@WhiningCoil's banner p

WhiningCoil

Ghost of Quokka's Future

6 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 23:24:47 UTC

				

User ID: 269

WhiningCoil

Ghost of Quokka's Future

6 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 23:24:47 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 269

you'll be acutely aware that you're living a lie

And ironic criticism of his proposal, given your preferred solution leaves you no better off in that regard.

Lifelong medicalisation happens anyway no matter when you transition, but if you do it as an adult, it's much worse. You have to pay huge sums of money (tens, if not hundreds of thousands of dollars) for very painful, potentially risky surgery - for MtFs, facial feminisation surgery - which is literally slicing your face open, shaving your bones with a saw, and stitching it back up - tracheal shave, voice feminisation surgery, hairline reduction, and some more. All of this you do if you want to pass as a normal member of the opposite sex instead of a freak that's the butt of jokes.

My understanding, is that the state of the art research on the topic, before the mania, was that the vast majority of gender dysphoric individuals ceased being dysphoric with the completion of puberty. Upwards of 90%. Part of the diagnostic criteria in fact demanded you wait, to make sure the dysphoria persisted, before you began throwing medical interventions at it. Because "do no harm" still reigned.

The current state of the art is that the 90% that would have had their dysphoria resolved, and required no medicalization, must now be medicalized before puberty to make the transition of the 10% who's dysphoria wouldn't have resolve easier.

In other words, 90% of kids with transient gender dysphoria are being irreparably harmed for the benefit of the 10% with permanent dysphoria.

I get that if you have permanent dysphoria, this sucks. It might seem unfair. I don't care. I value the 9 other kids that would have grown up to be gender nonconforming and/or gay adults with intact bodies over you.

Even so, if that was as far as it went, I wouldn't be half as hopping mad as I am. What has me incandescently furious are the local school districts around me pushing pornography on children, and fighting tooth and nail to transition children in secret. And I'm especially livid at gender ideology being pushed as early as Kindergarten. This article, framing it as if it's a good thing:

In his kindergarten classroom, one teacher in western Massachusetts using “Rights, Respect, Responsibility” introduces the idea of gender as part of an exploration of identity. He explains that people use all sorts of pronouns: he, she, they, ze. He introduces the terms transgender and gender queer but doesn’t fully define them because that is too much for kindergartners, said the teacher, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because his district did not authorize him to speak publicly.

He talks to students about anatomy but declines to classify various body parts as male or female. “We don’t say a penis belongs to a man,” he said. It belongs to a human, he explains.

All I see is institutions, starting as soon as kids are verbal, amplifying neurosis around puberty, nurturing them relentlessly, and then medicalizing the children that they've brainwashed behind their parents back. As such, we're not letting our kid anywhere near those institutions.

You know, when my wife and I were expecting our first kid, we had a conversation about this. I basically didn't want it done if we had a boy, for a host of reasons. She, at the time, had a more normie perspective, but no strong feelings one way or the other.

I think it is slowly falling out of favor in the US? I haven't checked rates or anything, but anecdotally I see more people questioning it and saying they won't do it to their children.

But it doesn't come up here because there is no culture war flashpoint over it. Weirdo's who control institutions aren't trying to get it done behind parent's backs. In so far as it's a "problem", it follows the usual pluralistic principles of it being nobody else's business what someone does with their kids.

In 1950, the population of the United States was about 150 million. Between the late 30's and early 50's about 60,000 lobotomies were performed. So an incredibly small percentage. Even so, despite the very small number spread out over 20 years, there eventually was a moral outrage at the horrific nature of the procedure and the aftermath.

Crimes against humanity don't need to be widespread to inspire a backlash against them. In fact, it's probably the opposite relationship. If everyone had a lobotomized family member whom they were deeply invested in believing had the right and proper thing done to them, it's possible people would have had too much buy in to have effectively banned the practice.

So, caveat, this was told to me in a Global Ethics class circa 2004. But supposedly the biggest proponents of female genital mutilation in the middle east are the older women who had it done to them. They are deeply invested in continuing the practice, because their entire identities are subtly intertwined in valorizing how it was done to them. To walk that back undermines everything they understand about themselves.

Among normies who are aware of the problem, I think most suffer from Jessie Singal syndrome. Jessie Singal has been covering the trans-insanity beat for a long, long time from the left. He has correctly identified much that is ethically horrifying about the current trans movement. He has correctly identified institutional problems that need to be stopped. But he's so locked into "Republicans bad, Democrats good", that when Republicans literally stop the things he has written extensively about, he is horrified that Republicans are "making the problem worse". He's convinced that if Republicans would just lay off, now, after 10 years of his side ignoring him and actively promoting all the problems he complains about, he could convince them to reverse course. But those darned evil, bigoted Republicans just won't stop making his side crazy.

