@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Eh, there are plenty of Christian evangelists here I wouldn’t worry too much.

I’m assuming based on your name you believe in a more Hindu/Buddhist ontology?

Yep I believe that’s the one. It has come up multiple times since the move offsite though.

I tend to find it interesting to get down to irreconcilable value differences, and to me the question you posed is a great way to get there on trans issues.

Going off of @George_E_Hale’s post below, I’m curious to gather a list of effort posts that aren’t the norm on here, which people would like to write on but don’t have the time.

I’d be happy to take up the challenge of writing a few into an effort post, with or without credit for the idea depending on what folks want. I’m sure other effortposters would be down too. Feel free to reply or just DM me if anything jumps out to you.

If you or any other folks have a topic you want to post about, go for it!

On the other hand, I’d like it if we could have some sort of anonymous pool where lurkers could put in topics they want to see in the CW thread. Then posters like me who love writing longform bs but don’t always have an idea can write things the lurkers want.

@ZorbaTHut any thoughts on doing something like this?

I specifically try to post different top level comments than we normally see, absolutely. I lurked for a long time but got fed up as many people in this thread are, and decided to start posting things interesting to me.

This was discussed a few weeks back. Myself and a couple other folks agreed even though we are generally not pro trans at the moment.

Sure I’d agree with that. I think the line between science and pseudoscience is often blurred, however.

Yep, that’s modern or pre-modern, depending on which historian you ask. Currently we’re firmly in postmodernity.

My experience of last month is that most of the big ones have totally stopped prescribing any sort of controlled substance.

Well yes, that’s the point of a noble lie. It’s in the name - the intellegent elite lie to the public for their own good.

With modern liberal values that’s generally considered immoral, but in the case of psychosomatic pain I can see how it would be useful. A key part of the ‘cure’ is to convince people they aren’t in pain. Using a fake scientific method to give them confidence may be dishonest, but with the amount of people Sarno has helped I can see how he could justify it.

Interesting, I haven’t heard this claim before but it’s certainly plausible. Know of any further reading on the subject?

try not to get excited

Can you explain why you think a massive political purge via execution of a ruler’s personal enemies would be something exciting?

Sulla is one of the most cursed figures in Roman history for a reason.

Yeah I definitely think massive economic shocks will happen in the 5-10 year range. Honestly I hope things get shaken up quickly so that western governments are forced to enact some sort of social program or face mass unrest. Otherwise we could be in for a real dystopia as labor gets devalued.

The main difference this time is that the cat is out of the bag. Older AI systems were relatively under the radar, not accessible by most folks, not reported on by the media.

Now the public knows the power of these tools, and can go ask GPT about medical questions whenever they want. That changes the game significantly.

I see it as the value alignment of those at the head. Sam Altman isn’t perfect, but he’s at least nominally aligned with EA values of making things better for everyone. He’s not a classic sociopathic shark at one of the big tech firms that was born into massive wealth, went to Harvard, did the standard track, and parasitically drained value from the masses.

Again I’m not saying Altman is some sort of hero, clearly he’s sociopathic if he’s made it that far into the power structure. But at least he’s a relative outsider and there’s hope he can steer us to better outcomes because he thinks more deeply about the consequences of AI than the folks who stop at the idea of gaining money and power.

A well-credentialed doctor in a prestigious institution has once prescribed me a massive, costly and crippling operation in response to some worrying symptoms. I thought for a bit, reasoned that hypochondria and credulity are shameful, and just ignored the problem, which subsequently… mostly went away.

(I visited the Church for the first time in years after that).

There truly is a massive problem with the amount of authority and trust we place in doctors in the modern Western world. They've taken over the mantle that has been passed from shamans to pagan druids to Eastern sages to Catholic priests. Doctors function as our way to stem the anxieties and problems in society, not just medically but now spiritually as well.

After Christianity suffered its fall, the medical system was bootstrapped into a sort of Frankenstein monster, where instead of curing illnesses we now expect doctors to make us happy, less anxious, help us understand our brethren and self-actualize into better people.

Clearly this was a mistake.

How has your experience with the current medical system been? Have you always gotten an accurate diagnosis from a doctor, relatively cheaply, with no complications or errors on their part?

I truly don't give a flying fuck if the AI is only 90% accurate, in my mind that means it's shooting far above what doctors are generally doing. Besides as @self_made_human has already stated, you should always double check and get a second opinion. I figure that AI diagnostics will be the first line of defense, if that doesn't work you can go to a human doctor. I think it'll work and be far more accurate and cheaper in the vast majority of cases though.

