@iprayiam3's banner p

iprayiam3


				

				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2023 March 16 23:58:39 UTC

				

User ID: 2267

iprayiam3


				
				
				

				
3 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2023 March 16 23:58:39 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 2267

TL;DR: Autogynephilia isn’t caused by cringe story books in which Jimmy has a trans mom and a cis mom lol.

No, not directly but it's crowd cover and encouragement to take your paraphilia public / evolve it into an identity. No, I highly doubt that anything put on by the school is ever a spark for a kid to trans (except actual groomery grooming), but it's definitely gasoline, and a firepit.

For a lot of paraphilias including agp, the exhibitionism and humiliation is part of the excitement and can eventually sublimate into association.

A teen in the 90s who got turned on by putting on his sister's dress, would still not be caught dead coming to school like that. So it's ability and context to grow is stunted, and in many cased desisted, subsumed into hetero-erotic exploration with women, or maybe remains a mild kink. But when the teacher and school is encouraging it, and more importantly you are given examples of other people doing it and seemingly getting away with it, you now have a context to dive all in and let it consume you, and receive the positive social feedback.

TL;DR: Autogynephilia isn’t caused by cringe story books in which Jimmy has a trans mom and a cis mom lol.

Finally, returning to your initial TL;DR, again no I doubt it's causing anything outright, but certainly someone with some mild curiousity can get tickled by the idea and it's a great way to grow into an earworm.

As a guy I can tell you there are a lot of random little slightly 'strange' fleeting experiences that I can still trace certain shapes of my adult sexual-psyche back to today. Even if you want to make an argument that in every scenario, the spark was already there, I'm saying that something as ridiculous as a teacher reading a book that makes you feel weird can really feed that spark.

This post and the thread in response is unreadable, as it and most responses are a long collection of unrelated ideas and only the ability to respond to some before branching off into dead ends and redundancy.

I suggest we don't do this. It's extraordinarily annoying.

Perhaps you meant the thread discussion to be confined to the meta-discussion about discussing such topics, but it clearly didn't turn out that way and you shouldn't have itemized several dozen.

A top level post that throws out 73 disparate discussion topics is an abuse of the concept of topics. This is essentially 73 low effort posts that amount to "controversial statement... discuss."

I think this question is very hung up in the complexity of the concept of 'happiness' (and possibly also confounded by correlations between who does and doesn't have money. The richest people I know are also the most stressed out because they are rich because they're broken in a never ending quest of career and financial improvement. But if you took a well adjusted middle class family man and paid of his house, I bet he'd become happier.)

In terms of the complexity of happiness, I am a pretty happy guy dispositionally. I have a positive attitude, I'm relatively low stress and I love the simple things in my life. It's true that on a daily hedonic level, it would be hard to make money adjust by day-to-day mood all that much. I suspect it's also true of people dispositionally unhappy, restless, etc.

On a more fundamental level, my sense of value and meaning in the world is tied to my philosophical and religious beliefs as well as some deep ingrained pre-dispositions (like hating change, and being naturally nostalgic). Again, I doubt money could change that much, or possibly negatively.

But between my deep sense of happiness and my daily mood/disposition, I think there's a middle concept of happiness that would be helped greatly with more money. If the stress of working, saving could be reduce, the opportunity cost of my time, etc. It would affect my ' middle happiness' quite a bit.

Not everyone has the luxury of tradition, religion... Try to get a traditional relationship as the average Western 20 something now, see what happens. Fucking try. There literally aren't places for you to even look for those things anymore.

It's not a luxury, it's a choice and a difficult to substitute ingredient. If you want a traditional relationship & family, get religion. If you don't want religion, accept that you might not get the relationship.

Jeffrey Atomic asks Danny Familyman what he's eating, because damn it smells delicious. "It's called pizza. It is delicious, and pretty simple. Highly recommend!"

Jeffrey: "Maybe for you, but I don't have the luxury of a pizza dough. Try eating hot cheese and liquid sauce out of your hands. Fucking Try."

Danny Familyman: Yeah that sounds terrible. Why don't you get a pizza dough? People are offering them literally all around you. Here have one of mine!

Mr. Atomic: "I don't want dough!"

