To me, it's kind of like asking what happens if an amateur managed to prove the Riemann hypothesis or a billionaire self-funded a cure to Alzheimers; perhaps it's possible in theory, but in practice if it was so easy it would already have been done.
We can see that even pre-AI the romantic idea of another Ramanujan arising from outside the establishment was risible in reality, and now post-AI all of the most significant advances are being made with the contribution of some of the smartest mathematicians in the world backed by internal models and enormous amounts of compute; I see no reason for this trend not to continue.
In some senses it's not really all that surprising. It's already impossible to push the frontier in biology or physics without significant amounts of capital backing and a decade of training to even begin to understand a tiny fraction of the existing frontier; mathematicians will just have to deal with this reality as well. The fields medal is kind of a symbol of the mathematical fetish of youth and the lone genius, which AI is now killing for good; see Terence Tao on the end of the age of heroes.
So in your view, they would probably just stop awarding Fields Medals?
Anglo people (and many other cultures e.g Chinese) view housing as an investment and hence over time laws are shaped around this preference e.g strict zoning laws to keep property values high and the population happy. T
Well what's your evidence for this link? Do agree that zoning laws are rather lax in Houston? And if so, are you saying that the culture on the Texas gulf coast doesn't see housing as an investment?
Yeah I agree with most of your criticisms, but my point was I don’t think the complaint about women’s attractiveness really falls into the same category as 14th century Hungary having the racial diversity of Chicago.
I respectfully disagree with your point very strongly. Because in my view, with flag-planting, it's the underlying message that matters. And that message is the same either way regardless of how subtle or blatant the flag is.
The former has a certain charm, a certain patina, because it doesn’t just cast hot people. It could, there are enough beautiful underemployed actors even in England. But it gains something by not doing so, for in American television the impossible hotness of everybody in a small town grocery store or police department or family on TV contrasts with the reality of those who know it to be laughably impossible, laughably unrealistic to the point that one’s sense of disbelief is tested.
FWIW I would definitely accept a "realism" deal when it comes to media (video games, television, movies, etc.). I find it really annoying when, for example,
(1) black people are inserted into a medieval European fantasy setting, or even an actual historical setting;
(2) with almost every husband and wife, the woman is always smart and wise while the man is a bumbling idiot;
(3) small villages in fantasy settings are presented as having the racial diversity of modern-day Los Angeles;
(4) street thugs are almost always portrayed as white men;
(5) women are portrayed as men's equals (or betters) when it comes to hand to hand combat;
I could go on, but I think you get the point. If I could get rid of all this woke nonsense at the price of losing hot women, I'd be pretty happy about it.
But I doubt the woke would go for it. Because I'm pretty sure that for them "realism" is an excuse not an actual motivation.
The end point of this logic is that endless stream of Japanese media where all the characters are hot teenagers and everybody’s depressed their whole lives because media overfocuses on romanticizing like a 3 year period before adult life begins.
If games only feature hot young adults they miss out on telling stories about the middle aged, the old, the ugly, children, the disabled, and those are often some of the most interesting stories in any literary canon.
If the goal were simply to tell interesting stories (with realistic characters), I wouldn't object. But from the circumstances, it seems reasonably clear that that's not what's been going on. So for example, suppose there is an existing and popular franchise and a new game comes out in that series and it contains a lot of "woke" elements. Perhaps the female characters are less attractive or less traditionally feminine (but a similar change is not necessarily made to the male characters). If the goal is simply to tell interesting stories, why insert this specific set of elements? For that matter, why do it in an existing franchise and not do something completely new?
As the old saying goes, please don't pee on my leg and tell me it's raining.
So..what was all this talk then about Woke being dead or on the retreat?
Yeah, I think that the basic mechanism of wokeness has been around for thousands of years and isn't going away any time soon. Because in my view, wokeness is not so much a set of beliefs as a process by which people compete for social status by making a show of siding with the (perceived) downtrodden/underdog/marginalized.
And even the most recent incarnation of wokeness (in which the designated victims are blacks, trans people, Palestinian Arabs etc.) doesn't seem to be going away at the moment.
I think Miranda was very much a case of design and/or tech failures meaning Bioware didn't achieve the desired look for her, rather than them actively deciding to make her look plainer
I don't know about this particular game, but I've seen comparison of male and female characters which make me think that the "tech failure" argument is generally invalid.
In other words, I've seen cases where (1) the male actor for the game is handsome and the character based on him is similarly handsome; and (2) the female actor for the game is beautiful but the character based on her is noticeably less attractive.
