self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
Five Eyes collaboration made it quite easy tbh, especially when they figured out I could write a legal script for all the crack cocaine I was asked to smuggle in!
Why?
I am firmly for people being in as close to total control of their bodies, in life and manner of death, as feasible.
For the same reason babies can't be trusted to not eat toys, toddlers can't be trusted to be alone around fire or bodies of water, and children can't be trusted to make large medical decisions on their own, adults generally can't be trusted to fully understand what it means to be killed and eaten.
I disagree strongly. I understand perfectly well what it means to be killed and eaten, and have no desire to undergo that fate. So do most people. But if someone, however rare, is otherwise a sane and functioning member of society and harbors a desire to be cannibalized, then I support their right to do as they will with the most inalienable of properties, themselves.
I'm an advocate for the availability of MAID (though implementation details can vary) and I see nothing wrong with the occasional art piece where someone lets others dine on bits of themselves while alive (memory brings up someone using the fat removed during liposuction to fry food). Where's the stretch when I already consider those acceptable? Personally, if I was dead beyond hope of recovery (and wasn't set for cryogenic preservation), I couldn't care less what's done with my corpse.
The few who can be trusted to actually understand what that decision means, are also perfectly capable of orchestrating and getting away with it, so a strict law banning that decision is really more of a filter banning it for the less intelligent and conscientious.
A fair point, but I'm a stickler for principle here. I'd rather have a formal system where people are exhaustively examined and certified as being "sane and intelligent enough to make stupid decisions" and then let them do as they will. I'd hope that's the default assumption for most people, we already let people drink more than is good for them or eat themselves into obesity, and while attempts to regulate that or reduce negative externalities by things like banning drunk driving exist, most people are against societal meddling as invasive as outright prohibition or somehow making fatness illegal.
A society that only lets people make "good" decisions is a tyrannical one as far as I'm concerned.
I don't want to nitpick every way someone can off themselves. I'd rather have a means for people to prove that they're competent to kill themselves, and then let them choose how to dispose of the body (or the means of death) as long as it doesn't hurt anybody else.
If your belief is more general--that people have a right to their own preferences--then I submit to you that people are frequently wrong about their own preferences. Preferences are built atop more basic preferences, and most people are not great builders.
Inconsistent preferences != wrong preferences!
We all have conflicting preferences. My desire to have a burger conflicts with my desire to lose weight. Someone's desire to have a good family life conflicts with their desire to be a billionaire.
There are often temporary conditions that can make people do things that cause a combination of permanent harm while being something they wouldn't want on reflection. But if someone who isn't otherwise mentally ill wants to be eaten, is able to articulate their preferences and reason about them, and can't be convinced to do otherwise over a decent length of time, I'm not standing in their way (unless legally and regulatorily obligated, which I am).
Quite a few things that are common in the human condition are past the verge of what counts as sanity for me. That being said, while I agree that the majority of people who wish to be killed and eaten are mentally ill, in a manner that might be amenable to treatment, I think there are a non-zero number who have no other mental illnesses, ignoring "wants to be eaten" by itself.
For the latter, well, it's their body and their choice, advocating for radical bodily autonomy requires me to bite that bullet.
Some people enjoy being killed and eaten. They even record a video telling everyone they were fulfilling their biggest dream. Their partner still goes to prison for murder and cannibalism.
I will push against the lack of is-ought distinction here. I am entirely in support of radical bodily autonomy, if a sane and informed person wishes to be killed and eaten, I won't stop them, or seek to punish anyone who, uh, lends them a hand or a mouth. Emphasis on sane, of course, but people can be weird enough to have all their cognition and still want absurd and harmful things, but as long as it's done to them and they can't be talked out of it while retaining capacity, I wish society would let them.
Liquid acetaminophen is safe as long as you mind the doses, and IIRC, paediatric suspensions are usually intentionally made in sizes and concentrations where even consumption of large amounts or the whole bottle won't be lethal.
Supplements? Not aware of any that work.
I'd recommend topical minoxidil. Works great if you have the patience and discipline to stick to a several month long regime.
Impatient? Or high tolerance for erectile dysfunction? Toss in finasteride. I'd just go off the former for now, especially if you're starting on the early side of things.
I've been enjoying some Verner Vinge (RIP to a real one who predicted the Singularity but died potentially just a few years short of seeing it). A Fire Upon The Deep and a Deepness in The Sky were pretty good. It's a damn shame it's just a trilogy, I was hoping for more to chew through.
