us stuff
Not taking a stance (although I have one), just suggesting some deliberation and care and thinking - it will serve you well with deciding where to put the boundaries.
rizz
Haha it's less about dating in the workplace and more about "ooooh I can fuck this girl in the closet" type trouble. Increasing puritanism and declining doctor respect have thankfully hampered this, but its not uncommon for young male doctors to get into trouble just by following along with flirting - but it's a small unit and now its awkward because you made a (mutual) pass at 1/4 the nurses.
An additional but somewhat unrelated element is this - if you have personal presence, competence, and authority you will start running into other kinds of trouble - people will listen to you because you are the boss.
This is a lesson for anyone in manager roles, but when you are in charge and people respect you....your offhand opinions, tastes, and requests become reality.
Say: "I think this pathology is annoying" and it becomes gospel. Get frustrated with a patient and let it out verbally during a meeting? Now a good chunk of people are going to think of and maybe even treat the patient worse.
"Will no one rid me of this turbulent priest?" can be an accident with sufficient poise and authority and those are things we often try and cultivate because they improve care quality.
Wait until he finds out what they do with crayons.
You know I think you see war less in media these days and OIF/OEF were "small" in many ways. The military is pushed out of our culture in a way that's kinda new given the World Wars and Vietnam have defined American identity for a long time.
I'm wondering if you see vets in political office less now?
One of the first things I encourage students to do is to look at the people around them and pillage them for things that they like and things that they don't. I still remember the names of the physicians who make up who I am.
You should also do the same for the environments you've experienced.
People don't like to admit it but the standards for care and for professionalism in the U.S. are higher than anywhere else.
Is this one of those times? Is being more strict here part of why? Or is it irrelevant. I don't know.
You could make an argument that investment compromises objectivity. You could argue it's sensible in India where knowledge and passion are much less evenly distributed. You could argue that investment trumps anything else. I don't know what the answer is - but you should actively think about it and make choices instead of falling into family involvement as your "this is water" where in the UK it may be more malpractice. Being deliberate will bleed into your professional skills in a positive way*.
I don't think one particular decision is correct, but it is one you want to actively consider.
Two additional points - it's much easier to be involved with family medical care in "medical" care. Psychiatry is inherently trickier for a multitude of reasons. It's also worth noting that it becomes easier to avoid boundary violations if you avoid boundary crossings. Some old school doctors will insist everyone refer to them as doctor so and so not because they are stuffy but because they find it helps with boundaries. Nobody talks back during a code with those guys...and of course there are costs for that.
I'd also note that based off of some of your other writings I suspect you have or will develop the "rizz" as the kids say. Many a young male doctor has gotten into trouble because of that (don't worry outside of work or with staff lol). Caution.
Haven't fallen into that trap, and I don't intend to! The GMC had me remove "Grippy socks, grippy box" from my flair, on pain of death. Goddamit, are there any perks left in the profession?
On a more prurient note, unironically disagree - lability is liquidity after all.
Bruh the place has some pretty great food, for the history buffs it's one of if not the best choices in the U.S. and for men of culture it's got one of the most exquisite art collections in the world. Not a bad spot. Now Philadelphians......
This deserves a long response for you but I have a busy day today.
The good news: you are in good company, all of us need to figure this out.
The bad news: your family will ask for medical advice. Your friend's partner will complain about her vaginal discharge. Your barber will start telling you about their suicide attempt in the 8th grade.
Since you are a psychiatrist you will probably work on polishing your presentation and bedside manner and unless you run into demographic issues or somewhat you will have insane interactions with the general public. The same response to you will be useful professionally.
Figuring this out is hard. In psychiatry it will be a core topic at least, which will help.
Also with respect to psychiatry - don't sleep with your patients. It sounds stupid advice but it isn't.
-If you haven't been before do some of the touristy stuff. Much of it is overrated but it is still worth doing once (ex: Time Square).
-NYC is arguably the greatest city in the world. With the most selection in the world. This means shopping (for a partner maybe?). You ever wanted incredible Indian food but don't have it in your usual area? What about something more specific like Cambodian? Pull up some lists of stuff and go to town.
-You'll be there for a minute, depending on what your situation is it may be worth doing something like taking Amtrak to Philly for a day trip. If you are coming in from say Toronto or otherwise have limited access to the east coast you'd be surprised at how much you can do nearby. You'll never run out of things in NYC but it can be overwhelming and adding extra stuff can be paradoxically helpful.
