@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

they’re all so damn neurotic I can’t seem to respect them or truly look up to them

Basically they are extremely driven workaholics or highly passionate about something, but they're also constantly anxious and can't seem to relax. They don't have a confident, relaxed air is another way to put it. Hard to put into words I suppose.

Personal experience with it has convinced me that’s the case.

This is a great response, I absolutely agree and think I’ve been flailing towards something like it myself. There definitely needs to be a shift in modern masculinity away from physical violence and ore towards social fluency, emotional stability, and overall intelligence. At least that’s where I’ve been able to carve a niche for myself.

Unfortunately it seems like family is a hardwired instinct for a lot of men, and I think a big problem is a lack of male role models. With the rise is divorce rates it’s not uncommon for men to grow up not seeing a single well adjusted, relaxed, competent man. Especially not one in a happy marriage. In fact I’m over thirty and can’t think of a single one in my life, including myself - though I do aspire to be there.

While I do know men who are married and accomplished, they’re all so damn neurotic I can’t seem to respect them or truly look up to them. The media doesn’t help either, with the bumbling dad tropes. I’d be curious if people could name one good father figure in modern media. (Bandit in Bluey is great but he’s a dog.)

Anyway, older men have largely failed to adapt masculinity so I suppose it’s up to the coming generation to salvage what we can.

But how do you gatekeep when the only gauge is based on feelings? This is my biggest frustration talking to people about trans - it always boils down to "that's how I feel" and there's no real way to get around that since it's not a logical proposition.

For anyone who has low back problems and sits a lot, I cannot recommend this Pipersong Meditation Chair enough. My partner bought one on a whim and I tried it not expecting much, but damn it is a game changer.

It basically lets you sit cross legged at your desk, and for me at least makes it far easier to relax my lower back. I immediately bought another after I had sat in it for a couple of hours.

Given the response to my post below about culturally bound illnesses I figured it would make sense to write out a top level post specifically discussing gender dysphoria, since I expressed a desire to avoid that topic initially. I was inspired by Scott Alexander's recent post on culturally bound illnesses.

The basic idea of my previous post is that some illnesses which seem quite common in our society, things like anorexia, depression, chronic pain, and gender dysphoria, seem likely to be highly culturally mediated - i.e. they would not exist if the cultural norms we are inoculated in didn't account for them. This goes against the standard narrative for LGBTQ+ people, who often put forth the idea that before a minority gets social approval, there are a ton of 'closeted' individuals who simply live in suffering. Under this model, the social approval actually creates the urge to, for instace, sleep with the same sex or transition gender. (I'm less confident about homosexuality being highly cultural.)

I'm sure someone here could give a better history of rough numbers of trans individuals/gender dysphoria cases over time, but the gist seems to be that numbers have exploded recently. A quick search shows laughable results such as:

The percentage and number of adults who identify as transgender in the U.S. has remained steady over time.

And then on the exact same website:

Our estimate of the number of youth who identify as transgender has doubled from our previous estimate.

This is some of the most clear double think I've ever seen, and I tend to be much less invested in the trans debate than many here. Other studies are more honest explaining that:

The population size of transgender individuals in the United States is not well-known, in part because official records, including the US Census, do not include data on gender identity. Population surveys today more often collect transgender-inclusive gender-identity data, and secular trends in culture and the media have created a somewhat more favorable environment for transgender people.


I think this whole topic presents a clear problem, but I'm less sure about the actual solution. I'm sure many would jump at the chance to say we should just tell people who have gender dysphoria to suck it up and keep it to themselves, but I doubt the feasibility of that given how easy it is to create subcultures on the internet. Also, if you try to apply that frame to other problems like say anorexia, or depression, the failure modes become extremely clear.

Then again we can't just let these culturally created illnesses run rampant through our culture, and I predict they will only become increasingly problematic as our communication infrastructure and leisure time scales up. Ideally we want to replace these unhealthy cultural memes with healthier ones, but we run into a chicken and egg problem.

So - what are your recommended solutions to the issue of transgender ideation and other culturally bound issues?

If we just legalized most drugs and educated people on them, these gangs would lose significant power. It boggles the mind how much suffering is created, both in the U.S. and outside of it, by our ridiculously over strict laws on substances.

"The usual suspects" went mask-off and no one should take their complaints of "tyranny" and "human rights violations" seriously ever again. It is only ever an attempted bludgeon to manipulate people to do what they want.

This is an extremely slippery slope. I suspect that if people in the first world truly stopped taking tyranny and human rights violations seriously you would be very concerned.

Sure the language is being abused by a subset of the left, but come now, do you truly think we should throw the whole framework of human rights and tolerant governance out of the window?

I must say I'm incredibly impressed by Bukele. He's one of the few leaders in the modern world that truly seems to be willing to experiment with new technologies or policies. So many politicians, especially in corrupt areas like South America, just try and hold onto power while they have it without taking any risks. Whatever your take on Bukele's actions, you have to admit he's got balls.

That's the thing I wish more folks in the West could understand about the second and third world - they are in an incredibly bad way. They can't just repeat the things that the West did to industrialize, because we would never allow them to. (Slavery, massive use of fossil fuels, horrid working conditions, etc.) So they need to find something new if they want to jump up and fix their societal problems - either that or go back to older ways of doing things.

Yep, it's a costly signal of your allegiance. A quite common tactic among any group that wishes to establish tight bonds and high costs of defection.

Huge thank you to whoever recommended my post! (And a day before the deadline too.)

As someone who has always aspired to write but never really followed through until this site came about, it gives me immense satisfaction to get positive feedback here, and also refills my motivation to keep writing. I have to say it feels like I've been searching for this type of community for years without knowing exactly what I was looking for, and I'm surprised to still be so excited and grateful I get a chance to participate.

