@Throwaway05's banner p

Throwaway05


				

				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

				

User ID: 2034

Throwaway05


				
				
				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 January 02 15:05:53 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 2034

My very red tribe buddy back home, who watched it and found it benignly viewable, asked me to watch it and explain what the anger is all about.

If you just watch it, absent any knowledge of the context or milieu it's bad - just mostly bad in the way that most popular entertainment is bad. Inoffensively and boringly so.

Someone who is truly red tribe is unlikely to hit the common fail states. Someone from that background is probably used to just passively consuming TV (and is therefore unlikely to not notice or care about bad/inconsistent writing, poor cinematography and so on*). They also probably don't know that Star Wars has a rule about having no white male primary protagonists. They don't know about the interviews ranting about Star Wars fans, men, red tribers, etc.

It's entirely possible to watch a season of Star Trek Discovery and not notice that their were no straight white men with a speaking role who weren't fascists but once you start noticing its hard to go back.

Your friend probably hasn't gone through that process, and if he's a real red triber he's probably in a supportive environment. Grey tribe and questioning blue tribe people feel like they are in a hostile environment and are far more likely to notice and get upset about these kinds of things.

Lastly: given the way that Disney cancels projects, especially ones with political correlates like this one (typically they just.....keep saying they are working on it until everyone forgets) the fact that they actually cancelled it tells you how bad it must have been in a watch-metrics sense.

*Compare: some people watched The Last Jedi and walked out of the theater when Admiral Purple Hair turned her ship into a KKV because it fundamentally invalidates decades of writing and world building. Lots of people went "oooooh pretty." The latter isn't invalid but a lot of Star Wars fans were the former type of person.

Edit: let me give a plot example. Here's the season summary: the Jedi were evil AND incompetent, and lesbian space witches were the true power of the force. You can see why this may upset someone with investment in the rest of Star Wars.

The men who have entirely stopped reading and replaced it with video games are equally matched by the women who have stopped reading and replaced it with social media.

The men who would be traditionally reading a lot still read a ton it's just been replaced with non-fiction and stuff like this. Reading forum posts and /r/HobbyDrama or whatever is reading, it's just not fiction. And again, there are still large communities of men clamoring for fiction that appeals to them just a lot of them are looking at Royal Road or other stuff outside of traditional publishing.

Demand exists, supply is constrained. And again we see this in other markets impacted by wokeness.

Overall reading is down but as suggested in my link by someone who knows more about this than either of us, that doesn't need to be gendered.

Tons of ink and YouTube hours have been spilled about the difficulty in getting male themed products out there, and the removal of male appeal from existing products, and the way Asia doesn't do this and a single Manga has more sales than the entire Western comics industry, and how companies are losing out on hundreds of millions of dollars in sales by doing this....etc. I think you'd have to make a case for why this would suddenly not apply to this niche the all these other things are having the same problem.

It's hard to find specific articles in the moment because this finding is against the narrative, but over the years I've seen tons of complaints from male authors (some of who have published with success) about this.

I did find a Huffington Post article from 2010 which may as well have been from 1872 in Culture War years commenting.

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/why-men-dont-read-how-pub_b_549491

I cannot imagine how much worse it has gotten since then.

Yeah I read those guys in High School and College because it seemed like The Thing To Do and so on but these days I just switched to lowbrow book-crack since I have to read so much non-fiction for work.

Ideally later in my career I'll switch back.

...and for people who read way too much and who have worked through most of the backlog.

Nope not me.

If you are talking about the backlog than sure, but the vast majority of the books I've read in the last 5 years have been self published/online and while a few legacy authors are still around there isn't an abundance of new appealing stuff.

I'll admit that having a friends group that is interested probably helps, none of my IRL contacts really read fiction so I have to go off of reddit etc fro recs and /r/fantasy for example is pretty fucking woke.

I don't think I've seen a book recommended on /r/printsf that was written in the last 5-10 that wasn't by Adrian Tchaikovsky.