-I've never been to an IRL Motte/SSC diaspora meet up but I've always figured you'd have a chance at getting some of the paranoid opsec types with an open invite to some location instead of a direct "lets meet up." Food for thought?
Many of the possible organic causes are horrible.
Many of them aren't though! And some if treated may remit.
With respect to timing .....not really brief, but things can get better spontaneously shockingly far out. The human brain gonna do what it do.
The increasing paranoia is concerning but not as unilaterally bad as you might expect, while getting worse is obviously not a good outcome, it can sometimes lead to treatment that makes things better in the long run!
Try and recruit as much support as you can. :/
First things first: "Secure the scene first," "at a cardiac arrest, the first procedure is to take your own pulse," "self-care bro."
However you frame it - this is going to be tough make sure you are getting support. Likely you did not do anything wrong. Try not to blame yourself. Try not to blame yourself for blaming yourself.
Caveats: I deliberately only skimmed so everything is general and pretend it's general if I didn't do a good job making it general (I am not your or her doctor and am not asking the questions required to provide specific or informed advice.
Second: These things are more common than you think and go in all kinds of directions. Be aware that catastrophic decline is on the table, but so is total remission and so is things like backbreaking medical causes. Try not to get locked into a particular hope or despair without more understanding, information, and crucially - time.
Third: You are going to get a lot of shitty medical and psychiatric advice. Your therapist may accidentally be right but already this doesn't seem like a true delusion (insufficiently fixed?) is inconsistent with borderline personality persistence and doesn't really exhibit evidence for bipolar. Could be prodrome however. Don't worry what any of that means that isn't your job. Could be you don't have the language to relay the behavior you are seeing (that's not your fault! You aren't a trained healthcare professional). Most of the geographic area of the country has poor access to psychiatric care (NPs/PAs have some uses in medicine but never in psychiatric care, I've never met a psychiatrist who was willing to privately say something good about an NP except those who were getting a significant financial benefit. With unusual patients they are significantly worse than useless), and while it's out there it is hard to find a FM/IM/ED doc who is sharp on psychiatry which is important because-
Four: In order to meet the criteria for a DSM diagnosis the symptoms have to not be better explained by a medical condition or substance use. Usually the work up for this is inadequate in most settings. The ED will usually get a head scan if the patient has a first episode of psychosis in atypical age range, but they don't always.... Other basic lab work like an RPR usually needs to be done, but they might not have done it. Someone who knows what autoimmune encephalitis is needs to think about it for three seconds. Realistically it isn't any of the rare stuff, but those things do happen. For drugs a UDS is grossly inadequate if she's doing anything weird, which she may be. Patient's get access to a benzo with the wrong metabolite, use some local herb, or buy some weird designer drug. Shit happens and in the case of something like caffeine nobody may ask the right question when it totally explains the psychosis.
With someone who is uncooperative it will be hard, but taking her to a competent PCP under the basis of "hey I'm worried about you its not your fault lets see if anything medical is happening" can sometimes gain traction.
This is difficult however because people who aren't truly mentally ill don't think they have anything wrong with them and are correct and people who are truly mentally ill often have refusal to acknowledge that they are as a symptom.
Medical/substance/environmental/lifestyle causes of psychosis and/or mood disturbance are not as common as simple causes but they aren't rare. If you wish get access to the medical records and google things and make sure the right crap has been done.
Five: Some facts about potentially relevant DSM conditions. -Women get schizophrenia later than men, especially a bump is seen around menopause. -The DSM has a diagnosis of "Brief Psychotic Disorder." Some people have true psychotic symptoms that remit spontaneously (and never come back). -Adequate care can get someone back to normal. It can also get someone normal enough. -The DSM has a diagnosis of "Delusional Disorder" which means someone is otherwise normal but has delusions about a specific thing. -If someone has schizophrenia you will see some combination of other things in addition to delusions. People act weird. Usually the family can pick up on this (but not always). Same is true for other conditions. Take stock of what you noted. Point it out to medical professionals. -Depression can manifest with psychotic features or other significantly concerning behaviors.
Six: Not every behavioral problem is a DSM disorder (they have a cheat option for "unspecified" or whatever but that's not really the same).
This moves out of medicine to the reality of people doing weird shit and having weird beliefs. I think social justice people are crazy! But they aren't DSM relevant. Some problematic behaviors respond well to therapy some don't but you will find people in the population who have something like midlife satisfaction issues, political freak outs and so on.
