WhiningCoil
Ghost of Quokka's Future
No bio...
User ID: 269
I was correcting the record. I thought the cheap shot of "This woman doesn't want Sam Ceder, a jew, in her country" was a gross mischaracterization.
I mean, going from steel manning the woman in the video, to my own personal beliefs, I find myself nodding along with things I've heard Saagar Enjeti say. And his stance on immigration, at least at the time I heard him say this, was that America is in too much cultural turmoil for any immigration right now. He cites as the historical example that from the 20's through the 60's America had an incredibly restrictive immigration system, largely in backlash to how mass migration from other European nations was altering the make up and social contract of America. It took a solid generation or more for America to figure out who it was again, without further waves of mass migration causing even more chaos and social incohesion. It just took that long for the melting pot to melt, before American Chauvinism was destroyed by demoralization propaganda.
Like I said, I find myself nodding along to that. I think America needs 40 years to answer, for itself, what it's culture is going to be, without either side trying to import allies to tip the scales. And it needs more American Chauvinism to actually assimilate the people we already have, if that's even possible any longer. I can only imagine how much more fucked up prohibition would have been if the prohibition side began mass importing Muslims who don't drink, and the anti-prohibition side scoured the globe for alcoholics. And it's hard to imagine either approach making America better off long term, even if the short term culture war issue gets "settled".
You know, it's funny you went straight to the bronze age, cause I just wrapped up The Iliad and The Odyssey, and it was a trip. The morality on display was virtually amorality. Common stories included murdering someone in a town, and having to flee before their brothers kill you back. This was bad. If you fled to another town and found allies, who would then help you finish off the entire family of the person you killed, this was good! If you manage to steal the flocks from a town, that's awesome. If the town you stole them from hunts you down, steals them back, and burns your town down for the effort, that was bad. And all along the way, it's all as Zeus wills it. Zeus doles out success and failure, and the most common reason anyone's attempts at murder, thievery or revenge fails is insufficient piety. Even the most talented individuals must be beloved by the gods for their murder and mayhem to succeed.
The only exceptions are of course, the lands, flocks and people's that belong to the gods, those are verboten to fuck with.
Increasingly I lean into religion/morality as a social technology with consequences. Does it promote prosocial values that help your civilization flourish, or does it burn out or wither and die? Morality is not a single axis, it's a 4X custom civilization screen with lots of pluses and minuses, and it has to compete with a lot of different people's that made different choices, possibly adapted to their environment.
Whatever else you can say about Sam Seder's morality, it's clearly dying. Either because the legacy American's it seeks to rule over no longer feel like being oppressed, or because the foreign legions it imported to keep the natives oppressed don't actually have any buy in to it. But one way or another, whether Sam Seder knows it or not, his morality is an evolutionary dead end.
If you think "We should have a dominant culture", "We should have assimilation" means "Deport Sam Seder", yeah, it's intractable. But if you hear what she's actually saying, brashly, it's that there should be no hyphenated Americans. You need to abandon your native land, your culture and your history at the door. Sam Seder needs to leave only in so far as he's incapable of dropping his distinctly Jewish identity.
And if this sounds like a horrific ask, well, that's what the White Europeans of this country have been forcefully subjected to the last 20 years with demoralization propaganda and the rewriting of our history, and the defamation of our culture.
It's not unreasonable to want born again Americans, not entriest who try to mutate the "idea" of America, or even hate the pre 1960's history and people of it.
I guess that woman debating Sam Seder is getting more attention, but it pairs well with this other guy who "shredded" Sam Seder.
https://x.com/IamSean90/status/1898979265615409509
In this clip, Sam basically fails to articulate a single moral principle beyond "Well, that's just what our society had decided is right and wrong" and when dude says society can change it's mind over time, Sam's only meek response is "Please don't".
Pair this with lady who points out this whole "melting pot" narrative undermining the Christian European roots of America, and Sam comes off as a guy who's left hand is constantly working to change society (through mass migration and media control) to match his preferences, and who's right hand just shrugs and goes "I donno man, things just happen to be the way I like them because of society or whatever man."
