@naraburns's banner p

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

				

User ID: 100

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 100

A week? That's ridiculous, it wasn't even a swear word.

What fucking difference would that make? It's not the words you use, here--it's how you use them.

I think you banned him because you know he is one of the few motters who could and would eloquently and persuasively defend that position.

I think I temp-banned him because next time I want him to lead with the eloquence and persuasiveness you seem to think he has at his disposal. I have quite had my fill of people getting moderated and then responding to me with eloquence and persuasiveness--or at least, with the evidence and effort they declined to furnish in the first place.

I want people to do that before they get moderated, and if they fail to do that often enough, then they're going to eat a ban. That's how this works--as you well know.

some Japanese megacucks

This kind of thing just degrades discourse.

Banned for a week.

I'm not engaging you on substance here--I was just providing examples that might help you understand why you were being moderated on inadequate effort.

That seems messed up.

This is not really sufficient effort for engagement on the matter. "That seems messed up" signals your disapproval ("that view seems low status") without explaining why you disapprove, or how the observed evidence might be explained in other ways.

(It may help to sub a different ingroup/outgroup to grasp the dynamic here. For example, if the other user had suggested that men are naturally more violent than women, would you say "that seems messed up?" Or imagine they had suggested that young people are naturally more violent than old people, or that people with cognitive impairments are naturally more violent than cognitive normies. Whether any of these claims is actually true or false, you can hopefully see why someone might make such claims, and think of the kinds of evidence that would strengthen or weaken your tendency to endorse or reject such claims.)

The current release (as far as I know) of the agenda specifies that any child that expresses any interest or ideation about himself being transgender, should be immediately medically, socially and surgically transitioned, parents have no legitimate way to react to it except fully supporting and enabling it, and in case they do anything else, they should be immediately and irreversibly striped of all parental rights.

I'm not sure this even rises to the level of a weak man, though maybe you could point me to someone actually espousing precisely this position. My suspicion, though, is that this is a full fledged strawman. Please work harder to portray your outgroup's views in a way they would be likely to recognize and agree to, or barring that, at least in a way that brings strong argument/evidence that this is what they actually believe in spite of their protestations to the contrary.

I think you’re totally misunderstanding the motivations and thought process of the average woman who gets an elective abortion.

The motivations and thought process of the average woman who gets an elective abortion was not the point, there. The point was that progressives do not oppose eugenics per se; practices of a eugenic character are in no need of special particular motivational states in order to be eugenic practices.

Eugenics requires perceiving oneself and one’s progeny as part of a larger biological project

So, yes, if we're talking on a personal level about individual motivations, the science of "improving stock" (as Galton put it) is something individuals are not necessarily thinking about when they make decisions of a eugenic nature. But this was a discussion about policy, and I was responding to someone else who suggested that progressives oppose eugenics, which is simply not true. Progressives are fine with a wide array of eugenic practices, so long as people don't talk about the eugenic character of those practices (especially, while using the word "eugenics").

Ah. Thanks for letting me know; it doesn't show as "deleted" for me when I follow the context link; I have go to their user page to see that. @ZorbaTHut, this is a very minor issue and I know you're very busy with important things, but I'm pinging you in case this is site behavior you're not aware of.

@Felipe, if you're out there, given that it was a burner account I'd love for you to restore the comment! But I won't reprint it here since it I will assume you took the affirmative step of making it unavailable for good reason.

progressives as considering Eugenics so taboo that they oppose even oppose sperm banks of very talented people

They don't, though. Or rather, they do in cases where society has attached the word "eugenics" to a particular activity, but primarily a matter of social signaling. I cannot think of a more obviously eugenic practice than elective abortion; "the time is not right to have a child" or "this child is genetically defective and so I will terminate the pregnancy" is an extremely eugenic decision, and of course abortion is a keystone of American leftist politics. Virtually every human I know is at least weakly, and often strongly, eugenic in every way that makes any practical difference. Progressives have always loved eugenics, and still do; they just hate the word and its historical associations.

replaced by deep concerns about ableism

In particular, a progressive is far more likely to abort a Down syndrome baby than a conservative. In some especially progressive parts of the world, Down syndrome has essentially been eliminated via elective abortion. I admit that I regard most cries of "ableism" as fundamentally unserious for this and other reasons (like the progressive advocacy of assisted suicide for non-terminal and/or psychiatric maladies). You have to separate the signaling from the substance, though.