You can peck around the edges but if this is the case the medical and legal systems (including medication) will be of limited assistance.
This leaves some room for "maybe two years from now she'll be like....that was dumb" but the lack of options isn't really comforting right now.
You should be prepared for the possibility of this being a true medical/psychiatric issue and also for the possibility of it being a "she's changed." Both will be tough to deal with but in different ways.
I'm sorry.
For a few reasons, one is that the hospital is not in charge of the patient's bill, they are in charge of the bill that the patient's insurance gets. They don't have access to or control over that information, what the hospital can provide is something else.
Another is that anything more sophisticated than "the average patient in the ED generates X dollars in charges, here are the error bars" requires significant clinical time to develop. Do you deliver the patient only ICD codes? CPT codes? One primary code vs all encounters with comorbidity? Who is "like me" for expected billing purposes is NOT an easy question.
Another is that this information is materially valuable to the hospital's "enemies" yes that means competing hospitals but also the insurance company who if they have more complete information can leverage that. Famously - hospitals go bankrupt if they only get paid in Medicare and Medicaid (which is less than cost often), extracting the most money from commercial insurance is the only way to stay afloat without significant financial subsidy from the government, with Hahnemann being the most infamous example of how that isn't usually enough. Also see the recent issues with rural hospital failure.
The last reason is that the information is beyond the average person's ability to use and can significant problems. Someone with good insurance might go to the hospital with chest pain, generate 300,000 dollars in charges for their insurance and then be on the hook for a 150 copay. If you get a piece of paper that says "1 percent of ED visits generate charges more than 250,000 dollars" then the average person will sprint away before they can be told that their insurance is never going to charge them that.
You might maintain that you will use this information sensibly and that may be true but the average person is not you and you are unlikely to be you if you are in a moment of medical extremity. The graph isn't that useful and will literally cost lives even if they aren't lives you particularly care about.
Nobody who has complained about this in this discussion or last time has really given me an example of a clinical situation where they would put this information to use. I imagine it's not running away from the hospital when they have a ruptured appendix. It's probably for trying to figure out which colonoscopy is cheaper and shit like that. That's a much more fair use case but hospitals are disincentivized from providing these numbers for multiple financial and liability reasons and it's extremely hard to legislate this given things like the difficulty in defining care settings (What's ASC? You are telling me the ED and Obs are not the hospital even though they are in the hospital and your are on a hospital floor? Oh they are for some things but not others.....blah blah).
Hospital spending is the largest single category of healthcare spending.
My apologies but I don't really feel like we are going to have a productive conversation and we should call it here.
Providers have to decide if they want to give a unified price to all their customers, or if they can predict which type of customer is associated with which kind of cost, and offer different prices based on that.
No?
Nobody is really calling for this and if given a list of priorities (like overall expensive, waiting room times) people will put price transparency at the bottom.
Additionally health system do not decide how much patients pay. Insurance companies do. If you would like more price transparency in how much people pay ask the people in charge of how much patients pay.
It's yet to be demonstrated in ways relevant to the question of the difficulty of providing patient with the price information.
A simple ED visit can cost <5k, 50 thousand dollars, 1 million dollars, or 5 million dollars.
An estimate for your kitchen getting redone is not like this.
The error bars around those are secondary to the fact that when people want an estimate in their mind that estimate is a commitment and being told a range from 500 dollars to 5 million is worthless information.
Yes plenty of healthcare interactions are simpler than that but if you are going to demand estimates for everything you have to capture this problem, if you are going to demand estimates when feasible we already do that.