One of the most startling aspects of the woke revolution is the way select companies have chosen to just leave money on the table and abandon profit. Disney has been the most obvious example of this but it's pretty common in nerd hobbies and you see a lot of it in the comic book and video game industries.

With respect to publishing you'll hear anecdotes of male authors with a good idea being told that they just "aren't looking for your kind of book" right now or whatever.

Authors in the PF/LIT RPG genres often have massively profitable Patreon's indicating that the market exists, but struggle to get published using traditional methods. It's stupid but it is the same mistake a lot of business entities are right now.

Somehow what is happening in video games and comics is even worse however.

Two things are happening at once here:

-Traditional publishing is pushing men out, likely for culture war reasons. Unsurprisingly this has resulted in a huge bloom of non-traditional publishing for masculine focused genres (ex: Patreon and Progression Fantasy). The readers are still there, just the big publishers are mostly not selling to them and are confused why they aren't buying.

-Reading in general is down, less so in women's genres. Women still buy romance books for instance.

So if you want to see more reading by men you can look at the male genres (again Progression Fantasy, LitRPG are BIG right now).

The rest of the west has less of the general anti-intellectualism and therefore more reading so you can look there.

Something I've noticed in my social group is that the majority of men who still read are reading non-fiction for life improvement or knowledge development. I bet this group is mostly unchanged from the past it's just the fiction guys have been chased out or fled.

Second this! (both parts)

So I've benefited from this. I have a relatively common name, and also a significant amount of discoverability on search engines using the correct search terms, but the ways most people search they instead catch one of the several people with wikipedia entries who have the same name.

I've had dates report this to me (women doing the usual stalking to figure out if someone is a creep), so I suspect you may be protected in the same way.

/r/CredibleDefense suggests that it's primarily a way of redirecting and exhausting resources, since the Russian war machine is incredibly slow and lumbering. Little desire to take and hold territory, more to force them to deploy a bunch of resources and then teehee and peace out. Russia probably knows this, but because of the propaganda aspect...they have to make the mistake.

Yep.

Lots of people commit crimes and scheme in various ways. Mental illness that would result in this behavior (like Schizophrenia) appears earlier in life the vast majority of the time. The personality structure we usually see with this kind of thing, outside of explicit ideology (ex: religious extremism) tends to boil over earlier in life, see: school shooters. Personality disorders of all kinds dial down later in life, in part because the people with the worst manifestations get killed, kill themselves, or end up more or less permanently engaged with the legal system.

He could be the exception that proves the rule of course, but the usual stuff is less likely given what we know about his life history and success.

He doesn't pattern match to a serial killer, someone struggling with psychosis, cultural bound attacker (or other ideologue/extremist).

It's very, very weird.

My suspicion is that this was a literal troll. Supposedly a lot of people in the breakdancing community (and general dancing community) were unhappy about its inclusion in the olympics as they feel it goes against the counter culture roots of the performance and because it's more of an artistic endeavor than an athletic one.

I watched her performance live and it seemed like she did have technical skills but preferred to use a more artistic interpretive dance style. Her outfit was also a vibe in a way that she had to know about.

Could have been a protest.

Him being that crazy doesn't square very well with the rest of his life history.

My theory is that somebody (likely the FBI) set up a fake arms deal and he realized it a bit too early but equally too late to get out, so being faced with life in prison he decided to just lash out and went the murder suicide route.

The FBI, hid their involvement for the obvious reasons, which is something they've tried to do in the past in response to various fuck ups.

It's a movement 100% centered around an ancient guy with little real interest in politics and no real possibility of a successor that doesn't switch back to usual Republican politics. Trump would be functionally gone at this point except for screeching on social media and attempting to make himself relevant with endorsements if he won last time.

The anti-woke and normal republicans exist independent of Trump and will exist after he is gone. MAGAists are Trump fans.

Hell, if he somehow managed to get himself elected for a third term....guy would just die of old age.

The easiest way to end team MAGA is to let Trump win, suck it up for four years, and then he'll be done and go back to golfing for the rest of his life. If he had won last time MAGA would be already over. If he loses he'll probably spend at least four years complaining with support from his base.