You'd still want whoever the smartest people in the world are currently working in your labs regardless of how their children turn out.

Even if, say, their children turn out to cause a crime wave? Surely that can't be right. Anyway you're not entirely mistaken, but the case is essentially overdetermined here.

There's no IQ gap that would be small enough to not be taboo, because we're all the way down the slur cascade.

Sure, but it's important to notice the difference between tabooing a word and certain specific historical examples, and actually disavowing a concept. Eugenics remains a fundamentally progressive idea; progressives just stopped calling it that. This is a very common approach to progressivism, shedding unpopular names for things while keeping their practical substance intact (see e.g. "cultural Marxism").

Can you be more specific? I just went through and mod-noted everyone's accounts (we keep track of AAQCs) and none of the current crop appear to be deleted. However I am logged in as a moderator so perhaps you are seeing something I don't.

What should be done about racial gaps in IQ?

Progressives have this insane tendency to assume that if it really is true that blacks aren’t as smart as whites on average, then the only logical thing to do would be to murder all of our fellow black citizens in Treblinka-style death camps. Why? Because, they apparently reason, only Nazis, as they’ve so often said, think blacks have lower mean IQs, so if it turns out that the IQ Nazis are right, well, that means Hitler should be our role model.

This article is not the worst thing I've ever read on the subject, but it's frustrating how readily people go to the strawmen/weakmen/worst-case-scenario in these discussions.

If you don't personally think of native intelligence as high-status, then you aren't going to much care if (say) Asians are more likely to have it than Native Americans. In fact many people throughout history have treated native intelligence as either neutral or low-status; in some circumstances it might be bad to be smart (recall the manioc example from The Secret of Our Success). Because the "Information Age" has imbued nerds with social cachet they haven't always enjoyed, this is less often the case today than it has been in the past.

Progressives are (like most Westerners) far too quick to run to the Nazi analogy, but their underlying concerns are more, I think, a combination of their own eugenic instincts and their concern that social programs not be dismantled. Because progressives tend to think of intelligence as high-status, they also think of it as the sort of thing that should be distributed "fairly" (i.e., as equally as possible, whatever that means). But because progressives also tend to think we should "follow the science," specifically through government intervention in the human condition, they tend to jump immediately from facts to action plans. Tell a progressive that you've developed a low-cost, low-energy, non-polluting technology that turns dirty water into clean water, and they're immediately wondering how that technology can be deployed to benefit of humanity. Tell a progressive that you've found the genetic cause of a particular disease, and they're immediately wondering how we can turn that discovery into a treatment. The progressive mindset is fundamentally one of engineering the human condition.

To a deeply conservative mind, the proposition that "some people are stupid, it runs in families just like eye, hair, and skin color" is not only so blindingly obvious that researching it seems like a huge waste of time money, but also just a fact of life from which no particular conclusions need be drawn. Oh, sure, maybe you have second thoughts about marrying the handsome boy when you realize he's kind of dull; you think "do I really want to have this guy's dull children?" But this is not substantially more eugenic than secretly hoping that your children get your wife's red hair.

But the deeply conservative mind is living in the human world, not attempting to renovate it. So when a progressive is presented with mountains of meticulously-assembled peer-reviewed evidence that (1) IQ is substantially predictable along the lines of racial heritage and (2) IQ substantially influences the quality of a community's culture and economy, they don't just shrug their shoulders like a conservative. They start to wonder--how can we use this information to engineer the human condition? And the human mind, in its wonderfully inventive way, starts making suggestions: sterilize the idiots! Increase high-intelligence immigration from other nations! Uh... date white men and Asian women, perhaps?

In this way, progressive opposition to the very expression of the data on these matters is a kind of "telling on themselves," so to speak. It's not that they think the only logical thing to do would be to murder anyone with a low-IQ; it's that even a cursory grasp of HBD painfully illustrates the incredible shortcomings of progressivism as an ideology. If it turns out that your life is good, not because of anything the government has done for you, but because you live among the right sort of people, then huge swathes of social policy are just pointless and wasteful expenditures, fruitless attempts to engineer the human condition that can never, ever succeed until we literally engineer the humans themselves. This is incompatible with Western liberalism, and further exposes the daylight between "liberal" and "progressive." It threatens to unravel such entrenched political interests that the only possible response from the ingroup is to taboo the subject entirely.

You've managed to draw seven reports on this comment (boo-outgroup - 3, antagonistic - 3, low-effort - 1) which is far from a record but it's still pretty impressive.