There was a story sold to us growing up that we can accept immigrants who want to work hard, and by working hard make America a better place, but that they will assimilate and the America we experience will not meaningfully change. People will experience diversity of shopping and dining experiences with zero externalities. This story, broadly, got widespread support. This story has also been exposed as a complete falsehood. There is little assimilation, and towns are becoming foreign countries out from under their native residents not in generations, but in election cycles. And the response from our ruling class is basically "Fuck you, you suck, your standard of living is too high and you vote wrong, so we're replacing you on purpose and there is nothing you can do about it." We get a bunch of unprincipled and self serving "America is only an idea man, and ideas can change" rhetoric. But change can cut both ways, and people are waking up to the fact that they are faced with America being changed into a completely foreign country out from under them, or being changed back into a more explicitly Christian European country.
But one way or another, the change is coming. Clinging to the status quo is no longer an option.
I'm not shocked more people are nakedly ethnonationalist. It's the gold standard for all of human history, lots of the world currently still is, and it's the only meaningful alternative being provided to "Just let infinity third worlders have your legacy because you suck". I personally don't think legacy Americans have the vitality or institutional capacity to stop it, though I sincerely hope I'm wrong. The project is going to take a lot longer than another 4 year Trump term.
I think the idea is that people don't want to waste taking time out of their day to vote for a loser. That the pain of having had skin in the game and being disappointed is enough to discourage people from putting that skin in the game in the first place if you demoralize them enough beforehand.
Surely he’s burning credibility, too.
You know, I want to take a longer stab at this part. This is less "What I believe" or even "How I think things should be" and more "Is this just the human condition?"
What even is credibility? Is it being absolutely truthful and aligned with reality in every word you say? Or is it delivering the goods, what you said along the way be damned? Musk has a long record of optimistic timelines for various technological achievements. I recall full Falcon 9 reusability was regularly years behind where Musk would confidently say it would be. All's said and done though, none of those "lies" mattered. SpaceX developed a fully reusable rocket and nobody else is even close a decade later, much less beat SpaceX to market in the few years Musk was off in his estimates.
I also recall the story about how Tetris was licensed to Nintendo. Some businessman shamelessly lied that he had the rights to it, signed the paperwork with Nintendo, and then flew off to Russia to do whatever it took to actually secure the rights. He lied... but he did deliver the goods. What does that say about his credibility? He certainly wasn't blacklisted or anything, and in fact goes around bragging to an adoring press, telling the story over and over again.
I was reading The Odyssey lately, and towards the end there was this peculiar part that really struck me where it's mentioned that Odysseus' maternal grandfather was a "world renowned perjurer and thief". Just the way it was phrased, as an admirable thing to be known as struck me as a hilarious bit of bronze age morality. But this more or less meshed with the rest of the bronze age morality on display in The Iliad and The Odyssey, where lying, cheating and stealing is just smart and brings honor if you succeed. Only failure is dishonorable. The line about his grandfather just served to further snap it into focus. One might think we've left that behind, but we're the same human animal now as we were then.
We still say "Fake it till you make it" after all.
So, with respect to Musk, Trump, or anyone's credibility, I think they can lie as much as they want so long as they deliver the good more often than not. Zelensky has a 4% approval rating? Fuck it, why not. Does a ceasefire get declared soon, or some sort of lasting peace agreement? That's credibility. Nobody will remember Musk's tweet when peace and prosperity returns.
World War 3 breaks out and Kiev eats a few megatons? Well, that tweet might end up in the history books, and not in a good way.
I don't especially enjoy this view of the world. And when the shoe is on the other foot, I will likely be losing my ever loving fucking mind that the other side is lying up a storm and "getting away with it".
Learned helplessness? Hmmmm, perhaps. Its been 10 years. I don’t think there is any shame in realizing I'm outgunned in an information war. I ignored as best I could the breathless coverage of polls for the entire election cycle, and I can't say I missed anything. Likewise, I simply cannot be made to care about Elon's or Trump's tweets, Cabinet drama, etc. I'm waiting for peace or world war 3, for my life to get better or worse. All the beefs Hanania has with Elon are just noise. Sour grapes that he didn't make it into the cool kids club like he hoped.
