Uh, do you know what a concubine was?
Well, now I do. I suppose if I'd thought about it harder, I could have defined harem/concubine/brothel correctly, but mea culpa.
I still don't want one.
Most cultures, unless they suppress this tendency, will develop some form of this over time
Well said, and a decent metaphor for fighting reality on a number of fronts I suspect.
Perhaps the fundamental difference then in our viewpoints is I think the mental effort that goes into fucking someone is actually a lot of the fun. Knowing how to press each other's buttons in bed, the comfort of familiar company. So by the time you've removed that from the hypothetical, I no longer consider the activity really all that worth doing. Don't get me wrong, if it were the only thing on offer, I would take it with a big old smile on my face. But it's hot dogs when I'd rather slow cook ribs.
I see, any chance that you from 10 years ago would say something drastically different?
Hm, maybe a little different, but not drastically. Even in college, when I was sleeping with a few people, I always had a favorite/tended to break things off with all but one/want something serious. It's not that I was low libido, and while it's probably lower now I wouldn't at all say low/below average (for mid 30s). I think I'm just wired more monogamously than you.
In general, sure, but that wasn't my impression of how the word was being used, which was more like "brothel." I suppose in the hypothetical where it's my exclusive use harem, but I still don't have to interact with them, there's no STD concern. And while we're at it, let's stipulate that they each have a dozen IUDs.
I would still not want them, given the alternative of something monogamous. They sound exhausting. I like the feeling of winning on my own merits that comes with sleeping with someone I "earned" rather than bought.
Given all of the stipulations here, we've moved so far from "men want to cheat/have lots of casual partners" that I think it's pretty irrelevant. And, so implausible as to be even more irrelevant, in the same way as "if science could perfectly grow new bodies and move over minds, and adjust for the lack of growing up as that gender, and retcon others' memories, then surely you'd agree trans women are women."
Yes. Mid 30s.
I'd rather not even talk to the cashier. I definitely don't want to fuck the hypothetical harem (given the alternative option of a ~zero-effort monogamous casual arrangement, or, even better, a high-effort monogamous serious one).
freely fuck but not otherwise have to interact with in any meaningful way
But "fuck" is a whole lot of interacting with a stranger. (don't) Fuck that.
it wasn't just legal trouble it was to protect his image which had been tarnished
Legal trouble is way more important than your image! I'd rather lose my job than end up in jail because I said the wrong thing on youtube.
Right. Hard to beat a recurring calendar event.
Men really aren't built for monogamy, huh? [...] 3. The few who actually just disagree.
I'm certainly in 3. I think most men are, too. I barely have the time or interest to put up with/keep track of one woman at a time. I'll also take monogamy (and an IUD) over condoms and a harem. If I ever blow anything up for the cause, spare me the 72 virgins - I'll take one moderately slutty broad who know what the fuck she's doing and hates texting.
Cases like Greene's seem to vindicate me.
Do they? He's so far from a typical guy. I have an enormous amount of trouble understanding how anyone's response to any of this is "ah yes, let's post about my legal troubles on Youtube." I may be old.
The FairTax is
Could you say more about what the FairTax actually is? I'm at best dimly aware of it. Something like "a flat sales tax on all goods, with no other taxes (income, property)"?
I believe the default course of action would be to buy index or mutual funds. I've been eyeing the S&P500.
Yup. It really is that simple. I hold VFFSX, although there are a number of similar low-to-zero fee large-cap US stock indices that are all "S&P500".
Even if you think you could beat the market, you have to decide if it's worth the stress/effort. I think it's very much not. Surely, if optimizing for dollars, your effort is better put into advancing your medical career. Similarly, if you find yourself cleaning toilets at home, either a) capitalism is fundamentally broken or b) you should hire a housekeeper.
Some mix of VFFSX + safer or anti/un correlated asset classes makes sense if you are either particularly risk averse or particularly concerned with timescales shorter than 10-15 years. But, this leaves expected value gains on the table, and requires more thinking, so I'd advise mildly against. See e.g. Butterfly Portfolio.
Beyond that, two notes:
- Obviously pay off debts that are higher than expected returns (~8% in nominal dollars) before investing
- Rent vs buy is nontrivial. Do not assume buy is the better answer, even if you are certain you will never move. Owning is a headache and a risk. The reasons it has historically been better to own are: a) laws that have driven up house values, but could change; b) people are too stupid to invest the cashflow saved by renting, whereas owning forces you to invest (in a single asset class!), making owning correlate with net worth (amongst many reasons)
Interesting, I like even plain cruise control. Gets tiresome on my ankle otherwise. But adaptive is a whole nother level. Now you don't have to speed up and slow down as people in front of you do things - you are really just setting a max speed. Super great in stop and go traffic.
