TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
IP is horribly abused in practice, the creators often get Pennie’s or less on the dollar especially in industries like print media.
Yep I had the same realization as you. Motte moving offsite helped me stop going on almost entirely.
Recently Scott Alexander and a few others have been talking more about the idea of a social contagion, one which spreads real physical problems.
As I’ve argued in previous posts, this social contagion likely causes a number of what we see as purely physical injuries. Many feel that their body is injured. They deal with diagnoses from the medical community such as:
-
Chronic pain
-
Fibromyalgia
-
TMJ
-
Joint Hypermobility
Some doctors, like John Sarno, have even argued that far more injuries are based on psychological harm, rather than physical, such as:
-
Hives
-
Eczema
-
IBS
-
Gluten sensitivity/Celiacs
-
Herniated Discs
The list goes on. These are extraordinary claims, which Sarno backs up with impressive statistics in his book.. Unfortunately I can’t find his paper online, would be curious to take a look if anyone has a link. What Sarno calls the issue, and what other doctors or medical writers such as have supported him in, is a disorder called Tension Myositis Syndrome (TMS.)
The basic mechanism he posits is that our mind uses defense mechanisms to prevent us from thinking certain thoughts. We distract ourselves with drugs, alcohol, fast food, and many other addictions. He thinks that in the modern world, due to our views on physical injury, some people deal with their mind creating physical pain to distract them from emotional issues. This distraction comes out in certain nerves being deoxygenated, which he claims to have proven.
Much of this stress comes from trauma due to unresolved emotional issues, which is pretty standard accepted literature in psychology nowadays. Sarno specifically calls out “anxiety, anger, and feelings of inferiority” as the big culprits, citing that modern life causes many of us to have a lot of anger boiling under the surface. Constraints from work, relationships, illness, loss of loved ones, and in extreme cases childhood neglect or abuse.
To use a more rationalist lens, you could say the most stressor would be status anxiety. Many on the motte have argued that status anxiety is an incredibly common and hidden force that generates massive emotional problems, since the Western world is so hypercompetitive, and it’s difficult to measure up in any walk of life, let alone most. When you don’t feel you're at the top in your work life, social life, or family structure, people get frustrated.
What makes this problem worse is that due to the way modern society operates, we can’t express anger frequently depending on our situation. For those in the PMC, or the business world more generally, it’s considered almost unthinkable to yell at a boss or a client. The whole microaggression concept exacerbates the issue.
Some believe this is a recent phenomena due to stresses of modern life, but I’d argue that the connection between mind and body is far more complicated and older. Writers throughout history would cite feelings of pride which make your chest well, or having your hands tremble with rage. Our minds and bodies are inextricably linked, so it stands to reason that if we have rampant neuroses in our society, some of it would express itself physically.
I’m sure many of those reading this who are more physically active may have an instinctual response of “duh, of course the mind and body are one, it’s the most obvious thing ever.” I’d argue that the inferential distance around this issue opens a vast gulf which is difficult to imagine. If you have not experienced chronic pain, I don’t think it’s something one can confidently model with any real accuracy.
To some degree, patterns of behavior also must matter. A common response to an injury is to exercise, and for most generalized chronic pain issues, this seems to work. The issue arises when someone creates a trapped prior. Basically the idea that they have some condition is so deeply ingrained that the typical fixes don’t work. Many sufferers of chronic pain even admit they think it’s psychosomatic, but still struggle to deal with it. Ultimately Sarno’s method seems to work for them over time. Point is, our modern medical fixation on mechanical causology for injury seems, if not totally wrong, at least to be missing a big piece of the puzzle.
This idea may already swim in the water all around us. After all, we have plenty of colloquialisms such as “trust your gut” or “follow your heart” that suggest a connection. However, the common idea that injuries are almost entirely physical persists.
If true, this hypothesis could be one the discovery of which would shake our society to its roots. Long-lasting physical injuries being caused by emotional pain would alter our entire approach to medicine, let alone overall health or the pursuit of virtue.