Maybe! But that is criticism unrelated to Hanania's thesis which he is absurdly and laughably wrong about.
My point is not that I believe Zelensky has a 4% approval rating. It's that Hanania is point of fact wrong that the lies Trump & Elon are telling are in any way, shape, or form morally or qualitatively different than the lies the last regime told, and especially not in any way that makes them look worse. He's sanewashing the last 8 years of neoliberal hegemony in media and the deep state because in his little bubble, they weren't that bad.
Believing this requires significant sane-washing of the last 8 years of media. I mean, to pick a random example off the top of my head that Youtube reminded me, Joe Biden's mental decline. The behavior of those in the media is completely unhinged and totally detached from reality, not to mention nakedly self serving. They've gaslit all of the country on an industrial scale about innumerable topics, or instituted a bizarre form of cognitive mutilation where you are only permitted to think of fact in ways they have told you that you are permitted to think of them. Impossible tangles of double-think abound for sex, gender, crime, equality, equity, you name it.
I would hope Elon has better sources of information than I have. But, to pick at Zelensky's 4% approval rating Hanania leads with, is it even possible to know what the real number might be? Also, I'm supposed to be assessing these "debunks" in a media environment where all the election polling around our own election was purposeful lying. Trump's internal polls showed him winning. Biden and then Kamala's internal polls showed him winning. At no time during the entire election cycle did anyone's internal polls show anyone but Trump winning. Public polls on the other hand, with the exception "low quality" pollsters like Rasmussen, all showed Harris winning. The Harris campaign even went so far as to gaslight the nation claiming Trump was lying about his internal polls as a pretext for election denial.
So why should anyone believe anything these people say about Zelensky's poll numbers? How can they possibly claim to be more credible than just making shit up? If Trump and Elon want to parade around some fake numbers the IC gave them that serve their agenda, they are in good company. Well, maybe not good company, but you know what I mean. Don't pretend this is a deviation.
I mean, this is just naked revisionist history and sane washing right here.
When it comes to arguing about platforms and media outlets, we usually think in terms of political bias. It is true that the old system at Twitter disadvantaged conservative voices. In the past, conservatives and liberals would argue about what books you should read or where you should get your news from.
What past is he talking about? "Misgendering" was a ban on sight offense on every social media platform. Books about it were banned, at least temporarily. Liberals didn't calmly argue with conservatives about where to get news from, they banned it. It's pure imagination that anyone, anywhere, was calmly debating what sources of information were preferable to seek the truth. It was a boot stomping on a human face thinking the roles would never be reversed.
Furthermore, I keep going through Hanania's supporting evidence, like "Editor-in-chief of The Federalist joins others in repeating repeating the completely made up lie about Zelensky meeting with Democrats beforehand." except, oh wait, here is a Democrat tweeting about meeting Zelensky before the Trump meeting. Just finished a meeting with President Zelensky here in Washington. He confirmed that the Ukrainian people will not support a fake peace agreement where Putin gets everything he wants and there are no security arrangements for Ukraine. . Did the original rumor name the wrong Democrats? Yes. Is it a made up lie that Zelensky met with Democrats beforehand? Absolutely not.
Frankly it's barely worth the effort to continue to pick apart these sour grapes that Hanania isn't making the living on Twitter that he used to or expected to. Though I am especially tickled he cites Elon being on the wrong side of an argument with Sam Harris about how bad COVID was going to be. The same Sam Harris who has horribly beclowned himself with extremely motivated reasoning about the measures that he still believes were justified to deal with it. Elon might have been wrong about the numbers, but he was directionally correct about how serious to take it. Especially in retrospect, and especially compared to Sam Harris.
I had no idea who Ian Carroll was and was going to skip this episode, but the top comment was "Ian Carroll is not suicidal" and I knew I was in for a good time. I think they barely exchanged names before they launched into conspiracies and alternate perspectives on history.
IMHO, Ian Carroll is the definitive consequence of a young man growing up effectively historically illiterate, "having to teach [himself] all this in the last two years", and growing up in the era of mass government censorship and lies (Russiagate, COVID, climate alarmism, etc). The conspiracy theorist have been right about nearly every major event for the last 10 years, so the desire to look into the past and run up the score is overwhelming.