Danny Familyman: Ok, then you don't want pizza. Delicious sauce, cheese, and toppings are all founded on the crust.

JA: I want the deliciousness of pizza! But I don't have the luxury of wanting the dough.

Danny Familyman: OK. But you will have to find that deliciousness some other, much harder way. And the dough is right here available for you. If you don't want the dough, you don't really want pizza, and your desire for pizza without it being pizza isn't a real or coherent wish. This isn't a luxury, or a cheat code it's the foundation.

If republicans only cared about vigor, why are they aligned around a spetegenarian? Why is this plan centered around having Trump refuse? Is there anyone in the world who doesn't already believe Ron would beat an old man in a boxing match?

Is there some large demographic that would only be convinced (and also switch support) by having this demonstrated either physically or constitutionally? What a bizarrely stupid take.

Also, where is the evidence that 'Ron hasn't captured the republicans id?' he won Florida handily, and is pretty popular and would be the far front runner if Trump died tomorrow.

Ron can't beat trumps popularity is the motte to the bailey were being sold that he's not popular with conservatives.

It's certainly a rare view, but I was quite disappointed with and bored by 3. A good deal of what makes it work is the subversion of Connery from his usual expectations, and that is very cultural moment in time referential that degrades the further away you are. I also generally don't like the 'old-timer' tagging along or the adult man reconnects with distanced dad plots so, the whole team up weighed it down for me, and the Holy Grail bit with associated deadly magic was just derivative at this point.

2 was quite surprising at the quality and tone downgrade from 1, but once you accepted and adjusted I thought it was a fine and unique movie that really only suffered from following up on 1. It being more of a bottle made it comparatively worse than 1's globe-trotting but better than being a shallow derivative, which 3 and 4 and likely 5 all are.

  1. Almost brilliant, only weighed down by the fact that Indy doesn't actually have any agency over the plot. IIRC, Nazis get the arc and die from opening it in a timeline where he didn't exist. (9/10)

  2. A fun romp. (7/10)

  3. Boring, derivative action movie with a few timeless visuals, but overall better left in the 80s (5/10)

  4. Bad reboot with a has-been protagonist, with some watchable bits and some cringe bits in equal parts. (3/10)

  5. ... Flaming Garbage? (1/10)?

I watched the entire series for the first time a few years back and without the nostalgia or leaning on the cultural context of Sean Connery, I found each movie dramatically worse that the previous one, and about evenly. I thought the difference between 3 and 4 was about equal to the distance between 3 and 2, and then 2 and 1, quality wise.

Yeah but, by that logic it's a double reversal here. Not over-talking and refraining from gossip actually are admirable traits in anyone: women and men. So Ursela was actually giving good advice in the first movie - and explicitly worked out for Ariel. Her quiet shyness did endear her to Eric. And so removing that advice actually makes Ursula a worse person.

the man should be turned down a few hundred times before she finally accepts he can’t resist her and it’s true love.

In fairness, this is almost equally bad and unrealistic advice. Simping your way through the friendzone is not a much more effective strategy.

You're arguing for sexuality as a special zone of inappropriate discussion in public

I'm not arguing for anything here, it's that it's the relevant dimension here, and the comparison to other secular festivals is different on this specific ground. To equate Pride with them, is a game of hide the pickle.

Break out the template by it's components, the "Holiday Festival" starter kit, from the inside out:

  1. The core concept

  2. The values, priorities and value-system embodied by the concept

  3. A particular instance, example, or memorial of the concept forming the holiday

  4. Pious observance of the holiday

  5. Secular celebration and festivities connected to or an outgrowth from the holiday

  6. 'Spicy', 'Adult', or 'inappropriate' takes on and circumstances of indulgence in the festivities.

Take Mardi-gras:

  1. Catholicism

  2. Catholic morality, esp. pray, fasting, and alms-giving

  3. The Beginning of Lent

  4. Shrove Tuesday traditions

  5. Mardi-Gras

  6. Drunken carousing, partying, sex, and nudity.

4th of July:

  1. America

  2. American Patriotism & Democracy

  3. The signing of the Declaration of Independence

  4. Patriotic Displays, memorials, Bank holiday, etc.

  5. Picnics, parades, fireworks, boating at the lake.

  6. Adult parties with booze, etc.

In both of these instances, (and many more), one might criticize the inappropriateness of them on account of 6, or be specifically upset by children being around too much 6. And, like you have done here, we can rebut that the adult themes in 6, are not central or even necessarily relevant to 1-5. Neither does partaking in or exposing kids to 5, imply any sort of approval or support for 6.

