@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

I belong to a profession where not only is there a great demand for large amounts of focus and cognitive output, but by virtue of being medical professionals, they would have a far easier time getting prescription stimulants if they desired them.

We don't see that happening, at least nowhere I'm personally aware of, even anecdotally. A doctor on a reasonable dose of stimulants is a harder working and more attentive doctor, but there's hasn't been a red queen's race.

The close analogue to that might be med students who are tempted to take them to cope with the enormous amounts of coursework, but I have not heard of abuse at rates >> than any other class of students.

In any competitive ecosystem where cognitive enhancers offer an advantage, not taking them starts to become a handicap. The problem isn’t addiction, but the slow ratcheting effect where, once a critical mass of people in a high-performance space use performance enhancers (e.g. stimulants), everyone else has to do the same just to keep pace.

Coffee is a cognitive enhancer. Most people working regular jobs drink at least some amounts of it. This doesn't seem to strike most people as an intolerable state of affairs!

While rarer in the UK, more doctors than I would prefer were heavy smokers in India, a habit induced by the insane levels of pressure at work. This did not force all or most doctors to smoke either. And leaving aside the meek modafinil, I would expect a society where ~everyone is on prescription stims would be a healthier and happier one than where everyone smokes a pack a day.

Regardless of all that, the original point stands (and is only reinforced!): trying to ban cognitive PEDs among rats has the same effect as an AI ban. "Well, I'm not slop-posting, I'm just using it like auto-conplete to handle the boring boilerplate. I know what I think. I'm just speedng up my throughput. I have ADHD, you know. I'm just handicapped. I find boring stuff boring! It's a disability. Anyway, the meat isn't in the boilerplate," ad nauseam etc.

I'm a regular user and early adopter of LLMs, I'd probably be a power user if my work flow wasn't particularly friendly for them. I still wouldn't want to use them to write comments for me, especially on the Motte. I expect that most of us here enjoy the act of crafting their own prose, and the amount of boilerplate they stand to avoid is surprisingly small.

I expect that since GPT-4, maybe even 3.5, it would have been possible for someone to slip in an account that used exclusively AI generated text, and likely not even be noticed beyond being a rather bland and boring user.

We could easily have been overrun with bots, but we haven't. I doubt that unless we end up Eternal September-ed with an OOM more new users, bot-apocalypses are not a very serious risk for the Motte as a forum.

But it turns out that "I don't want to do that" is an entirely valid emotion to feel! It was my socialized self-concept, and not my empirical experience, that was wrong about what it means to be human.

"This must be what normal feels like" is a giant self-deceiving trap that enables high-potential low-kinetic human capital to pretend like their drug use isn't a crutch for a gappy upbringing.

I am a radical transhumanist, so we might very well have a difference at the level of fundamental values, at which point we can't do more than acknowledge each others opinion as valid, but not actually get closer to agreement here.

In a hypothetical world where you were diagnosed with ADHD and your parents were just as overstretched, but medication for it wasn't available, would your childhood and adolescence have been better?

I doubt it. The absence of ADHD meds don't turn parents more capable of parenting, and their existence doesn't make them worse. Being denied vyvanse wouldn't have given your parents more time to spend with you while you did your homework.

I also reject the framing that a "crutch" is a bad thing. Driving a car to a supermarket half an hour away is a "crutch" for not being willing to spend 2 hours walking. I prefer it over the alternative.

Ozempic is a crutch for not having better dietary habits by default. Why is that a bad thing? It still makes people lose weight and become healthier. A world where everyone takes it, both to reduce their obesity, and out of the pressure of everyone else being on it (a world we're approaching right now) is still a better world than everyone being fatter and unable to anything about it in practice. A similar analogy applies for cellphones and cars, society is broadly better off even though they've become de-facto necessities, even if the people who don't like them are marginalized.

There are ways for society and cultures to burn up their slack and leave everyone strictly worse off than if they had put a line in the sand, but as far as I'm concerned, stimulant meds or the use of LLMs in a reasonable manner wouldn't do the same to us.

It's as sensical as telling the broader rat community writ large DO NOT TAKE AMPHETAMINES FOR PERFORMANCE GAINS while you can see everyone in the background self-talking about their Totally Real ADHD diagnosis and how Modafinil doesn't really count.

Without engaging with the rest of your comment (which I'm inclined to agree with), I'm tackling this bit.

Modafinil? It's long-acting coffee as far as I'm concerned, and about as benign. I would know, I was on it, and it was a self-prescription to boot. I quit because I built up a tolerance and knew that upping doses beyond 200mg was futile. I had no issues quitting.

It has next to zero addiction potential. Patients consistently report mild euphoria once, on their very first dose, and never again no matter how much they up it. Dependency is also a non-issue in practice. You don't see junkies shooting it up on the streets, not that they'd be nodding off.