There's further evidence of this hypothesis being correct: the Woke could simply go on to invent, design, create and market their own original games, which can then be just as Woke as they want them to be. But this is not their strategy. It's capturing and ruining games and franchises that already exist.
Yeah, I have had thoughts along these lines. So for example, one can imagine a game developer which gives users an option to choose a "traditional mode," in which the female characters are beautiful; there are no black people inserted into medieval European fantasy worlds; and so on. Naively, one might think this would make everyone happy: People who prefer more woke gameplay can have that; people who prefer more traditional gamely can have that.
But I'm pretty confident that in such a situation, the woke would not be happy at all. Evidently it's very important to them that EVERYONE play the version of the game which accommodates their preferences. So yeah, it seems to be about flag-planting.
I suppose it could just be as simple as "I don't want (unworthy autistic) men to be able to view images of attractive women".
FWIW, I think it's "I don't want men to get inexpensive female gratification or validation."
I am always skeptical of evolutionary "just so stories," but I think that in the ancestral environment (as today) women were utterly dependent on male provisioning and protection for survival. (It's an interesting thought experiment to ask what would happen to women in 2026 if men disappeared. Almost certainly 99% would be dead within a few months.) Fortunately for women, men are very desirous of female validation and gratification. So not only do women not starve to death, they are given an exalted position in society.
But I think that instinctively, women perceive it as a threat to their very lives if men get inexpensive female gratification or validation. Here's an example of what I mean: Suppose a woman is hired by a male-owned pornography producer and is paid $200 to do some nastiness on camera; the resulting video is sent all over the world to be downloaded and appreciated by men for a few dollars each, if that. Almost all women get extremely upset by this. "objectification! exploitation!" they scream. By contrast, suppose there is a female OnlyFans producer who makes millions of dollars a year from desperate men who get naked pictures of her and text with call center workers who they think are this OF girl. By and large, women have much less of a problem with the situation, even though it still clearly involves both objectification and exploitation. Objectification + woman makes lots of money = fine. Objectification + woman makes very little money = bad.
Anyway, I think this principle makes sense from an evolutionary perspective and seems to fit pretty well with women's behavior.
There's a certain brand of woke woman that just genuinely does not enjoy seeing attractive women in media
Is it that they don't like seeing attractive women in media, or they don't like the idea of MEN seeing attractive women in media? Certainly I get the impression that if there's a movie made for women which contains an attractive lead actress (perhaps the Barbie movie?), it's far less of a problem for woke women.
I think this second issue plays a role, which is part of the reason video games are such a touchy subject. They are perceived as being made for men.
Rose Belmont looks rather androgynous, but the game's rated Teen, how horny could they make it?
Is it possible to make her look (1) attractive and feminine; (2) dressed modestly; and (3) like an action hero?
Maybe I'm imagining things, but I am pretty sure they pulled it off with Sarah Michelle Gellar in Buffy the Vampire Slayer. She was at least modest enough for network television, if I am not mistaken.
Also Nadiuska in Conan the Barbarian 1982 comes to mind. If you do an image search, you will see what I mean.
Man I know so many real women who have vastly squarer or more masculine jawlines than this character, if that is really the ‘issue’. The reminds me of the controversy over the Cora character in Mass Effect Andromeda, whom BioWare inexplicably decided to give the Full Karen haircut (which itself was apparently reactionary ‘queerbaiting’ because they made her straight). Again, people said she looked like a man, even though in the real world many biological women have faces like this.
Traditionally, cartoon heroes have been exageratedly masculine or feminine. So charitably speaking, this is probably part of the reason some of these characters seem off. But it still raises the question of "why?"
You raised the issue of realism, but I think this is more of an excuse than an actual reason. In many of these games, the female characters are uglified but NOT the male characters. Also, in some cases of uglification there is a female human actress who is very attractive, far more attractive than the character based on her. These circumstances strongly suggest that there is something different going on than a quest for realism.
The arms are definitely not large
I disagree, but anyway, what about the hands? Doesn't the person's right hand look very large to you?
Because people like looking at gorgeous women, the same way they like playing games that are fun
I agree. I would add that making female characters plain or unattractive isn't necessarily or automatically an ideological choice. It depends on the motivations of the game designers. Which you can never know with certainty. Still, it's pretty clear that the decision to uglify female characters in recent games really is an ideological choice.
I think there's something a little off about her in this image, but it's not 'trans' by any stretch
For what it's worth, that image definitely pings my trans-dar.