You've also managed to get meta-moderated at "Not-Bad" (lowish confidence) so I'm pinging @ZorbaTHut as this is the first significant meta-moderation outlier I've seen during the testing phase.

Anyway, more partisanship = more effort, please.

Too much "boo outgroup," not enough thoughtful engagement. More effort than this, please.

Should I develop bioweapons or go on an Uncle Ted-like campaign to end this terrible take?

More effort than this, please.

Nah, he apparently went through peak trans recently, but otherwise this is perfectly in character.

Although the mod team is, in general, comparatively thick-skinned, this is still not the sort of response we ever, ever want to see here in the Motte. It is low effort and antagonistic, all heat and no light, sweeping where it should be specific (the fuck is "peak trans" in this context?) and specific (i.e. personal) where it should be more sweeping.

This is a bad comment. Don't post like this.

Then, you really do have an odd definition of "anti-Catholic." The Mormon Church used to teach that blacks were the cursed descendants of Cain and/or Ham; were those who criticized those doctrines therefore "anti-Mormon"? I don't see how.

It seems like a pretty common belief in the history of Christianity generally, but yes--I have a hard time imagining someone discussing the racist history of Christianity in a way that is pro-Christianity. Perhaps it could be discussed neutrally, as a mere historical curiosity, but you yourself identify these transvestites as doing something to "clearly ridicule Catholicism," and ridicule is not a neutral act. So you're either being disingenuous now, or you are maintaining an untenable distinction between ridiculing something and being "anti-" that thing. And like, if that's really how you're splitting the hair, okay, but it seems a little absurd to me.

Catholics, maybe, but Catholicism? This seems like splitting hairs incredibly fine

Isn't that exactly what Martin Luther did? He criticized the Church, but not the religion.

To the best of my understanding, his maintenance that there even is a difference was itself anti-Catholic, and history (specifically, the existence of Lutheranism as a competitor meme) seems to bear that out. But I'm not a theologian, so.

But, if one looked at the website of the organization in question, and saw zero references to Catholicism there, I would think that one would update one's beliefs.

Except you yourself already allowed that there is not "zero references" to Catholicism at that website, owing to the caricatured Catholic nuns. This substantially increases my suspicion that you are, in fact, just trolling.

So would you agree that blackface is not "anti-black" per se? Do you believe that caricatures of Jews are not "anti-Semitic" per se?

There are a thousand reasons to dress in drag as a nun other than being anti-Catholic. To criticize certain Catholic doctrines re homosexuality.

Er... maybe we have different ideas about what it means to be "anti-Catholic," but criticizing Catholic doctrines of homosexuality sounds paradigmatically "anti-Catholic" to me. Pushing back on political efforts by the Catholic church seems "anti-Catholic," especially given the Church's long political history.

And, btw, one can criticize the Catholic Church (an enormously powerful institution) without criticizing either Catholics or Catholicism.

Catholics, maybe, but Catholicism? This seems like splitting hairs incredibly fine, to the point of suggesting a motte and bailey doctrine at play. Mockery has long been a highly effective approach to criticism, and criticism is not pro-, it is anti-.

"You can keep your Catholicism, we're just going to level your Church, caricature your symbols, mock your practices--no, we're not anti-Catholic per se, don't be ridiculous!"

That seems implausible to me.

You linked to their website, but there is nothing there about Catholicism at all.

...you don't think a panoply of wildly caricatured Catholic nuns is about Catholicism "at all?"

Why? You're literally telling me that I can't say that the Emperor is naked, even if he is in fact naked.

No one on the mod team is treating SecureSignals as an emperor, least of all @Amadan.

I should point out that he is naked in a round-about way, hoping that everyone goes through my argument and comes to the same conclusion that I'm not allowed to state openly.

Yes.

...it's that he's stupid or pretending to be stupid.

Well, maybe, but you haven't actually assembled the evidence for that. I don't think SecureSignals is either stupid or pretending to be stupid. To the contrary; they post evidence and arguments that are cherry-picked, but they do post evidence and arguments, things you can go check for yourself. And often when someone has gone to the trouble of checking for themselves, it has produced interesting posts that further confirm the fact that Nazi Germany is directly and through second-order effects responsible for the deaths of millions of Jews in the mid-20th century. I have never seen anyone produce evidence that SecureSignals is stupid or lying, only that they tend to engage in isolated demands for rigor and focus only on one side of the argument--which is exactly how the bulk of Holocaust affirmation has proceeded for decades, and exactly how the bulk of most arguments proceeds.