Also happily enjoying Collen McCullough's Masters of Rome series, ah, she's a very good writer, and it's time to truly grapple with Caesar's adventures.
IQ appears to be as close to an unalloyed good as it gets. To the best of my knowledge, the markers for most things we consider indicators of a good or successful life positively correlate with IQ, such as overall health, mental wellbeing, income and so on.
Is it theoretically possible that after a certain point, further IQ gains will require horrible tradeoffs (such as an example Scott once brought up of a family that seems to get +20 IQ points at the cost of going blind)? Yes.
But for very large and very meaningful gains, well past the 160s, we have existence proofs that people with high IQs do just fine. Better than you or me for the matter. I'll take plenty more gains along those lines.
I'm pretty sure that the test specifically asked us to avoid zooming in haha.
But I was also looking out for artifacts. A lot of smaller details lack symmetry and become squiggly in a nonhuman way. Also random blotches and spots that don't make much sense.
I'd say that I did pretty well, maybe around 80% accurate from eyeballing the results.
The ones that really tripped me up were the abstract paintings (and the ones 'intentionally' made by humans can often look like an explosion in the paint factory in the first place) and some works in an older style. There was a human painting in the last 8 that had really fucked up hands and feet on the dozens of characters, so that threw me for a loop.
Of course with each passing day, it gets harder and harder to tell, and Flux is absolutely solid, though I haven't had the luck of using it yet.
The only reliable/efficient way of memorizing large amounts of information I'm aware of is spaced repetition. I'm too lazy to make Anki cards, but I do try and apply the practice to reviewing the copious amounts of notes I need to memorize, and it does work.
On the nootropic side, ashwagandha is more or less robustly shown (going off last time I read up on it) to have mild benefits for memory. There's not really much you can do to improve it above your usual baseline unless you're a dementia patient needing memory enhancers really.
"Great writers" such as Gwern or Scott both do their best to note down things, and are also blessed with great memory by default, which strongly correlates to intelligence anyway.
Specifically, I've heard that the quality of healthcare is better in India and that the standard of living is generally higher. The people who say this still want to stay here, despite having been among the most privileged people in their home countries and living in a country that often doesn't recognize their qualifications or experience.
From what I've heard online, the health-care system in Canada is highly overburdened, though if it's better or worse than the NHS, I can't comment.
When most Indians abroad say that healthcare was better back home, they're referring to private hospitals, decidedly not the government ones (I'd know, I've worked in both).
There's no months long queu to see a GP and you can pretty much self-refer to see a specialist. And a single consultation costs maybe 1% of your monthly salary to boot. And once in, I can't say the quality of care is any worse than in the West, and probably much more timely too for elective procedures. Look at me, staring the alternatives of being out a thousand quid for a psych assessment for ADHD here versus a 2 year wait list through the NHS.
In terms of standard of living, I'd say they're missing the creature comforts that come from low wage menial labor being available. There are so many things that are starkly better in the West, to the point where I don't feel the need to elaborate here.
Of course, by revealed preferences, the people you speak to still opt for Canada over their native lands. I don't think they literally mean that things were better back home, but certain aspects that they're missing now that they're gone, even if on an intellectual level they knew what they were getting into.
The first port of call would likely be a hysterosalpingography (HSG), where we pay dye up the uterus and visualize its distribution, primarily to check the patency of the tubes and identify uterine defects like septate uteri and the like. You'd also certainly check for hormonal irregularities through blood tests. Beyond that, I'd assume a USG would be the next step, I struggle to think of anything a CT or MRI would immediately add for most of the common potential issues.
Beyond that, it depends on what the particulars of the infertility causing disease you have in mind are.
whoonga (heroin and god knows what, sometimes HIV meds)
I admire the diligence of the local dealers, why not give your clients some PEP for HIV gratis? Saves on the costs of sharing needles and you hold onto a lifetime client for a longer value of said lifetime.
That is something we need.
Further cementing my belief that Claude 3.5 Sonnet is the only LLM that can write worth a damn:
Pride and Rush
It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single freshman in possession of a good wardrobe must be in want of a bid. However little known the feelings or views of such a young woman may be on her first entering campus, this truth is so well fixed in the minds of the surrounding sororities, that she is considered as the rightful property of some one or other of their houses.
"My dear Elizabeth," said Mrs. Bennet to her daughter one morning in their Tuscaloosa hotel room, "have you selected your rush week outfits? You know the first round begins tomorrow."
Elizabeth Bennet, who had been arranging her perfectly pressed blouses by shade of white, merely nodded. She had heard quite enough about rush from her mother since their arrival from Longbourn, Georgia, three days prior.
