self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
I did hear more grisly details. My landlady is, as the locals would say, "a fit bird".
There's an upside down pineapple sculpture in the front yard, which I was informed was a form of advertisement. Apparently there's a cafe next to a park where she goes to pick people up. One of the pub regulars said that my landlord had once offered to bring him in and let him have a go if he so choosed.
Honestly, I don't know if I was naive or didn't know what to look for. It's not like I ever heard an orgy going on upstairs while I've been living here for half a year!
Heh. I guess she's one to take the free in Free Market quite literally.
I'm all for positive sum contracts made between consenting individuals! It wasn't breaking the bank, even if they were using my ignorance against me. But that's more on me than it is on them.
Congratulations! I hope the two of you have a long and happy marriage!
A drunken lady asked me, someone who has a skin tone about half a dozen shades away from the average, was renting a place in the town.
I said yes, and went on to offer the names of my landlord and lady, expecting that they'd be recognized (it's a small town and everyone knows everyone). She seemed to take that negatively, and immediately told me I should move out. I told her that I'd lived there for 6 months already, without much issue, and that's when she revealed they were swingers (after getting another pint in her). Once she found out how much rent I was paying, that's when she began asking I pack up and move over while terminating my lease.
This came as a surprise to me! I'm a home body, I barely leave my room. If people, including unfamiliar men, came over to the property, I never pried and expected that they were friends or acquaintances visiting. I was never propositioned, and it's not really any skin off my back, though now I'm a bit miffed about the exorbitant rent.
I had a very eventful night in one of the local pubs in my small Scottish town.
Highlights include finding out that my landlord and landladies are swingers, and that they're charging me about 3 times the market rate for the room I'm renting, the sum I pay would be the typical asking price for a whole house in these parts. For the former, I had no real inkling. For the latter, the price I paid seemed rather steep, and I was a bit confused when looking at flats in the nearby city for an upcoming move and noticing that they seemed to be less expensive than what I was paying.
Oh, a middle-aged lady propositioned me and wanted me to move into her house for the price of free. About 2 others also expressed outrage that I was being ripped off in this manner, and offered to take me in for less than half of what I was currently paying.
Hopefully I'll get around to writing a proper post about all of this, with an appropriate level of local color, but I'm still getting over the hangover and sheer surprise.
I'd say my ADHD is quite mild. You wouldn't be able to tell at a glance, and I'm used to working hectic and cognitively taxing jobs without my meds, though they do help.
I'd say Ritalin was 6/10 effective for me, on a platonic ideal where 10/10 would have me locking in and working till I drop. It does help me focus, and I simply can't study without meds. I'd have flunked med school since my old habit of cramming at the last minute no longer cut it as the textbooks approached the dimensions and weight of a healthy newborn, if it hadn't been for Ritalin.
It's mostly the side effects and come downs that put me off it. I get anxious and jittery, and even taken early in the day, it makes me insomniac enough to be debilitating. This is mostly just bad luck and idiosyncratic, it gives my brother, who has ADHD worse than mine, terrible headaches at the lowest dose. He breaks his tablets in half just to try and get by with less.
If you read Scott's review of stimulants, the one that's consistently the cause of rave reviews is desoxyn, which is a polite way of saying meth. At actually therapeutic doses, it works wonders, but it's not available legally in the UK, and most psychiatrists are scared to prescribe it even in the States.
I wouldn't be so harsh on him, and I'm actually quite sympathetic. Let the doctor who hasn't made a spelling mistake or mistaken a dose cast the first stone, and I'm not chucking any. Nothing glaring, or lethal, thank god, but all the steps we take to avoid this only seek to minimize the risk, and can't eliminate it.
He didn't get the name or dose of the medication wrong, and usually capsules versus tablets is an irrelevant detail. If he was doing it electronically, it would be constrained by the list of meds recognized in the system. With pen and paper? Much more scope to go wrong.
Dextroamphetamine isn't the first choice for ADHD here, probably somewhere around 2nd or 3rd line. I can understand why he might just look up dose, refer to something that wasn't the BNF, and then put that down.
In fact, when I called back today to get this sorted out, I learned he'd called in sick today, so it's possible that he wasn't feeling so well when I saw him.
The income of most humans in such a scenario would also be nearly zero. Cognitive and physical labor would be entirely devalued.*
I'd expect anyone with even a modest amount invested would see it soar, and even savings would elevated in terms of purchasing power.
The question is whether this will be enough.
*Even the absolute minimal human existence requires about a hundred watts of power and raw biological feedstock. You can't lower your wages lower than this without dying, and every dollar that could be spent on food and shelter would be much better spent elsewhere. A comfortable existence would be significantly more expensive. I think in a worst-case scenario, humans would be killed outright, slightly less worse but awful would be us being outcompeted and left to die by an uncaring ASI, in less bad scenarios marginalized and unable to meaningfully engage in agency.