Which is not even to say Ian Carroll is enormously misinformed. He brought up CIA coups to protect US commercial interest (Banana Republics) like that was something shocking Joe might not know about. He focused a lot on the Dulles Brothers and the founding of the CIA. To him, there is a very blurry line between organized crime and the state, and he harps on the Mafia controlling dockyards in WWII a lot. I don't know this to be true, but it wouldn't shock me at all.
For the people complaining that saying Epstein might have been a Mossad honeypot operation is antisemetic, I'm just wondering where they've been the last several years. Literally everyone of any public profile has publicly wondered that, and not without merit. In fact, I think the political winds will only have to change a very little bit before Zionist are bragging about it with the same zeal they brag about the pager bombings, or other famous intelligence operations from their past. Assuming they were actually involved.
That aside, knowing nothing else about Ian Carroll, even listening to him on Joe Rogan I suspected he was hiding his power level a bit. He threw out a few things like "Nasa fakes space footage all the time" that he dropped pretty quickly with Joe asked some pointed questions. I think he is largely a casualty of growing up in an education system that has turned history into proselytizing diversity versus any understanding of the timeline of human development, and the last 10 years of the government and all the intelligence services telling naked, obvious lies that are revealed in near real time. When you grow up being told shameless lies by every authority figure in your life, you'll be left with zero foundation to resist the lure conspiracy theories which, lets face it, are just fucking fun.
I wonder if the Democrats will eventually have a moment when the stark reality of their failures simply can't be tolerated anymore, resulting in a change in tact. I was hopeful right after the election last year, but most signs since then have made me pessimistic. I just hope it comes sooner than later, because, as bad as SocJus is, I fully expect Republicans to be just as bad if they find that they have nearly unchecked power without a strong opposition party.
I've lost all capacity to steelman the DNC. I can barely form a notion of what motivates them that doesn't come across has a hateful parody. And yet clips like this exist and I find myself going "What else am I supposed to think?"
I know left leaning people want a DNC that improves their quality of life, some form of socialized health care, living wages. I'm not hating on them.
But the DNC, the organization that tries to develop a bench of candidates and spend scarce political capital and state capacity on it's top priorities seems absolutely insane. All we got was infinity immigrants, trans kids and censorship. Oh, and lots and lots of graft for a DNC patronage network. I can only possibly model these as top priorities for people that are stupid, evil, or both. They don't even attempt to explain a through line from open borders, trans kids and censorship to living wages and health care for their base.
Say what you want about Trump, he can at least tell a story about how deportations will lower crime and cost of living, how tariffs with improve wages, how DOGE will lower your taxes. I get that people will claim those are all lies and there is no causation between one or the other, but the case is at least made by Trump about what he's going to do, and how it's going to improve people's lives. And then he actually is seen to be doing the things he said he was going to do. If everything goes to shit and none of it works... well... at least he was honest about what he was going to do.
All I see in the DNC is weird ideological crusades, corruption, and zero sum power jockeying.
Women are ridiculously weak compared to men. I suck at BJJ and I can easily beat all the women in my gym except for the very best one who is arguably in the top 10 female BJJ fighters in the world. Even if their technique is far better than mine (and it often is), it's so easy to overpower them. I completely sympathize with your neuroses with BJJing with girls, I avoid them at all costs.
So, every now and again I watch fights when I can catch them. Like, I made the mistake of watching the Tyson v Paul fight, and all the undercards. And the announcers could not stop talking about how stunning and brave the women's match was. I kept wondering what the fuck fight they were watching? It was practically a slapfight where neither opponent was the least bit worried about the other's blows so much as stunning them. And these were both title holders! Even the wannabe actor/boxers in the first fight put on a better show than that. Then at the end they both looked like they were about to cry. It was gross, and it felt like abuse to put them up on a stage for everyone to watch.
Yeah, I'm not sure sucking forever at something you never get better at as a hobby is quite the "building character" Calvin's Dad is always talking about. I mean, if it's something you love, suck away. But otherwise, at a certain point you have to assess if this is a proper use of your limited time on this Earth. "Building character" is only useful when it's overcoming temporary hardship, or going nose to the grindstone for truly necessary hardship. Not for doing something you aren't enjoying and suck at recreationally.