"Lady Catherine de Bourgh's niece, Anne, is legacy at Delta Nu," continued Mrs. Bennet, fanning herself with a recruitment pamphlet. "Such connections! And to think, if only my own dear sisters had attended Alabama, you might have been legacy somewhere yourself."
"I assure you, Mama, I am quite content to make my own way," said Elizabeth, though she knew this would bring little comfort to her mother's anxious spirits. The whole business of formal recruitment struck her as rather ridiculous – all these elaborate social niceties, performed with precision timing under the sweltering Alabama sun.
"Jane has already made such an impression at orientation," Mrs. Bennet continued, speaking of Elizabeth's elder sister. "That Caroline Bingley, the Recruitment Chair at Kappa, absolutely doted on her. Such refinement! Such grace!"
Elizabeth smiled, for she could not disagree about Jane's natural elegance. Her sister possessed exactly the sort of gentle manner that seemed calculated to win over even the most discriminating of sorority women. Elizabeth, on the other hand, found she could not help but view the whole proceedings with a degree of bemused skepticism.
"And have you heard?" Mrs. Bennet lowered her voice conspiratorially. "Mr. Bingley's friend, that Darcy fellow – the one from the old Mountain Brook family – is serving as a recruitment advisor to his sister's house. They say he's terribly proud, but with five generations at Alabama, I suppose one might be."
Elizabeth raised an eyebrow. She had glimpsed this Mr. Darcy during orientation, standing aloof from the cheerful chaos of move-in day, his crimson tie perfectly knotted despite the August heat. She had thought him handsome, to be sure, but his expression of general disdain for all around him had rather diminished the effect.
The afternoon wore on, Mrs. Bennet fluttering between her daughters' rooms, dispensing advice about conversation topics and the proper way to cross one's ankles. Elizabeth found her thoughts returning to the week ahead – the houses she would visit, the conversations she would have, and yes, even that proud Mr. Darcy, who seemed to embody everything both magnificent and ridiculous about this peculiar Southern institution she was about to enter.
Little did she know how significantly these next few days would alter the course of her freshman year – and indeed, her life.
Pride and Rush
[Previous chapter remains the same...]
Chapter 2
The first morning of recruitment dawned bright and merciless, the Alabama sun already asserting its dominance over the manicured lawns of Sorority Row. Elizabeth, dressed in a carefully selected sundress that her mother had deemed "not quite the thing, but it will have to do," found herself assembled with hundreds of other young women in the grand ballroom of the student center.
"Potential New Members," announced Charlotte Lucas, a sophomore Rho Gamma who had been assigned to Elizabeth's recruitment group, "remember to smile, be yourself, and trust the process." Charlotte, who had temporarily denounced her own sorority affiliation to serve as an impartial guide, delivered these platitudes with what Elizabeth detected as the slightest hint of irony.
Jane, naturally, looked perfectly composed despite the early hour. Her blonde hair fell in elegant waves, and her white dress seemed to repel both wrinkles and nervous perspiration. "Lizzy," she whispered, "do try to keep an open mind. Everyone says these houses have such different personalities."
"Oh yes," Elizabeth replied with a arch smile, "I'm particularly looking forward to discovering the subtle distinctions between the thirty different versions of 'Sweet Home Alabama' we'll hear today."
Their conversation was interrupted by the arrival of Caroline Bingley, resplendent in her Kappa leadership polo, her auburn hair arranged in the sort of casual updo that required no less than forty-five minutes to achieve. She was accompanied by none other than Mr. Darcy himself, who appeared to be inspecting the recruitment arrangements with all the enthusiasm of a man attending his own funeral.
"Jane, darling!" Caroline trilled, skillfully ignoring Elizabeth's existence. "You must be so excited. First rounds are such fun – though of course, some houses are more... selective about their future sisters than others."
"I'm sure every house has its own wonderful qualities," Jane replied diplomatically.
Mr. Darcy's expression suggested he strongly disagreed with this generous assessment, though he said nothing. His eyes swept the room with what Elizabeth could only interpret as disapproval, lingering briefly on her own decidedly unfashionable hometown boutique dress.
"I suppose some of us must content ourselves with whatever bids we receive," Elizabeth said sweetly, meeting Darcy's gaze with deliberate challenge. "We can't all have five generations of legacy to recommend us."
A flash of something – surprise, perhaps, or irritation – crossed Darcy's features before he resumed his mask of indifference. "Legacy status means little without the proper... qualities to maintain our standards."