The institutional sterilization and mutilation of children is a crime against humanity, the scale of which is difficult for the average normie to honestly contemplate. And especially the average normie Democrat. My extremely normie MSNBC consuming in laws just straight up disbelieve it. There side only does good things, and the way we describe it sounds like a bad thing, therefore it's not happening. It's right wing misinformation. We must have heard it from Fox News, always the boogie man, despite the fact that we don't even have cable. When we describe the things happening in our own state, they just mutter "Well I never heard about that." It doesn't help that the whole debate is shrouded in euphemisms like "trans healthcare", and lies about it being "fully reversible".

Among the true believers, charitably you have trans activist who mistakenly view every child through the lens of their own experiences growing up. Uncharitably, they've been horribly mutilated with no way back, and the only way to justify what was done to them is to perpetuate it. Otherwise they'd have to face the stark reality that their entire miserable existence was based on a lie. It's no wonder so many kill themselves.

And then you have the child castration fetishist in the medical community who write the standards of care.

Let me illustrate my expectations by going over some historical pogroms.

The 1821 Odessa pogroms are sometimes considered the first pogroms. After the execution of the Greek Orthodox patriarch, Gregory V, in Constantinople, 14 Jews were killed in response.[1] The initiators of the 1821 pogroms were the local Greeks, who used to have a substantial diaspora in the port cities of what was known as Novorossiya.[2]

So just 14 Jews killed, but the message of "Your kind isn't welcome here" is clear. Moving onto 1881

The event which triggered the pogroms was the assassination of Tsar Alexander II on 13 March [1 March, Old Style], 1881, for which some blamed "agents of foreign influence," implying that Jews committed it.[9][10] One of the conspirators was of Jewish origins, and the importance of her role in the assassination was greatly exaggerated during the pogroms that followed. Another conspirator was baselessly rumored to be Jewish.[11] The extent to which the Russian press was responsible for encouraging perceptions of the assassination as a Jewish act has been disputed.[12]

So that's the trigger. Here are some of the excuses made during that time.

For decades after the 1881 pogroms, many government officials held the antisemitic belief that Jews in villages were more dangerous than Jews who lived in towns. The Minister of the Interior Nikolay Pavlovich Ignatyev rejected the theory that pogroms were caused by revolutionary socialists, and instead he adopted the idea that they were a protest by the rural population against Jewish exploitation. With this idea in mind, he promulgated the notion that pogroms had spread from villages to towns. Historians today recognize that although rural peasantry did largely participate in the pogrom violence, pogroms began in the towns and spread to the villages.[17]

Man, the more things change, the more they stay the same, huh?

At least 40 Jews were killed during pogroms between April and December 1881.[18] An additional 225 Jewish women reported being raped; Of these, 17 were reportedly killed while being raped.[citation needed]

Only 40 casualties. And the results...

The pogroms of the 1880s caused a worldwide outcry and, along with harsh laws, propelled mass Jewish emigration from Russia.

I'd say historically, pogroms weren't about murdering even a significant proportion of the population. That's why it's not called genocide. Instead, they are about instilling fear through the much beloved stochastic terrorism, so that they leave. Historical pogroms also aren't a single event, but a steady roil of targeted racial violence with peaks of mob violence, and occasionally lethality. The role of the state seems to alternate between inflaming tensions with racial rhetoric, and being incredibly passive aggressive towards defending the rights of the unwanted citizens.

Frankly it's a state of affairs most Democrat run cities are already in, in their racial anti-white libelous rhetoric, and their slaps on the wrist, if any enforcement at all, for racially motivated anti-white hate crimes.

I don't know about the entire united states. But many Democrat run cities seem to be at a pre-pogrom boiling point with all these massive pro-Hamas rallies. The fact that our borders are completely open, and illegal crossings are at record highs even from the last record highs doesn't bode well either. And if you've been following the activist ringleaders, their rhetoric makes few distinctions between "whiteness" and "jews" when it comes to what "privileged colonizers" deserve.

Wouldn't be the first time white people were extirpated from the societies they built, won't be the last. There is a massive population of invaders and collaborators who believes white people deserves to be eradicated.

A pogrom is a violent riot incited with the aim of massacring or expelling an ethnic or religious group

Doesn't need to be organized, as riots rarely are. Just a racialized carnival of violence.

