One thing that has happened is that modern weed is stronger than older weed (and therefore people are more likely to have severe shit happen). Synthetic marijuana is popular in some communities and can also cause extremely severe issues.
For a fun one: too much caffeine (and stimulants of any kind) can also cause psychosis.
I love college students who are super crazy because they are drinking too many monsters and not sleeping. One of my favorite presentations. Consistently hilarious to see when you walk into the ED.
The problem with ideas like this is that the people who are causing most of the problem are mentally ill, and part of that mental illness is often a lack of insight, impaired judgement and even things like a profound lack of awareness of the fact that they have a disease (anosognosia).
People who are more or less making a choice (ex: the mentally well, people with substance abuse absent mental illness)....it may be reasonable to treat these people harshly.
But figuring out who is in which population is HARD.
Could this be something similar to how you see more male-male physical affection in Muslim countries? In that case it's just assumed that the affection is not gay (because being gay could literally result in death) so it's therefore more common and accepted.
Likewise the drag shows might be for "harmless entertainment" since nobody would think anything else could happen.
People don't become psychotic out of nowhere.
Yes and no.
Drugs can make people become psychotic (acutely/temporarily), we think they can also make you stay psychotic permanently less commonly. We think they can set off psychotic disorders in people would not otherwise be likely to get that disorder and also trigger people earlier. People with a psychotic disorder (such as schizophrenia) that appears absent substance often end ups with addiction problems of all different kinds. Because we don't full understand the pathophysiology of these things and these populations are um....not reliable historians that does make it difficult to be sure about some of this stuff.
But yes psychosis does come out of nowhere....and at the same time is almost always associated with substance abuse (even if we are just talking about smoking).
Not all drugs have this impact on psychosis. It's generally pretty obvious (PCP!) but not always (Marijuana).
If you were a homeless schizophrenic with a disease addled brain and zero social support you'd probably abuse drugs also.
All that being said a whole bunch of things probably come together to make the U.S. so uniquely troublesome with this stuff. I think an underrated cause of this is probably the support for freedom in the U.S. (which I support) this means less ability for police to just toss and/or arrest vagrants, but also things like more limited ability to involuntarily commit and force medications on the severely ill. Since many of these diseases have a stepwise decline it's pretty easy to burn through your resources and supports and end up in a spiral leading to extremely poor functioning. Same person forced to take medication by their family maybe dodges the whole thing.
Interesting.
Admittedly I haven't given the guy a physical exam and I haven't watched any footage of him walking around (gait is huge for this).
It's worth noting that if you are movement disorder specialist, you are still a Neurologist. Biden's PCP probably doesn't need outside help to diagnosis PD (although they would absolutely bring in expertise for management) so it's very possible they had some concern for general Parkinsonism, especially since more "normal" age related cognitive decline or dementia may have somewhat similar presentations and they wanted to rule something out with neurology help. Again scrambled old brain does weird shit that can complicate diagnosis.
That said, my bias against it being PD is that because if it is PD or Dementia with Lewy bodies then we have big problems, Biden should be impeached and people should probably go to jail. Both of those have neuropsychiatric manifestations that are unacceptable in a sitting president.
I'd expect them to decline to publish his health assessment instead of essentially fabricating it but maybe I'm expecting too much professionalism.
For comparison (although not quite on this level), what do you think should happen if they find out he's become schizophrenic and hid it?
Best steelman I got is that he's got regular dementia or cognitive decline with quite a bit of movement disorder type symptoms so they wanted an outside effort for suggesting management etc.
While I don't really want to be labelled as agreeing with OP, it is worth noting that "men who can't control themselves" is absolutely a real phenomena, and mostly outside the lived experience of the people who post here.
People with poor impulse control, high testosterone, substance abuse and other character flaws are normally buried in the lower classes, but you'll spot it sometimes with things like well positioned athletes who fuck up their lives for no apparent reason given that they can get women with minimal effort.
The best place to find these people in prison "why did your rape her?" "oh she looked hot" "I mean she was at the bar at 2am, of course she wanted me to fuck her" "what's the big deal, she came over to my place, that's like asking for it" etc. are common refrains.
Women don't need protection from the majority of posters here but they do need protection from those guys, and those guys probably need protection from themselves, no amount of "just use your free will bro" is gonna cover for their biological and cultural failings.
Also, again most posters here are pretty reserved, rational, etc. Even high intellect, educated, moral men may be unable to fight off that feeling, especially if they've never experienced it before. I suspect that's responsible for a lot of non-serial cheating.