It sucks getting old. I'm not quite to the point where exercise goes from hitting new personal bests, to just trying to slow the inevitable decline and doing it because you have to. But it's within sight. I hope I can maintain my discipline when year by year I'm capable of doing less and less. I hope that inflection point could be 50, or even 55. I'm afraid it could be 45 (I'm 42) or sooner.
I mean, that being the case, the report from Homeland Security might come back "Nah, we good" and no insurrection act gets invoked and no troops get deployed.
Best of luck! I'm not sure I could stomach sucking at something with little to no improvement for more than six months.
I know one thing that really aged me out of martial arts was the fact that I plateaued, if not moved backwards, and I was watching people with more drive just fly past me. More willing to train 4 hours a day, more willing to train injured, somehow able to keep their adrenaline pounding the whole damned time going 110%. Meanwhile I'd get maybe 40 minutes of high quality training in, and then I was just tired, and my shitty bum ankle with half a tendon didn't want to function properly anymore, and I just didn't feel like getting punched in the head that day or ending up with bruises up and down my arms from hard blocks. But what made it worse was looking at those other guys remembering how I used to be them! Then I decided to just get out of their way.
Man, that sounds really fun. At some point the fight just went out of me though. Several broken bones, torn muscles, and a concussion over a 12 year amateur martial arts career just wore me out. To say nothing of the more regular bruises. Just wasn't worth the wear and tear anymore. Felt like I was always healing from something.
But man, you do make it sound fun.
Not really. Just lots of personal experimentation and problem solving.
Delayed onset muscle soreness. Pretty normal, sucks a giant unwashed dick.
My journey to 200 24 kg kettlebell snatches continues. Got up to 116 this week. Been mixing up my training with large sets of 24 kg snatches with good breaks for more endurance before switching hands, and then also some 32 kg work with either one armed swings or maybe a few snatches per side for raw grip strength. It's a slog to keep pushing. My cardio is feeling better, and less like my heart is going to explode in my chest towards the last few reps. But the muscle fatigue, especially in my forearms is intense. I'm smooshing my workout in between work and dinner, so often I sit right down when I'm done with snatches and eat. More than a few times my arms are so shot I can no longer grip a fork, shit just isn't working.
That said, knocking out that first 100 has gotten way easier, and I've modified my technique such that my hands don't feel the least bit tore up anymore. If you've ever done a lot of kettlebell snatches, or maybe rock climbing, you know what I'm talking about. Ripping off callouses, or even just that burning sensation as you beat the hell out of the palm of your hand can be a real show stopper. But I think through better technique I've circumvented that limitation, at least for now. Basically have to bounce the kettlebell between a loose hook grip and your thumb, without letting it roll across your palm. Easy as pie going up, going down I basically have to throw the kettlebell out of the racked position overhead. Not sure how common that is, but it works for me.
Getting older definitely sucks. Takes a lot of stretching to limber up, especially in the shoulders and hips, and then if I don't take a post workout protein shake, I have the worst DOMS I've ever had in my life the next day. But I'll be damned if my daughter grows up with her dad getting old and fat, and hearing about how exercise is one of those things he "used to do".
99% certain invoking the Insurrection Act with respect to the southern border is purely to get around weird, nonsensical laws that forbid our armed forces from actually protecting the border. Because due to the clown world we all live in, the one thing our armed forces is not allowed to do is defend it's country's borders. It can only destroy things overseas in pointless adventurism. Even these last 2 months, they've had to pussy foot around the issue, having the armed forces only provide logistical support to border patrol. But due to labyrinthine tangles of court precedent, bad (imho) law, and other objectively insane nonsense no other country would ever conceive of tolerating, unless they invoke the insurrection act, the armed forces are not allowed to protect our border.
The structuring of the EO, having these deadlines and having these reports is probably nothing but bureaucratic legal necessity to minimize the chances that some random Hawaiian judge with pull an Uno Reverse, and then the Supreme Court will agree with them on purely procedural grounds.