I think the idea that East Asian societies are generally more comfortable with social control and/or community oriented action compared to Western individualism makes sense and is well founded. I don't know if we need to get into anatomy of noses.

Besides as others have commented, I doubt it makes a real difference.

That they completely ignore nearly-guaranteed misuses of the technology by governments and the powers that be, and just go "Woo! Cool new toy!". They're so blinded by it's shine that, as gilmore606 pointed out, they don't realize they're repeating, word for word, the promises people were making when they were working on the Internet, and ignoring how it worked out in practice.

I am very worried about this, I just have no idea how to stop it. What are we supposed to do? An AI slowdown will only serve to cement the power in the hands of the large labs. People are working on open sourcing models like LLaMa, but it's inherently a sort of technology that lends itself to centralization, with the massive data and compute requirements.

Honestly I think Open AI being the leader is better than many alternative outcomes. Sure Microsoft gets to use it but theoretically Open AI comes back under it's own control after $92 billion in profits is made. Seems like an okay situation compared to Microsoft or Google or another big evil corp controlling everything.

Personally I am a Butlerian Jihadi, but that's irrelevant to the conversation, the discourse is so sidetracked, that it makes no sense to even bring up my objections to AI.

Why do you follow the teachings of the Leto II, God-emperor?

What is your issue with AI enthusiasts? Or doomers for that matter?

Do you just not like AI and want us to burn it all down or something?

No direct evidence but there are large communities of people with similar experiences. Check my NYT link in the original post.

It's not like it's coming only for doctors after all, it'll burn down a swathe of professions in short order.

I am actually going back and forth on this. On the one hand the tools are amazing, but the inertia of bureaucracy and regulation can be onerous indeed. Plus I wonder how well the models will work in fine-tuned environments. Most of the business cases would rely on GPT-4 being trained in a very narrow or niche field/topic.

What makes you so positive that so many jobs will be destroyed in short order?

Thanks for the writeup, this is fascinating. As I've said before I tend to agree with @Primaprimaprima that many, perhaps even most people, will prefer to see a human doctor for the majority of symptoms. I see a hybrid model being the future of medicine. This sort of fundamental topic on the health of yourself and your loved ones is deeply emotional for people and I think they'll want the reassurance of a human authority figure they can look to.

That being said those who choose to adopt AI doctors will probably gain a significant edge in health, and just like any other technology early adopters will convince the rest to follow. The deep seated prejudices will remain, but I'd imagine kids who grew up with the internet, or especially those growing up in the age of AI, will take to AI doctors quite readily.

I'm actually far more interested in the applications to mental health than any sort of physical diagnoses, even though I do think those are impressive. I've used GPT-4 to get tips on meditation, visualization, and generally teaching myself wisdom, and it's incredible.

In a podcast on the Lunar Society, Ilya Sutskever of Open AI wrote that he imagines a situation where every human will have access to the wisdom of our greatest sages and wise men. We'll be able to immediately get answers to our deepest religious or spiritual questions at the drop of a hat. If we don't get satisfaction we can always go to a human therapist, but LLMs will be an incredible 'first line of defense' so to speak.

I'm tempted to think he's intentionally acting out a Noble Lie, as he is caught in a bit of a double bind. On the one hand he needs people to confidently believe his diagnosis, but on the other hand he doesn't have excellent scientific data. So he may be fudging the facts a bit to make it more convincing to patients. I plan to do a follow up post on this if I get the time.

Thanks for the detailed response, I’d definitely love to do an adversarial research collab on this at some point if you’re game.

I’ll agree that I think Sarno dramatically overstates his claims in terms of how many illnesses are caused by mental issues. That being said, as you’ve admitted below, the idea of ‘stress’ is clearly a huge gap in our current medical corpus of knowledge. Not only is it a gap, it’s one the medical field seems allergic to probing at anything but the basic level.

As someone who has personally dealt with chronic pain, I can tell you that this sort of psychosomatic technique works extremely well compared to other interventions. I’ve regained full function of my body, after having over five recommendations for surgery by practicing specialists.

I understand why your perspective would be so against this idea, but imagine my perspective here. It’s extremely hard to be charitable to doctors on the chronic pain/fibro front when the evidence for their interventions is so bad and the field stubbornly refuses to look at alternatives to treatment.