TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
I just started The Triumph of Christianity. I like the framing laid out so far, but haven't gotten more than a few pages into it yet.
You've got some very thought-provoking riffs in here, I am fascinated by greater male variability, surprised I haven't come upon that myself yet.
I find it difficult to fault people for preferring stability and the well-trod path, but when too many people take that path it introduces its own forms for vulnerability.
I generally agree with this framing, the oft-cited solution is a social 'safety net' of sorts. Although as @The_Nybbler points out in the CW thread, this type of 'solution' tends to make the problem worse. If anything being on a welfare problem leads to people taking less risk and feeling less secure.
I recognize now I've just rederived "greater male variability hypothesis," which leads me to rephrase that question: which should society optimize for?
This question is definitely beyond me, however I'd argue that as a society we should help people genuinely discover their own strengths, talents, whatever, then optimize in that way. This could look like more self-selection into different tracks during early education, a stronger emphasis on genetic determinism in education (although this may be hopelessly fraught with the current Overton Window) or just a greater push on making folks aware of the benefits and downsides of risk. Currently the social consensus, at least among the majority of productive members of society, is that risk is always bad and you should never take a risk professionally.
Even if people don't say this out loud, their preferences certainly reveal an extremely low risk tolerance. What's ironic is that we have so much more wealth than previous generations, yet we seem ever more afraid of loss.
If that is true, why are crazy people still in the gene pool period?
Our conception of 'crazy' in the modern world may just be a symptom of our worldview. Many people who have schizo-affective disorders today would probably be legitimately accepted as prophets, or being possessed by demons, or called by the gods in previous societies. And based on historic data, those 'cures' seemed to be quite effective, at least form the anecdotes that we have passed down.
Perhaps our entire frame of the problem is an impediment to solving it.
While it's fashionable to sneer at this today, it is not a new idea that one solution to evil is to fight it.
Is using a systematized solution to stop evil not fighting it?
I suppose what I'm saying is that there are many ways to fight problems. In general I favor non-violent solutions where possible, which I think is the start of where a lot of system-oriented folks get to. Our whole modern conception of agency is incredible fraught, I don't know if I can even touch that reasonably.
I agree with your point on safety nets. It's a bad term, and permanent welfare is often far worse for people. Once someone's self image becomes weak and dependent, I think it exacerbates the problem rather than solving it.
Yeah, I think that a lot of folks here have been really struggling with the Problem of Evil, so to speak. There's so much mental illness and frankly broken people in the world that they want a quick easy solution, just sweep all the 'bad people' under the rug to fix it.
The problem as I see it is that there's clearly some major issues with the way we have organized modern societies, or maybe the influence of technology on us, that makes it so an increasing number of people just can't cope. They don't have meaning in their lives, and they can't seem to function well in society.
The progressive view is that we need to better our institutions and safety nets to allow for more flourishing, the conservative ideal looks to be that we just shame and punish people over and over until they act better. I think that we do need both sides, but too few people are willing to find a compromise between the two.
Thanks! I hadn't heard of that Haidt book, putting it on my list. Sounds right up my alley. And yeah, unfortunately Safetyism has infected pretty much everything, not just childcare. You have IRBs in healthcare, legal statutes that stop anything from happening.
I feel like we modern Westerners have this delusion that if we just implement a ton of rules and get regulations right then we can fix everything immediately and prevent pain from happening. It's a comforting delusion because people don't like complexity and uncertainty, but in my mind it's doomed to fail. We have to accept the world as it is, understand that bad things will happen for no good reason, and try our best to mitigate the bad circumstances while still taking risks. I agree that I'm not sure how to break out of the status quo.
Thanks for the reply.
By instilling terminal values in parents that incentivize them to expose their own children to doses of adversity at each age and to foster in them a sense of responsibility for their choices and for those circumstances over which they can exercise control.
With this, I think the problem I see is one, nobody can agree on which terminal values will help here. This solution sounds nice but we need practical steps that can be implemented today, or at least strived towards.
Do you have any ideas that you can lay out as to how to achieve this instilling of terminal values?
The name? Of a blog or you mean transhumanism?
I know the fashionable term is “accelerationist” now but I tend to find a lot of politics thrown in around that circuit.
Interesting point. I'm moving my CW effortpost into a new thread, we'll see if it takes.
Don't think so, I use the save feature for that.
