there is not much of a chance for you to get out. In fact, this Brookings study on male vs female social mobility says:

In most quintiles, women have a higher risk of being downwardly mobile than men. Most striking of all, women find it much harder to escape from the bottom income quintile than men. Almost half (47 percent) of women born to parents in the bottom quintile remain there as adults, compared to 35 percent of men.

For men, there are many things that don't seem fair on the surface. That being said, the variability inherent in being a man is worth quite a lot. Having the ability to rise out of your circumstances, despite a bad throw on the genetic lottery, means that men innately have optionality that women generally don't. Sure you can argue that programs and other things biased towards women help them move up the socioeconomic ladder, but at the end of the day most women don't seem to have the mindset to let them take the risks they would need to take to climb.

Ultimately I do think men get the short end of the stick in some regards, and women in others. It's not clear to me at this moment, and I doubt we'll have clarity for a while yet, who gets the 'better minimum deal' overall.

Congratulations!!! I’m so happy for you man, hope to see you stateside sometime in the future.

What is your next step now, UK?

Thanks for the answer, definitely interesting. Im curious, why wasn’t the hospital job less stressful?

Yeah, making a career pivot is difficult for me and I don’t have kids! I can’t imagine how hard it is with a family.

We really do get locked into our career paths so to speak, just like our brains our work seems to calcify over time.

Yep, as others have said it's too low-effort. Although on a cursory scan I don't see that specifically in the rules. Closest I can see is:

Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.

@Amadan or another mod, is the low-effort piece anywhere in CW rules?

How many of you have made major career changes? How long did it take you, or how did you go about it?

Sounds like my old friend social anxiety. We all have it to varying degrees.

What helps me is just pushing through and saying/posting stuff and resisting the urge to clarify or edit or whatever.

Hey man, the Motte wouldn't be what it is without passive aggressive condescension. I find attacking someone's relationship online who you barely know based on one data point to be particularly distasteful. In general, I think the CW thread should be more focused on actual topics and arguments than our personal lives.