@Throwaway05's banner p

Throwaway05


				

				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

				

User ID: 2034

Throwaway05


				
				
				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 2034

You know, the American edge of this kinda stuff runs into a few issues. One is our legitimate exceptionalism, we are the superpower, we don't usually need to make compromises. That's not a completely terrible approach and for long enough that most of the people alive in the country have only experienced that....it worked.

It limits our facility with actually going through this process however.

Part of it is that people know that something can be shaved off without impairing patient care. This is probably right but nobody knows (or agrees) what it is.

Then you have American specific attributes - we are pussies when it comes to pain for instance, we are more willing to seek and use care, we are too independent, and so on.

Low societal temperament to say "yeah let some mee-maws go down if it saves a few hundred million dollars."

But yes you are right that this conversation is happening just less transparently, and at the same time if you came over here I think you'd be shocked at how much we through at things.

Is it good that we'll code a clearly dead kid for 90 minutes? Is it good that we will give homeless crack cocaine Fred the standard of care 12 times a month when he presents with psychiatric issues caused by his recreational polypharmacy?

I don't know.

I am however at times horrified and at times proud.

I try and keep in mind that (in the U.S. for sure) the PUBLIC HEALTH apparatus absolutely did some shady business and doctors were complicit. This killed a ton of trust.

MRNA vaccines had legit concerns when they were being forced on everyone and I knew plenty of docs (including liberals) who had concerns initially for politics came into it.

Vaccines have always been a tough topic as far back as the Salk/Sabin days lol.

you will cause new cancers once you scale to hundreds of thousands of people.

Ugh this is one of the biggest issues with large scale medical interventions like vaccines. Yes your vaccine can be perfectly safe for plenty of sigma but if you give it billions of people some weird shit is going to happen!!!!

Laziness or ineptitude is certainly a cause at times but "I don't want to lose my livelihood" is a potent motivator.

ED pan-scanning is functionally "standard of care" because using your training effectively is going to result in a few miss or near misses at some point and it is much safer to hide behind the donut of truth.

When laziness and safety line up it's really hard to alter behavior.

However there is something to be said for "we are the richest country why can't we have the most expensive care and avoid making certain kinds of mistakes."

I don't think people realize the trade offs we are making and it's certainly worth a discussion but we rarely do that.

"Good surgeons know how to operate, better ones when to operate, and the best when not to operate."

Alternatively one of the rules of The House of God - "The delivery of good medical care is to do as much nothing as possible."

Both are far harder than they sound.

Are we talking high co-insurance costs here? I've never been on or been offered a health plan with a significant co-insurance burden although I'm aware they could hypothetically exist.

Interestingly, google-gpt says about 20% of plans have co-insurance.

So they certainly exist but aren't common.

If you are paying co-insurance charges would matter more but that dovetails into the rest of the discussion on this topic.

Outside of co-insurance - am I brain farting on anything other than: premium, deductible, co-insurance, co-pay? I guess uncovered nonsense.*

*Out of network costs are a separate problem that I forgot to mention in the other line of questioning (which is why my point is that shit is stupidly complicated!). Health systems don't really control who is and is not in network, it's usually a insurance fucking the consumer and hospital mechanism since canceling a scheduled surgery because Phil is the only anesthesia provider networked and he's off today or because the thing is emergency. This is one of the reasons why the hospital "know" they usually know what they charge, rarely know what the price is, and have zero ability to control and generally predict what the insurance company will pass along to the patient especially in uncontrolled situations like a hospital stay.

But yes thank you for reminding me of some of the other insurance related expense elements that I don't think about as they aren't in my plan, I dont think this alters the thrust of my argument though which is that the insurance is in charge of how much a patient pays and they have lots of ways to change that number away from the "price" and "charge."

I didn't mean your specific situation, apologies if it came across that way.

In this case, there is a pre-negotiated master charge list

Those numbers should still have been negotiated with some bullshit juju thought right?

One of the crazy things

Ahh shit, I meant to also blame providers in my post and may not have. Yes it's not uncommon to see someone and have them go "oh I can't handle that" and send you to the ED. A good chunk of that is absolutely to shift liability and is inappropriate but common. Biggest issue is when you say something unrelated to a specialist. Tell your endocrinologist that you checked your blood pressure at home and it was 160 over something and they'll send you to the ED even if that isn't quite appropriate. Another common problem is increasing specialization leading to specialists not knowing as much outside their field and PCPs being limited in what they can do and know (especially with midlevels). Lastly you have legitimately complicated shit, I don't really do peds at all IIRC from med school people are super fucking careful with kids that young. I think an urgent care would probably also sent you to the ED especially if ultrasound was standard of care.