You know, as an adult who grew up in the 90's, a lot of the demoralization propaganda just makes me roll my eyes. When I got to the 3rd season of Disenchantment and they made the main character gay, I roll my eyes and say to my wife watching next to me "because of course she is." Usually happens 3 or 4 times every single show we watch. More or less every episode of The Fall of the House of Usher had an absurdly on the nose progressive propaganda moment.

As an adult, it's eye roll worthy. Sometimes you can see past the politically motivated characters or plot points. Sometimes you can't.

Considering the media we'll expose our children to however, it gets scary. If a person uncritically consumed current popular culture, you get the Nashville school shooter mentioned below. Brain turned to mush, on a path to mutilation and sterilization, hating everything and everyone. There was nothing I saw in that manifesto that isn't constantly beating me over the head in modern pop culture.

I'm reminded of some joke about the difference between a cult and a religion. A cult is all made up by people. In a religion, all those people are dead. We're coming up on generations that have only known demoralization propaganda, and who's parents have only known demoralization propaganda. Whatever kayfabe social signaling hating cis white males, normal women, or wholesome white families used to mean, the people uncritically consuming it and signal boosting it now don't understand it's only supposed to be insincere virtue signaling. They're ready to start pogroms now.

I'm not nearly that far. Only to North 2. Been a long time since a puzzle game grabbed me like this. Maybe since the last Talos Principle. Manifold Garden got me initially, but then it got so open ended it became overwhelming.

I am 1000% into Talos Principle 2 right now. I'm not sure how much the plot changes based on dialog choices, but it makes my heart sing watching them take shots at Malthusian bullshit left, right and center. It's a refreshing change of pace from the typical soy slop that passes as a story in games these days.

because bombs are grandfathered into everyone's expectations.

...

You didn't say anything about expectations or the like.

I honestly don't know why I even try.

There is also apparently no penalty to committing warcrimes beyond words.

...

we have lots of evidence of people disapproving of the former (and indeed of indiscriminately applying the "war crime" label).

Yes.

So I want to be clear. I'm not saying bombing gaza (or any hostile region) is grandfathered into the law, I'm saying it's grandfathered into peoples expectations. Because every country has done, is doing it, and reserves the right to do it again. It's against the law in name only. Like sodomy.

It was the same way when Trump was in office, and his corrupt was novel. He was flexing his hospitality industrial complex. Where as everyone else grew up with the military industrial complex being nakedly corrupt. They're all corrupt, but he acted corrupt in a novel, unique way. So it drew more attention, and people were tricked into thinking his corruption, such as it was, was somehow uniquely evil.

So it goes with bombs versus other novel means of warfighting. Israel might be wrong to bomb gaza, but they wrong in good company. You don't want to be the only nation on Earth to have weaponized sewage.

At some point I acquired a fan edit of the original trilogy that attempted to combined the highest fidelity sources available of the original version. I know there are a ton, and I honestly can't tell you which one I got. But I can confirm I've watched it several times and no longer feel gaslit about how I remember the movie looking and feeling.

Why not identify 1 of the tunnels on high ground and flood them ? Maybe flood them with sewage just so it is extra disgusting.

I watched two incredibly pedantic former armed service members argue over whether this would be legally considered a warcrime last night. Because apparently it's against the laws of war to purposely destroy the environment, which flood Hamas tunnels with sewage would do. It's also illegal to flagrantly endanger civilian lives, which flooding the tunnels with sewage would do since you don't know all the places they go. They specifically cited this law, and it was apparently common knowledge to them where it came from, but I have no clue.

Intentionally launching an attack in the knowledge that such attack will cause incidental loss of life or injury to civilians or damage to civilian objects or widespread, long-term and severe damage to the natural environment which would be clearly excessive in relation to the concrete and direct overall military advantage anticipated;

All I came away from the conversation with is that it's apparently illegal to use any novel forms of warfighting that may save innocent lives over bombing Gaza to glass, because bombs are grandfathered into everyone's expectations. There is also apparently no penalty to committing warcrimes beyond words. Unless you lose. But since Israel faced genocide should they lose, it's not like they have any reason not to commit warcrimes. Better to warcrime and win, and let people say mean things about you.

Oh, clearly I consume the things I like, and you consoom the things you like because you suck.

I'm kidding, that's a really good question. To me, there is almost a level of abuse in the average consoomer relationship. Publishers almost treat them like paypigs. Just actively shit all over them, to see how much they can get away with. Kill off their favorite characters, utterly humiliate their demographic repeatedly, all while preaching that it's important to show everybody (except you) being heroic, moral and capable.

There is an element of disposability to it all. The whole meme, near as I know, spawned from a Red Letter Media line like "Don't ask questions. Just consume product, and then get excited for next product".. The full parody video is also worth a watch. Timeless classic IMHO. Consoom RLM, ahem what?