"And what qualities might those be, Mr. Darcy? The ability to look down one's nose at perfect strangers?"
Caroline Bingley's carefully penciled eyebrows shot up towards her hairline. Jane looked mortified. But before Darcy could respond, a chime sounded through the ballroom, signaling the start of first rounds.
"All PNMs to your groups!" Charlotte called out, saving Elizabeth from whatever cutting response Darcy might have formulated. As she took her place in line, Elizabeth couldn't help but notice Darcy watching her retreat, his expression unreadable.
The day stretched before them: twelve houses to visit, each for precisely twenty minutes, with three minutes between to hurry down the row to the next destination. Elizabeth steeled herself for what promised to be an exhausting parade of identical conversations about her potential major (English literature, to her mother's despair) and her high school activities (debate club captain, which had already earned her several concerned looks from the more traditional Southern belles in her group).
As she climbed the pristine white steps of the first house, already echoing with synchronized clapping and singing, Elizabeth reflected that Mr. Darcy's disdain might not be entirely misplaced – though she would rather die than admit it. Still, she was here now, and she intended to make the best of it, if only to prove to certain parties that a girl from small-town Georgia could navigate these rarefied social waters with as much grace as any Mountain Brook debutante.
The massive door swung open, releasing a blast of air conditioning and the perfectly harmonized strains of what was, indeed, "Sweet Home Alabama."
This is a US thing? I'm pretty sure that in the UK, this wouldn't fly at all. We're obliged to disclose all relevant information to our patients, though if memory serves there are criteria like mental incapacity where that's not strictly necessary.*
*My gut instinct was wrong. From GMC guidance:
You should not withhold information a patient needs to make a decision for any other reason, including if someone close to the patient asks you to. In very exceptional circumstances you may feel that sharing information with a patient would cause them serious harm and, if so, it may be appropriate to withhold it. In this context ‘serious harm’ means more than that the patient might become upset, decide to refuse treatment, or choose an alternative. This is a limited exception and you should seek legal advice if you are considering withholding information from a patient.
I certainly find this perplexing, I can't under any circumstances endorse people not being given medical records that they paid for (or were paid for on their behalf). I suppose this a clause more likely to be invoked in psychiatry than elsewhere, but it's not one I particularly want to use.
Heh. I can't resist to throw in some alliteration, a pinch of prpsody, and I'm glad someone appreciates it!
Hmm.. I'd like to claim that I've been prevented from just rescanning the same item twice, but I'm not sure of that. I'll try and see if that works for duplicate items next time I'm shopping.
Does self-check-out work differently in the States? At least in the UK, you need to put everything on a counter with a scale, that's pretty sensitive to the point where a minor discrepancy between an item put there and an item scanned and put in the bagging tray will get it to lockup till manual intervention by staff. All on camera too. Everything has barcodes too, so I doubt you can just scan produce differently. Or maybe I'm just naive here, I don't know.
I disagree that the death sentence is a qualitatively different punishment from the usual.
We do not have a 100% accurate legal system, or even one that approaches it. It is still, speaking broadly, an acceptable one. I and most people present here have negligible chances of ending up behind bars if we go on leading relatively normal lives.
If I were someone wrongly convicted of a crime, and only released at the hoary age of 80 with a few million dollars as an apology, it isn't much better than being dead. Better, yes, but assuming I was in there for most of my natural life, I would have lived a very substandard existence, I would have lost the opportunities that I cared about.
Life is fungible with time, and time with money.
Look, I get where you're coming from about the irrecoverable nature of death, but I think we're missing the forest for the trees here. Sure, death is final - but so is losing decades of your life to imprisonment. Many seem to consider that there's there's this huge, qualitative difference between execution and long-term incarceration, but I'm not convinced it's as big as we make it out to be.
Think about it - if you're wrongfully convicted at 25 and spend the next 40 years in prison, only to be exonerated at 65, what exactly have you recovered? You've lost the prime of your life, missed out on career opportunities, relationships, family, and pretty much everything that makes life worth living.
Most of us need to donate a decade or two of our lives laboring to make ends meet. And (for the moment), death has been an inevitability for 97 billion anatomically modern humans. You steal my life savings, and I can draw up a figure for the years of my life you've stolen for me.
Keeping someone alive in custody for decades is expensive. Yet, the damage done, if done wrongly, cannot be trivially reversed.