Some important things to note here:
-
The majority of the average patient's interaction with healthcare are the type of thing where this has some element of technical feasibility. You are likely thinking "okay what's the cash price for a relatively constrained activity like an allergy shot, elective MRI, even a basic procedure like a colonoscopy" the whole system (I'll come back to this) has some possibility of delivering this to you. However the system is designed around the more important and more complicated activities like a hospital stay. If you show up the ED with diverticulitis you could be seen in the ED and sent home with conservative management. You could be put in obs for a day and started on Zosyn and fluids and kept NPO, you could have a perf leading to surgical management, necrosis, and a 3 month hospital stay. Nobody knows any of the numbers associated with this visit until it's done. It's extremely hard to legislate for one but not capture the other, so it's easy to end up with meaningless bullshit numbers if you put a law down. In a healthy system the people involved will try and give you numbers when it's possible. Your doctor will usually be able to estimate what the professional fee for his visit with you will be, but:
-
Physicians aren't in control of this. Usually when this comes up people demand the burden be on the doctor. I have other shit to do....like clinical work? Keeping up with the changes in billing is a full-time job for sometimes something like hundreds of staff. Elsewhere in this thread we have someone who used to work in insurance passing around misinformation - it's hard to keep track of this stuff and estimates are usually considered binding if not legally then in someone's mind. We can't feasible deliver this. Often the billing department can't deliver this until after we do our job because they aren't clinical. You'd need to have a meeting with your insurance, the billing department, and the physician in advance to have something with any accuracy for anything remotely complicated (and again we can get in a spitball distance but people get pissed at healthcare if you are wrong at all it'd be worse than not trying). On a more micro level it's worth keeping in mind that working for a health system these days usually involves surrendering lots of control, including often over billing. I can't control the billing department and what they put down, but:
-
Health systems aren't in control of this. Most importantly we can't control insurance. Insurance decides how much you get stuck with. Usually we get a feel for what common plans and what common charges will end up resulting in but an insurance company can essentially decide to randomly say "no I'm not paying for that" which may or may not get addressed. While I've been rightly smacked on the nose for forgetting about coinsurance and other things like that, ultimately the person who decides what to do with the bill is not me or my hospital and I have no control over them and they are famously awful.
My only nitpick would be that I don't see it as a "vulnerability". I just see it as a constitutive part of being human.
I mean the more objective style we generally see here is extremely valuable most of the time and is usually "better," but it's important to remember that the average person doesn't really think or act like us and that has implications for explanatory power of most of our thinking.
You know it's funny what makes connections in your brain and gives you the eureka moment.
Here I am taking my morning shit, reading this, and my instant response to the conversation here is:
"Oh yeah of course people don't care if this one is 'the story' it just captures the emotions just right, exactly like BLM..."
Oh.
OHHHHHHHHHHH.
Obviously I know intellectually that BLM is an emotional movement about frustration in response to perceived injustice. But I've never really felt it. Until now.
Good reminder that most of us are reasonably good at being objective and decoupling, but those things have vulnerabilities and have chasm sized holes with respect to predicting populations and people.
Physical books or kindle + libgen. I find reading on the phone to be terrible, and really, kindle isn't great either.
Some of this is different strokes for different folks - I would never in a million years ago back to a separate music player.
I will say that I have a kindle and used it over my phone for a long time until I got an oversized phone and then suddenly reading on the phone didn't bother me.
I'd really rather stay focused, because you made a very specific claim, and whether or not healthcare "functions as a market" is not even relevant to it.
My claim was that the price, charge, and cost are all highly different from each other, often have minimal relationship to each other, have little value to the patient, and are highly misleading and hard to understand.
You noted "but I don't see how this is any different from any other industry that faces uncertainty (which is all of them)."
Well yes healthcare is different. That's important. It's inherently obvious in many ways. One of those is that "price, charge, and cost are all highly different..." the other is the problem with the supply and demand curves, the level of governmental intervention...... I provided several examples.
Furthermore -
Two posters in this thread neatly outlined the problem with what you are talking about.
If you charge people for what they use and only what they use and try and give them an answer in advance they get pissed when their hot dog costs 1 million dollars instead of 5.
If you add up the total costs of the ED and do some math to throw out the people who won't or can't pay and then charge people something that more resembles the true cost of the service on a per capita basis they then come on the motte and complain that they sat in a busy ED for 6 hours and got an ultrasound and it costs them how many thousands of dollars? (Sorry dev, but it's a good example).
Ugh we are back to healthcare doesn't function like anything else.
Few if any other lines of business are required by law to provide services to someone who walks in and says they will refuse to pay. Add on the fact that sometimes but not always you can get it covered by the government and the accounting is ferociously hard.
Obviously you can generate numbers like total revenue but turning that into useful information at the patient level is an ethical and political problem long before it becomes a practical one.
It's worth noting that specific market segments in the U.S. can and do do things like this but while that stuff can be a large fraction of the profit it isn't a large percentage of the overall activity.
A large part of the problem is that insurance companies will deliberately provide poor service because their clients are usually unrelated institutions and not the individual patient or anyone on the healthcare side (remember we mostly get our insurance from our employer).
When they do fuckery like the examples I'll provide below nobody has any recourse unless they randomly manage to fuck up the CEO's healthcare or something.