The goal, of course, is to transcend that, and we don't transcend that by calling people names. As we often end up needing to do here, I have to remind you that this is explicitly a place for testing shady thinking, which means that shady thinking is explicitly allowed. In fact the mod team has recently been discussing longer-term bans for SecureSignals, because there is an "egregiously obnoxious" threshold on being a one-note piano. But instead we're spending our mod time dealing with the low hanging fruit of people who are trying to insist that no, they don't have to follow the rules when they are engaged with Holocaust skepticism.

Sorry: yes, you do.

@SecureSignals is either stupid or is pretending to be stupid to spread his bullshit. This is what I truly believe and I can defend this belief with arguments if anyone is interested.

Start by defending that belief with arguments, and you may even get more leniency on your word choice! But doubling down on "stupid" after a direct warning from a mod just gets you another warning. Knock it off.

More effort than this, please.

You think these are the core defining traits of the Holocaust? Not, say, the mass murder?

For those who were aware of the camps but not personally aware of the murder--yes! Those would be the core defining political traits of the Holocaust for German citizens.

Considering how often I was personally accused of literally committing mass murder by being vocally opposed to lockdowns and government-mandated masking during COVID, I have to agree with @Azth here. "Certainly they wouldn't be considered synonymous with absolute evil" seems like a wildly optimistic take on "Nazi concentration camps without the actual executions." Indeed, it is now widely agreed in American jurisprudence that the Japanese internment camps were barely distinguishable from Nazi concentration camps, and they are often offered as an example of nearly-absolute evil, listed alongside slavery and Native American relocation programs as among the worst of U.S. history.

I understand that many people (maybe you?) are utilitarians who think that the reason to favor or disfavor certain things is to just check the consequences. But you don't actually get to check the practical consequences of the laws you pass, before you pass them. Rounding up the Jews in Nazi Germany was not sold to the German people as a campaign of mass murder. There was never a law that said "the penalty for being Jewish is death." The law was: we're gonna massively curtail your rights if you're an undesirable, we're gonna segregate you from the population, detain you, relocate and re-educate you for the greater good.

"But COVID was a good reason to pass such laws, and anti-semitism wasn't" is an argument that does make these things distinguishable in substance. But with regard to the relationship between state action and individual rights, the only difference between the Holocaust and COVID lockdowns was how things turned out in the end. And even then, based on the attenuated logic of the people who accused me of being a mass murderer, COVID lockdowns likely also resulted in unnecessary deaths (e.g. of loneliness), further blurring the lines.

This is why I am so strongly opposed to large, powerful governments. I do not think it is at all unfair to compare those who went along with lockdowns with those who went along with the Holocaust, because the consequences were not knowable in advance in both cases. For non-victims, the question was always and only: "how far will you go along with the government when you think its individual rights-constraining actions are intended for the greater good?" And the answer in both cases, distinguishable though they were, was, "apparently, pretty damn far."

EDIT: I guess I think I should add, for clarity, that while I do somewhat fault the German people circa 1935 for the horrors their government perpetrated, I would not strongly condemn the rank-and-file Germans for the Holocaust (the way I would strongly condemn, say, Hitler or Goebbels), any more than I strongly condemn rank-and-file Americans for putting me through COVID lockdowns. I do weakly condemn both groups! What I think makes this line of reasoning interesting, in part, is that I suspect a lot of people strongly condemn the anti-semitism of rank-and-file Germans as being, essentially, complicity with the Holocaust. For pro-lockdown Americans who feel that way about 20th century Germans, I can imagine being quite offended by the comparison. But I personally do not regard pro-lockdown Americans as "literally Hitler," I regard pro-lockdown Americans as "approximately as culpably and benightedly statist as mid-20th century Germans, who were also not literally-Hitler."

Including shitty (literally) down towns in at least one case (SF). But go ahead, keep voting D to solve problems which the Ds don't solve; it's traditional.

This comment is paradigmatically partisan, but not paradigmatically evidence-laden. Please be more careful about that.

the results do show that most Thais are fed up with the status quo

Is it the "status quo" they don't like, or is it the king, personally? I don't know very much about Thailand, but my understanding circa 2010 was that the (then) king was overwhelmingly beloved, an important figure in culture as well as politics. He died in 2016, and his successor was apparently already unpopular at that point. In principle, opposition to having a monarchy is different from opposition to having this guy as the monarch. I recognize that in practice, the difference is largely academic--I just wonder how many other changes (perhaps including the LGB stuff?) are essentially riding the coat-tails of what is actually public distaste for a specific individual.

