@magic9mushroom's banner p

magic9mushroom

If you're going to downvote me, and nobody's already voiced your objection, please reply and tell me

2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 10 11:26:14 UTC

				

User ID: 1103

magic9mushroom

If you're going to downvote me, and nobody's already voiced your objection, please reply and tell me

2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 10 11:26:14 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1103

I thought I turned off the www.reddit -> old.reddit filter, but in any case, it's on now and I can't find any way to turn it off.

IIRC the Chinese WWIII plans are basically a repeat of Pearl Harbour (possibly excluding the "no declaring war" part), with massive missile attacks on all US bases in the West Pacific (and Free Asian bases) and, yes, massive ASAT use to destroy all US military satellites. So yeah, Kessler syndrome begins on day one.

Kessler syndrome would take some time to fully destroy Starlink, as it's more a case of "satellites have a half-life measured in weeks" than "all the satellites explode instantly". But I'd expect it to probably be useless by the time the nukes flew, let alone afterward (where scenario #2 kicks in).

Starlink will not cause Kessler, and that was legit clever.

It will be destroyed by Kessler, should it occur. There are other satellites above them whose debris can go through the Starlink volume without burning up, and elliptical orbits with drag at perigee lose apogee first until they circularise (i.e. they would continue going through the Starlink orbital volume for years).

Also, no, I didn't say "uber-Carrington". I just said Carrington II. The reason the historical Carrington Event didn't destroy satellites is just that we didn't have any yet.

I already have a lot of this (due to the nuclear prep that I started in 2022 and got serious about in 2024), including a fair amount of bottled water, but eh, I suppose I could increase the amount of non-perishables I keep on hand somewhat.

(Does help that I'm anorexic and well-fed, the latter partially as more doom prep. To put it another way, by the time I actually start getting upset with the lack of food, cannibal looter mobs will be rampant and I'll likely have had to shoot some.)

(Although, come to think of it, I think the existence of Starlink makes a total telecommunications outage extremely unlikely.)

There are quite a few scenarios in which Starlink is toast.

  • ASAT use or other Kessler Syndrome trigger
  • High-altitude nuke creates a temporary third radiation belt (as Starfish Prime did)
  • Carrington Event II: Electric Boogaloo

They're in space, but they're not invulnerable; they're just vulnerable to different things - and you may be noticing that all three of these cases look like they're likely associated with shit hitting the fan (although not all SHTF scenarios include one of these).

You wanted to stop contemplating existence of Carthesian-Daemon because

of this, which I've quoted already.

Essentially, if a Cartesian Daemon is messing with your mind, contemplation (individually or in groups via discussion) can produce arbitrary answers with no relation to what is true (a Daemon that wants to ensure you conclude X, or wants to prevent you concluding Y, can definitely do so by messing with your cognition).

So, let's break this down into cases.

Case 1: Cartesian Daemon. Discussion intended to achieve truths (which philosophical discussion - philosophical meaning "loving of wisdom" - is) will fail, so we might as well not do it.

Case 2: No Cartesian Daemon. Discussion might achieve things, but since there's no Cartesian Daemon we don't need to discuss that particular possibility.

Morton's Fork: both Case 1 and Case 2 imply that discussing Cartesian-Daemon scenarios is pointless, so since one of them's true this is true unconditionally.

I assumed that this proof was obvious i.e. that you would spot it the instant I alluded to the idea without my needing to spell it out, and that indeed spelling it out might be considered insulting. Apparently I was wrong and it's not obvious to you. So I spelled it out. The obviousness was not load-bearing, just a matter of etiquette. I have already said this. I am getting sick of repeating myself.