But this doesn't work with Pride because adult themes are central to #1 and #2. There is no instance of 4 or 5 that is divorced from themes of sex and sexuality or divorced from values of sexual liberalism.

And while some things in bucket 6 like boozing, nudity, or sleeping around are not central to PRIDE, they are not nearly so divorced or in contradiction with the core themes as in other holidays, secular and religious. Acceptance of sexual liberalism, breaking of taboos and social mores, and celebration of eroticism are a core component of PRIDE, not tacked on or in tension with.

While there are plenty of prude, chaste, and modest LGBT members, perhaps even most of them, PRIDE itself is not remotely about integrating same-sex into heteronormative forms of disgression.

Pride is about sex and is adult themed. You can accuse me of wanting to specially zone that out of public modesty, but it's the opposite, you need to defend PRIDE's special and unique inclusion of it, and comparisons to other, non-sexually themed holidays are a motte and baily.

Sure, but there's a major difference, in that drunkenness and sexual debauchery are not a central, or even licit part of Catholicism, while gay sex is central to gay sexual identities, and things like BDSM are all explicitly celebrated under the umbrella of Pride.

The analogy of "Target selling kids rainbow shirts is different from the gay sex" to "Mardis Gras debauchery is different from Catholicism and Lent" doesn't really hold up.

In fact it's the opposite. One is a family-friendly expression of a concept that is centrally about adult sexuality, while the other is a debaucherously expression of a concept which is explicitly chaste.

My point exactly. (with the caveat that these people aren't conservatives. They are right-wing, republican liberals.)

You are describing what I used to criticize here as liberalism of the gaps: the theory that the solution to culture and institutions falling to progressivism via post-detraditionalization liberalism is MOAR liberalism!

No, the solution to protecting tradition and institutions is protecting tradition and institutions, both through fortification and legal protection. Libertarian solutions to protecting / building institutions cannot work in a legal landscape that makes a key component: free association, illegal.

OP is pointing this out with the fact that 'no politics' is subverted when you declare X value neutral. But the other side of the coin is also on display. When X is value neutral, anti-X is illegal discrimination / harassment. Start your own... cannot work without first winning back the neutral ground, which cannot be done when you spend all your time abandoning your institutions and fortifying elsewhere.

Show me an example where conservatives/traditionalists abandoned X to go build their own X-prime, where X-prime remains both not a ghetto and not actively infiltrated.

Your question about why traditionalists don't build their own X is easily answered in that they can't build their own X, and part of the reason is ironically because half their rank are actually liberals who keep telling them to build their own X.

Example:

Jonny Vanheusterwhilton is a made up character who used to get picked on as a child for his ridiculous last name, but that is completely irrelevant to this story so let's call him JV and we don't need to spell out his last name again.

Jonny V (JV), has lived in his neighborhood his whole life, even buying his parents' house when they retired. It's June 1st, and bigot that he is, JV (Jonny) bemoans that the neighborhood is plastered in Pride Flags and preachy yard signs. He's saddened that his neighborhood July 4th picnic has been discontinued and replaced with a late June Pride Party.

Jonny's actually not even a bigot, not even by modern standards, nor even a conservative. He is very pro-LGBT right, a believer in letting people live their own lives etc. He's just a combination of patriotic, nostalgic, and finds pride to be tacky and over commercialized. Yet this gets Jonny labeled a right wing bigot, which almost frustrates him as much as getting picked on for his name as a child.

Eventually his friend, @Primaprimaprima encourages him to just build his own neighborhood. (+) Out of options and tired of being picked on JV sells his family house and buys some farmland with several others in a less desirable exurban part of the town to turn into a new neighborhood. Saddened by the lack of mature hardwoods, history, culture, or accessibility to the broader city, JB puts that aside and focuses on the upside: no more Pride Month.

