TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
Any ideas for how to address it? Butlerian jihad?
True he must've had some sort of divine inspiration for that series. It's truly remarkable.
I mention it downthread. I meant "Wegovy"?
This sounds great, I love it. Separation of Corp. and State?
I have no idea what projects you’re referencing.
Government intervention for massive, quick unemployment is one of the main areas we need intervention in my view. When it comes to unemployment, what other frameworks would we need intervention?
Theoretically if it’s a slow collapse of jobs the market can correct and create new ones. When unemployment come fast and furious we need something to bridge the gap.
What is that?
I’m not a doomer to be clear. I do believe the coming AI framework is creative disruption. That being said, it will happen fast. I think it’ll be too fast for our society to adapt without massive unrest.
During the industrial revolution there was also massive unrest, as a downthread discussion on anarchy went into. This revolution by nature of it being digital and software based, will likely happen far faster than the industrial revolution. You don’t think that will lead to massive societal issues?
This is a great answer, the problem is competition, incentives, and Moloch. If we want this to be a reality we need to immediately start lobbying and building a consensus for a shorter workweek. Something I don’t see happening unfortunately.
It’s a shame most socialist and communist groups have been totally captured by spewing and debating bullshit all day instead of discussing and planning for realistic outcomes like a 30 day workweek in light of AGI. Hopefully they’ll get their collective act together.
@thegayrabbi’s comment from the fun thread:
I've just started seriously studying machine learning, and I think the languages models are just the tip of the iceberg, and most of the powerful modern AI is hidden behind NDAs and less noticeable technologies. Many things quietly occurred without too many people noticing, for example:
Google tagged everyone's photos in Google photos with their contents. I have Google randomly displaying photos on my home screen when it's plugged in, and it knows not to show anything NSFW, and generally picks interesting photos. Google knows exactly what's in my thousands of photos.
Social media moderation also perfected AI filtering of NSFW content to any degree of precision the platform wants.
Every large marketing company or department has started to calculate someone called a "lifetime customer value" using machine learning to discovery and target the groups of customers predicted to spend the most over a lifetime. New marketing interventions will be measured for effectiveness in influencing consumer behavior. Eventually ad campaigns could be individualized and AI generated to a shocking degree, without even seeming personalized, because we don't look at each other's phones. It's possible in the future no one will ever see the same ad twice, or even be able to tell the difference between an AI generated advertisement and human generated content. The difference might even cease to be semantically intelligible. If it's trivial for an AI to generate an excellent exercise video with a small mention of a wellness product, is that an ad or a helpful wellness video?
What happens when AI can generate a new marvel movie just for you, subtly based on your consumer preferences and sense of humor? The experience of everyone seeing the same movie could disappear the same way the experience of everyone watching something like the seinfeld series finale at the same time did.
Absolutely humans will be necessary in the near and even medium term. But there’s no question that this will 5x the production of many jobs and 10x or 100x others. This is a foolish objection because even if there is a human in the loop there will be a need for far fewer humans than there currently are.
Agreed. I think that most in the laptop class are actually quite hungry for status and money hence their effort put into finding entry into the laptop class.
If status and opportunity shift, I’d imagine many of us will shift as well.
Wow the advertising portion is horrifying and a very salient point… it will be much more economically feasible than the whole “create personalized videos” thing. That is truly concerning.
Would you mind popping this comment into the CW thread on this topic I just posted? Would love to discuss there.
Ahh I've read a lot of your posts but didn't pick up on it. Interesting.
I agree that working in physical environments is better for overall mental health. Ideally we can just create more drugs like Semaglutide to avoid needing surgical interventions, but I am very much of the belief that there will be a massive biological revolution once AI tools scale into pharma companies.
If there's a big surplus of new capital due to AI efficiency, that means that there is more to invest in things that AI can't do right now, like manual labour.
Problem is things will go too fast - as you point out the majority of people that work in the laptop class right now won't be able to immediately switch to manual labor. More importantly, they won't want to. Like I pointed out work carries a lot of meaning for people. Besides, I think the changes are so drastic people will demand government intervention even if it isn't strictly needed.
I'm sure others have seen this, but AutoGPT is here, a framework that lets instances of GPT call other instances of GPT to create complex task chains with no human input. In other words, it lets GPT instances prompt other instances to complete projects. Only about a week after being released, the examples are staggering.