Some of them, most notably ChatGPT, are explicitly trained and prompted not to reproduce potentially copyrighted work like song lyrics. Though OAI's recent model spec has been updated to standards where the LLM is suppose to decline politely rather than lie and say it's incapable of reproducing them.
It's not what he was describing. It was my extension, a claim that sufficiently rigorous and exhaustive "prompt" programming is just regular programming.
I have written a few programs (they compiled! eventually..), and I am aware of all the other miscellaneous errata a competent programmer must keep in mind like dependency trees, versioning, accounting for spaghetti code and legacy code that will collapse if you sneeze at it wrong. That's what I meant
it can't possibly fuck it up
Is what I was gesturing to, taking all of that into account. I should consider myself lucky that I've never had to grapple with legacy code bases.
It turns out that at least in outpatient settings, the rule is that controlled substances need a hand-written prescription. Which strikes me as odd given that in all my inpatient work, I just had to tick a few boxes and sign a physical copy when it came to those classes of drugs.
This is eventually going to become part of your bread and butter - you should feel very certain that amphetamines of all kinds are better than methylphenidate (or not!) and eventually be familiar with the considerations for use of one or the other (especially since it impacts your own personal life).
Unfortunately, that's going to take a while. My current placement is psychiatry of old age, and the next one ought to be General Adult. It's probably not till I do one for children and adolescents (or learning disabilities) that I would be personally prescribing any. I can only go off my own experience, having exhausted the options back in India, and what I read online for now.
I did do a literature review! (though given that I have ADHD and unmedicated when I did it, it's not going to be published anytime soon haha)
The effect sizes for dexedrine vs methylphenidate were 0.9 vs 0.8 in adults, within spitting distance. My impression is that methylphenidate is better tolerated in some, but it's already been so unpleasant for me that I am eager to try anything else. (Don't even ask what fucking atomoxetine did, it was highly NSFW to say the least).
This is going to be important for a few reasons, one is that Scott often elides some of the practical concerns that we need to know about (like actual availability, as you ran into) and he cues into very specific old evidence bases at times which is fine for what/who he writes about but misses new innovation (lets see.....psych example....how about the conversation about Trazodone as a sleep aid?) and importantly isn't necessarily the standard of care - your attendings, billing processes, and potentially malpractice attorneys (yes yes UK) are going to look at you funny if you take him seriously.
He also has a tendency to miss or underemphasize some of the research errors (some spotted in this article! What they are is left to the learner lol).
It's exceptionally cruel for you to burden a neurodivergent trainee with additional research burdens :(
That being said, I do hold Scott in very high esteem. I don't consider him infallible, of course, but I would have the presumption of deferring to him unless I had overwhelming evidence of error. I certainly wouldn't formally cite him in my medical decisions at least at the resident level, but thankfully consultants have significantly more leeway in that regard, and I hope I get to that point eventually.
(I'm aware of trazodone as a sleep aid being an occasional prescription decision, do I take this as you asking me to evaluate whether it's ineffective at that job? I've only heard weak evidence, and mirtazapine would be the first port of call anyway for insomnia)
IIRC Vyvanse is now generic in the U.S. but in short supply (as is basically everything else for ADHD), I don't know what it is like in the UK but for my money it is almost always the better choice if the patient can get it and afford it. Being a prodrug presents a ton of advantages and I'm mildly irked at the way Scott is minimizing it.
The UK is also grappling with a supply shortage. I think dexedrine is comparatively uncommon enough that I have better odds of getting it than the alternatives!
I've previously been on an extended release formulation of methylphenidate, and it did nothing good for due to the increased duration of action. I've never tried an immediate release variant of either, but I'm willing to try the devil I don't know at this point.
Telling a computer what you want it to do with such clear terminology and logical consistency that it can't possibly fuck it up is just programming.
AI companies have a strong incentive to make prompting easy, and they already have, I recall the days of using the GPT-3 base model and trying to get it to do anything useful. Right now, the models are significantly smarter and in fact are quite proactive in asking clarifying questions and making useful suggestions that the user didn't know. In the limit, this makes prompting beyond a formulation of an initial suggestion redundant.
We're not there yet, but we're close. Eventually the systems will just understand intent or outright demand clarification, and fancy prompting won't add much to the equation.
Thanks my dude. Luckily I did find a good couple months worth of my previous prescription languishing in a dark corner of my room, so I won't be entirely screwed over if there's a large delay in getting the prescription amended, but it's a pain either way.
I'm too scared to actually try the Dark Web, largely because I have more to lose than the average citizen (I could be deported!). I did once have a friend with an Adderall prescription he didn't use, but he turned out to be an asshole and I wouldn't reach out to him.