Although JV is not a conservative, it took partnership with a lot of them, and some outright bigots to even get this neighborhood started. No worries, though, because they aren't banning anyone. JV has a simple liberal solution: Their HOA will just say, no value-messaging yard decorations.

The HOA includes a lot of other shit JV doesn't like. His old neighborhood didn't have an HOA, but now, just to get back to neutral JV has to accommodate regulating EVERYTHING, even the length of his grass. He hates mowing. Almost as much as he hates his last name. Or being called a bigot.

Trouble begins when some of their conservative neighbors put up a cross on their front door, or Easter decorations. 'Hey,' yell the libertarian sect. NO MESSAGING. The French neighbor, Le Prima, convinces everyone that secularism is the best they can hope for in this new arrangement, the conservatives mostly* sadly acquiesce, telling themselves, at least it's better than Pride Month. (*A few with conviction move away to an even shittier, further exurb, to find out what happened to them scroll up to the + above and start reading. Continue recursively.)

This satisfies JV until July 4th comes around, JV's favorite holiday. There will be no J4 parade, and he is forced to take down the American flag he hung must come down at once.... Oh well... at least in the name of fairness this is a compromise.

JV wonders how previous generations like the one he grew up in were able to use maintain communities with shared traditions, while keeping out the elements they didn't like without over-regulating everything. JV can't ponder long before his neighbor accusingly reminds him about the types of discrimination that happened in yesterday. Remembering quickly that nostalgia for any aspect of the past is for bigots, JV quickly stops his musing, and never follows his train of thought to the answer: The type of community JV is describing is found alive in the neighborhood he left, albeit with different values.

Well all goes well for 2 more years until, as the city grows, his neighborhood does too. His exurb becomes a desirable suburb, and now folks who would have simply ignored the neighborhood move in. Doesn't matter thinks, JV, they'll have to live by our rules just like everyone else.

Imagine Jonny Vanheusterwhilton's shock on June 1st of the current year, when after returning from a trip oversees, he sees PRIDE FLAGS everywhere and a flier for a neighborhood pride parade.

"But.. but...but...," stutters Jonny. "I thought we didn't allow value messaging!"

"We don't," his helpful, new neighbor replies. "But... this was brought up at the HOA meeting you missed. You see us new neighbors quickly explained that this isn't about value messaging. It's common decency. To suppress it wouldn't be neutral, it would be bigoted and hateful. They saw it our way.

There were a few hold-out undesirables, but our lawyers were there to make sure they understood this is not negotiable, it's equality. I mean, anything less would be like not allowing you to hold your wife's hand while walking around the neighborhood."

"I'm actually gay," says Jonny.

"And a happy Pride Month to you!," the neighbor replies cheerily, while handing him a school board voting guide for the candidates who most protect trans youth.

That night, JV's visiting his old friend distraught. "It's simple," says Primaprimaprima as he opens a beer and hands to JV. "Just start your own neighborhood."

My wife actually added a job in the year after the third kid was born. I'm not sure how far apart yours are, but ours are pretty close and the third didn't blow up much that wasn't already deconstructed after the first kid.

Our third one was temperamentally, and schedule-wise the worst by a long-shot (e.g. sleep-training and fussiness) and that sucked, but was really just luck of the draw. It didn't affect bigger things much once we got through the beginning period.

That said, overall, I think where possible mothers should be at home with their children at least part time in the first several years in their lives, and if you're trying to balance a career to the point that you throw that kid in daycare, I disagree with that call. Although I'll probably have disagreed with your first two. My wife went down to part time work when our first was born, then left work for a few years when the second was born, then went back to working part-time once the third was ~6 months old.

I have had to be much more scheduled to make it all work, and I've taken on more housework, but overall I don't socialize much less than I do now. I've probably given up a few hobby-projects due to time/budget constraints, but not consciously and not all at once. I don't feel like #3 really adds all that much to the time commitment, but makes some times within that commitment a little more stressful.

Maybe, but the badness of his ideas are not super relevant to what @ace has laid out as absolutely piss-poor rhetoric and presentation, except in the narrow case of having such a clearly and obviously great idea that poor communication is negligible. On a meta-level the poor rhetoric does make the general uh, "credential" of 'super-smart, rational thinker' tremendously weaker.