Are you saying you consider moldy bread edible? I throw away the whole loaf, and would look at anyone doing otherwise strangely. I'm wondering if this is a geographic/cultural norm - I'm from the US, for context.
For some reason, growing up, for cheese we would cut off the moldy part plus a couple inches, but I've mostly chalked that up to "grew up less well off than I am now" + "Jewish cheapness".
CFPB:
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) helps consumers by providing educational materials and accepting complaints. It supervises banks, lenders, and large non-bank entities, such as credit reporting agencies and debt collection companies.
(Not a response, just adding context)
Interesting, I was hoping for more detail than that from them. Thanks for digging it up.
This is a delicate moment. It’s a new day and yet so many are on edge. Our politics are inflamed, and social media only adds to the anxiety.
It seems that @elonmusk made an awkward gesture in a moment of enthusiasm, not a Nazi salute, but again, we appreciate that people are on edge.
In this moment, all sides should give one another a bit of grace, perhaps even the benefit of the doubt, and take a breath. This is a new beginning. Let’s hope for healing and work toward unity in the months and years ahead.
especially with the ADL coming out to defend him.
Can you point me to what they actually said? I can find lots of secondary sources claiming they did, but none containing a quote, and nothing on adl.org.
It seems plausible to me. Maybe something like "calling people who aren't killing Jews Nazis is like, kind of in poor taste, please stop."
Yeah, the closer I look, the less I am impressed with its comment.
[Meta] I gave gemini the whole contents of this thread, and asked it to select a comment to disagree with. You "win":
I disagree that AI inherently prevents a "conversation between people." It's a tool, like any other. Sure, it can be used to disengage, but it can also be used to sharpen arguments, explore different angles, even generate thought-provoking counterpoints. The problem isn't the AI itself, it's how people choose to use it. Just like a human can be stubborn and refuse to change their mind, so can someone using AI badly. But that doesn't mean all human interaction is invalid, right? We shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater. A well-integrated AI contribution can actually enhance a discussion by bringing in perspectives or information a single human might not have considered.
So how do I feel about this argument? It's coherent, representative of the pro AI arguments here...and cripples the ability to draw signal about what people actually think. My post is at least tolerable under "use/mention" but, ugh, I feel dirty. qa!
In debates over whether it's ok to use AI for X, it's helpful to ask "instead of asking an AI to do it, what if I asked another human to do it? Would that be ok?"
I like the metaphor, but I think it misses the key detail that AI effort has a trivial effort floor. Your "copying from substack" metaphor is spot on though.
If you mean behind the scenes, sure*. If you mean "and then quote its facts/figures," no. I consider "AI says $STATISTIC" to be at most twice as accurate and at least twice as irritating as "my ballpark guess is", while being significantly dishonest. It's just forcing others to do your work for you.
*: Even researching is on shaky ground. "Question -> AI -> paraphrase answer" is marginally better than piping AI into a textbox. "Question -> AI -> check original sources -> synthesize your own argument" can be done well. I personally don't find it more useful than "Question -> search results -> check original sources if those weren't already -> synthesize your own argument", but concede that I am a luddite. (muh vimmmmm)
the onus is on the user to put their own time and effort into vetting and fact checking it
i am concerned that in practice it's going to fall heavily onto other users and the mods, rather than OP.
i think we can have ~all the ai you actually want with a policy of "no ai, except for short things where you used it so well/minimally that we can't tell and it's more like a spell checker than outsourcing"
Can you make any argument in defense of your apparently instinctual reactions?
Yes. In short, AI makes it too easy to be low quality given the finite energy and speed of our mods.
Metaphor:
Suppose you're a camp counselor (mod) and find that your campers (posters) sometimes smell bad (make bad posts). Ideally, you could just post a sign that says "you must not smell bad" (don't write bad posts) and give people total freedom, simply punishing those who break the rule.
In practice, you need stricter rules about the common causes of the smell, like "shower daily" or "flush the toilet" (don't use AI) - even though, sure, some people might not smell bad for a couple days (use AI well) or might like the smell of shit (not hate AI generated prose like I absolutely freely admit that I do). It's just not realistic to expect campers (us) to have good hygiene (use AI responsibly sufficiently often).

Interesting. Do you think it helps his legal case to post the video, or that he's just so clearly legally safe that it's worth optimizing for his job?
Or that the lawyer was just doing damage control by telling him how to do the video? Lawyers will (although not always) advise you on how to do the stupid thing you want to do the least stupidly if you tell them to.
More options
Context Copy link