I think maybe her head is a bit small compared to the rest of her body? That's all I can pinpoint.
The hands and arms are very large; the neck is covered; there's not much of a waist; the face is a little on the angular side. The most charitable interpretation I can think of is that cartoon heroines have traditionally been exageratedly feminine and this one is not.
It's flag planting. It's always been flag planting. Taking a territory that belongs to your hated enemies and putting your mark on it
I think this is the most plausible hypothesis. Although I would add something, which is that flag planters often don't want to admit (to themselves or others) that they are flag planting. So they will come up with rationalizations, justifications, etc.
Houses are culturally considered depreciating goods that are worthless after a few decades, and zoning is extremely liberal compared to all other developed countries.
Assuming you are correct, it seems to me that's more of an accident of Japanese culture than a conscious plan to prop up (or not prop up) housing prices.
To some extent you're correct, part of the problem is just urbanization, and inevitably lots of money chasing physically limited space drives up the price.
Yeah, from what I understand there is extremely inexpensive housing available in Japan in various remote areas.
Anyway, since you bring up liberal zoning in Japan, I think it's worth noting that Houston is pretty well known for having lax zoning compared to other large cities. And indeed from what I understand, there's much less of a housing crunch in Houston than there is in other big cities in the US, for example San Francisco or New York. I just having a hard time believing that the difference between these areas is the degree to which government has been captured by greedy baby boomers.
Rather, I think that Houston has plenty of land and more of an individualistic libertarian mentality among people of all age ranges. While in the New York City area, land is much scarcer and the mentality is more statist and authoritarian.
Probably much like it does right now, a mathematical priestly caste who spend their lives training to understand and disseminate the arcane knowledge of frontier mathematics.
I see a potential problems with this. So what if there is an important unsolved problem of mathematics and before a member of the priestly caste solves it, Joe Blow from his basement publishes an elegant proof online which resolves the problem. Would Joe Blow simply be ignored? Would credit (and the Field Medal) go to whatever priest is the first to copy Joe Blow's paper?
Of course a more likely outcome is that each professional mathematician will use his own AI system, sort of like Gary Kasparov's concept of "power chess" back in the day. A human master to make big strategic decisions and a computer for tactical analysis. Except that power chess didn't last -- the computers got too good for humans to be of any use.
Ok, so what would an international chess championship look like if each player were free to use whatever computer assistance he wanted? It seems like it wouldn't confer much status on the winner. In any event he wouldn't be seen as a great chess player.
Let's put the question this way:
In a post-AI world, how would it be decided which mathematicians win the Fields Medal?
The housing thing is part of how Anglo countries have generated generational wealth. Homes in America have always been seen as an investment and thus it’s impossible, politically, to let housing prices fall, or even slow the growth of housing prices.
I'm skeptical about this policy you describe, which I will refer to as PHP ("protect housing prices").
How does the PHP policy work in practice? For example, there are parts of the US which are very pro-development. Texas comes to mind. There are also places which are very hostile to development, for example California. There are also areas where housing is very inexpensive, for example the area around Rochester and Buffalo, New York.
How is PHP implemented in all of these different areas?
Also, how do you explain housing prices in non-Anglo countries? I mentioned above that it's crazy expensive to get a house or apartment in or near Tel Aviv. I'm pretty sure the same is true of Rome or Oslo or Stockholm. Is every developed country implementing PHP?
Almost nobody who works in retirement homes, wipes old peoples asses etc is a born American citizen. If you’ve ever had elderly relatives in these places you’d know this. The reason we can’t have an American kafala system that sends the workers home after they’ve done 5 or 10 years is the fault of progressives, and birthright citizenship of course for their children. But it’s all connected.
Over the years, I've met a lot of people who were in the United States on visas for health care workers -- generally they were women from the Philippines or the West Indies. I would be interested to know (1) how many people end up staying in the US as a result of these immigration programs; and (2) how unruly these people and their descendants are. My sense is that the bringing in of healthcare workers is a very small part of the United States' third-world immigration problem, both in relative numbers and in social problems caused.
I would say that chess is analogous to track and field: You are competing against other people. The fact that there are machines which can move faster that Usain Bolt doesn't really diminish his accomplishments.
Is pure math like this as well? Not at the moment, it seems. Once they graduate college, the way mathematicians gain status is not by winning math contests, but instead by being the first person to come up with and publish an elegant way to prove or disprove some significant unsolved problem. And AI threatens to take this away.