If you present a good idea poorly, I am inclined to think less of it, if even subconsciously because I trust your evaluation less.

If you present a bad idea well, I am inclined to think more of it, if even subconsciously because I trust your evaluation more.

No matter how good or bad the idea is, there are better and poorer ways to present it, and Eliezer consistently chooses poorer. I spent years dismissing AI at all, mostly over Eliezer's poor presentation.

Ironically, as I've said before, he does come off as tremendously more human and likable to me in these interviews and my personal opinion of him has risen, but unlikely in a generalizable way across most audiences, and his persuasion game remains total shit.

does it give you any pause

It gives me no pause because I don't think it's seriously under consideration. If this was turned into a formal proposal tomorrow to be voted on at a Constitutional Convention, I can assure you I would regret the haste at which I spit out the content of my post.

Sounds plausible, but do you trust me?

I do trust that you would find that more aligned with particular object policies that you find better, and would be relieved that you were finally discussing the particulars of policy outcomes at such a level instead of the self-referential fetish over democracy as it's own end entirely.

I would likely disagree with your policy outcomes, and after going back and forth, you and I would settle on everyone getting a vote as a decent and fair compromise. But unlike the real you, we wouldn't think that the compromise was in itself the thing.

while disenfranchising those you dislike?

It has nothing to do with disenfranchising "those" I dislike and the fact that you read it so, is frustratingly uncharitable. This isn't a political test or a race requirement or anything like that. Almost anyone can become married and have kids. Those who chose to have more vested interest in the long term stability of the system.

it is about disenfranchising outcomes I dislike, which, by the way everybody wants. Everybody wants the things they value to be popular and the things they find bad to be suppressed. You do as well.

I don't think such a complex solution is workable anyway, but if you start splicing up voting rights beyond "everyone" it's a lossy thing to begin with, and I would worry less about catching edge cases. In this hypothetical, everyone above 25 gets a vote, but there is a general finger on the scale toward stable families, in such a scenario I would be less concerned about the distribution of that finger on the scale. Much like how a landowner requirements don't suggest that no-one without land would be capable of voting, but it's rather a broad brush toward a enfranchising a certain interest.

So overall both parents of a child get half an extra vote that they can use to vote as they wish. Then we can just count the votes after the election, giving 1/2 weighting to the green ballots.

This is the part I disagree with. Much of the benefit of giving a parent the extra vote weight is the investment and stability. Only married parents should get the extra vote.

If you want to get a divorce after having kids, you've proven your future planning unreliable enough. and if you're kids are already harmed by your (or your spouse's) bad decisions, you shouldn't have the benefit of sharing that with the rest of the country.

I think stable marriages is probably a stronger lever than number of children, and would largely mitigating @Walerodim 's hesitation.

My proposal would be something like:

  1. No voting under 26 unless you are married.

  2. If you are married your vote counts 1.5 extra

  3. If you ever divorce your vote reduces to .75, and remarriage doesn't affect this

  4. After age 40, if you are married and did not have children with your spouse, your 1.5 reduces back to 1

  5. After age 60 your vote reduces to 1 regardless.

Obviously that's too complicated to be realistic, but why not throw it out there for fun.

I think this is something that has to get figured out fast. I agree that right now, they can't really regulate that. At most the AMPTP could themselves agree not to train their own AI instances on it, but yeah, what's stopping you from using AI's already trained on that.

I have stated elsewhere, that I'm personally disposed toward supporting some kind of expansion of copyright-adjacent rights that includes training rights. But that would have to be a somewhat globally coordinated legal effort.

Natural law has nothing to do with christianity...only became part of catholic doctrine in the 13th century when Aquinas brought it in

In other words, it doesn't have nothing to do with it.

and never got baked into the other branches of christianity like it somehow did with catholicism.

Which is why I explicitly said that was an advantage of Catholicism over Protestantism, in this sense.

(and he does in fact exude lots of feminine energy)

I think this point is being refuted by the @hanikrummihundursvin :

His mannerisms are also just... gay.

which, I agree with. There's nothing feminine about his energy, maybe a grokkable distinction here is "effeminate". The 'energy' put out by this guy is not remotely like anything I've ever seen in any women I've met, and comes off more like someone who's never actually met a woman. On the other hand, it pattern matches for plenty gay men I've met, if a little less 'bitchy'.