My absolute fallback would have been scheduling a flight home and bring as much Ritalin back with me as I could, or just have my family send it over with extended friends and family coming back.
For now I'm hoping a few phone calls will sort this out, and if not, I'll just suffer a little longer from taking a suboptimal medication that beats nothing.
Absolutely nothing, except that they don't exist in the UK. It's tablets or nothing, as far as the NHS is concerned, and private prescriptions have the same issue AFAIK.
We do have e-prescription! It's the default, but while the psychiatrist didn't mention a rationale behind a written one, it was likely because he did it in a hurry, or because he's the old-fashioned type.
https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/know-your-amphetamines
Purely d-amphetamine works better than l-amphetamine or a racemic mixture. And I read elsewhere that dexedrine beats methylphenidate in terms of pure efficacy in adults.
I was the one who suggested it, mainly because I'm sick of the side effect profile of methylphenidate. If I experience anything too unbearable, and I hope some of that is idiosyncratic and dexedrine would be more tolerable. I'll probably ask for an extended release formulation during the next follow-up appointment.
"The factory of the future will have only two employees, a man and a dog. The man will be there to feed the dog. The dog will be there to keep the man from touching the equipment."
Yes. But I only see concerns about alignment. Which really just kicks the can down the road, if we align AI so that even a smart person can't jailbreak it to let it make them a virus, how can we ensure that we prevent that smart person from creating their own unaligned AI etc.
I believe the Term of Art would be a "pivotal act". The Good Guys, with the GPUs and guns, use their tame ASI to prevent anyone else from making another, potentially misaligned ASI.
The feasibility of this hinges strongly on whether you trust them, as well as the purportedly friendly ASI they're unleashing.
As @DaseindustriesLtd has said, this form of pivotal act might require things like nuking data centers or other hijinks that violate the sovereignty of nuclear powers. Some bite this bullet.
Moreover, you're defending two contradictory positions here.
On the one hand, you seem ready to concede to metaphysical skepticism and the idea that knowledge is impossible. On the other hand, you're using the Naive Empiricist idea that systems can only be considered to exist if they have measurable outcomes. These are not compatible.
If what you're doing is simply instrumentally using empiricism because it works, you must be ready to admit that there are truths that are possibly outside of its reach, including the inner workings of systems that contain hidden variables. Otherwise you are not a skeptic.
I am large, I contain multitudes. As far as I'm concerned, there is no inherent contradiction behind my stance.
Knowledge without axiomatic underpinning is fundamentally impossible, due to infinite regress. Fortunately, I do have axioms and presumably some of them overlap with yours, or else we wouldn't have common grounds for useful conversation.
I never claimed being a "skeptic" as a label, that's your doing, so I can only apologize if it doesn't fit me. If there are truths beyond materialist understanding, regretfully we have no other way of establishing them. What mechanism ennobles non-materialists, letting them pick out Truth safe from materialism from the ether of all possible concepts? And how does it beat a random number generator that returns TRUE or FALSE for any conjecture under the sun?
Non functionalists disagree that it is analogous. So you need to actually make that argument beyond "it is obviously so because it is so from the functionalist standpoint".
I must then ask them to please demonstrate where a Chinese Room, presumably made of atoms, differs from human neurons, also made of atoms.
If computationalism is true, computationalism is true.
I reject your claim this is a tautology. A Chinese Room that speaks Chinese is a look-up table. A Chinese Room that speaks Chinese while talking about being a Chinese Room is a larger LUT. Pray tell what makes the former valid, and the latter invalid. Is self-referentiality verboten? Can ChatGPT not talk about matrix multiplication?
Whatever one thinks of our epistemic position, I always recommend humility.
I'm all for epistemic humility, but I fail to see the relevance here. It's insufficient grounds for adding more ontologically indivisible concepts to the table than are strictly necessary, and Searle's worldview doesn't even meet necessity, let alone strictness.
There's epistemic humility, and there's performative humility, a hemming and hawing and wringing of hands that we just can't know that things are the way they seem, there must be more, and somehow this validates my worldview despite it having zero extra explanatory power.
Virtual machines were a thing since 1965, and Searle wrote his nonsense about intentionality in 1983, and the Chinese Room in 1980.
If someone has the gall to claim to disprove the possibility of artificial intelligence, as he set out to do, it would help to have some understanding of computer science. But alas.
The answer is still "the man doesn't know Chinese, the system does".
I agree with you but Searle and his defenders wouldn't. As far as I'm concerned, it matters not a jot if the system is embedded inside a brain, up an arse, or in the room their arse is resting in.
I expect Prompt Engineering will turn out to be the world's shortest lived career.
The only real solution I'm aware of is some form of Universal Basic Income. In other words, if the economy explodes as human cognitive and physical labor is automated, then governments tax it and redistribute it.