If you want the anti-woke impulse or populists to drift off that's a separate problem, but the MAGAists will go away when he does. Let him win and the timer starts and then he'll be bored and gone.

None of this is easy.

Some thoughts.

-One offered definition of delusion is: "a delusion is a fixed false belief based on an inaccurate interpretation of an external reality despite evidence to the contrary." Not mentioned here is the importance of cultural context. One of the reasons why it's not appropriate to label a Democrat or Republican, or a woke activist, or a ghost believer, or a religious person delusional is because their is some element of shared cultural support for the beliefs. This is important to keep in mind.

-Level of fixation and ignoring evidence to the contrary is variable. Delusions are some of the hardest symptoms to treat with medication but they can be treated, at times very successfully. Patient when less sick (and sickness can be caused by stress, sleep deprivation, medical sickness) may find that they still believe the thing but have the insight to lie about it to someone else (which they may not when fully decompensated), may be willing to say something like "I guess it's possible that this isn't true" or many have it resolve in totality.

-With schizophrenia it is more common to have a prodrome and/or progression of symptoms but it's not universal, especially with complicated factors like medical illness, severe stress, drugs, and other psychotic disorders like bipolar with psychotic features. Schizophrenia specifically involves a combination of factors and you'll generally see the negative symptoms, gross disorganization and other things that give you the whole "this guy is crazy" vibes. Disease like "delusional disorder" exist (patient believes one thing or a category of things without the other symptoms like hallucination and functional decline. Example: husband absolutely convinced his wife is cheating on him and seemingly nothing else is wrong. These patients can be very "safe" but are extremely terrifying to me on an existential level lol.

-As above mental illness is often defined as deviation from cultural norms and functional impairment. This gets hairy. Homosexuality was at one point a mental illness, does not appear appropriate now....but by this definition is that only because it's now culturally acceptable? Woke people with woke anxiety appear to be deviating from cultural norms and often have severe functional impairment, but they are social support for the beliefs. Shit's complicated.

-In the case of the more traditional disease like schizophrenia we can look at brain imaging, see things improve with antipsychotics but our understanding of what's going on is incomplete and the philosophical questions have tension with the medical ones.

-Often we are just saved by the fact that most people who are sick and present themselves for psychiatric care are obvious. Their are other types of mental illness that are more often seen by non-psychiatric doctors for general medical care because they stay out of trouble and function well (ex: schizoid personality disorder). This complicates matters.

-Other types of psychiatric disease like OCD, Autism, and Anxiety can appear psychotic and push into psychosis territory (maybe even become psychosis?).

-Leaning on formal diagnostic criteria helps greatly for reducing ambiguity but again most cases are obvious. It is possible that not obvious cases exist in large numbers and healthcare just doesn't see them because they don't need it.

What specifically would you like to know?

Initial specialty education and cross specialty education often results in some pretty solid plain English resources, not sure how this will parse to someone without a medical background but here's an example website that gets tossed around by Psych to teach other specialties about Psych considerations: https://www.bulletpsych.com/topics

The first topic is psychotic spectrum disorders! Speaking of which that's probably the highest yield concept here. In medicine we tend to be obnoxiously specific about our terms (for good reason).

Psychosis refers to a person losing the ability to discern what's real and what it isn't (Sidebar: borderline refers to the borderline between psychosis and neurosis, which tells you a little bit about the behavior of people with borderline personality disorder). It doesn't mean that a person is evil or engaged in criminal behavior.

A number of things can cause psychosis - chronic or acute medical illness, the effects of recreational drugs, another mental disorder (like Bipolar disorder).

People who are psychotic may or may not be aware that the voices and experiences are not real, often this very neatly matches up with severity and someone may have "insight" when on medication and well treated however this is not a hard rule.