This is an example of BabyAGI automating a sales prospecting pipeline, something I can say from experience normally takes a typical sales rep at least half a day to do. We can already automate it, and pretty well. This type of thing wasn't possible a week ago.
There are all sorts of other examples, and it's clear that massive automation is happening. I'm willing to bet we'll reach 30% unemployment in five years. If not sooner. The question becomes - what do we do about it?
The standard liberal answer is Universal Basic Income, and many on the left seem to think it will just magically appear once the government realizes the economic power of AGI. Problem is even if we get the buy-in from the political class, the implementation of UBI is not a simple undertaking! The funding, distribution, and potential impact on inflation alone are going to cause monstrous headaches and take years to work through. Plus even if we do have UBI, the potential of widening income inequality is insane, as those who own and control AGI technology stand to reap substantial profits, further concentrating extreme amounts wealth in their hands.
Another solution, favored by some conservatives, is to focus on retraining and upskilling the workforce. While I get the general direction here, I highly doubt a retraining program could possibly be enough to counter the rapid pace of automation. Furthermore, not everyone will have the aptitude or desire to transition into highly technical or specialized fields, which may leave a significant portion of the population without viable employment options. "Learn to code" just doesn't hit the same when software devs are going to be replaced as well.
Even if we get lucky enough to have both UBI and massive retraining, it may not be enough!
Why not get the government to throw some cash at massive infrastructure and public works projects? We could take a page out of the 1930s New Deal playbook and create a boatload of jobs in all sorts of industries. I've rarely seen anyone discuss this, but it may be necessary as it was during the Great Depression. Plus, it'd boost the economy, help repair our public infrastructure, and maybe even help tackle climate change if we invest in green tech. We could even turn this impetus towards space...
Last but not least we've got the potential impact of automation on mental health and societal well-being. We're already in the middle of a Meaning Crisis. As we increasingly rely on artificial intelligence to perform jobs and soon everyday tasks, we've got to ensure that people are still able to find purpose and meaning in their lives. This probably won't be what we've traditionally looked to, such as the arts or writing, since AI is already making that irrelevant.
Perhaps we will finally realize the importance of community in our lives and to our happiness, and start adding economic numbers and frameworks to those who create social goods. Have the government fund people to run local meetup groups, or help their neighbors with tasks, volunteer at old folks' homes, etc. It's a bit of a bludgeon solution right now, but we could refine things over time.
At the end of the day we all know the rise of AGI is going to be a shitshow for a number of reasons. I've outlined some potential solutions or stopgap measures to prevent the breakdown of society, but how does the Motte think we can navigate this change?
What is this ‘certain demographic issue’ you’re darkly hinting at?
I hate ads as well but they do help match buyers and sellers. Should we outlaw them entirely? If not how far do we restrict?
Even if it is a justification, seeking truth still has far more utility than any other option.
Ugh such an incredible plot point. Why can’t anyone do it as good as Herbert? With AGI on the horizon he’s a god damn prophet.
There’s also the whole eradication of blood feuds and distaste with marrying cousins that helped have better genetic outcomes.
Then again Christians weren’t exactly domesticated, they fought wars all the time. Also many of the elite were not exactly ideal Christians.
That being said Christianity absolutely led to a lot of scientific inquiry and building of knowledge, something often forgotten nowadays.
These are hilarious. The curling one especially cracked me up!
Yeah, I have mixed feelings about all the shallow cash grab companies/UX’s being built. On the one hand I know they’ll help drive the maturation of the technology on the whole, but there is something off putting about it.
It doesn’t help that I think 99% of these companies are going belly up within a year. The underlying framework is shifting so fast I think they need to be extremely agile to survive.
I suppose this is what it was like to be an adult through the dot com bubble.
I gotta say I’m having a shitload of fun talking about AI and making ridiculous predictions, arguing, mocking doomers, etc.
It’s oft repeated but this truly is an exciting time to be alive. Much of the last decade has felt stagnant, boring and too steeped in lethargy and hopelessness. The rise of LLMs seems to be changing that, and I for one am again waiting with baited breath to see what the technology of the future will look like.
I’ve only read that from Egan, do you have other recommendations?

If it’s email you won’t be able to tell. Expect 99% of sales emails in the future to be written by AI. Many already are.
More options
Context Copy link