It's arson, murder and jaywalking in the flesh.

Amphetamines? Well, I do have a Totally Legitimate Diagnosis of ADHD, and while I have not had the luck of trying actual amphetamines, just Ritalin, they're not dangerous at therapeutic doses. You don't need a diagnosis of ADHD to benefit from taking them, it boosts performance for pretty much everyone, including neurotypicals or those with high conscientiousness already.

I recall Scott writing about it at length, pointing out how they're much less dangerous than popularly conceived.

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/know-your-amphetamines

What's going on? I think addicts use meth very differently from the way generally responsible ADHD patients use amphetamine. It's weirdly hard to find good data on methamphetamine route of administration, but this study shows that about 60% of users inject it, 23% snort it, and 52% smoke it - also, see this paper about "the second case of rectal methamphetamine abuse in the literature". Route of administration makes a really big difference in how addictive and dangerous a drug is (see eg crack cocaine vs. regular cocaine), and I think this is a big part of the difference between seemingly okay Adderall users and very-not-okay meth users.

I'm all for better living through medicine, and I would, if I had a gun put to my head, say that for the modal Mottizen the benefits of taking either modafinil or therapeutic doses of outweighs the risks.

(GMC, please note that this is not medical advice, and provided under duress, I did mention being held at gunpoint. Unbelievable in a British context? Uh.. He had a very pointy umbrella)

Dase. You're a valued commenter, and the moderation team cuts you a disproportionate amount of slack.

You've already tested the waters with top-level LLM-posting, and even while I am not categorically against it, I recognize the points made by Amadan and Cjet that it's a dangerous direction for The Motte to venture. The overwhelming majority of us are here to read what other humans have to say, and write back to them. There are already two moderator responses that constitute clear warnings.

That's a borderline, almost novel category of potential offense, and we have yet to decide how to treat it going forward.

What isn't novel, is name-calling and insults. You know all too well that those don't fly here, and if you claim otherwise, you'd be insulting both your own intelligence and my opinion of it.

I understand you feel provoked and misunderstood, and you might perceive that as intentional obtuseness on your interlocutor's part. But here, we expect charity, and more of it than is normally demanded elsewhere on the wider web. "He shot first" is at best a weak defense. You happen to have a quasi-ideological dispute going here, but I must remind you that this place is a watering hole for heathens and witches, and often all we ask is that we don't bare wands or claws at each other. Even if someone pisses you off, especially so.

I will let you off with a warning, again. This is clearly special treatment, but you're a special poster, and we try our best to tolerate your foibles. But that leeway doesn't extend infinitely far, and we'd appreciate it if we didn't have to go easy on you. I hope you take heed, and if you have to disagree with others, continue doing so with effort and charity. Yes, even if it appears to you that they're making ridiculous claims or missing the point. I would really rather not have to say this again, or watch other mods no longer excuse what I occasionally can.

But also, workers will have to prove that they haven't been working a second or third job (in Reddit parlance, a J2, J3, etc..) It turns out this is actually a crime punishable by prison.

How are they supposed to prove that? Tax returns?

It should be legal to post synthetic context so long as it's appropriately labeled and accompanied by original commentary, and certainly when it is derived from the person's own cognitive work and source-gathering, as is in this case.

For what it's worth, I agree with you, and will plead the case with the other mods, but I do have to stand by the majority decision if it goes against it.

I raised an eyebrow at your use of an R1 comment, but in principle, I'm not against the use of AI as long as it's not low effort slop, the poster makes an effort to fact check it, and adds on substantive commentary. Which I note you did.

P.S. I could create another account and (after a tiny bit of proofreading and editing) post that, and I am reasonably sure that R1 has reached the level where it would have passed for a fully adequate Mottizen, with nobody picking up on “slop” when it is not openly labeled as AI output. This witch hunt is already structurally similar to zoological racism.

I agree that we're at the point where it's next to impossible to identify AI generated text when it's made with a minimum of effort. You don't even need R1 for that, Claude could pull it off, and I'm sure 4o can fool the average user if you prompt it correctly. That does require some effort, of course, and I'd rather not this place end up a corner of the dead internet, even if I can count on LLMs to be more existing that the average Reddit or Twitter user. We hold ourselves to higher standards, and talking to an actual human is an implicit goal.

Of course, if a human is using said LLM and directing it actively, I don't strenuously object. I'm against low effort bot use, not high effort.

With models like o1 and R1, they recursively improve themselves. Synthetic data works fine.

You also aren't accounting for the fact that OpenAI lost $5 billion last year.

And this is a problem? Are their investors with hundreds of billions to offer running scared? They're aware, they don't care. Running out of money is not a problem for them.