Incidentally peds providers get paid way way way way way less than adult medicine.

If our child was on telemetry

It sounds like you were paying for hospital level of resources and in ye olden days your kid would have been admitted but now instead it can be managed conservatively outpatient - but you need inpatient level equipment (the ultrasound). One of those weird gaps.

Ultrasound is in a weird spot because it's evolving from a "nobody in the ED to can do this" to "we are starting to train everyone from day one to do this because its safe and cheap" but we are in the middle of that process. Wouldn't be shocked if in 5-10 years most PCP offices were doing it.

Pretty normal to essentially charge for "doctor - seeing you, thinking about you, and documenting you" and "things doctor did to you."

However in this case you could alternatively summarize it as "random blender of shit put together in an attempt to get the insurance company to pay enough for the hospital to stay afloat."

Agree with the other poster and - insurance companies practically practice medicine all the time by deciding what is covered and what isn't, they deny this is the case however "you can still get X thing we just won't pay for it" works very well as a legal smoke screen and in the case of things like malignancy they can absolutely drag their heels and turn your melanoma from a short procedure to life altering or death causing.

Okay so two things going on here:

  1. The funny numbers bit. The system is designed around everyone having insurance. The numbers on a bill a not random but can essentially be thought of as random. The hospital negotiates with the insurance by saying X and the insurance says 1/4X and then the hospital says 1/2X and that's what the insurance decides to pay. It's stupid but it is the system, the numbers are funny on purpose. If you don't have insurance you get absolutely obliterated but you can usually negotiate with the hospital because they know the numbers are funny, but "you have insurance" and "this weird shit happens" is how society and government have decided to run this bullshit so that's the way it is.

  2. The ED is for if you are dying, if you are not dying you are not supposed to be there, and it is expensive in the way that you'd expect for "this is the place where you are dying."

Unpacking this is complicated and it results in a mix of things that are the fault of various patients and things that aren't, but for the most part the ED is more expensive, complicated, and a higher level of care than actually being in the hospital. On a hospital floor things happen slowly - you might have a handful of nurses on a step down floor, your doctor might see you once at the beginning of the day. In the ED nurses have few patients, numerous types of staff you might not even think about are running around constantly (like the lady whose only job is to get people's insurance), people are in and out of your room, labs come back stat, people are constantly checking if you are dying or not. Most patients in the ED are on telemetry, most patients admitted to the hospital aren't. All these things are extremely expensive and a lot of them happen outside of patient understanding and line of sight. The ED is more like an ICU. This is part of why patients being boarded in the ED is such a catastrophe.

In any case the ED is designed such the majority of patient's are pre-triaged. You are "supposed" to go to your PCP first, or people to call your PCP's answering service. Most people used to do that while the modern model was being developed but they don't anymore. Many people use the ED as a PCP, go get obvious "wait and see" things checked out, don't use common sense, and so on. Other people can't really be blamed because they have a sensible complaint and don't triage because they aren't medical people, or because it's hard to get a PCP these days or one with a good answering service. But the system isn't designed for this. Add in other things like homeless and illegal immigrants don't or can't pay and you've got a mess.

Part of this is specifically American - in other countries people use PCP as designed more, or are more comfortable with waiting, but that isn't how we are. Step-down EDs or the equivalent have been triaged but they hard because if you fuck it up you'll get sued to hell (another American problem).

Additionally emergency care doesn't reimburse well from private or government insurance so one has an incentive to build out and staff EDs to match the volume they are getting.

The last piece is the professional fee aspect - you are paying for someone with a lot of training to figure out how safely they can do the minimum on you. Ideally we diagnose without any testing, give you the minimum of interventions, and use our brain power to rule everything that could kill you or be going wrong with your body.

Because we are on the hook if anything goes wrong! But we also don't want to give you an expensive full body scan that will give you cancer in thirty years.

NPs have much lower professional fees but they also scan and test people much more and cause more bad outcomes and unnecessary complications.

You pay ED physicians so much for them to safely do nothing, which is weird as hell but is what the ED is designed for.