There's no reason why the human practice of mathematics can't reorient itself around the supremacy of AI while continuing to draw down salaries and playing petty academic status games; god knows none of it was any practical importance in the end.
How would that look? Would there be an International Math Olympiad for adults, with problems generated and graded by an AI? I'm not saying that you're wrong, by the way.
What is it that causes current models to be great theorem provers and poor conjecture and definition makers?
Assuming that this is true (and I think you are probably right), I would guess that it has to do with the way the model is trained. The easier it is to verify that a correct answer is indeed correct, the easier it is to put together a big pool of training data for an AI system.
So for example, suppose you wanted to train an AI system to create funny jokes. If you had a million jokes and funniness scores for each joke which were precise and accurate, you could probably do it pretty well. But it would be extremely difficult and expensive to construct this kind of training data set.
With mathematical theorems, it's much easier to verify that a proof is correct -- to a large extent it can be automated. Which means that it's much less expensive to train an AI system. By contrast, with conjectures, it's much more difficult to evaluate how good a conjecture is.
Anyway, I am not an expert on AI but that's my guess.
Housing - if a boomer’s house value goes down by a single dollar it is a genocide.
Hyperbole aside, I am skeptical of the claim that it's the interest of boomers which are driving housing policy. To be sure, those boomers who bought houses between 1968 and 1995 have seen tremendous appreciation in home values, but there are other possible reasons for this increase other than legislative decisions aimed at serving the boomers.
A more likely scenario, in my opinion, is the urbanization trend which has been going on for quite some time now. For work, school, and cultural opportunities, lots of people want to live near big cities like New York, which arguably drives up the price of housing. An interesting example of this occurs in Israel, which has a much smaller overall percentage of baby boomers than the United States or Western Europe. And a government which is very much pro-growth. Nevertheless, it's crazy expensive to buy a house or apartment in Tel Aviv. And why not? That's where the fancy jobs are; that's where the nice restaurants are; etc.
So I guess I would ask for your evidence/argument for why housing shortages are due to legislative prioritization of baby boomers and not other causes such as urbanization.
Health care - if we don’t keep them alive for infinity years with free healthcare and infinity third world immigrants to wipe their asses Jesus will weep.
This was an issue 20 years ago, well before the first wave of boomers became eligible for Medicare. Of course, if your argument is simply that setting up the entire Social Security system created an entitlement program with a devoted constituency, making it difficult to cut even when fiscally advisable, then of course I would have to agree. At the moment it's the boomers who are benefiting but pretty soon Generation X will start becoming eligible for Medicare. And I am pretty confident that Generation X will be pretty adamant about receiving those benefits.
National debt/fiscal policy - obviously they deserve to have free money in their accounts every month, with zero means-testing.
I think there is means-testing in the sense that the government imposes a progressive tax on social security benefits. But anyway, as with Medicare this doesn't really seem like a Boomer problem so much as a systemic issue which resulted from decisions made back during the 1930s.
By the way, according to the AI, the annual program cost of Social Security is $1.609 billion while the annual receipts are $1.449 billion. Which is not ideal but it doesn't seem like a massive crisis waiting to happen. Just speculating, but I would guess the gap could be largely fixed through a modest increase in retirement age and higher taxes for wealthy recipients of Social Security.
That being said, given the rapid progress in AI, I doubt it's really necessary to increase retirement ages. Rather, I think that the government should get ready to start reducing the retirement age. Because the best case scenario with AI is that there is mass long-term unemployment. Which in practice means that the government needs to find a way to get money to people, and the obvious way to do this is to make use of the social welfare programs which are already set up: Social Security; Unemployment Insurance; etc.
That would make the gains to intelligence more important, not less.
I think this is probably correct, but my point is about a different issue, which is the issue of an AI company swooping in, making the discoveries, publishing them, and foreclosing the opportunities of the human researchers to make and publish the discoveries. This seems to be what is likely to happen in mathematics, if it's not happening already.
Arguably, with physics one could prevent this kind of scoop by keeping the data close to the vest. I'm pretty sure that even before AI got big, there were blackout periods with astronomical data. Although one can ask whether the situation is really that much better for individual researchers if most of what they are doing is feeding the proprietary data into their own AI.
But to your point, yeah, it seems that for scientific progress as a whole, AI analysis of experimental data would make things faster and more efficient.

So if OpenAI resolves some great unsolved problem and publishes it, Sam Altman would get the Fields Medal?
More options
Context Copy link