The big ticket manifestations of psychosis are delusions and auditory hallucinations (typically: "voices"). The latter is pretty self-explanatory but it's worth noting other hallucinations exist but are less common - if someone has tactile hallucinations or visual hallucinations the issue is more likely to be non-psychiatric in nature. Delusions are a bit more complicated. Someone believes something that isn't true. This can be benign ("my neighbors are from Mars but that doesn't bother me in any way") or very scary ("all the doctors work for the CIA and are going to sterilize me so I better kill them").

Additionally you'll see things like disorganized speech, disorganized behavior, and "negative symptoms" like passivity and reduced emotional range.

Something to note specifically about schizophrenia is that it's a somewhat progressive, chronic disease that usually manifests in early adulthood that requires medication management. Even with mild symptoms the risk of progression is high and therapy and willpower alone are not adequate to treat it. You'll see horrible things like a young lawyer from a rich family slowly decompensate over the years, get disbarred, run out of money, and run out of family patience, leaving them homeless and destitute. It blows.

On a funny but dark note, these patients can often be hilarious through just saying something funny, or behavior in a grossly irrational or inconsistent way that can't help but make you laugh.

They are also often dangerous.

We also have a psych trainee here self made human I'm too much of a boomer to tag him but I'm sure he'd have a lot to add.

Though I'd add that modern jobs struggle to sufficiently fulfill many primal female urges as well.

I'm not sure this is accurate. Many female jobs: Nursing, Teaching, HR, etc. seem to scratch feminine itches and are either high status or have significant social support for arguing they should be high status.

In contrast the male jobs are very much low status, and status is an important part of scratching the male itch.

I absolutely do not remember enough biochemistry from medical school to know off hand, but a brief lit review gave me these:

"Alcohol has a high energy content, and this energy is utilized by the body as efficiently as the energy in normal food. Ethanol has such good properties as a substrate for energy production that we are faced with the problem of explaining, not why it is consumed, but why it is not consumed in still larger quantities by nonalcoholic humans or by animals. When alcohol is consumed by animals, the intake of food decreases in relation to the caloric content of the alcohol; if a choice of macronutrients is possible, alcohol decreases the consumption of carbohydrates most."

"Step 3 Much of the acetate produced by the oxidation of acetaldehyde leaves the liver and circulates to peripheral tissues where it is activated to a key Acetyl CoA. Acetyl CoA is also the key metabolite produced form all major nutrients- carbohydrate, fat and excess protein. Thus, carbon atoms from alcohol wind up as the same products produced from the oxidation of carbohydrate, fat, and protein, including CO2, fatty acids, ketone bodies, and cholesterol; which products are formed depends on the energy state and the nutritional and hormonal conditions."

My main recollection is that it's shockingly energy dense but I don't remember which form of metabolism it most mimics. The above implies probably none of them, with the "it becomes sugar" perhaps being related to the carb's bit in the first quote, or the way it can absolutely fuck you up with hyperglycemia (which does not necessarily require pure sugar intake).

Not sure if anything I said last week was at all helpful but some more stuff to add: alcohol is really bad for you. I think we all are aware of this, but we mostly kinda ignore it (minus the whole "a glass of wine is fine" thing that more recent research has called into question).

It makes it harder to lose weight, it fucks with your sleep, it causes multiple kinds of cancer, your liver is robust but liver problems are one of the worst ways to die, one of the few things that can very easily kill you withdrawal, etc.

It can certainly be worth it, but health reasons to stop can be pretty motivating, and it's relatively common, even with more mild to moderate use, to find that cutting it out makes you feel a decent amount "better."

On a pointless academic note: alcohol withdrawal can last for multiple weeks but that's rare and would be vanishingly unlikely to apply in this case (5 days is a reasonable rule of thumb however).

neuroscientists telling us that conservatives are motivated by disgust but liberals are more open minded and don’t have that feeling as strongly. I guess that was all bullshit.

I think that may have been true prior to the recent realignment, likely driven by American women who would otherwise be conservative but are pushed into Wokeness by other aspects of politics. These people are officially left leaning but don't seem to have a strong interest or understanding of policies, seem very disgusted by all kinds of stuff (including male sexuality) and seem to have abandoned many of the values the left was holding onto for awhile (like freedom of expression) and likewise carry many beliefs that we would have associated with the right a few decades ago (banning books, etc.).