I've used almost every major LLM for the purposes of writing fiction or prose, and I would put R1 at about the same tier as Claude 3.5 Sonnet. Which is to say, very good. Too close to call in my opinion.

GPT-4o is better than GPT-4 in that regard, but it, like even Gemini 1206, lacks a certain je ne sais quoi. I don't like reading fiction they've written, or feel satisfied when I ask them to expand on my own.

I find that asking it to specifically emulate the style of a human author works well. Who that author is, is up to you, but I usually try Peter Watts or Ian Banks for starters as they have very distinctive voices.

I would say I have a very distinct voice in my fiction. There's nobody else quite like it. Just today, I was thinking about taking a web serial of mine off hiatus, and had gotten through most of a chapter before I felt less than happy with the overall flow of a few paragraphs and the overarching structure of the entire chapter, and was too tired to think of better options.

I fed the entire thing into R1, told it I was unhappy with a few bits, and asked it to try to rewrite the last few paragraphs, in my style, while maintaining the quality of the strong start. It did wonders. I found myself nodding my head and thinking yep, that's how I write, and that would be an example of what I consider good writing from myself. Except it wasn't me doing more than hinting.

For the record, Claude 3.5 Sonnet is just as good (or so close I can't call it), and I ended up doing a final edit while taking inspiration from both.

You might get some mileage out of asking it to emulate Yudkowsky, Gwern or even Scott.

I'd advocate for it. If you experience unpleasant side effects, you should be able to stop, and even then, the most common ones like bloating pass with time as your body adjusts.

The main issue is that you need to be on it for the longterm or nigh indefinitely to keep off the weight. I'm not sure if your relative will be able to share their supply with you for that long, but I presume there must be online pharmacies or prescription mills that might help (no judgment involved, I think that's a useful service when there's too much red tape around).

For what it's worth, some here claim the author is female, and I've seen her referred to as "her" in essays she re-tweeted.

When information becomes free and universally accessible, voluminous research for a novel is devalued along with it.

Is it devalued? Maybe. But it's hard to write a novel that takes the reader's time and intelligence seriously if you don't do some research. At the very least a wiki lookup or asking an LLM doesn't hurt.

The most purely autobiographical fiction requires pure invention. Nobody ever wrote a more autobiographical story than The Metamorphosis.

Absolute nonsense of the "sounds deep, makes no sense if you think twice about it" variety. If your work is "pure" invention, then I struggle to see how it can be autobiographical. I expect most objections to be quibbling about what counts as pure invention.

"I always wonder why birds choose to stay in the same place when they can fly anywhere on the earth, then I ask myself the same question."

-Harun Yahya

One of the few poems that reliably induce frisson in me. I felt it again just reading it.

I would never play the Pathologic games but I'd certainly watch Mandalore review them for hours. They can get wild.

I had the same experience with RDR2 for what it's worth. I chalk some of that to being excessively immersive to the point that I wished I could just get around and do things easier.

Hmm.. Definitely EVE Online. I'd much rather read stories about the game than play it. Debatable Factorio, because I feel like I'd need to be on stimulants to enjoy it.

I've recently been playing Arma Reforger, and it's this close to being too boring and slow for me. In Arma 3, I have the majority of my 3500 hours in the Zeus mode, where I'm managing a mission for anywhere from a handful to dozens of players, and there's always something to do. Setting up the next objective, micromanaging AI, listening to the players chat. It beats driving for half an hour or standing on guard for ages not to see anything, which is both a realistic depiction of warfare, but also boring (I do my best to have my players not end up there).

The map in Reforger feels too large even for 128 players, it's less restrictive than something like Squad, where the game mode channels you into lanes (even if you are technically free to faff around anywhere). The spawn points can easily be tens of minutes from the action, and God help you if you forget where you parked the car. I still play Reforger because I enjoy the novelty of an Arma game that doesn't look like it was made in 2013 and also runs way better, but sadly the Zeus/Game Master mode is atrociously half-baked. Bohemia learned nothing from the mods that made Zeusing in Arma 3 a million times more fun and useful.

I shudder to think of low the probability of guessing the perfect values would be at random. I'd start attending church with Pascal.

Sigh.. Shame I never got to see things at their true peak. Not that we've done poorly here, I think The Motte has outlasted the initial pessimism and then some. And in the end, our migration off Reddit was because of Reddit turning the Eye of Sauron towards us with a frequency too high to bear.

If I had a Christmas list, I'd put Scott reversing his decision and/or regularly signal-boosting us pretty high up there. He attempted to smother something beautiful, and he acknowledges that.

Forget? I wasn't even alive at the time!