Re: Haidak I have to plead ignorance on how much of the UMass grievance procedure is shaped by Title IX requirements, but either way I don't think it is really that important to the broader point.

I mean, it was your example, so to backpedal when it becomes clear that the example cuts against your argument seems like poor sportsmanship, but sure.

If 'government jobs where I feel that the cost outweighs the benefit' comes under 'bullshit jobs' then it's a stupid and pointless framework.

There's nothing about feeling happening here, and it is bad rhetoric for you to sneak that in there. My argument is that the supposed "benefits" of Title IX could have manifested without bringing along the obscene degree of bureaucracy. You conceded that point:

I suspect that as you suggest the growth of women's sports was happening anyway

And that's all you need to concede to agree with me. A bullshit job is not a job where nothing ever happens, or nothing meaningful ever happens, or things happen that I don't like. It's a job that either adds nothing, or is actively harmful, compared to a world where the job was never brought into existence in the first place. And you have already conceded everything you need to concede for Title IX jobs to fit that description. I think someone else has already pointed this out to you elsewhere in the thread, but you seem to have an idea of "bullshit jobs" that does not match with the sociological writing that coined the phrase.

Why the hell was Haidak kicked out in the first place? Because Title IX has been interpreted to require universities to referee adolescent relationships!

Can't say for certain of course but I am fairly confident that universities would want to punish rape/sexual assault quite harshly even without Title IX.

What does this have to do with anything? First: no, in cases of rape and sexual assault the universities would be best off letting the police handle it. Universities should not in general be in the business of punishing criminal activity. They don't even generally have the expertise to reasonably investigate it. Not even the people running Title IX offices are, as a rule, trained to investigate and prosecute crimes. (Frankly it would be preferable for higher education become completely sex-segregated, than for us to ask a bunch of academics to hold the kangaroo courts they generally hold on such matters.)

But second, what do you think this has to do with Haidak?

The plaintiff, James Haidak, and his then-girlfriend Lauren Gibney were both UMass students studying abroad in Barcelona in 2013. There was a physical altercation between them; Gibney said Haidak attacked her, while he asserted that he was defending himself while she was trying to hit and kick him. Gibney complained to UMass, which started a student conduct case against Haidak and imposed a no-contact order between the two. However, despite the no-contact order, Haidak and Gibney continued to have frequent, consensual contact and maintained a relationship over the summer. After learning that Haidak was contacting Gibney, UMass waited 19 days, then issued a second charge against Haidak: for harassment and failure to follow the no-contact order. Less than a week later, Gibney and her mother reported that there was continued contact between Haidak and Gibney. UMass waited another 13 days, then issued another charge against Haidak for harassment and breaking the no-contact order and summarily suspended him.

Neither rape nor sexual assault appear to be implicated here at all. This was a lover's spat--to even call it "domestic violence" would take things too seriously. This is exactly what I said it was: Title IX being interpreted to require universities to referee adolescent relationships, something universities might be even worse at than refereeing charges of sexual assault.

The key question is whether the benefits of Title IX outweigh the costs

Well sure but that doesn't really address the question of the bullshit-ness of the jobs, that's then just an ordinary policy debate.

I feel like you are telling me that you don't understand bullshit jobs without telling me you don't understand bullshit jobs. A job in which the cost of the job outweighs the benefits of the job just is a bullshit job.

I suspect that as you suggest the growth of women's sports was happening anyway but nonetheless Title IX accelerated and shaped those changes (same for the other areas that Title IX impacts).

Agreed: it "shaped" the process by implementing pointless bureaucracy for no discernible benefit. The perceived benefits were coming anyway, without the costs. Now the status quo is so entrenched that nobody will countenance ending those costs; indeed, the discussion is that we should pay more for a process that should never have been started in the first place. This is paradigmatic bullshittery.

In my non-US university, there were a tonne of 'Women in Defence Intelligence', 'Women's night for networking with accounting company people' events. I imagine these kinds of things still happen in the US but aren't federally funded. Any US university people know anything about this?

I'm not entirely sure what you mean. Such events certainly happen at American universities. Whether they are directly or indirectly "federally funded" will vary from case to case. But for example the U.S. Department of Agriculture has a grant program for "Women and Minorities in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics Fields" that could probably be used to fund some such things.