I think we need to go back to basics - it seems trivial to me that healthcare doesn't function as a market and doesn't work like other non-governmental activities. I provided a few examples of this in my replies.

If we can't get on the same page about that I'm not sure we'll be able to talk productively.

Oh yeah I see - yes we are in an area where you run into two problems "this should have a billing code and doesn't" (classic example again - insurance fuckery) and as in this case "even if this had a billing code it would be unwise to use."

If you use "low priority - don't need to see patient" billing code on someone and they have an adverse outcome you are going to get eviscerated on the stand "you could have saved her life if you just went to see her!" and going to straight to bankruptcy.

I don't know what the right solution is to this but I am pro-tort reform.

It's true that I under emphasize coinsurance and deductibles in these conversations but the deductible is going to end up used fully if anything significant happens in most insurance plans and should be considered a sunk cost when evaluating plan choices.

Ultimately using hospital pricing information if it was available would be difficult since the hospital prices interact with your insurance in unpredictable way and a lower sticker price could end up being an order of magnitude higher when comparing after insurance costs.

You are right that I need to be more active at remembering that in some of the individual situations though, even if it doesn't impact the more structural issues.

Modern U.S. healthcare is probably more adversarial than you think because of the role of insurance companies that will try and refuse expensive things.

This doesn't work well for a million reasons (including Pharma basically paying the insurance company to only accept certain med requests). But supposedly we have these systems in place including with Medicare/Medicaid (sort of).

The problem is that nobody agrees what is an appropriate use of these things and in America that's going to be impossible.

Even if you can get agreement on what kinds of things are worth it........every last person is going to disagree when it's their turn to be told no, especially when it's no....you'll die now.

With respect to fraud it does happen but it's rarer than you think, calling out Medicare fraud is actually incredibly profitable for the whistleblower. Which is neat and stops a lot of bad stuff.

The government has also come under fire in the last few years for faking fraud because they had a quota system.

For context I have Idiopathic Thrombocytopenia and I think my OB wanted to ask how to titrate Prednisone.

Yeah my suspicion is this is one of those weird situations where the OB legitimately needed help and wanted to make sure the hematologist got paid for their expertise. They may even have done you a solid by not making you go to a random doctor's office unnecessarily since this was OP.

What was supposed to happen was that the doctor was supposed to review your chart (probably did), see you (clearly no), and write a note (maybe?).

Not seeing you and saying they did is fraud but it's also okay sometimes. Does the delirious or sedated patient really need to see the psychiatrist to give an agitation rec? No.

Unfortunately physicians do a lot of unreimbursed work (like providing education to colleagues) and attempts to get some credit for this can be sketchy or fraudulent without actually being bad behavior.

Obviously in your case you may have appreciated the chance to ask the doc questions but most people would be excited if offered "hey let me just call this guy instead of scheduling you an extra appointment somewhere else" but it's technically not allowed.

Sometimes what we can vs cant bill for is stupid as hell (for instance: dealing with insurance!).

Since the hematologist would have accepted legal liability they def wanted to make sure they got paid and because most people's bill turn into a 20 dollar copay it doesn't get looked at closely.

Personally I think this is sketchy but fair, for those who think otherwise consider the side effects of formalizing things and reducing flexibility.

Insurance is already calculating the relevant numbers, they can just show them to their customers / the public.

I don't think this is accurate. Insurance knows how much it costs to insure someone in aggregate and where to set their premiums.

They do not know how much stuff actually costs a hospital in aggregate (they attempt to guess and knowledge of this is extremely valuable to the insurance company and extremely detrimental to the hospital). They know what the hospital claims the stuff costs them in aggregate. Often the hospital doesn't know how much it really costs because even though they can add up everything they spent money on it is incredibly difficult to breakout what was spent on what because how do you account for things like admin costs. Do you spread them equally over all departments? Do you try and track what department those admin were spent working on (expensive, hard). How do you account for all the salaried people taking on extra work for no additional pay like physician committee work. Hospital employee a lot of people, a lot of types of people, many places will account for things differently than each other.

All of that is the aggregate stuff.

Nobody knows how much many types of individual things are going to cost a specific patient because the error bars are so large. You also have stuff like "this patient is ready for a downgrade to rehab but the insurance company isn't approving the prior auth because it is Labor Day. Does that suck? Yes. Does it need to get paid for by somebody? Yes. Is the insurance going to pay for it? Usually. Is that hard to calculate when giving cost estimates? Yep.