We may be a den of witches with our own quirks and repeated topics, lack of overall cohesion, or whatever, but I have to say I truly think the Motte has improved my own beliefs quite a bit, and helps me gauge the quality of my writing. Compared to the quality of discourse on the rest of the internet, and increasingly in other rationalist spheres, I have to say this site feels like an oasis in a scorching desert.

Cheers to us friends.

Pre-Columbian Central American societies seem to have been some of the most violent in human history. They also established highly complex civilizations with rituals, a strong rule of law and a deeply ingrained culture that existed to manage, sanction and possibly limit (or at least constrain) that violence.

This is misleading in my opinion. It's likely that pre-conquest Mesoamerican religions failed to go through the Axial Revolution that happened primarily in Greece, Israel, Japan, and China between the 8th and 3rd centuries BCE. The main thrust of this revolution was the shift from a cyclical view of history to a "progressive" one. In other words religions and culture began to adopt the idea that individual humans and humanity as a whole could actually improve themselves, and weren't doomed to toil endlessly on a repeating wheel of brutality.

The classic example in the West is Socrates, "An unexamined life is not worth living." It's hard to overstate how much this type of cognitive revolution changes the way society works, or how baked into the modern world this view is. Nowadays we take it for granted that improvement and progress can happen, and indeed those who don't seek to improve themselves are seen as morally inferior.



On the other side of the world, Mesoamercian religion was highly cyclical and as far as I can tell never had a true axial revolution. Ritual sacrifices and as you put it "A strong rule of law" to contain violence stayed necessary because that's how it was. Without an understanding of self improvement, Might makes Right is the only thing that works.

All this to say, I disagree with the framing:

Pre-Columbian Central American societies seem to have been some of the most violent in human history.

I'd argue they were just as violent as many other pre-axial civilizations, we just have better records since we encountered them well after our own Axial revolution.

Not going to lie, when I see "SA" I immediately think "Scott Alexander." Maybe I spend too much time in the rat-sphere.

I wonder what “this feels good but it can’t be for a reason” discovery science will support next. Perhaps wearing certain fabrics, grounding (feet on grass), being safely outside during a thunderstorm, wooden homes, and maybe being in spaces where people experience strong positive emotion will have some transference effect.

It's important to test our assumptions ruthlessly - this is what science was based on, and where all the big and useful discoveries are made.

We scoff at our own peril.

This gets back to group differences. At the end of the day it’s extremely taboo to point out any negative differences at a group level. Unless of course that group happens to have been “historically powerful” aka white people or men.

This is a holdover from liberalism which has been breaking down as actual liberalism is finally being implemented. I suspect that over time we’ll either smooth out the differences between groups through intermarrying or technology.

If not, we may be heading into a difficult situation. I’m not convinced the modern world, with the amount of sheer destructive potential we have at our fingertips, can survive without a liberal culture. At least not until we can all fuck off to different planets if we don’t like our current one.

Any nootropics folks here? I know someone mentioned Silexin (lavender oil) recently and I tried it. It has been okay, noticed a decent change but only after I forgot to take it - had some big changes in my life so difficult to tell if that affected me.

The one nootropic substance I do love and use regularly is Kratom. Is is truly powerful and I’m surprised it isn’t more popular. It has strong effects, is really not addictive, and very cheap/easy to produce.

I’ve tried alpha GPC and other stuff in the past but I’m too lazy to do research and leery of messing with my brain. Any highly recommended supplements folks on here like?

There’s also some evidence that stress can significantly increase risk of autoimmune disease which can make this whole argument a bit circular. We don’t have great categories yet for discerning between “real” and “psychosomatic” pain.

Even pain as a concept is poorly labeled and understood.

So the only men that these women consider worth dating are therefore unicorns (celebrities who won the lottery) or people who grew up in wealth. The only way to be successful, have time & hobbies in your 20s is to have your success handed to you.

Anecdotally, this is completely untrue. It is possible to climb in social status / financial status still, albeit perhaps harder than in the past.

If any young men are curious, just go into sales. You make a lot of money, don't have to deal with bullshit if you're competent, and learn social skills from your job.

While you’re still yelling at clouds I’ll be riding my spaceship around new solar systems pumping out utilons by the quadrillion, old man. ;)

Hah you’re fine. I think the terminology here is mostly to blame, “real” and “psychosomatic” don’t really map onto what we’re getting at. Maybe culturally-induced vs mechanical?

It’s a 50 episode series attempting to build a framework for meaning and consciousness. It’s actually quite good although it takes a while to build.

Ahh yes, you might like Scott’s older post Society is Fixed, Biology is Mutable.

The problem with this model is that if these illnesses are truly caused from cultural issues, there can’t be a pill that fixes them. Sure we can try to use the placebo affect but doctors already do that by prescribing Gabapentin or other weak drugs for everything.

Wow that’s quite a big stick. Surely we don’t need that much?

Crackpot theory time: It would be possible to significantly reduce the burden on chronic pain by doing something like the following:

*Experienced debilitating, chronic pain for some period of time

*Changed something plausible about their lives

*Immediately after making the change, noticed something that was an obvious consequence of making the change

*Now mostly find that, while they do sometimes experience pain, the pain is no longer continuous, is usually telling them something specific, and usually does not interfere with their ability to function

I don't really understand this - can you give a concrete example?

Yes in absolute quantitative terms. I don't particularly care about whether individual trans people have it worse than depressed or anxious people, I think the question is beyond confused anyway.

When you're looking at societal issues it makes sense to focus it on the aggregate, in my view. Why the heck would anyone talk about a mental illness 100 people had? (Obviously trans is larger but the media massively overplays the numbers.)