Object naming IS a component of a standard mental status exam over here (not that most are doing a full one), but for detailed analysis you'll want to use one of the validated screening tools.
I think they were picked because the silhouettes are known to nearly everybody in the western world (charismatic megafauna!).
One of the tests asks you to identify three distinctive animals from a drawn picture - a lion, camel, and rhino.
People do get this wrong, sometimes people that you wouldn't guess because they stay sharp in some areas but not others.
Obviously, most are highly interested in the president’s mental status right now so I figured I’d outline some related medical content.
Caveat- I’m not a geriatrician because fuck that (sorry if you are), so if anyone wants to throw out more specific domain knowledge feel free.
As is usual for medicine, terms are both highly specific and something that specialties don’t necessarily agree on, I’ll skip most of this to avoid blathering about the difference between a mild vs. major neurocognitive disorder vs. dementia as much as possible, but is it worth noting that the word dementia in a colloquial sense can end up being used to refer to normal or above normal age related cognitive decline and changes (which is likely what is happening to the president), or it can be used to refer to one of several highly specific disease process that may result in things like fast or slow progression, or extremely worrying symptoms like hallucinations.
A lot of people have commented “well my grandpa had looked like that” type comments and that’s not necessarily bad data but specific diagnosis of this stuff is surprisingly complicated and unsatisfying since a lot of it requires looking at the overall “clinical” picture and going “yeah probably” (including waiting years to see if progressive decline is happening) with confirmation being only available post-mortem if at all. One of the reasons for this is that the wheels falling off your brain results in some weird shit, some people get behavioral changes years before they get memory problems which leads to them getting diagnosed with something completely different, or something that is not even a “dementia” at all. It’s a huge pain in the ass.
As an aside, I think we may good evidence that the Biden administration is aware of and lying about his neurologic health, which I think many suspect but something that we can point to as evidence is helpful.
Readers may be aware that for a number of years Biden has been publishing his health assessments due to questions about his medical health and fitness. I have used these as a teaching tool because they are exceptionally well written notes and learners can get quite a bit from them. They can be found via google, however: https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Health-Summary-2.28.pdf. Caveat – I don’t have specific knowledge on presidential notes, it may be standard of care to neglect to mention the specific stuff I’m going to talk about. But I question that.
If you read his note, you’ll observe he had a very extensive neurologic exam (as every president probably does and everyone probably should but doesn’t), but he actually has notable neurologic findings. These are ultimately unexciting and not related to the problem at hand, but it means his neurologic exam was performed and reported. Problem: a neuro exam includes assessment of cognition, sensorium, etc. It’s not all reflex hammers and muscle tone (for shits and giggles here’s a citation PMID: 32491521). Sidebar: this note does seem to rule out most pathology with notable physical component like Parkinson’s or cerebellar problems. Since specific deficits are present and commented on, I actually believe that.
However, I do believe his mental status exam is not being reported on, or was declined. Every patient who sees a doctor is having their mental status assessed. Most of this is invisible and often it’s not commented on in documentation. For a primary care provider role, you don’t need to comment on thought process and affect, but you will eyeball the person and if something looks off chase it.
Your doctor is paying attention to what you are saying and how you are saying, but mostly this is on autopilot. Standard of care is to assess orientation “who are you” “where are you right now” “what’s the date and time.” You might not get these questions every time because if you are having a complicated conversation with the doctor, they’ll assume you are oriented (rightly so) and then spare you the stupid questions. Asking them is however the standard of care, and you bet Biden is getting asked those questions and other basic mental status exam questions, which typically include things like some basic math and read back of three objects at five minutes.
Example MSE: https://meded.ucsd.edu/clinicalmed/mental.html
Now with someone in Biden’s age range, gaffes, stress levels, and observed behavior I’d want to do a more exhaustive test. Again, my feeling of what represents standard of care is that he needs a higher level of screening tool, which I do not see reported. Likely declined or deliberately skipped by his physician.
So, what are these? Two standard ones you can look are the Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE) and the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA). You can google these yourself and these are what inspired me to write this. For the most part there isn’t fancy brain imaging or lab tests, we ask you to name a lion on a sheet of paper and you can’t and you get a “dementia” diagnosis.
The fact that nobody gave him an MMSE, reported that he got full points (which he should if he’s the fucking president) and has pointed to that as positive evidence….that’s concerning.