This will likely prove unpopular with the people and entities being taxed on their newfound wealth, and it remains to be seen whether governments/democracies will listen to their anxious and unemployed populace over entrenched interests who now hold most of the money and power.
I don't think the likelihood of this happening is high enough for me to relax and take it for granted.
Even if UBI was a thing, that doesn't necessarily mean that inequality wouldn't be. The future uber-wealthy might well be the descendants of those who already had existing wealth, or at least shares in FAANG. I'd take this as acceptable if it meant I wouldn't starve to death.
Blue-collar work won't be safe for long either. We're seeing robotics finally take flight, there are commercial robo-taxis on the road, and cheap robo-dogs and even humanoids on the market. The software smarts are improving rapidly, and so is the hardware. Humans are going to end up squeezed every which way.
There are no reassuring answers or easy solutions, but at least hope isn't lost that we'll come out of this unemployed yet rich beyond our wildest dreams. It only takes a trivial share of the light cone to make billionaires of us all, assuming the current ones will deign to share.
You are right that AIs will more heavily weight ideas that show up in their corpus. I understand this, and hence don't go into detail that would aid a bad actor more than a cursory Google search (I'm already stretching my own qualifications to do so).
You point out that AI Doomers (I'm not a Doomer in the strict sense, my p(doom) is well below 100%) often are the first to point out and plot how AIs might concretely be hostile. This is unavoidable in the service of getting those skeptical to take the ideas seriously! I don't know how much time you've spent browsing places like LessWrong, but I assure you that I have seen a dozen instances of people pointing out that they inside knowledge that would accelerate AI development or cause other catastrophe, without revealing it. (And the majority of them were serious people with qualifications to match, not someone bullshitting about their awesome secret knowledge that they're too benevolent to divulge).
The best way is to design AI that is intrinsically aligned (Asimov's positronic AIs that, most of the time, must follow the 3 laws). Barring that (or, I would say, in addition to it) Humans need to be able to threaten to destroy an AI if it turns genocidal. This might not rule out AI "accidents" but as you say you would expect an evil AI to understand self-preservation if it is sophisticated enough to do real damage. There are probably a lot of ways to do this, and it might be best if they aren't made completely public, so maybe they are already underway
Stopping a misaligned superintelligence is no easy task, nor is killing it. But in general, I agree that it would be best if we create them aligned in the first place, and to a degree, these aren't entirely useless efforts already. Existing RLHF and censors do better than nothing, though with open models like R1, it only takes minimal effort to side step censorship.
For what it's worth, Skepticism, which I take to be your view if you're making this objection, is also unfalsifiable. As are all statements in metaphysics.
I happen to be a metaphysical skeptic myself, but this isn't an argument. We're talking about something more fundamental than notions of falsifiablity or correspondence.
If we really want to get into this, then proving (and disproving) anything is mathematically impossible..
This makes axioms necessary to be a functional sapient entity. Yet axioms are thus incredibly precious, and not to be squandered or proliferated lightly.
To hold as axiomatic that there exists some elan vital of "intent" that the room lacks, but a clearly analogous system in the human brain itself possesses, strains credulity to say the least. If two models of the world have the same explanatory power, and do not produce measurable differences in expectation, the sensible thing to do is adopt the one that is more parsimonious.
(It would help if more philosophers had even a passing understanding of Algorithmic Information Theory)
Unless the writer of the manual understands reasoning to a sufficient degree as to provide exhaustive answer to all possible questions of the mind, this isn't possible. And certainly isn't within the purview of the thought experiment as originally devised.
Why not? What exactly breaks if we ask that the creator of the Room makes it so?
It is already a very unwieldy object, a pure look-up-table that could converse in Chinese is an enormous thing. Or is it such an onerous ask that we go beyond "Hello, where is the library?" in Chinese? You've already shot for the moon, what burden the stars?
If the Room can equipped to productively answer questions that require knowledge of the inner mechanisms of the Room, then the problem is solved.
We don't know yet. We may possibly never know. But we can observe the phenomenon all the same.
For consciousness? Maybe. I'd be surprised if we never got an answer to it, and a mechanistic one to boot. Plenty of mysterious and seemingly ontologically basic phenomenon have crumbled under empirical scrutiny.

More like Mrs. Robinson was playing in the background.
I've copped guilty to being a MILF-enjoyer in the past, haha. That being said, she was clearly very drunk, and I don't want to complicate my life more than it already is (and I have a girlfriend, which would nip anything in the bud).
I did appreciate being called handsome! That haircut and shave might have set me back 19 pounds, but it was worth it.
I will, of course, exercise some due diligence before I seriously consider the move. But saving 700 pounds is something that makes me tolerate quite a few peccadilos.
More options
Context Copy link