Well Catholicism has the additional advantage of a sub-philosophy that suggests all these morals expressed within Natural Law, which doesn't necessarily have to be founded on "God".

But you're going to run into the pushback you find in the relativism across your other responses. You're framework is dismissed as an aesthetic complain because the moral relativist, the materialist, and the moral liberalist are married in gnawing at an object morality as arbitrary.

A Natural Law view offers a complete and coherent opposite view (while other conservative or Protestant viewpoints don't imho), but it doesn't and can't address why this not that. I suggest biting the bullet and deriving a religious foundation for your moral intuition or accept being homeless in a neighborhood of transhumanists.

I find surrogacy morally absurd, in pretty much the same reaction you do. I have gone back and forth on it with @TracingWoodgrains (respectfully) before, and it is (sadly) one of the best examples of why I can't adopt a 'live and let live' perspective, although I am dispositionally inclined toward that. I think it is a a sister moral issue to abortion, involving the commoditization of children and subordinating the natural family to liquid modernistic relativism.

Where I will push back, is that I don't think it's so much a transhuman issue as another slip of the sexual liberation + LGBT slope and repudiation that gay rights had much more social effect than, people doing their thing in the bedroom. Much like Grindr-> Tinder, this is another social-sexual transformation of norms that really matured in the gay community before being adopted by elite, then PMC straights.

Of course, straight surrogacy has been in the public consciousness for a long time (Phoebe from friends had a plotline around this in the 90s). But it really became trendy in the last decade through wealthy DINKy gay couples using this as an equal access avenue to 'biological children.

You will probably be mocked here and elsewhere for the Lovecraftian horror descriptor, but it fully resonates with me. But let me back it up, and roll back my anti-LGBT perspective here. This is ALL DOWNSTREAM from contraception, socially acceptable divorce and casual sex. I have become less and less patient with people who try to propose some limiting factor to sexual liberation that stops exactly where they want it.

The Catholic view is really the only one that provides a complete and coherent counter framework against this that isn't a bunch of special pleading.

I remember a later season Full House plotline where Jesse and Joey's side plot involved trying to build a self-driving car with help from Danny's mechanic (Hank?). At one point, Joey joked that it would be easier to teach a dog to talk than teaching a car to drive. Sure enough a few episodes later, Comet, the family dog, had a POV bit where he could talk (in the Garfield way). Of course, that just turned out the be a dream or imagination sequence of Michelle's.

Unfortunately, the actor who played Hank (I forget who) left the show and the plotline was kind of dropped and I think that's when Joey and Jesse went on to host a radio show. Point being, Full House, had a pretty good perspective on the challenges of AV and AI a few decades ahead of their time, albeit with a few forgivable misses and some comedic exaggeration. Possibly apocryphal, but "Whatever happened to predictability?" was supposedly meta-commentary on this whole idea.

personal perspective: I've listened to the first two Eliezer interviews and part of this one. Yes the guys, presentation is horrible etc, but I'm actually suprised at how receptive I've been to hear him out. I have always had very negative view of most ratsphere things, and Eliezer was prime example.

He does not present well outside of his fanbase in writing. Twitter to lessWrong, to HPMOR, he's always come off to me as insufferably arrogant, weird, and over concerned with how clever he is. (Anything SA has ever written on AI has been much much worse, his regular simple penetration of issues falls apart on the subject of AI, and has done more to make me (wrongly) dismissive of the whole thing than anything else.)

Back to Yud, having never actually seen or heard him before, I am shocked by how much more I like the guy in video format. He seems a lot nicer and sympathetic and likable than I ever imagined him. To the point that for the first time ever, I'm honestly open to hearing out his concerns and combined with Musk's views on the issue, I am in medium to high medium support of any 'pause' efforts, but tentative to being done in a way that doesn't require nuclear war or a totalitarian world government.

It is very bizarre to me that every normie in the world may have to, in their lifetimes, decide where they stand on a 'Butlerian Jihad'. This is a possibility I would have mocked relentlessly 18m ago, and am depressed that I even have given thought to.