These instruments can be performed by anyone, I want to see Trump chase Biden around with a MoCA sheet, shouting “do you have a moment to talk about your mental status???” The tougher part is ruling out medical causes of illness, which they did as normal.
TLDR: Typically, if you come in for a neuro-cognitive assessment you’ll get labs and imaging, but the doctor will know the level of impairment from history taking (including with family) and from the physical exam. The history taking requires some art, but the exam portion comes on a sheet of paper and can be performed by basically anybody in under 20 minutes. It’s not asking the president to sit in an MRI for a couple hours. This has concerning implications.
The word procedure in a medical context refers to physical tasks that must be performed on the patient, such as surgeries. PAs/NPs are allowed to do a very small subset of these, which makes sense because they don't have things like formal Anatomy Lab or years of supervised practice doing hysterectomies etc.
I'm guessing you don't want to get wrapped up in semantics on that though, so NPs, or my friend John who works in IT can handle the most basic admissions, but what we train for in medicine (and what you pay for in the hospital) is for correctly identifying if the patient is basic (which midlevels suck at) and for when a basic admission suddenly turns not (uncommon but not rare).
Midlevels typically extend the nursing model of "the blood pressure is high, we should fix it, let's use this medication" pattern recognition. The physician model emphasizes understanding the underlying physiological reason for the rise in blood pressure, and identifying a pharmacologic agent that addresses that physiologic response in a way that does not interfere with any other medication or pathology the patient has. "How" not "what." I know what emphasis I'd prefer if I was in the hospital and for my family. This may seem like a harsh characterization (although if you look at training material you'll see legitimate emphasis on "the nursing model") but this is also where that time gap comes into play. Doctors barely get all their learning in and that is with 7-12 years of 60-80+ hour weeks.
Most people don't realize what goes on in medicine because the majority of their interaction is an outpatient visit with the doctor rolling in and asking a few unsatisfactory questions before making some vague pronouncement and then leaving, and if they have a family member in the field it's a nurse who is high on her own supply.
Like with pilots and flight attendants most of the training and activity is invisible to you, but it's absolutely critically important for when things go wrong.
For the hours stuff think of it as more like a combat sport than normal on the train training. Who you putting your money on in a fight? The person with 600 hours of training or 23,000 hours, especially given the fact that the people with significant native talent go into one field preferentially over the other? This isn't something like a role where you have to learn how to use one machine that does the same thing every time, its something where you need experience blocking all kinds of attacks from all kinds of body types which takes year to build up.
Also keep in mind stuff like the fact that it takes years of practice to respond appropriately when someone starts actively dying in front of you, something which happens rarely in most types of finished practice, all the time in MD training, and not really at all in NP training. You need that in your tool belt.
I'll stop here.
Procedures? Nearly all of them, although if for no other reason than the fact that midlevels don't do most types of procedures. This being for a variety of reasons including the fact that they don't get training in this area (or much training at all - NPs can be online degrees).
The best case data presented by the NP lobby will argue that MDs and NPs have the same outcomes, when MDs are handling complicated cases and NPs are handling basic ones. More balanced analysis is pretty lopsided.
The differences are stark. For instance a Child Psychiatrist has 23,000 hours of clinical training. An equivalent NP has 600. And the formers hours are predominantly work, with the NPs being shadowing. And if that Child Psychiatrist wants to switch to Emergency Medicine they'd need an additional 15,000 hours of training. The NP would need zero.
Yeah nurses can figure out basic things. That's the point. Basic.
Nurses are blue collar construction workers and physicians are architects. Yes one implements the vision of the other and can see patterns in what the other requests, but that doesn't mean they can safely do the planning. They do think they can however.
Not commenting if this has situational parallels lol.
Are you normally someone who becomes "one with the crowd?" I find that people with the personality types you see overrepresented here are good at keeping their ego with church, protests, political stuff, but something about sports seems to loosen it up sometimes (probably because it's just fun with less baggage?).
Further evidence for this comes from Hollywood and other businesses - organizations addicted to making money but seem incapable of not leaving money on the table by fucking with their customers etc because of obviously unpopular woke politics.
Gross stereotyping and oversimplification time:
Historically in the U.S. each specialty has had somewhat of a character (less so now with the way social justice has infected and homogenized the pipeline. Surgeons are conservative and would never get a tattoo. Lots of psychiatrists have them but only in places where they could be covered in hidden from patients. Pediatrics would have typical girl tattoos. Orthos are bros, and therefore never have tattoos, but ED docs are a very different kind of bro (outdoorsy, Colorado types) and often have tattoos up to and including full sleeves.
