TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
Gpt-4 has been released!. Looks like the cat is finally out of the bag. The CW implications of large language models are obvious and have been discussed here, so I figured I would drop a few fun facts.
Also, here's a peek at LessWrong freaking out.
The full technical report gives some fascinating information. Here are some highlights:
-
GPT-4 can pass a bar exam and score a 5 on several AP exams.
-
GPT-4 is 82% less likely to respond to requests for disallowed content and 40% more likely to produce factual responses than GPT-3.5 on our internal evaluations.
-
GPT-4 can accept images as inputs and generate captions, classifications, and analyses.
-
GPT-4 is capable of handling over 25,000 words of text, allowing for use cases like long form content creation, extended conversations, and document search and analysis.
Of all of these, passing the bar exam is the one that sticks out. We'll have to see how much it still hallucinates, but this is clearly a water mark, at least for the legal profession.
I'll go ahead and stake a perhaps dramatic but I believe warranted claim - the culture war is about to get ugly. Creating ads, propaganda, and bots to argue politics has never been easier. Whichever side moves first on scaling and implementing these language models to persuade humans to their camp will own the future.
But I have to live in the world that I live in - a highly-complex, highly-diverse urban society that demands stratification and the ability to reason probabilistically about people based on group generalizations, since I have no possible way to get to know each person I meet as an individual. I need to be able to draw reliable probabilistic assumptions about people in order to impose some measure of legibility onto an environment which by its very nature defies that legibility.
This is the key and I strongly agree with it. Especially for folks like myself in sales, you have to be able to understand and thrive within many different types of communities and social settings.
It may not be ideal, but it's the world we've built. Blame Capitalism, blame science, blame Christianity, blame whatever you want, but we are in a fully global world. Our societies are so intertwined we would likely collapse if we were fully cut off (as we got a peek of during the Covid supply chain crisis.)
The biggest tell for me that these sorts of posters wouldn't be able to survive in a different world comes from Resident Contrarion's post on what it's like to be a Christian. He flat out states that the center of the Christian worldview is that anyone who is not Christian, who doesn't hold the faith, is morally wrong and will go to hell. He tries to equivocate by saying he doesn't really think they're bad people necessarily, but it's clearly hogwash.
You can't operate in a global society if you go around thinking that everyone who doesn't share the specific interpretation of your religion is immoral, a view @TheBookOfAllan very clearly lays out downthread. The cognitive dissonance will either drive you insane, or you will become a cold emotionless shell who can't connect with the vast majority of people. Maybe some trad folks are okay with that tradeoff, personally I find it repugnant and against the very point of society.
The stable equilibrium you believe you’re endeavoring to protect has already been destroyed some time ago in the environment wherein most of us have to make our way in the world. And unless we all go back to living in the Shire, that equilibrium won’t be coming back, because it is inherently at odds with the necessities created by complex and diverse modernity.
I get the sense they realize this, and want to persuade/manipulate/force everyone to go back to that time. Unfortunately the Djinn is out of the bottle, and I find it ludicrous people seriously think we can return to that sort of traditional world.
I lurked but I started posting after the jump.
I'm curious where you get your evidence for this view outside of anecdotal examples? A quick wikipedia check of the Progressive Christianity shows that there are many branches of progressive Christian thought:
Though prominent, the movement is by no means the only significant movement of progressive thought among Christians. It draws influence from multiple theological streams, including evangelicalism, liberal Christianity, neo-orthodoxy, pragmatism, postmodern theology, progressive Christian reconstructionism, and liberation theology.
There's also a separate movement called liberal Christianity I can't find stats on how long individual churches last, but clearly they've been around for a while. The "New Thought" movement has been around since the 1830s, and apparently the original denomination/Church The New Church has been around since then. Two hundred years give or take is nothing to scoff at.
subtract the very things about the philosophical aspects of Christianity that make it appealing in the first place.
Could you expand on this? I agree that the things you listed are appealing to you, but why do you think they would be appealing to most modern people, especially those who do go and join these progressive churches?
For instance, this is pretty clearly not true since these churches exist and do have a significant amount of followers:
Leftists who already hate Christianity are not going to be convinced by a softer form of it.
Some leftists are - otherwise there would be no church/discussion.
Making 30hr/week of work count as "full-time" for employers so you get health insurance would be a big one. The work culture / health culture in America at least is insane. I'd like to see it for everyone but parents are a good start I guess.
This is more controversial, but you could also let parents exercise kids' voting rights before they turn 18. Essentially give another vote for each kid your family has - maybe make the parents agree on where to put it?