Somewhere in me I have an effortpost on why crypto, including cryptocurrency is bad for rule of law and that a sane society would have banned both
This would definitely be contrarian here, curious to get a discussion going.
Why do you hope they’re not in the CW thread?
This is a lot but basically boils down to something like: we are all driven to seek power, but are born powerless and are told not to seek it. Power is given to those who either earn it or steal it from others. Good rulers earn their power through respect and bad rulers earn their power through toxic power games. If we can't be powerful we want to be under the rule of someone we respect. It's degrading to be ruled by those we disrespect. Present day American culture is in such a state of disarray because we have little respect for institutions and each other.
This seems to strike to the heart of a lot of the issues I have with current US society. I'd love to see a more fleshed out version. Obvious parallels to Neitzsche's Will to Power and the Hobbesian struggle against nature.
I'd also argue that, going with your late capitalism post, it's degrading to have fundamental parts of meaning in our life reduced to transactions with money. Not sure why but something about the numerical aspect of transactions takes away something ineffable when it comes to relationships, social circles, etc. Having most people's primary social interaction or hierarchy be a corporate structure is destroying purpose and self-respect.
What are some good transhumanist blogs that are focused on telling interesting stories or generally being more entertaining than number crunchy?
I'd recommend starting slow on the drinking, and getting used to the feeling of being drunk in a more relaxed setting and/or with close friends first. Getting drunk for the first time on a vacation may not turn out well. It could, but depends on how alcohol affects you.
You Carp? I am beyond shocked.
I’d love to read your inferential distance posts. I often find myself wishing I could go back to the days before utilitarianism, determinism, and other non-values based belief systems convinced me of their logic. While those sorts of beliefs may be more true in some cosmos sense, they certainly have far less utility on a personal basis. Ironic.
Most of these are quite fascinating - I’d love to see your defense of Marx in particular. Communism is definitely a bugbear around here.
Interesting parallel with the dream world being something similar to the internet or cultural discussion. I do wonder if our ability to so completely enmesh ourselves in a virtual world prevents or discourages dreaming. Something to look into.
I love the idea of looking into semiconductor manufacturing- very much a crucial piece of the modern supply chain. Perhaps the central piece as AI becomes more relevant.
Curious about the mental load thing - do you mean the common meme that women do more emotional labor than men? Or the idea that the modern world adds a lot of mental overhead for day to day tasks?
Here are a few ideas I've been wanting to see more of. I've written on some of these topics, but want to put them out there for more discussion regardless:
-
Implications of space travel on the economy/culture war etc.
-
AI alignment based on politcal lines - seems this area is up in the air right now, but given the current partisan environment I highly doubt we'll get both partied agreed on one side or the other. I tentatively think democrats will push for safety/halting research, while Republicans will push for acceleration. I'd like to see a more rigorous analysis though.
-
The rise of the medical establishment, especially psychiatry, and how it has interacted with the downfall of Christianity and classical Western beliefs. A few other posters have written on this idea but I'm curious of the specifics.
-
Nuclear power and how/why it become so polemicized. I'm sure that everyone knows the big incidents like Three Mile Island and Chernobyl, but I'd be willing to bet there's a story to be told about the behind the scenes politicking that led to the current status quo where nuclear is toxic (heh) in public discourse.
-
Dreams and how they are totally disregarded in modern technological societies. Almost every culture throughout the world placed a large significance on dreams - now we don't! Wonder why this is and how it could play into our neuroses.
#1 and #4 are definitely interesting to me! Being in a politically divided family would be quite difficult.
To your point about beliefs post, I feel like that would be almost too large an undertaking to do in one passage. Maybe a sequence? It's definitely an interesting thought exercise.
ChatGPT isn’t great for therapy yet. But it can be very useful to provide texts written on topics like spiritual development or emotional development, and summarize the points therein. It can also synthesize the ideas between two works to produce interesting corollaries.
As a way to increase the breadth of your knowledge on the topic of personal development it’s irreplaceable in my opinion. There is so much knowledge out there one could literally spend multiple lifetimes reading and never get it all - GPT helps condense that process quite a bit.

You're in for a great ride. Definitely curious to hear your thoughts after you finish it.
Since you're interested in religious philosophy, I'll note that Bakker has by far the best conception of religion in a fantasy world I've ever seen. His knowledge of how religion shapes us and is shaped by us goes incredibly deep.
More options
Context Copy link