If you're interested in making generalizations then you might actually be reassured by an ED doc with visible tats because it means they are conforming to the stereotypes and norms of their speciality and therefore have a higher chance of being a good doctor lol.
Men are typically aroused more visually and often engage in sexual comparison.
Some examples that results in this engaging with the male participant in porn:
-
Is my dick bigger? Smaller? Better looking? Also studies show men are more engaged with the penis in porn than woman typically (because again, visual). Lesbian porn is more popular with straight woman than you'd expect, and less popular with straight men than you'd expect for this (and other) reasons.
-
In the case of amateur porn especially, "can I get this girl" which involves look at the involved male model and figuring out if for some reason the watcher can steal his woman.
-
Self-insert. Sometime the fantasy is "I could be the one here." As with video games this involves observing the avatar for similarity.
A lot of this is unconscious behavior so people without an excessive amount of insight into their porn habits are unlikely to be aware, but eye tracking would likely be supportive.
If hordes of Maddow's followers started physically harassing Trump and she seemed to be egging it on (or at least conspicuously silent about it), he might have a case.
Isn't Trump the victim of a nearly decade long harassment campaign that was initially started (in part) by very spurious claims and outright lies, which has now cost him millions of dollars and resulted in outright harassment from his political enemies via the legal system?
Do keep in mind that while it's still bizarre it was probably less bizarre at the time - back in the day wearing a suit was much closer to default behavior, and therefore this may have been an eccentricity, but not as far off from appropriate.
is a meme. Is there any evidence that experts by and large find that the NYT misrepresents findings in their field?
It's absolutely a thing.
Any time a NYT article pops up on Meddit you'll see tons of discussion about how incredibly inaccurate the medical content is, often to the point where we can't figure out what the hell is supposed to be going on or what they are talking about.
And I'm not talking things that are political or if you squint have political content (although that stuff always happens) I'm talking full on "they are saying this patient was upset about her cancer but what they are describing isn't a malignancy???"
Citation needed.
Labor protections are much better in other Western countries. Less hours, less call. Protections against getting fired etc. U.S. doctors work twice as much as other countries, especially during training.
Much of what of what makes being a doctor in the U.S. bad is related to our healthcare system - charting requirements, regulatory requirements, insurance bullshit, malpractice environment.
You also have hundreds of thousands of less debt and a much greater social safety net during training and after training in Britain and France.
Also: Nurses make more than 100k in the U.S. a good chunk of the time, and we still have a nursing shortage with those salaries. You want doctors to make less than nurses?
Check it out. Totally is a debate as to if it's real or not (although the FDA and mainstream thought leans on yes with qualification) HOWEVER, IIRC it's just for Peds (so the common apathy narrative is less applicable), it seems small, and it's just a risk for SI not completion.
Standard of care is still to counsel for everybody just in case.
Ah, the innocence. While I'm more familiar with the bomber aircraft with that designation, you really need to visit /r/drugs, sort by top all time, and just see the RIDICULOUS things people do with or on benadryl. Who thought people could get addicted to a bad time?
Oh yeah Benadryl use? Absolutely, with Haldol? That I haven't seen. You see a lot of Benadryl abuse in a correctional setting in the U.S. And really abuse of anything. Apparently Oxybutynin is popular in the women's prisons. And licking pesticides off the walls is popular whenever the prison successfully cracks down on drug imports. If it's at all anticholinergic life, uh finds a way.
Zyprexa is decently sedating. Benzos are sedating. That's probably it. You get a bad outcome and then it generates a black box warning or whatever and we get stuck with it (see: SSRIs increasing suicide risk).
While I usually like to complain about the lack of EBM in this case it's probably just defensive medicine. Be curious to see if they teach it in the U.K. which obviously has a different regulatory environment.

If someone was acutely delirious from say, sepsis, we'd forgive them for certain types of bad behaviors (like flailing and hitting their nurse). If they were high and did something they wouldn't usually we do we wouldn't forgive them. This is in part because the latter is a choice and the former isn't.
Mental illness is more complicated. Some people with schizophrenia don't take medication because they are lazy, or because they don't like the side effects. These people may be making a benefit risk calculation and failing. Some people don't because their illness tells them they are healthy and don't need medication. These people aren't making a "choice." Telling who belongs in which bucket can be very hard.
More options
Context Copy link