I suspect a good chunk of these people would have been conservative but being that is super unpopular in their social circles, and the feminist tint to left leaning politics brings them a lot of benefit.

In my mind the Woke movement is conservative in many ways (at least in reference to recent American politics).

Psychiatry has some terms that are great for this kind of problem: egosyntonic and egodystonic.

Example: OCD bothers you. You don't want the impulses and urges. OCPD (Personality Disorder) doesn't bother you as much. You like being meticulous and double checking things.

Lots of pedophiles have egodystonic fixation, they are attracted to children and don't want anything to do with that and then slip up or whatever (or don't).

This exercises is useful in a variety of contexts and is generally a good way to assess the importance of cause of behaviors and can be used in assessing prognosis and so on.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egosyntonic_and_egodystonic

One of the joy's of medicine is that everyone gets sick and therefore if you work in enough practice environments and for long enough you'll interact with every slice of society. AKA I've talked to more pedophiles than the average bear, unfortunately.

The distinction between pedophilia and ephebophilia is constantly panned on the internet, because this topic breaks everyone's brains but the distinction exists for a reason. Impulsivity (including sexual impulsivity) often implies some level of overriding of legal and ethical concerns on the alter of biology. If you find a picture of the girl and she passes for 16 the guy is sexually impulsive, not a pedophile (perhaps legally a pedophile and ethically a pedophile, but when people think pedophile they think "sexually attracted to children" no, most people who commit statutory rape type crimes are saying things like "damn she had some nice titties." A 4 year old does not have secondary sex characteristics).

Some subset of the sexually impulsive people are likely antisocial, but the majority of these cases by volume are like this one, honestly kinda close in age range but just outside the realm of propriety for modern audiences (appropriately so!) but the motivation is fundamentally "I want to have sex with someone who in their messed up brain triggers normal sexual impulses due to a lack of impulse control." I doubt we have data on this, but I do wonder if modern earlier sexualization and earlier development of secondary sex characteristics has increased the frequency of these encounters. Again these people aren't "truly deviant" they are just horny and impulsive (which is a different form of deviancy). A sufficiently advanced sex-bot that looks like such and such popular model would keep them out of trouble. They are not necessarily otherwise bad people (but can be). Satisfaction can be achieved with normal, healthy human behavior they just impulsively choose to make poor decisions.

A different group of people is the true anti-socials who are not obligate pedophiles and but engage in pedophilic behavior because they are "evil" and either enjoy power differentials or just don't care what they stick their dick in. These people aren't pedophiles, they are monsters. They are also super rare.

I think it's important to break group 1 into those two components because it can have a strong impact on things like recidivism rates and moral judgement, especially in cases that are a little more debatable than this (classic would be the 16 and 18 year old couple, which in the past resulted in a lot of jail time).

Agree with your characterization of the second group though, without more details we can't figure out which group this guy is but statistically it's more likely to be the first group, he likely just wanted to have sex and she probably looked adult enough to him. He's probably an idiot not someone obligately attracted to children.

Also, don't fall into the feminist "rape is about power" trap. Rape is sometimes about power but mostly it's about sex. Group 1 people just have a high enough sex drive and access problems, group 2 have a fundamental distortion in the way their attraction works. They generally feel super guilty about their attraction and decisions. Group 1 people typically have a much more egosyntonic relationship with their urges.

Cocaine is complicated by Crack, which is one of the "harder" non-opiate drugs.

Normal cocaine usage is firmly in the party drug side of things, most users do a bump or two while they are at the club or whatever instead of sitting in a room with shooting up 24/7. That doesn't mean people don't get addicted and it's not dangerous (it can absolutely kill you), but I do think people's idea of the modal cocaine user and meth user are very different, and that the latter is high or withdrawing a larger percentage of the time and has a more fucked up life. Cost is also a factor here.

Crack totally different though.