Sometimes the insurance company is increasing the costs for no reason other than their own inefficiency!

In short medical billing is hideously complicated and doesn't work like anything else and that should be trivially obvious because of what healthcare is necessitates that it not function like other economic activity.

Attempts to criticize or change it should necessitate some Chesterton's fence type thinking.

You do see this kind of behavior sometimes and it can be extremely sketchy/represent illegal behavior or it can be ".....fine" or outright "okay."

Be curious if the hematologist dropped a note on you.

Examples of each:

-A kickback program of some kind. They are rare but they still (theoretically) exist.* Typically in shady for-profit health systems. Hematologist didn't do anything useful and didn't see you.

-An annoying consult or weird consult interaction. OB asks the hematologist something. Maybe it was a stupid question, maybe it wasn't. Maybe they dropped a note on your chart maybe they didn't. Now it gets weird. Do they go see you? They might be doing coverage in another city. Did the OB say they talked to you even though they were supposed to just ask a non patient specific question? Did they actually review your chart?

Probably they reviewed your chart and provided legitimate advice but didn't want to see you because it didn't alter management or was grossly inconvenient. Now they've done something and have legal liability so the hospital will insist they bill and it is somewhat legit. Radiologist and pathologist don't come to see you.

-They did actually see you. This is most common (we inpatient at least). Stop by at 4am and make a token effort to make you up? Oh you are in the bathroom, I'll come back later? These are obviously annoying as hell as a patient but depending on the interaction it may meet standard of care (especially for consultants that may not need to see your or talk to you). I promise you whoever did this is actually doing work somewhere or otherwise engaged in fruitful activity.

Of course it could be total nonsense and someone actually scheduled an appointment accidentally.

*I've worked/trained at some places where I've had concerns but never been approached or had any actual evidence.

Ask them the most ridiculous thing they couldn't get covered or documentation change they had to make to get coverage.

Should get some good stories.

The cost-benefit landscape is high-dimensional, fuzzy, and rapidly branching with time-delayed consequences. "Informed" consent is a complete misnomer and I have to wonder if given complete price transparency whether healthcare wouldn't completely devolve into a Market for Lemons.

Psychiatry is a great example of this. Do you prescribe the homeless schizophrenic the best drug or the cheapest one or the one that is easiest to take. These are very often all different medications and have different results.

In a different patient population you might ask the patient to decide what makes sense for them, but the schizophrenic has cognitive deficits from the disease (not counting any other factors like malnutrition and drug use). They can't adequately consent to to complicated cost benefit analysis.

Even highly educated, intelligent, frickin healthcare workers botch this when they are on the receiving end.

So then we have to wonder if the plan is to dictate patients get the cheapest medication not the most effective one....or vice versa.

As you mention it's complicated and ethically difficult.

One of my attendings in training did an exercise with a patient where the patient was requesting something that was technically appropriate but would cause prior auth difficulties and could be avoided.

It was at the end of the day so he told the patient he would get it approved if the patient sat with us and if the patient left he would be discharged from the practice (deeply unethical but hilarious).

The three of us sat there for something in the 2-3 hour range while the attending argued with insurance, completely unpaid.

It worked.

Was it worth it? No.

Did the insurance win even after they approved the med? Yep.

I mean I think that happens every time?

"Oh shit that looks bad" here are basic details "oh shit we were wrong."

This one was certainly "worse" (as in looked bad) than most of the others.

I think the dems blew a lot of juice in magnifying Floyd though, and as mentioned all kinds of other pressure cooker stuff was going on.

Accepting the fixed costs of a quality insurance plan is obviously the best idea.

After that it depends on risk tolerance. A hospital is required to treat you if you show up even if you clearly won't pay you can then deal with medical debt. This is how homeless people function. Obviously not a great idea but you pay nothing (and also get no preventative care).

Speaking of which if you have any medical complexity you need a real plan.

That said if you are otherwise healthy you can try and get a catastrophic plan or other high deductible plan and realize the risks. Again recurring expenses cause problems.

I will draw your attention to direct primary care however which may be viable - you basically pay for a subscription to your PCP. Obviously this has recurring costs but it means you cut out insurance and therefore it can be much cheaper (because dealing with insurance is expensive for your doctor also) and if your PCP is good you won't need much in terms of specialists.