The foolish belief is a standard chemical model of addiction, and the idea that it’s a failing of willpower. Drug addiction is caused by a society wide lack of purpose, meaning, etc.
Blaming addicts is foolish and unscientific, doesn’t solve the problem in fact it makes things worse. Again look to how Switzerland dealt with their heroin problem.
I’m saying someone is “lost” if they care more about arbitrary standards of purity than actually solving the horrific problem our society has with drug use. They’re going to pay either way, but the status quo means a lot of people are going to die for their foolish beliefs.
Finished Tales from the Ketty Jay, now I’m onto Unlocking the Emotional Brain. It’s written for therapists but mine actually recommended I read it, and it has been great so far. It specifically discusses memory reconsolidstion, basically permanent removing traumatic emotional memories to get rid of anxiety depression etc.
It’s pretty impressive, optimistic, and well grounded in neuroscience. I’m enjoying it so far.
Glad to hear you liked it! I recommended it a few weeks back, also on the rec of someone from here.
It’s pretty on the nose with its themes but I like that unabashed world building. Curious to hear your take after you’ve finished the series.
Drug restrictions for lost people is a sort of disgust/purity issue, as a holdover from Christianity and other various religions. In my experience when pressed people don’t have good reasons against it.
People will bring up ODs of course but then if you point out that legalizing/decriminalizing heroin and allowing use in supervised scenarios will decrease ODs (like they did in Switzerland) you get the whole “I ain’t gonna pay for those people’s heroin!!”
Good stuff!! Thanks for sharing this is fascinating.
Sad thing is this was a top 20 bank with all the regulator stamps of approval. Will they never learn?
The bank announced they were liquidating some assets or something.
I usually say something like "I'm spiritual but not religious" or some other tripe. If pushed I'll say I believe in Buddhist philosophy but think there's a lot of wisdom to be gained in a Christian tradition, and I believe in the importance of community, etc. People are shockingly accepting about it so far at least.
Ahh I see. I think most History + Philosophy courses are solid (at least I hope) but I agree there are a whole host of pointless majors and courses out there.
Can’t paste on mobile for some reason, but your initial post was complaining about them not knowing Socrates or history etc. So it seemed like you found history and philosophy valuable.
This is inevitable unfortunately. Spam communication is about to 100x my friend. LLMs are coming for a sales team near you.
Well that’s what I get for sourcing my information from hacker news.
History and philosophy are humanities and “liberal arts” as well you know….
Silicon Valley Bank crashed just a day ago, and many folks in the VC/startup world are freaking out. I’ve seen predictions that 50-100 different startups will go bankrupt over the next month. This could cause a contagion effect and lead to worse effects, although I’m skeptical of a major economic collapse as some doomsday prophets have discussed.
Apparently the bank was mostly into mortgage backed securities, which lost a ton of value due to the Fed’s precedented* rate hikes. I don’t know enough about finance to confidently hop on my soapbox here - @BurdensomeCount may have a better idea of what’s going on.
As this collapse mainly affects very left coded super technical folks, I don’t expect many on the right to shed tears. That being said I do think this speaks to a larger issue of growth in the economy as a whole. Tyler Cowen has famously backed the stagnation hypothesis, or the idea that overall production has been slowing down.
Tech startups have recently been the major sector looked to for economic growth, especially with all the AI/LLM hype. This collapse not only will slow the industry but shows a marked incompetence from this growth sector which may cool investment there in the future.
How can we sustain economic growth without the recent massive gains from Silicon Valley technology?
That I reject revelation as a source of divine knowledge on one hand, and that empirical reason and observation of the natural world are totally insufficient to determine the existence of a Supreme Being on the other
Wouldn't a philosophy like Buddhism or Stoicism be compatible with this?
The whole 'reject organized religion' doesn't mean you have to reject all prior knowledge and thoughts on how to live a good life.
What did you find?
Absolutely.
It would help if you make your points directly. From your top level post I can't even tell if you're pro or anti-trans?

This is a fair point, and I could’ve made my argument more logically.
I suppose what I’m getting at is that the tradcon worldview needs serious updates if it is going to convince or work for many people in modern urban life. Obviously the SJW view is pretty bad for folks as well, and I’m not trying to defend it.
I suppose I’m saying I blame the tradcons of yesterday for not updating their beliefs and making them relevant in light of science/modernity/whatever, and I blame the tradcons of today for the same thing. You can be happy in your bubble, but someone really trying to do good would be working to update their spiritual or social technologies to help society as a whole.
Then again maybe it’s a doomed project, who knows.
More options
Context Copy link