It’s important to note that depending on your values, you may prefer the current state of events. If subjecting the emotionally damaged in Western society (most of us) to self-caused physical pain is worth preventing large amounts of anger and other negative emotions from boiling over, that is not necessarily an irrational choice. I’d certainly prefer dealing with one of these issues than living through a revolution or large war.
That being said, it’s a choice we must make without blinders. To ignore the issue entirely is to prevent us from solving it.
I genuinely had never seen a fake or ridiculous recipe before seeing a chatgpt generated one about a month ago. I know it was chatgpt because the poster explicitly called it out.
Just because there’s some fancy psychological effect about it doesn’t discount my anecdote, sirrah.
Ahh hell yes Second Apocalypse is incredible. Make sure to appreciate my boy Kellhus.
I’m reading Healing Back Pain by John Sarno. It’s an instant classic.
I think they’re LLM generated, bout a month ago one went viral because it’s hilarious.
You’ll have to join myself and @self_made_human in the cyber verse once the Singularity happens. We’ll have a whole gaggle of Motte based transhumanists.
If you start modeling too you could become a large language model.
…. I’ll see myself out.
Is this /r/thedonald? Oh man we had fun times there back in the day. That subreddit was the whole reason I voted for Trump in 2016.
New cities could be a way to expand with new forms of government, and let people that have different political opinions from mainstream big cities see if their ideas work.
As the US spread West this type of city formation driven political change was crucial. It kept eastern US societies more stable as well since there was a place to send the misfits.
I’m surprised the comments here are so supportive of bullying, and frankly I wonder if it’s because it confirms many of our anti-trans biases.
When I first read this I noticed myself disagreeing that the bullying was important, but after reading some of the arguments in the comments I realized I’m not convinced for any logical reason, just because I am frustrated that trans ideology is spreading in middle schools. I think it should be reserved for adults.
If this child were being harassed for something like believing in God, or an immutable characteristic like a big nose or their race, I would find this situation terrible.
For all the people saying kids need to toughen up or whatever - I firmly disagree. Humans can learn to operate in high trust, net positive ways, and that’s the society I want to build. If we keep creating cycles of kids being fucked up and aggressive in their early lives, adults will continue to act that way too. You can say hierarchical psychological violence is necessary to the human condition or whatever, but if that’s truly the case I say we strive towards something better.
This must be one of those core differences between traditionalists and others. There are many awful things that have been happening for thousands of years and I’m glad we ended them.
Status quo bias is one of my biggest frustrations with the world.
Yeah I think this is the path. As @Primaprimaprima said focus on the harms and the mental illness etc etc.
But he can let the boy be as feminine as he wants. It’s likely this is a phase anyway.
Ya know, fair point.
I wish I got more meaning from my relationships to be honest. My partner and my mother are the main two people I care deeply about, but even there I don’t find them to be a significant and reliable source of meaning.
I sometimes wonder if I grew up seeing family more frequently if I would care about relationships more, I had a relatively isolated youth which I’d imagine plays into it.
Yeah it’s wild how green the grass can get. It’s very strange how our minds work, almost like we’re optimized to never be satisfied whatever we achieve. I suppose in a way we are, since evolution is not kind to idleness.
Eh Magnus is a poor sport but at least he’s enjoying himself. We modernized folk need to learn to take ourselves less seriously.
A man can dream….
Is doctor the default path for a lot of folks in India, or was it more of a family thing?
Sales. I think part of the issue is even though I do contribute, sales just feels slimy to me. It pays well though.
How many of y’all find purpose in your career? I try to but ultimately I don’t think my work is that important. I’m not sure what else I could reasonably do that is important, is the problem.
I have people I care about and get meaning from other sources, but work is a perennial stress in my life since I spend so much time on it. Periods in my life where I haven’t had to work have been excellent and I have zero issues finding happiness and meaning, but obviously we have to make a living.
How does everyone else cope with a lack of meaningful employment?
Glad to hear it! Even though we’re long past the seasons directly affecting our lives, I also seem to have deeply seasonal moods.

So… men and women are the same?
More options
Context Copy link