However you need to pay for other types of costs somehow (like hospital care).

As long as these are reasonably predictable, you can calculate a price. The specific issue you're talking about might mean that the price is higher, not that it's impossible to give an accurate number.

Doing these necessitates a bunch of complicated questions. Do you refund people if they "use" less? Can you charge them more if they "use" more? Is it fair to charge someone 4k instead of 100 dollars because of an alcholic? If we are going to make everyone pay in and pay out according to who uses it why not just simplify it and make it socialized medicine which is the logical solution?

Developing accurate numbers is complicated, time consuming, and expensive and puts hospitals at financial risk due to insurance shenanigans. If you make it voluntary they'll do it where it makes sense like they do now. If you make it mandatory you need to put a number on how much you are willing to increase healthcare costs to do that and answer some of the questions above with respect to what to do about it when it fucks up.

I wrote up a response a few different ways but ultimately I couldn't write something satisfying without a lot of follow-up questions so I'll just point out that usually the reason why things are weird and complicated is because the insurance company refused to pay for something common sense so the hospital had to do some equally weird shit in response.

Fuck. That. Noise. So, an army of functionaries use their best judgement to try to translate a doctor's notes into one or more of a series of codes to reconstruct the exact service provided? I

Depending on your perspective it's either far better or worse than you imagine.

The physician's note was historically designed as a record of medical decision making on a patient and we are still primarily trained in this task. However they are now used as a record for billing, a record for legal ass covering, delivered to patients, used for cross staff communication, and as repository of information for research purposes.

As there is the greatest financial interest in doing so you more often see time and effort spent on maximizing billing but it's totally reasonable.

If I see a patient with high blood pressure I'm going to write something like "yo this patient has hypertension get some amlodipine in here stat."

Then the insurance goes oh we aren't going to pay because you didn't establish this patient has hypertension. What do you mean their blood pressure is high and its been high for 20 years and the last doctor had them on amlodipine.

Nope no hypertension.

(Billing staff: psst doc write primary hypertension)

.....Primary hypertension.

OH WHY DIDNT YOU SAY SO HERE HAVE SOME MONEY.

The classic for a long time was the Review of Systems which is sort of deprecated now but had resulted in tens of thousands of doctors being trained that if they didnt ask about renal, dermatologic and reproductive symptoms they couldn't get paid for this trauma patient whose arm fell off.

"The patient was anesthetized!!!!!" "Well just write 'patient declined to answer seven times.'"

It's not charging you for every 15 minutes of time like a lawyer its struggling to get paid for stuff we clearly did.

Yes some fraud and abused exists but essentially every physician has to be constantly thinking "what humps do I jump through to get paid for the basic standard of care thing I did."

Many don't like this but you can't really function in our system without having insurance and this has been attempted to be enshrined in law.

The reasons for this are many but some things to keep in mind:

-Medical care is one of the most inelastic things arounds. If you need something or you will die that's a pretty good thought experiment for what perfect inelasticity looks like. For things that are less inelastic (primary care appointments say) usually not doing it is the actuarially wrong decision and demand should be more inelastic.

-Patient's aren't the ones paying. Insurance pays. "Randomly" your insurance or the health system or some weird combination of laws and policies screws you. The government tries to close these but it turns out to be really hard to do for a variety of reasons.

-Insane fuck off cost overruns are more common and possible in medicine than in other areas. Compared with say car insurance - the number of cars on the road worth over a million dollars is incredible small. Your chance of crashing into one of those cars and somehow being on the hook is one in a million. Major complications of surgery are 1%-10% depending what we are talking about, certainly orders of magnitude more (yes I know I'm missing some things about car insurance for the sake of simplicity). You can just not drive. Everyone has health and the lack of it - and it can become phenomenally expensive to manage through no fault of your or own or fault of your own. Getting a liver transplant or ECMO is a multi-million dollar endeavor.

Between those three things healthcare does not resemble any other industry. It's probably most similar to national defense in its fundamentally "non-economic" nature and that's why both of those things are usually run by the government.

But We Don't Do That Here.

Also - now insurance companies can use fancy computers and actuarial tables to even things out and stay functional but if you tried to do this directly with health system you may end up with something like: "hey this thing should cost 100 dollars but instead it costs 4000 because that guy over their refuses to stop drinking soda and vodka instead of water." People get pissed by that in the U.S.