I'll eat crow (and probably cheer from the roof tops, I can't lie) if Trump uses this as an excuse to start a 1000 Year Trumpenreich. But I'm 99% certain it's just to get around the objectively terrible legal environment for having our army actually defend our country. Because we are apparently insane as a nation.
I mean, as usual, define "Blue Tribe normie"? I've seen everything from "We should have implemented a complete information control regime in 2014 instead of 2018" to "The Democrat's shouldn't have rigged the primary against Bernie Sanders" to "Revolution now! Get out the guillotines!"
Personally, I'm not sure how the information control regime that existed up until Elon bought Twitter would have prevented an "Elon buys Twitter" type extinction level event, perhaps a bit earlier. Maybe earlier information control could have kept Elon inside a cage of censorship himself. Maybe with a 4 year head start they could have convinced him that sterilizing and mutilating one of his kids in California is actually great. I can't completely rule it out. Maybe after Trump is denied the presidency in 2016, having never been President, a focused DOJ could have been more effective at destroying him, throwing him Prison, and confiscating all his assets like they Alex Jones. I'm skeptical to all this, but it's a major strain of thought of a lot of "Blue Tribe normies". The only lesson they've taken is they should have done censorship sooner and harder. You need to outlaw the other political party.
I'm more sympathetic to the "Bernie should have won the primary" blue tribe normies. A bit more kind hearted than the MSNBC brained ones above, I find myself more able to have a pleasant conversation with them. I still think they are wrong. I think Bernie's sell out behavior since his loss in 2016 with his conforming to every DNC policy that he previously disagreed with, and generally being feckless to promote his agenda with even the small amount of power he'd been given indicated a Bernie 2016-2020 Presidency would have just been Neoliberalism as normal. We wouldn't see "Open borders are a Koch Brother's Conspiracy" Bernie in the White House, which leaves Republicans their strongest issue, which takes us right back to an information control regime and lawfare to stop a Trump who simply doesn't give up in 2020.
Then you have the "Get out the guillotine" Blue Tribers. I see no flaws in this plan. It's a lesson I've taken to heart.
He really needs to lie better like the Biden admin did. Just slow role it, tie it up in court, complain about the "Parliamentarian", and give the money to a Republican Patronage Network that might, after 10 years, spent 0.01% of the money on Ukraine versus their pet causes. Shit, spend all of it on that Strategic Crypto Reserve and claim it's to keep Russia from getting all the Crypto. It'll hold up about as well as all the money Biden drained from the government for illegals getting tons of free shit. Trump's problem is that he's such a worse liar than the typical politician to whom words mean nothing, and passive aggression is the primary winning strategy. Trump feels this compulsive need to beat his chest and openly fight with people, instead of just lying that he'll do something, and then doing whatever he wants anyways with 100 layers of indirection and plausible deniability.
I think thats the guy! Awesome, thanks.

I had a friend who used to be a teacher. He was all in on virtually every neoliberal shibboleth of teaching. Against school choice because it took resources away from public schools. Always making snide comments about what will happen to special needs kids if schools got fully privatized.
Naturally, his sons all have some non-specific emotional/behavioral problems that lets him game the system for them to have personalized education plans and extra resources. He's always been good at gaming the system like that.
We're currently struggling with some shitty behavior our daughter is tracking home from school. My wife is adamant that it's something the school should be "fixing", and I keep asserting it's not their job. It's our job. So our daughter is currently grounded.
I donno man. I guess there is some theoretical intellectually in tact individual that needs extra resources either because of a physical disability or idiosyncratic mental problem (like dyslexia) that if gotten over the hump of not being able to help themselves, can go on to utilize their education for the betterment of society. Personally, I've never seen one. I mostly only see parents pushing their parenting duties onto teachers through fake special needs, or fake special needs students becoming fake special needs employees, expecting all the same accommodations around their emotional needs and learned helplessness.
I do expect lots of malicious compliance around this though. Totally normal shit like just wanting to have a conversation with a teacher about how to help your child in an area they are struggling with becomes "Sorry, Trump said I'm not allowed to."
More options
Context Copy link