(That's illuminating, I had presumed it was controversial from the word go)

I decided to look around some more and the more I read, the worse an idea this seems.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31100715/

When GH and IGF-I are secreted in excess, bone remodeling is enhanced leading to deterioration of bone microstructure and impairment of bone strength. Indeed, acromegaly causes skeletal fragility, and vertebral fractures are reported in a remarkable number of subjects exposed to GH and IGF-I excess.

In other words, you'll have thicker bones. But they'll be unhealthy bones, that'll be more prone to fracture under stress. That seems entirely counterproductive for your goals.

By all means see that doctor if you're keen to have a definitive answer, but from where I'm standing, this probably won't have any positive results even if you have a strong risk appetite. I see no evidence of threshold effects, where there's an amount of HGH post-puberty that-

  1. Noticeably thickens bones
  2. Makes those thick bones actually stronger
  3. Doesn't cause acromegaly.

Be very careful with the stuff.

I can see them just fine on my Reddit app. It's one that's been modified to hide ads, but I don't think I ever touched anything in the APK that affects the mod list.

Our very own Zorba is still on there, but from memory he isn't active. I believe Bakkot does most of the modding there.

/images/17370577062779107.webp

If you're looking to have it:

thicken bones like your feet, hands, wrists, ankles, vertebrae

You're basically into acromegaly territory, and I don't think that's a very good idea, unless your lover is into the Neanderthal look.

I doubt there's much concrete evidence out there, but I found this:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2657499/#:~:text=It%20can%20be%20argued%20that,%2C%20menstrual%20irregularities%2C%20and%20impotence.

There are few controlled studies on the effectiveness of GH on the performance of top level athletes. In general these studies have been performed with supraphysiological dosages but not with the large amounts claimed to be effective, for instance, by bodybuilders. The results of most of these controlled studies are generally less impressive than the claims of those who misuse the substance. A study of volunteers under heavy resistance training found decrease of free fatty mass but no difference in the muscle strength.23 With weight lifters, it has been shown that short term GH treatment does not increase muscle protein synthesis more than placebo24 or other factors such as maximal voluntary strength (biceps or quadriceps).25

The long term risks of hGH use are not well known since epidemiological data regarding this type of treatment in healthy sportsmen are unavailable. Acromegaly, which results from a pathological increase in endogenous production of GH, is often cited as one of the major risks associated with excessive use of hGH. The major symptoms are swelling of the hands and feet, coarsened facial appearance, dentition problems, arthralgias, fluid retention, and excessive sweating. Acromegalic patients have an increased risk for diabetes mellitus and hypertension that can lead to premature mortality from cardiovascular diseases.26 It can be argued that long term hGH doping with high dosages will probably result in misusers experiencing symptoms of fluid retention and increased risk of development of diabetes mellitus and hypertension. There is also a risk of cardiomyopathy, osteoporosis, menstrual irregularities, and impotence. Some of these side effects are reversible after withdrawal of the drug.

You're in the peculiar position of wanting thicker bones as opposed to more muscle. I don't know how you can get that just in your peripherals without fucking up your face. If you want an actually well-informed answer, you probably want the kind of sports-physician who has a cult following in the powerlifting community and isn't overly afraid of losing their license.

India is a lower-middle income country?

LOWER-MIDDLE INCOME ECONOMIES ($1,146 TO $4,515). [51]. Angola, Honduras, Papua New Guinea. Bangladesh, India, Philippines. Benin, Jordan, Samoa

https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519-world-bank-country-and-lending-groups

We might disagree on the criteria for being a "functional" one, but it matches my own standards in a way most of Africa doesn't.

Is it high-functioning? Hell no, but it's also not Sub-Saharan Africa, and better than Nigeria and the like (I happened to have a nice chat with a Nigerian doctor who joined my workplace)

I expect that in a decade or two, if AI didn't steal livelihoods, we'd reach Thai or Eastern European standards. Think of how the average middle-class American looks at how impoverished the middle-class Brit is (and the latter really isn't starving to death or has a absolute dearth of consumer goods) and perhaps that's how they'd look at the middle-class Indian.

Well, Scott seems to be defending and crediting Lynn quite vociferously. It doesn't really get much earlier than that for the modern, data-based HBD movement, though sadly for Lynn he happens to be dead before the tides turned.

I know Scott has endorsed Cremieux (or at least drew attention to them) and the latter was doing HBD before it was mainstream. And is, more importantly, alive to celebrate.

I think the average /r/SSC mod seems to have thrown up their hands at this point. They can't censor the topic very well if even Scott is talking about it, and he was the one who had the old CWR thread forced off (if memory serves, I only frequented the subreddit and The Motte's sub when it had been a year or so since the declaration).

I know that they'd have banned you for that, and even banned people for saying it can't be discussed and that they should go elsewhere (that happened to me, though they were nice enough to reverse it when I brought it up in the mod mail).