Executing someone, in the USA, even those guilty beyond the shadow of a reasonable doubt, is somehow more expensive, but that speaks more to political opposition and organizational failure than the price of a bullet or a noose. It is not intrinsically difficult or expensive to end a human life, quite the opposite.
You mentioned the idea of Hammurabi being all we have left when restorative justice is impossible. I'd argue that this applies just as much to life sentences as it does to the death penalty. In both cases, we're essentially saying, "We can't undo the harm done, so we're going to remove this person from society permanently."
And that may as well be cheaply. Because the rest of us are paying for it with our finite time and money. Not without due process, extra care even, but the kind of people who end up on Death Row aren't particularly sympathetic characters if the recent discussion about the questionable candidates that the Innocence Project were forced to advocate for are any indication.
I'm an unabashed transhumanist. I think there is a very significant probability that human lifespans could be made nearly unbounded in the span of our current life expectancies. I think it's a tragedy that anyone dies, especially today, when the end is potentially in sight. That only changed the values of the calculus, not the core of it. Still, beyond wishful optimism, I know no reason to assume that humans can live literally forever, not while thermodynamics and Feynmann's quip about it stands. But as the world exists, reformative and restorative justice seem farcical to me. The closest we can get those congenitally inclined towards to criminality to desist within the tender caress of a prison is to age them out of their proclivities. While still outside, with the fear of swift and likely punishment (hence why the perceived odds of being brought to justice outweigh the kind of justice involved, the death penalty isn't a detterent over life in prison). Thus, without access to better ways of removing the crime from the criminal, we keep them away from those they might hurt. Maybe one day we'll be able to edit minds or genes to turn even the most murderous maniac into someone who sobs at the idea of hurting a fly, but that day isn't today. If the possibility of killing someone before that eventuality seems too much, oh well, cryopreserving their brains in a vat preserves some possibility of reform even after death, and is more than their victims received. It's a rounding error compared to the costs of trial, prison, or execution at the end.
Almost all societies recognize the necessity of governments making hard decisions, often unpleasant decisions, about who goes behind bars and who dies. We simply have to choose how to calibrate that curve, decide how many innocent men die and how many guilty men go free. For a functional society, the optimal number of either is not zero. When you bite that bullet, I genuinely don't see any reason to be squeamish about the most villainous biting theirs.
On the topic of going Dutch on dates, I don't know if the norms are different in India or if I had better luck than usual, but I'm pretty sure that's how I did it for the overwhelming majority of dates. I can think of only one date where she outright asked me to pay, and I would consider that a "vetting" date, because afterwards she offered to go Dutch. All the steady relationships I've had, we've split bills or at least alternated paying.
Personally, I'd be rather annoyed if someone expected me to foot the bill. I could potentially see myself doing it if there was a massive gulf between incomes, for example if they were a broke college student, but that would very much be the exception, not the norm. I'd consider someone who never veered from that approach tantamount to a gold digger, and give them the cold shoulder ASAP. I've never felt the need to impress women by flaunting my wealth either. Anyone who resorts to doing that loses esteem in my eyes.
A per rectal examination, when the doctor sticks a finger up a bum, most commonly to check if a prostate is enlarged or if the bowels are full of compacted poop. Not much fun to do, and potentially messy.
Just use minoxidil? It takes longer to show effects, but it dodges most of the negative side effects of finasteride, such as your dick not working. I know that's my first port of call if my hair does begin balding.
I thought Hydrogen Sonata was an okay novel (by Bank's standards). I read it after exhausting the others and I wished the Culture had a better send-off. If I had to pick favorites it would be either Player of Games or Excession. Perhaps Matter as a third.
On the other hand, if you're done with the Culture, the Algebraist is really good even if it's not set in the main universe.

It's a good thing I'm not an American, because I'd be driven to despair by the choice of candidates in every election since Obama and Romney. Though my mild disappointment in a Trump win would be even more mildly assuaged by Vance becoming more likely to be elected himself in the future. I like smart people being in power, even if they have to ride Trump's coat tails on the way there.
I do recall when too much time on Reddit had given me minor TDS, I remember my gut dropping when I heard the news he'd been elected back in the day (I was very concerned about him kicking off a nuclear war with the Chinese). I very quickly learned that was an overreaction, mostly by becoming a regular on the old Motte and being exposed to more reasonable (or at least varied) viewpoints than the Reddit mean.
Anyway, I'm mostly ambivalent between the two, or at least I can't pick one I think is strictly superior. If I had to bet, I'd pick Trump going largely off the prediction markets, it's too close to call from what I can tell otherwise.
More options
Context Copy link