But it's just this endless spigot of low quality, disposable, formulaic entertainment products. You aren't meant to rewatch, there is barely time, the next thing is already on the way. We went from an MCU with 6 movies in 5 years for phase 1, 6 movies in 3 years for phase 2, 11 movies in 3 years for phase 3, to a quantity of films and tv shows on such a compressed timescale it's taking me actual work to add it all up. 9 movies in 2 years, plus 8 6-9 episode tv series?! Jesus fucking christ. It's almost threatening. Like, you enjoyed this franchise. You want to be in the cool kids club and not miss out on current thing. But instead of abusing 2 hours of your time a year, they are abusing probably closer to 100 hours of your time! And it went from the price of a movie ticket to 4 movie tickets and 12 months of an online subscription service!

Maybe it's all a false distinction. Maybe I'm consooming just as much when I rewatch my hard copy of Lord of Illusions every year around Halloween, or National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation during the holidays. Maybe my sense of cultural continuity, enjoying the same "classic" films my father enjoyed, and exposing them to my children as well, is a thin veneer over generational consooming. Maybe reading the original Dune every few years, and finding new things to appreciate isn't any less consooming than picking up the latest Dune novel and giving it a go.

Oh god I think I threw up in my mouth a little bit.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I feel in my bones there is a qualitative and quantitative difference between consuming and consooming. Maybe phase 1 of the MCU was consumption. Maybe it was on the line of consooming. We're so far past that now in phase 5?!, there is only consoom.

I don't think this is a locally unpopular position. Experts are good and useful. When I want to know something about how magnets work, I look up standard expert material rather than consulting Insane Clown Posse. When I'm curious about whose work Picasso built on, I trust that art historians are basically telling me the truth to the best of their abilities, and that even if they're wrong, it's much better information than I would get by doing my own research. Most approved vaccines are reasonably safe and basically work. I want engineers to work on bridges, experienced dentists to work on my teeth, and historians to tell me about ancient wars.

Yeah.... about that...

As a family that used to regularly get a rotisserie chicken from Costco, Walmart, Harris Teeter, really anywhere they were available when we felt lazy and wanted a quick meal, the price only tells half the story. The chickens themselves have gotten tiny. 25% smaller at a minimum. You can't trust the inflation numbers on any prepared meal what so ever. Portion sizes have plummeted.

I suppose it's really nice that we have access to both eh? Anyone not enamoured by the current Star Wars soyslop can watch the older movies too, and cheaply.

No they can't. Last I checked, there is not a single available legal source for the original films. In fact, they keep getting remastered even harder unannounced as time goes on.

We're also rapidly moving into an era where physical releases are no longer being considered, and streaming services regularly take down even their own original content, or edit it after the fact such that the original version can never be viewed again.

The long term goal is clear. The bean counters are slathering at the fact that you'll have to pay a monthly for your entertainment, locked in an ever present cycle of consooming. And the thought controllers are excited that you'll be forced to be exposed to their demoralization propaganda because nothing else will be available.

To further lend support for a vibes based argument...

Times of plenty are over. For people, for businesses, for nations, on all levels, people are switching to a scarcity mindset. No amount of data is going to change this. Inflation is squeezing people, even if their income has kept up, of which I'm highly skeptical. Businesses are experiencing a massive credit crunch with rates going up as high, as quickly, as they have. And nations are sweating constant supply chain ripples that still haven't stopped in the aftermath of COVID. Factory shut downs gave way to trade wars and hot wars. It feels like everything is coming apart at the seams on all levels, which is going to motivate agents at all levels of society to make decisions that cause the seams to come apart faster. I'm fearful every day the other shoe will finally drop with Taiwan.

Chaos and destabilization rule the day. People aren't just looking at their quality of life now, which has likely gotten measurably worse, but can feel the vibe that nobody is making any actual headway in making tomorrow better.

Maybe you can pay a variable rate starting at ~9% to access that "wealth".

Nobody reads anymore do they?

How is any of that a rebuttal to you being point of fact wrong about how much people spend on food, and how impactful food inflation is to them?

Throw whatever food categories you want, the point is people spend a tiny amount of their income on food.

Why are you so stuck on being wrong? 12% is not a tiny amount! It's trades for second or third place in spending categories behind housing and, often times, transportation.

Equity in your house is only barely wealth. Sure, when you die or laughs retire, you might cash out. Or you could actually pay off the mortgage in 30 years, right before you retire. Maybe you can pay a variable rate starting at ~9% to access that "wealth". But for most people, all that extra "wealth" does for them is increase their property taxes.