Right now one of the world's most prestigious health systems (Johns Hopkins) is threatening to punt United from their health system. One of the two will blink but the service insurance provides to everybody is awful as hell.
A few classic examples: -My patient has been stable on an inhaler for 20 years. They get new insurance company which is one of the ones that has some kinda of complicated kickback program where they rotate the covered inhaler every year. My patient might die if they change inhalers and switch to one that doesn't work for them, so I can spend 5-10 hours on the phone fighting insurance or just cross my fingers and switch. FUCK THIS.
-Patient is sitting in the hospital and needs rehab placement after discharge. The insurance company refuses to approve rehab. The patient sits in the hospital getting hospital level care for an extra 3-5 days before going to rehab. The insurance company pays for that care. Why did they do this? WE DON'T KNOW.
-Psych patient in the ED, clearly needs involuntary care. Insurance refuses to approve, likely hoping that the patient calms down enough to be sent home with suboptimal care or the ED gets frustrated enough to roll the dice on sending the guy home and hope he doesnt kill anybody. THIS WORKS DAMNIT.
Also the "Hawaii" example: You provide a service, you are the only one on your island who does it. Insurance offers you a deal that's barely over cost for your services. You say no. The insurance company spends the next five years flying patients to one of the other islands for their care until you break or go out of business.
The more charitable explanation for what is going on is that when the private insurance is functionally the whole system (Medicare/Medicaid aside) it has to work for all parts of the system not just the ones where you can make things simple and offer a boutique product like your UK elective stuff.
How old are you?
My life before smart phones was so different. I love that I can pull out and read any book I want, I love that I don't need a separate device for music, I love that I can research anything anytime instead of writing it down and searching through my encyclopedia at home.
Have you ever tried a long road trip with a physical map?
Yeah they ruin a lot of stuff and may not be worth it but don't forget what they've added.
I don't think you are wrong, and at the same time if you look at the NFL the majority of the coaches are quite obviously awful.
Is giving advice just that hard?
Uhhhhhh what? You know animal and human medicine are different right?
The difficulty in the ED is rolling out training to everyone because the modality wasn't as common when most people went through Medical School and Residency.
This is probably the best summary I've ever seen on this topic. Thank you.
Usually (and especially here) my angst is generated by people's frustration with physician salaries, as it's an easy target for frustration but is A (but not the) load bearing feature of the U.S. health system and angry people don't care.
I can tell you that in my personal practice I try and be cost aware when possible but that a number of practical concerns come first. For one my job is to get people better, not spare their wallet, the threat of litigation makes it extremely hard to deviate from that even when both the patient and myself want to.
In some situations it appropriate (or required, most often with homeless people) to be more careful about this but I can't always do so. A classic example is inhalers, insurance change what they cover all the time, if I don't know your specific insurance plan well....it's just going to be wrong some of the time, even if I do know the insurance. Hospitals have invested in tools like e-prescribing which help with this.....but all kinds of negative effects of those things have also been generated.
One of those is that I am highly limited in what I can do. The hospital owns most physicians right now because of increased costs like EMRs we do what they say. Some times that involves practicing on our license essentially. It also frequently means things like me signing away my right to bill the hospital just does it for me based off of what I charted.
When it comes to inpatient medicine ultimately I'm going to be like "I'm sorry you are going to get a fuck off huge bill and I have no control over it and depending on your insurance that may or may not be a problem." I am also incentivized to not think about it too much to avoid burn out.
For outpatient medicine usually it's a stripped down professional fee that I have no influence over and a medication bill that I can try and save you money on.
I don't really know what percent of patients have co-insurance, and as you demonstrated and like I said I don't think about co-insurance at all most of the time. This is because legally and practically it has nothing to do with me, that's what the regulatory and legal environment have decided.
Usually when this kind of thing comes up it's "put the doctors on it" but the hospital and insurance company are in charge!

So a few years ago I ran into a cover of "A Cruel Angel's Thesis" with Frank Sinatra on vocals (AI obviously).*
I remember this kind of thing having a brief moment, getting knocked off of the internet....but might now be back given everything that has happened since.
Anyone have any recommendations along those lines?
Or really any stellar mashup/remix I'm a sucker for those.
General recommendation: The White Panda.
*https://youtube.com/watch?v=FLmt6dQmMTU&list=RDFLmt6dQmMTU&start_radio=1
More options
Context Copy link